Issues With Gentically Modified Animals, Food And Organisms

1840 words - 7 pages

Animals that have been genetically modified have adopted the name “pharm” animals. It is a mix between the word pharmaceutical and farm, and shows what the animals are used for. Such as the goat that was mentioned earlier, there are several other animals that are considered “pharm” animals. Many reporters, critics, and researchers alike all use this term to describe their dislike for the way that these animals are being used. “It is a mechanistic use of animals that seems to perpetuate the notion of their being merely tools for human use rather than sentient creatures.” A reporter from the Humane Society of the United States says in its position paper on the use of GM animals (Pollack). Critics and researchers ask: What makes these animals different from walking pharmacies that we use at our disposal?
The last con argument is the worry about the power in the market world that biotechnology companies will be receiving from the use of all these GM foods and organisms. Even in the past 10-15 years, the amount of acreage used for farming of GMOs has grown a considerably large amount. In 1997, it was estimated that there was an average of 4.2 million acres Globally, in 2013 there was an estimated 169 million acres Globally (Denault). And who would be benefiting? That’s right, biotechnology companies. The top biotechnology seed companies include Monsanto, DuPont/Pioneer Hi-Bred, Syngenta, Land O’Lakes, and Bayer. These companies control over 71 percent of the world’s seed market and account for an average of $50 billion per year in sales of seeds. Monsanto, a monopoly, owns over 27 percent of the worldwide seed market (Wohlers). With this much control, what is stopping them from raising prices to unseemly amounts, and causing farmers to find themselves in a logjam of debt.
Each argument has excellent points to them, however some of them are based off of fallacies, and it hinders their strength and weaknesses. The argument on GMOs genetically transferring their genetically enhanced abilities to weeds and creating “superweeds” has a weakness in its argument. The argument is mostly based on logos. George Erdosh’s standpoint, in his article “To GMO or NOT to GMO?”, is neither against or for the use of GMOs. Instead of a solid standpoint, George Erdosh gave points and arguments for both sides. His argument for “superweeds” is mostly based off of hypothesis, however the sequence of events seem logical. The same for Anton E. Wohlers’ article “Labeling of Genetically Modified Food”. He discusses the possibilities of “superweeds”, and backs up his accusation with a hypothetical situation and facts. There was a fallacy of appeal to tradition used in Anton E. Wohlers’ academic journal. He brought up the fact that people managed to live without GMOs, so why should they have to change their ways? Why fix something that isn’t broken? The weakness of the argument is that there is no absolute data that has been collected that “superweeds” actually exist. The only...

Find Another Essay On Issues with Gentically Modified Animals, Food and Organisms

Genetically Modified Organisms: Impact on Society and the Environment

1522 words - 6 pages modified organisms without a single case of health or safety issues, environmental groups and many governments vehemently oppose genetically modified foods (Reville). This fear is based off of inaccurate science or no science at all, and is restricting the implementation of hugely beneficial technology. Extensive research into this subject has come to one conclusion. Genetically modified foods have a positive impact on society and the environment

Mandatory Genetically Modified Organisms Labeling and Revisions to Regulation

2211 words - 9 pages time, it might be wise to check for a food label, perhaps reading “Frankenfood.” The problem is, these transgenic foods don’t require labels. These are the types of sensationalist advertisements used by opponents of genetically modified organisms (GMOs). They certainly grab one’s attention, associating GMOs with the stuff of science fiction and labeling them as “Frankenfoods.” This stigma associated with GMOs needs to be eradicated. Although the

A Case against Genetically Modified Organisms and Foods

2068 words - 9 pages are many people who believe that an apple is just an apple, when there are actually 4,000 species of apples and that does not even include the variation on how or where an apple is grown. In recent years Genetically Modified Organisms or GMO’s have become a common product in our food even though research shows that it can have adverse effects such as cancer on the human body. There are too many people who simply follow what the label on their food

The Ignorance of Media and Public about Genetically Modified Food

2407 words - 10 pages food can be traced back to the early twentieth century. According to Dr. Janet E. Carpenter, a United States Department of Agriculture consultant, the beginnings of genetically modified food originated with the discovery of genes by the Austrian monk Gregor Mendel in the early 1930s (Carpenter). Shortly after this discovery, growers began experimenting with the mutation of DNA in order to improve the performance of future crops and animals. This

How Do We Farm If We Must?: Analysis With Peter Singer's Down on the Factory Farm and Stanley Curtis's The Case for Intensive Farming of Food Animals

2537 words - 10 pages better understanding of his priorities. While Singer focuses his entire essay on the suffering and inhibition of animal's natural behaviors, Curtis openly declares that, “In agriculture, it is not sufficient to be interested only in physiological, behavioral, immunological, and anatomical indices of animals' environmental adaptability” (171). In other words, any meat-producing farm model must concern itself with issues besides just animal

The Problems With Genetically Engineered and Modified Foods

2042 words - 8 pages further research and production of them. As scientific evaluation and testing continues, many issues are raised on the validity of claims that there are possible increased toxicity levels in genetically modified foods and that there is a change that with the production of this kind of food, that certain antibiotic immunities can alter. The toxicity of plants is a widely debated issue by supporters of biotechnology because of the fact that most

Messing with Nature - Is our food supply safe? Essay response To a article I read in my Biology class: The Teacher wanted our opinion on genetically modified food.

562 words - 2 pages Messing with NatureIs our food supply safe? By genetically modifying our food sources will we have problems in the future? Enough time has not passed to answer this question; we could be unleashing untold consequences that we are yet to suffer. Ecovandals, people who fear GM (genetically modified) plants and foods destroyed them in an attempt to stop their spread. These people fear that these GM plants may cause problems that we won't be able to

Genetically modified foods and (some of)the ethical issues involved in this debate

1258 words - 5 pages Genetically Modified Food (GMF) is perhaps one of the most important and divisive issues occurring at this time, it is a global issue requiring much thought and forward thinking. There is much debate surrounding GMF, the environment, health, livelihoods, property rights and the future of agriculture are just some of the areas the development and introduction of GMF will affect. GMF is such a complex issue, and there are many stakeholders

Issues with Buddhism and Christianity in China

1247 words - 5 pages A wide variety of religions have been practiced in China since the beginning of its history of China history. The introduction of Buddhism and Christianity to China is complicated by several of the same issues. Buddhism was first introduced into China at the beginning of the Eastern Han. This had something to do with the opening of the Western Regions, which made travel between China and India easier than before. The Silk Road also, paved the

Ritalin issues and popular use with children

1149 words - 5 pages continues and the search is on to define ADHD and its cause. Some research indicates that ADHD is an inherited deficiency of dopamine in the brain.At this point in time the main drug prescribed for ADHD is methylphenidate or more commonly known as Ritalin. This drug induces a child's brain to focus, helping him to stay in his seat and attentive to assigned tasks. It is noted by Mary Eberstadt that boys are diagnosed with ADD three to five times as often

Privacy and Ethical issues with Google Glass

2119 words - 9 pages Introduction Google Glass is wearable computer, looks like a pair of glass which has high resuloution optical head-mounted display (OHMD). As its name suggests it has been developer by Google in one of their research and development project called “Project Glass” [1]. The product has been designed to be a ubiquitous computer displays information, communicate via Internet and interact with the user by natural language voice commands that starts

Similar Essays

Genetically Modified Organisms In Food Essay

1312 words - 5 pages Genetically Modified Organisms in Food Tomatoes, soy beans and McDonald’s French fries- what all of these things have in common? They are all some of the most commonly genetically modified foods on the market today. With scientists in the race to invent newer and better everythings, genetically modified organisms, or “GMOs” have become a hot topic of research in just the past 10 years. By using the genetic information from one organism, or

Genetically Modified Organisms And How They Have Changed Food In America

2098 words - 9 pages Modified America Food is an essential part of everyday life without it one could not survive. Every day we make choices on what we put in to our bodies. There are countless varieties of food to choose from to meet the diverse tastes of the increasing population. Almost all food requires a label explaining the ingredients and the nutritional value allowing consumers to make informed decisions on what they are consuming. However, many may not be

Are Genetically Modified Organisms Safe In Our Common Food Supply

882 words - 4 pages GMO stands for genetically modified organism; Today, Health and local.com explain that a genetically engineered food is a plant or meat product that has had its DNA artificially altered in a laboratory by genes from other plants, animals, viruses, or bacteria, in order for the plant/meat product to take on the positive qualities of the added DNA. This process produces a new plant that can be more resistant to pests, able to grow in harsh weather

Genetically Modified Food And Food Additives

2331 words - 9 pages discovered that enhanced foods can withstand harsh unexpected weather. For example, if a harsh unexpected winter came then a regular corn field would die whereas a corn field that was genetically modified would be more likely to survive (Mound 4). Hormones in our Food Hormones in food cause for animals to grow faster and bigger in size than they normally would. Fish have been known to double in size, and small calves have been said to grow faster with