This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

'it Was Not The Weakness Of The Nationalists But The Strengths Of The Colonial Rulers That Led To The Failure Of The Nationalist Movements In Sea Before Wwii.' How Far Is This True?

3039 words - 12 pages

On the eve of World War II, despite much effort, the nationalist movements were unable to make any headway and failed. The failure of the nationalist movements can be attributed to various factors. Nationalist organizations were saddled by disunity and the failure to win mass support. On top of the weakness of the nationalists, external factors including the complex demographic makeup hindered the nationalist in achieving success. Most crucially, the colonial rulers proved to be a force too formidable to deal with- their employment of tools of repression and ability to co-opt sections of the native populations eventually caused the nationalist movements to fail.The oppression of the colonial rulers prevented the nationalist movements from making any headway. To begin with, most of the colonial rulers did not have the intension of sharing powers with their nationalists. The French were being described as "offered no more than example; they offered no power-sharing, and they had no concept of a commonwealth... The nationalist movement was formed very much in antagonism to them." The colonial powers were willing to crush any opposition as long as they deemed it to be a threat to their authority. The oppression limited the space for the nationalist to grow legally in terms of nationwide associations and movements. In Vietnam, through the series of uprisings planned by the VNQDD in 1930, mutinies at Yen Bay and elsewhere were suppressed. Forty- three bombs were dropped on a village named Co Am. Twenty- two death sentences were carried out and thirteen of the parties' leaders were later guillotined. Another such example of colonial oppression is evident in Indonesia whereby the Dutch clammed down on the Partai Komunis Indonesia (PKI) during the Banten uprisings. The Dutch arrested 13 000 followers of PKI. An ambitious long- term plan of training a nationalist cadre drawn up by Hatta and Sjahrir was also ended by Dutch police action. For the rest of 1930s, nationalists were reduced to attempting, without succession, to argue concessions out of the Dutch in the semi- representative People's Council. Any progress the nationalists made was eliminated almost immediately using extremely efficient intelligent services which acted swiftly against any opposition it met. Therefore before the nationalists were able to make any significant development in the nationalist movements, they were faced with execution or imprisonment, causing the nationalist movements to fail eventually.In addition, the oppression also limited the success of the nationalist movements in terms of causing the nationalist groups to have a lack of leadership. In Indonesia, many PKI leaders were arrested in the strikes of 1925. The leadership of PKI was dislocated and caused confusion in the direction of the party. This caused a division and curtailment of the leadership. The large degree of banishments decimated the PKI's lower- echelon leadership to a vanishing point. In the late 1920s and...

Find Another Essay On 'It was not the weakness of the nationalists but the strengths of the colonial rulers that led to the failure of the nationalist movements in SEA before WWII.' How far is this true?

Events that led to the start of WWII

1305 words - 5 pages who was Admiral Miklos Horthy. In Albania, Bulgaria, and Romania, the kings also ran dictatorship. There was less democratic experience and severe economic problems. Many of the Europeans saw one-man rule as the only way to protect instability. To get back on track, Fascist dictatorships had a will to use military aggression.Another reason that led to the start of WWII was the weakness of the League of Nations. To prove this weakness, the Japanese

Factors that Led to the Outbreak of WWII

1927 words - 8 pages and the Struggle for Supremacy." War in History 10.3 (2003): 365-367. Print. The events that took place since the end of World War I to the outbreak of World War II are highlighted. From the book, one can easily realise that it was not something spontaneous. Contrary to that, the sequence of events that preceded the outbreak seemed to send a clear message; that of an impending war. This book is instrumental in understanding what most parties had

It has been said that Tennessee Williams' plays are 'full of hate, anger and envy'. How far is this true in scene three of 'The Glass Menagerie'?

2492 words - 10 pages For a play to be full of anger, hate and envy implies that there is no room for other emotions such as happiness, sympathy and sadness. It implies that the play revolves around hateful, angry and envious characters and that the audience feels no other emotions reflected from the characters other than hate anger and envy. This is true to some extent. In scene three of 'The Glass Menagerie' (set during a blazing row), these emotions are expressed

How Far Was the Failure of the Weimar Democracy Responsible for Hitler’s Rise to Power?

1674 words - 7 pages How Far Was the Failure of the Weimar Democracy Responsible for Hitler's Rise to Power?The failure of the weakened Weimar Democracy was a significant factor that allowed for Hitler's unprecedented rise to power, but there were many other considerable events and circumstances that practically 'forced' Hitler into power and enabled him to assume leadership of the country at a dismal time of recovery and rebuilding. Other factors also responsible

Was It The Contribution Of Foreign Powers That Tipped The Balance Of The Spanish Civil War In Favour Of The Nationalists?

1459 words - 6 pages Whatever was in the minds of the Nationalists and the Republicans during the spring of 1936 it was certainly not a Civil War that lasted years rather than months. Most writers agree that once the war was underway its outcome depended on the foreign aid that the two sides received and how it related to internal and political considerations. It can therefore be said that the strong support from Germany and Italy put the Nationalists at an

March 2nd 2004 "The weakness of peace treaties is that they tend to address the past war rather than the future peace." With reference to WWI, show how far you concur with this assertion?

1145 words - 5 pages it would be impossible for them to ever act aggressively towards France again. Lloyd George's position was somewhere in between the two mentioned. He would like to see Germany punished but not to a degree of destruction. Also decided during the Versailles was that Germany would lose all her colonies, Poland would be recreated and there would be a "corridor" that would divide Germany and give Poland access to the Baltic Sea. The economic

“Alfred was not only a great warrior, but more importantly a nation builder”. Explain whether or not this quote is a true assesment of King Alfred the Great.

1031 words - 4 pages Untitled "Alfred was not only a great warrior, but more importantly a nation builder". Explain whether or not this quote is a true assesment of Alfred. King Alfred the Great was not only a great warrior, but more importantly a nation builder. I think this quote is a true assesment of Alfred and I will explain why in the pages that follow. Alfred was born into a royal family in 849 in Wantage (now in Oxfordshire

The causes and results of the Vietnam War were those of a post-colonial situation rather than of the Cold War. How far is this true from the period from 1953-80?

1986 words - 8 pages The Vietnam WarThe causes and results of the Vietnam War were those of a post-colonial situation rather than of the Cold War. How far is this true from the period from 1953-80?Aboud Al-AliAs one sets out to observe the underlying causes responsible for the outbreak of the Vietnam War, we notice that it could have a been a result of two main factors which are the Postcolonial situation in Vietnam and the Cold War which had contributed to the

"Of Mice and Men" by John Steinbeck - It is not Lennie, nor Crooks but Curley that is the most pathetic character in this novel

579 words - 2 pages Crooks but Curley. John Steinbeck has shown me that Curley is cold-hearted, cruel and pathetic.Some may think that Lennie is no doubt the most pathetic character in this novel but although Lennie may be slow, dimwitted and someone that is a grown man yet has the mind of a child this doesn't show how pathetic he is because Lennie has Mental disability and can't help it whereas Curley does not have any disability of the sort and can do something

The U.S led invasion of Iraq was not legally justified

3435 words - 14 pages law is that it does not enforce any penalties if a breach of the Article occurs, and thus no action towards the U.S has been taken for its breach of international This leaves doubts over the U.N's ability to enforce its laws among all nations equally, it's not acceptable that the more superior and powerful states have been able to lure their way around the law without being questioned and brought down to justice. In order for true impartial

"The Berlin Blockade was the turning point in the outbreak of the Cold War in the period 1945-1949." How far is this statement accurate?

2046 words - 8 pages seen in two events, namely the liberation of Japan and nuclear diplomacy. The atomic bomb allowed the US to liberate Japan without the help of the Soviets, causing the SU to lose its chance in having a foothold in East Asia. This led to worsening of relations as it went against the Yalta conference where it was agreed upon that the Soviets would have a hand in the liberation of Japan. Furthermore, the Soviets were not consulted regarding the

Similar Essays

How Far It Is True To Say That World War Ii Was The Result Of Hitler's Aggressive Policies?

1360 words - 5 pages ; this is the strict militarism, embedded in the minds of Germans ever since the times of Prussia, further developed by Wilhelm II and his Weltpolitik. It formed the necessary foundation on which Hitler’s anti Semitism was to be built and provided energy that merely came out in the form of fashionable political views. Anti Semitism on its own was however quite common around the world. In Germany, it resulted in the deaths of millions of Jews

How Far Is It True To Say That The Weimar Republic Was Doomed From Its Foundation?

1361 words - 5 pages How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from its foundation ?In November 1918, the first republic is declared in Germany. It is however unable to survive, and only 25 years later replaced by the dictatorship of Hitler. Indeed, the democrats lacked legitimacy right from the start. Directly after the war, army generals blamed the SPD as "November Criminals", accusing them of having betrayed the German people by signing the

"How Far Is It True To Say That The Weimar Republic Was Doomed From It's Foundation?"

2034 words - 8 pages government and the groups at the other pole of the political spectrum. However the basis of the conservative-nationalist opposition lied within the legend of Germany being stabbed-in-the-back which had been promoted throughout almost the entirety of the Weimar Republic. This should not have posed any real danger to the democracy since "it was General Ludendorff who had asked for an armistice while the Kaiser was still in power." and whatever governing

How Far Do You Agree That The Policy Of Appeasement Was The Main Cause Of Wwii?

1949 words - 8 pages Agreement and invaded the rest of Czechoslovakia in March 1939. Soon Britain and France realised that the policy of appeasement had only made matters worse but they could not go to war with Germany as at this point Germany was too powerful and had lots of land. Britain promised to declare war on Germany if Hitler invaded Poland. Failure of the League of Nations With the multiple causes of WWI, and many more ready for WWII, there was the League of