Problems That Led To The Wrongful Conviction Of David Milgaard

2611 words - 10 pages

How to appropriately and fairly carry out criminal justice matters is something that every country struggles with. A major reason for this struggle is the fallibility of the justice system. It is acceptable to concede that the possibility of human error in every case and investigation may lead to a wrongful conviction. In the case of David Milgaard, however, Canada's Criminal Justice System not only erred, but failed grievously, resulting in millions of dollars wasted, in a loss of public confidence in the system, and most tragically, in the robbery of two decades of one man's life. Factors including, but not limited to, the social context at the time of the crime, the social perception of deviance, the influence of the media, and the misconduct of investigating police and prosecution played a substantial role in the subsequent miscarriage of justice.

Much of society mistakenly interchanges the two concepts of crime and deviance, assuming that they are one in the same. "A crime is what the law proclaims it to be, and is an act punishable by law" (Winterdyk 9). Deviance, on the other hand, is a contested concept; it can be defined as differing from a norm or accepted standard of society ( Deviance involves acts that fluctuate from social norms; although such actions can be, they are not necessarily against the law (Winterdyk 9).

Society often constructs views, and perceives certain individuals or groups as deviants and as threats to established moral standards and values. Perfectly exemplifying such views can be seen in the wrongful conviction of seventeen-year-old hippie, David Milgaard, in 1969, for the rape and murder of Gail Miller. Then, as now, teenagers and especially hippies are seen as liminal in society. Groups who are perceived as liminal are often viewed as threats, ultimately creating moral panics. As a result of these moral panics, it is extremely safe to label such individuals as those engaging in criminal activity.

Labeling played an important role in the initial arrest of David Milgaard. Police officers, as members of society, often use character discrimination in identifying suspects. Unfortunately, the police likely began the investigation with a particular image of the suspect in mind, an image established by the elite members of society whom essentially determine what a deviant is. Regrettably, David Milgaard happened to fit the mold. The stigma that Milgaard would carry for next twenty-seven years of his life would be that of a rapist and murderer. The issue with labeling is that Milgaard felt no one would ever look at him in any other way than as a criminal. This was affirmed by the rejection of his final appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. As a result, Milgaard attempted numerous times to escape prison and commit suicide; he felt as though society had given up on him. Ironically, his escape from prison was his only actual criminal act, but it led to an even greater public perception...

Find Another Essay On Problems That Led to the Wrongful Conviction of David Milgaard

Wrongful Conviction: An Injustice Within the Justice System

1644 words - 7 pages in disgrace. In many cases, officers will arrest an individual who fits a certain description that they know will lead to an arrest and conviction. In the case of Guy Paul Morin it shows how the system failed in aiding the innocent who abide to the law. The law is established to protect those who are innocent from being targeted because of the law. The aspect of wrongful conviction is established within law to protect the innocent from being

The Issues that Led to the Emancipation of Jews

1395 words - 6 pages The Issues that Led to the Emancipation of Jews The transition of Jews through history is one, which is complex and took place over a long period. There are many factors, which contributed to the change of the status of Jews within their world and changes in their status as well; these changes affected the religious and cultural values of European Jews, which lead to an alteration in their own perception, as well as

Factors that Led to the Outbreak of WWII

1927 words - 8 pages There has been much speculation surrounding the cause of World War II. This paper seeks to answer the question: what were the factors that led to the outbreak of the war? Being one of the most defining moments in the 20th century hence necessitating the need for such studies. The in-depth study will include coverage of the causes, events surrounding it, the outcome and the effect it had the globe over. A lot of previous events such as the

Events that led to the start of WWII

1305 words - 5 pages who was Admiral Miklos Horthy. In Albania, Bulgaria, and Romania, the kings also ran dictatorship. There was less democratic experience and severe economic problems. Many of the Europeans saw one-man rule as the only way to protect instability. To get back on track, Fascist dictatorships had a will to use military aggression.Another reason that led to the start of WWII was the weakness of the League of Nations. To prove this weakness, the Japanese

Comparison of Three Factors that led to the Great War

779 words - 3 pages The three factors that I think that lead to World War I was German Ship Law, Balkan Crisis, and the Bosnian Crisis. They are all quite closely related still there is a level of influence in each one of these factors.The German Naval Law in 1900 literally marked the beginning of trouble. The Kaiser said he wanted a navy because he wanted colonies in Africa. In 1906 he started to build dreadnoughts. Because of this the British felt threatened. The

Factors that Led to the Great Depression

1505 words - 7 pages set the tone for the overproduction in industry that led to the bubble because many workers could not afford to buy the industrial output. Also, during the 1920’s, credit was introduced and the stock market was booming. What caused the worst depression in history? What events led up to the economic failure? Was the government aware that the crash was coming? Traditionally, President Roosevelt has been lauded as a savior of the economy and one of

Events That Led to The American Revolution

1374 words - 5 pages . These reasons elevated the restrictions that the British imposed upon the colonists and led to more outright defiance from the colonists and more reasons to begin a war. Although the colonists possessed an uncharacteristically high toleration of abuse, the British finally gave a reason for the colonists to retaliate. In the early spring of 1775, the colonists could take no more. The British went after some of the leaders that headed the

The War That Led to Love

2742 words - 11 pages It wasn’t my fault that England and France decided to go to war. It wasn’t me who decided that stealing King Philippe’s cow was a great idea. I didn’t declare war; I hadn’t even wanted a war. And, so, why was I sitting in a jail cell with a whole bunch of other innocent British? Why was it that I was soon to be sold as a slave for the crimes my country committed? Oh, I’m sure England was doing the same thing, but why me. “Your number is 1-0-6

Analyses of the factors that led to the rise of the communist party in China

2422 words - 10 pages SanyaDP-1Q. Analyse the factors that led to the rise of the communist party in China.In the beginning of the 20th century, the Qing dynasty, which had ruled China for 2000 years, was in decline. The period following the end of the empire in 1911 was a turbulent one, with various groups fighting for power in China. This civil war ended only in 1949, with the Chinese Communist Party establishing control over the country. There are quite a few

Ernesto Che Guevara: The Journey That Led to the Formation of a Revolutionary

1735 words - 7 pages begins to realize the problems that affect the lower class. In Chile, when Ernesto is asked to visits a poor women with asthma and a heart condition, he is horrified by the lack of medical resources provided for the poor, leading him to blame Chilean government as he says in his diary:How long this present order, based on an absurd idea of a caste, will last is not within my means to answer, but it's time that those who govern spent less time

What were the conditions that led to the growth of fascism between 1918-1939? - History - Essay

1036 words - 5 pages The Growth of Fascism | Sample answer 1 The Growth of Fascism | A1 Sample answer What were the conditions that led to the growth of fascism between 1918 and 1939? The economic and social conditions that prevailed in the inter war period of 1918 to 1939 provided a perfect climate for the growth of authoritarian regimes such as Franco’s in Spain and Salazar’s in Portugal. But it also led to more brutal fascist dictatorships such as Mussolini’s in

Similar Essays

The Cases Of Guy Paul Morin And David Milgaard

1467 words - 6 pages On hearing the names David Milgaard and Guy Paul Morin some of the things that come to mind are justice, betrayal and redemption. The trials of David Milgaard and Guy Paul Morin are among the most discussed criminal law cases in Canadian history. Two innocent men arrested, stigmatized, imprisoned and convicted. How do innocent people get wrongfully convicted? You may think it odd but it can and does happen. These two men were deprived of a very

The Wrongful Conviction Of Canadian, Guy Paul Morin

781 words - 3 pages The Wrongful Conviction of Canadian, Guy Paul Morin On January 23, 1995 Guy Paul Morin was exonerated of a first-degree murder conviction of Christine Jessop, ten years after his arrest and two lengthy criminal trials. This is a case where the justice system failed at all levels and has left the Ontario courts asking how it happened. On October 3, 1984 nine year old Christine Jessop was abducted from her home in Queensville, Ontario. Her

Wrongful Accusations Do Not Necessarily Lead To Wrongful Conviction

1659 words - 7 pages correlation to wrongful convictions in murder cases (Siegel, 2012). Two former legal aid attorneys, Barry Scheck and peter Neufeld, founded the Innocence Project in 1992 at Benjamin N. Cardozo Scholl of Law (Gould, 2010, pp. 825-868). Today, the Innocence Project is a non-profit legal clinic that handles cases where post-conviction DNA testing of evidence can yield conclusive proof of innocence (Gould, 2010, pp. 825-868). The Innocent Project

Wrongful Conviction Of Criminals: Right Help

1420 words - 6 pages , many people believe that he/she is no longer a threat to society. However, the felonious activities of confined inmates reach out into society every day. According to an Hark Jones “Most inmates run lucrative drug operations, commit fraud, and commit a multitude of criminal offenses from inside the walls of prisons” (Hark, 1986). Street investigation VS correctional investigation, Street investigations are more common than correctional