Concerns With Locke's Theory Essay

905 words - 4 pages

John Locke was a seventeenth century philosopher. In his Essay Concerning Human Understanding Locke makes the argument that the mind and body both exist and that they both interact with each other. However, in explaining his reasoning for his theory Locke raises some issues that are not backed with good reasoning. George Berkeley, another philosopher from the same time period, identifies Locke's flaws in his theory and presents his own theories that resolve the problems with Locke's argument.Locke's theory begins by stating that all ideas are the result of experience of sensations. In book two Locke states this theory:All ideas come from sensation or reflection. Let us then suppose the mind to be as we say, white paper, void of all characters, without any ideas; how comes it to be furnished? to this I answer, in one word, from EXPERIENCE; in that all our knowledge is founded.Locke continues on in his theory to say that there are ideas (mind) and qualities (body). Both of these are divided into two separate parts. Ideas are both simple and complex. Simple ideas come from senses that and unmixed and complex ideas come from more than one sense. Just like ideas, qualities are divided into parts, primary and secondary. All qualities have the power to produce ideas. Primary qualities cause ideas of motion, rest; etc? Secondary qualities are part of primary qualities and consist of colors, textures; etc? Secondary qualities are how we perceive primary qualities. Locke further explains that the body is a representation of ideas and that ideas are caused by qualities of the body. Locke reasons that this is how ideas are formed and how the mind is composed:The mind being, as I have declared, furnished with a great number of the simple ideas conveyed in by the senses, as they are found in exterior things, or by reflection on its own operations? not imagining how these simple ideas can subsist by themselves, we accustom ourselves to suppose some substratum wherein they do subsist, and from which they do result, which therefore we call substance.With this reasoning Locke explains that qualities are a substance and therefore they do exist. However, this is Locke's major flaw in his argument.With this theory Locke leaves himself open to criticism. He claims that matter is real and that it is a substance without any basis or reasoning behind it. He says that there are substances (things) but he does not know what it is other than a substratum of qualities. Locke assumes that qualities must exist because they cause ideas in the mind, but without any reasoning for this theory he leaves ideas open to criticism. George Berkeley studies this...

Find Another Essay On Concerns With Locke's Theory

The relationship between the development of the Enlightenment Period and the Scientific Revolution

621 words - 2 pages replaced it with a heliocentric theory in which the Earth was simply one of a number of planets orbiting the sun. Another great advancement during the Scientific Revolution was in the field of astronomy. Johannes Kepler proved the orbits of the planets were elliptical, but was unable to come up with an effective model of the solar system. That was left to Galileo, who in 1630 published his Dialogue on the Two Chief Systems of the World, in which he

John Lock, a universal thinker. Essay

1741 words - 7 pages extremely significant and when put to use in government were extremely important.Within all of John Locke's enlightened ideas, he had an idea and view for the perfect government would be. John Locke Believed that all people were born with three different rights called natural rights. All people have, by nature, the right to life, liberty, and property and he believed that they should and could never be taken away. These natural rights were the

Locke V. Hobbes.

1058 words - 4 pages Police inspector at Fantine's bedside and is trying to arrest him but Jean instead beats the Inspectors face into a brick wall.On the contrary Jean Valjean shows many examples of Locke's theory. After the Priest has 'bought Jean Valjeans life' with the candlesticks and silver, Jean dedicates his life to helping others whenever he can. One example is when he gets Fantine out of jail and takes care of her and keeps his promise to raise her daughter

John Locke's Theories in The Declaration of Independence

988 words - 4 pages in the activities of the Parliament. The other justifications for the dissolving of the bonds between the Colonies and Britain deal with Locke's theory that man should have control over their lives and their choices within the limits that they do not prevent any other man from the right to life, liberty, and property. So, when Jefferson is arguing against Britain's laws such as the quartering of soldiers in citizens homes and the taxation of

John Locke: Second Treatise of Civil Government

903 words - 4 pages Civil Government and Locke The Second Treatise of Government provides Locke's theorizes the individual rights and involvement with the government; he categorizes them in two areas -- natural rights theory and social contract. 1.Natural state; rights which human beings are to have before government comes into being. 2.Social contact; when conditions in natural state are unsatisfactory, and there's need to develop society into functioning of

John Locke

1676 words - 7 pages . While theorized nativists assume that innate ideas and experiences contribute to ideas of a mind, Locke's concept empiricism needs to assume only the contributions of experience. This is the basic structure of Locke's argument against innate ideas. The details of his theory and supporting evidences are briefly discussed in this chapter.In Locke's Book I, Chapter 2, he defines the three objectives of his philosophical project. One is to discover

Compare and Contrast the Philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, and Karl Marx

772 words - 3 pages influential feature of any Marxist theory. According to Locke, the natural reason allows us to establish civilized relations without force. The 'Rule of Reason' law has to govern the conduct of the ruler as well as the subjects. Taking the quantitative aspects of Marx's theory and mixing it with the qualitative characteristics of Locke's theory will yield in the maximum benefit for the civil society.Even with the same goal of improvement in

Skeptical Empiricism

1080 words - 4 pages . Ontological metaphysics is concerned with establishing a rational theory of the link between these two supposed worlds, butHume's arguments, if correct, establish that only imagination can possibly operate in this area. To the extent that metaphysics is based on reason there is the hope that it can achieve some degree of certainty and lay claim to being a rational discipline. But if metaphysics is dissociated from reason and must depend upon

Comparing John Locke and Thomas Hobbes

1232 words - 5 pages be overthrown we can look at Hobbes and Locke's theory's overall. Hobbes' theory is a pessimistic look at human being and the way they act around each other but Locke's theory suggests that people are more easy-going and peaceful towards each other. Hobbes point of view on human nature and how a government should be run is a more realistic way of looking at things than John Locke?s theory though. Both Hobbes and Locke see human nature differently

Innate Ideas

914 words - 4 pages . Also, do we think that the idea of God is an innate idea? Or do we take Locke's theory that you aren't born with the idea it's received through your senses and experiences? Your mind furnishes these ideas. I would like to think we weren't all idiots and weren't a blank tablet, but only time will tell. These two extremely different ideas show that this argument is far from over, and maybe Descartes and Locke now know the truth resting in their graves.

Philosophers Concerned with Political and Social Matters

1075 words - 4 pages America. His theory of the 'ideal' society, developed in his bookTwo Treatises on Government established a distinction between what he called 'the state of nature' and 'the political state.' By 'the state of nature' Locke meant a moral state; a state into which all were born as humans and all were bestowed with certain God-given natural rights. The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges everyone: and reason, which is that

Similar Essays

If You Know You Have Alzheimer's, How Do You Regard The Person Who Will Inherit Your Body? Is That Person You? How Is This Case Connected With Philosophical Theories Of Personal Identity?

769 words - 3 pages by their memories, held by Locke.Locke believed that for a person, Y, at T2 to be one and the same person as X at T1 he must remember doing what X did at T1. He holds the view that a persisting person is marked out by their memories. This view though can be easily argued against, for example according to Locke's theory a human being suffering from total amnesia ceases to exist as that person and a new person is created. I believe that this is a

George Berkeley And His Theory Of Human Knowledge God's Inexistence

1214 words - 5 pages mistake alone proves his theory wrong, it collapses with in it self. If we can't see, smell, taste, hear or feel (perceive) God he can't exist and therefore one's unperceived world can't exist.Berkeley's Theory of Human Knowledge begins with John Locke. Locke's object of human ideas were ideas or subjective impressions and not things. If ideas are the immediate object of our knowledge, is it ever possible to admit an external reality corresponds

John Locke (1632 1704) Essay

913 words - 4 pages time Locke arrived at Oxford in 1652, the club had grown, and Locke soon became a member. (This club later became the Royal Society, an organization dedicated to promoting the use of experimental science.)Locke's involvement with the philosophy club increased his interest in medicine. Although his official studies were still entirely classical, he spent much of his time attending medical lectures and performing his own experiments. Eventually

A Biography Of John Locke. Essay

636 words - 3 pages adopted these ideals. Locke also believed that if the people were unhappy with the government they were within their rights to change or remove it. Soon a revolution seemed to be the proper recourse of a people whose rights were deprived because of tyranny. Locke's theory became traditional in British philosophical circles in the eighteenth century.The principal philosophical work of John Lock was the Essay Concerning Human Understanding. It took Locke