The Question Of Existence: How Different Are We?

2102 words - 8 pages

Due to the fact that humans have developed a considerable dominion over the earth and its other inhabitants, we are often inclined to be anthropocentric. Backed up by cultural and religious tradition, we tend to subscribe to the theory that we are distinct among earth's creatures and that this affords us a certain right in how we interact with and use the others. Even champions of animal rights, such as J.M. Coetzee's fictional novelist Elizabeth Costello, tend to subscribe to this mentality of speciesism, albeit to a different end. Costello depicts human development as a war with the other animals that was, “won […] definitively only a few hundred years ago, when we invented guns. It is only since victory became absolute that we have been able to afford to cultivate compassion” (The Lives of Animals 59). While she believes our dominance should be used to spearhead the movement of sympathetic relations with other species rather than their exploitation, the fact remains that she views us as dominant, as having won the war. Perhaps there is a good case for human ascendency: we have clearly built complex civilizations, often at the expense of other creatures and habitats, and are able, through the various technologies Costello alludes to when she says we invented guns, to subjugate other animals to our needs and fancies. The crux of the matter, however, is not so much whether we are more powerful, more abundant, or more successfully manipulative than other animals, but whether or not these qualities indicate that we are distinct in any way. Do humans form a separate, higher form of existence than other animals or, like the lion that is able to capture and control the antelope, are we merely a more powerful predator of the same mold?
The basis of Darwin's theory of evolution seems to prescribe to the latter theory, that humans are merely another of the many variations of the structure belonging to all animals. He comes to this conclusion primarily through a system of comparative anatomy. Through observation he concludes that, “all the bones in [the human] skeleton can be compared with corresponding bones in a monkey, bat, or seal. So it is with [human] muscles, nerves, blood-vessels, and internal viscera” (The Descent of Man 22). He diminishes the possibility of interpreting these similarities as mere coincidence by exploring the implications of such likenesses. For example, humans are susceptible to many of the same illnesses as other animals, including noninfectious diseases that must develop independently in different creatures' systems. This is a strong testament to the similarity between humans' and other animals' blood and tissues, not only at the macroscopic level that Darwin first observed, but also at the microscopic and chemical levels. Further, these illnesses, being of the same kind, are cured equally well by our medicines in other animals as in humans (23).
As compelling as this evidence is, many humans seem inclined to dismiss its...

Find Another Essay On The Question of Existence: How Different Are We?

What market factors led to the development of automobiles, and how are those factors different today?

1845 words - 7 pages INTRODUCTIONAs we explore the automobile of yesterday, today, and tomorrow, we will examine what market factors led to the development of the automobile, how these factors have shaped the automobile into what it is today, and how we anticipate these factors will drive the creation of future automobiles. We will learn through investigation and analysis just how powerful the consumer is in controlling product design. Don't just sit there. Drive

How Are We To Assess Gender In Relation To The Formation Of Identity?

1580 words - 6 pages social roles that define our gender, i.e. how masculine or feminine we are. Since society creates our concept of masculine and feminine stereotypes society will also judge humans who use their gender as a part of their identity. For example a woman who is very feminine will be seen to be healthy and well adjusted by the society that defines the stereotype. She will by the same token though, be treated the way society decides it will treat

Terrorists: How different are they?

1771 words - 7 pages Terrorists: How different are they? Ever since September 11th, terrorism has been on virtually all of our minds. And now, some eighteen months later, as the nation perches on the brink of war with Iraq, our fears remain. The frustration that most people experience in the aftermath of extreme violence is largely the result of the question why. Why would anyone want to commit so heinous a crime? How could they live with themselves

How do we Become Who we are

1899 words - 8 pages expected by the people around us. We have also learnt how to perform socially accepted gender characteristics. Hence children are now able to define which toys are deemed suitable for their gender, and will generally steer well clear from those which aren?t so as not to appear abnormal, or be called by the opposite gender. This is the period of time when boys and girls of the same age tend not to get along, each sex possibly confused by the different

Schizophrenia. What is schizophrenia? What are the causes? What is it's history? What are the symptoms? How is it treated? What are the different forms of the disorder?

3275 words - 13 pages of schizophrenics. MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) scans show that people with schizophrenia often have ventricles that are larger than they are supposed to be, and reduced amounts of the other brain tissue. Tests have shown that people who have schizophrenia seem to have a difficult time balancing activity between different areas of the brain. For example, when some one thinks or talks, that person usually if you see what their brain is doing

Question: What are the 3 main kinds of rocks?

2361 words - 9 pages . Another property that I did not mention is relative rarity. Question: What are rocks made of?Rocks are made of minerals. Different combinations of minerals make different rocks. Also, different methods of formation will make different types of rocks. There are three types of rocks: igneous, sedimentary, and metamorphic. Question: How does oxygen help rock crumble?Oxygen in water that percolates down through rock is very important in the chemical

The Existence Of God

1209 words - 5 pages scientific methods. Even as of today with all the modern technologies and the development of sciences, we still do not have a definitive answer to the question "does God exist?" Among many philosophers and scholars who have tried to answer this question, we shall look upon Rene Descartes' theory on the existence of God. In terms of believers and non-believers, Descartes would be one of the believers. Before we go any further, we must ponder

The Existence of God

2488 words - 10 pages discovery that challenged their previous believes. They always laughed first, but when premises became proven, they were also the first to jump on the bandwagon. The question religious philosophers have been pondering for ages, why do we seek proof for the Existence of God? I think the answer is, we fear death and seek assurance that survival is not only possible, but also guaranteed. Since we can only survive within a condition that is

The Existence of God

2245 words - 9 pages objectivist thesis is ultimately the most traditional viewpoint since it views God as 'object'- that is, something which exists independently of us (such as a table or another person). However, there are a number of problems with this: a) How do we know that what we are experiencing is actually God (and not our imagination, or even some other being)? b) If there is no objective means of testing for God's existence

The Existence of Miracles

1070 words - 4 pages The Existence of Miracles When bringing the existence of miracles into question it is necessary to firstly establish a definition of a miracle and exactly what purpose they serve. As with many issues, theologians are divided on an actual definition of what a miracle really is. Paul Tillich (1886-1965) claimed that: "A genuine miracle is first of all an event which is astonishing, unusual, Shaking without

The Existence of God

1724 words - 7 pages since the best indication that we have is human love which oscillates over time or is easily broken. God as already defined transcends our experience so how exactly can his existence be proven when all philosophical arguments produce inconclusive conclusion due to a lack of evidence and/or doubt. One such way to address the problem of skepticism is to construct an argument by providing premises that build upon each other until a valid conclusion can

Similar Essays

In Socialisation How Conscious Are We Of The 'deals' We Make?

1379 words - 6 pages Socialisation is an inevitable and crucial process which involves adapting to the behaviour patterns of an encompassing culture. Whether this is done consciously or unconsciously is subject to much controversy and debate. This essay will attempt to evaluate these ideas; it will show how socialisation occurs and the outcomes and implications of such. The human being is an intricate and complex entity, and from socialisation we are shown how this

What Are The Differences Between Knowledge And Belief? How Do These Apply To Claims About Existence Of Objects?

1361 words - 5 pages existence. Our cultural upbringing has an affect on how we view the world, what we see as existing as the highest entity. Someone from India, for example, of course would not see Jesus Christ as being the most real entity, as strict Christians from a Western country would.'Existence' means a different thing to different people. The view I hold is that which is truly existing is all components of the physical world, simply because we exist as physical

How Beautiful Are We Essay

887 words - 4 pages of grains has fed several. His humble smile has melted metal.Beauty which provides joy lies in doing beautiful deeds. Meaning thereby when we start making the lives of others beautiful and happy our lives are also improved by the addition of immortal beauty into it. Beauty lies in the realization of what we are and what we should be. Being beautiful is a concept that how successful are we in enriching our lives with virtues like kindness

"The Effects Of Entertainment On The Taste Of Humanity Or Where Are We Going?" Neal Gabler's 2003 Ap Free Respoonse Question

561 words - 2 pages the nation; this just goes to show the true power and influence that is held by most persons of fame. Keeping in mind the nature of the behavior of some of these stars, is this really a good thing? I understand that many pin-ups may be positive role models for society, but these individuals are greatly outnumbered by the reckless and sometimes downright uncontrollable young stars.Therefore, as entertainment remains progressively deviant in order