This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

It’s All In The Mind Essay

2585 words - 10 pages

It’s All in the Mind

What is a mind? How is it related to a body? Descartes answer was substance dualism. A person consists of an immaterial substance (mind/soul) attached to a material substance (a body). But this thesis fails a crucial test. An immaterial substance cannot move a body; therefore a mind cannot move a body. I shall assume that to have a mind one must first have a brain. This is a materialist perspective. Some weaknesses in this perspective will be described. I shall argue that minds do not necessarily exist as entities, that we nevertheless are aware of our own mental events and that we are aware that other people have similar events.

The mind cannot exist like a body or a collection of cells in a body. If it did somebody would have found it or at least given a rough description of its location. Also, things do not exist just because we can name them. We speak of unicorns but this does not make them exist. Just because we refer to something as a mind does not make it exist. Nevertheless, we are each aware of internal experiences in the most intimate way. Doubts and fears, the blue sky, the scent of flowers, all have an immediacy that is undeniable.

Now if mental events and brain events (i.e., physical events) are one and the same thing, then research into the mental events would be reduced to research into the brain. Even if mental events are taken to be properties of brain events then ultimately we are forced back to look to the physical for the explanation of the mental. This will get us nowhere for two reasons.

Firstly, a close inspection of a brain is doomed to be carried out at the third person perspective. If I could look at the bits of my own brain involved in any mental act I would register the firings taking place and say,”Ah that’s the redness of red!” I would still be unable to convey to anyone else the exact nature of this experience – how it feels for me. Secondly, if someone else were plugged in to my brain so that they registered all I saw and thought, then they would register all the mental acts as theirs. They would say, ‘That sky was blue.’ If pressed about the feeling of blueness as compared to their own feelings they would be forced to admit that this was their own feeling of blue.

Suppose two people were connected by an apparatus which allowed one person (A) to monitor the other’s (B’s) mental events – thoughts, feelings, sensory experiences and so on. Further suppose that the apparatus is graduated so that A can gradually increase the input of B’s thinking and experience into her own brain. Assuming that A was in a resting quietly in a cocoon, at what point does A become fully aware of the distinctive feel of B’s mental events? The question misses the point because A’s experiences can only ever be her own and no one else’s.

Let us imagine that by some advances in miniaturisation and virtual reality techniques we take a tour of someone’s brain. The guide points out a series of neurone...

Find Another Essay On It’s All in the Mind

Turbulence in the Mind Essay

2226 words - 9 pages therapy. Psychologist tend to try and avoid them even more than schizophrenics. Borderline Personality disorder is highly prominent in the world population today. The authors of the nationally bestselling classic “I Hate You- Don't Leave Me, Jerold J. Kreisman, MD, and Hal Straus stated “approximately 10 percent of psychiatric outpatients and twenty percent of inpatients, and between 15 and 20 percent of all patients seeking psychiatric care, are

The Iranian Nuclear Threat to Israeli National Security: Similar to Real Estate, It’s All About Location

1157 words - 5 pages . Iran countered this concern by stressing that their nuclear programme is solely for peaceful purposes only, and that they need this nuclear energy in order to help themselves develop economically. This skepticism reigned true in 2002, when an Iranian opposition group revealed secret nuclear activities in Iran, making the program public to the international community. This included the discovery of the construction of the uranium enrichment plant

The Door in our Mind

2043 words - 9 pages the proper effects on the child. This process is done naturally when the door in the child’s mind is wide open. However, there are cases when socialization is done in an unnatural way or not at all. Two primary examples of these cases of un-socialized children are cases of finding an isolated child or finding a child living a feral lifestyle. Isolated, means to be shut out from society. Feral, is when a child is raised by wild animals. It is

The Mind Body Connection in Learning

700 words - 3 pages without the body performing at an optimal level supporting the minds effort to learn. The learning environment can be very stressful and an adults life can be distracting, understanding the mind-body connection in learning can assist in accomplishing all learning related goals. Activities that require the body to move, a person’s diet, emotional health, and spiritual health all influence learning. Ratey (2001) says, “It has become obvious that

The Mind-body problem in Descartes Meditations

1402 words - 6 pages approach to information processing. Both make very clear that the mind interprets data in one way, shape, or form and, based on those interpretations, acts on them. These determinations are based on the knowledge we have been taught and gathered ourselves, of which Descartes believes is formed on the base layers of our intuition and if one piece is out of place or is a weak idea, then all of the layers of higher cognition may be faulty as well

The Subconscious Mind In Orwell’s 1984

1008 words - 4 pages If life is but a dream, do we ever wake up? Or are dreams just a fragment of our imagination? Do they hold any relevance to our inner most desires and thoughts? Revealing one's character or repressed feelings can be known by in our dreams. In the totalitarian society of the novel Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell, the main character Winston Smith relies on his subconscious mind to maintain his sanity.Winston works for the Party rewriting the

beginning with the end in mind

1719 words - 7 pages Before the author, Stephen Covey, explains what “beginning with the end in mind” means, he urges his reader to visualize their own end. By doing this, the reader self-evaluates their own life thus far. The end all judgment is death. In death, your life will be paraphrased and condensed into a manageable story—will that story reflect the person you anticipated? To ensure that when you die you have accomplished your goals while maintaining and

Forever in the Mind of a Soldier

972 words - 4 pages anything, though, the stockings were a talisman for him. They kept him safe.”(111-112) Mr. Henry Dobbins uses the smell of his girlfriend to keep his mind tied to home and to keep him safe. They are what helps keep him motivated in the war and perhaps give him a taste of bravery. While all the happiness and thoughts of home helps, each man will be traumatized by the things they witness. Almost every human endures some sort of trauma in their

Terrorism in the mind of god

2322 words - 9 pages with one of its images, that of terror. Now-a-days, terrorism can simply be described as the fight of the underdog, a harsh and in most cases, immoral way to prove a point physically and politically when all other options have failed.According to Mark Juergensmeyer, The first religious based terrorism group in the United States was the Klu Klux Klan, otherwise known as the K.K.K. The Klan thrived after the Civil War in the late 1860's. They were

Mind Control || The satire in "Citizen Kane"

534 words - 2 pages they need is do is smear dirt in the face of their opponent, and everyone votes for them. The elections become a popularity contest. In Citizen Kane, Kane was doing well in the elections because he was so well known through his own newspaper. During his speech, all he had to do was dump trash on his opponent, and the public was his. However, as soon as the public found out about his affair with Susan Alexander, his popularity dropped as quickly

Anger in the Body and Mind

710 words - 3 pages are going on in their brain? Taking a deeper look can help with understanding what being angry really means. Everybody gets angry at some point in their life. There’s really no way to get around it. For some, their heart starts racing, their palms get sweaty, and/or they feel a heated response to whatever set them off. Plenty of things can get someone angry all the way from someone spilling milk, to the anger felt after a loved one leaves or

Similar Essays

It’s All About The Drive Essay

838 words - 4 pages work more than the typical one hour per day that all students were afforded. The bug may be seen as another opportunity. However, weren’t other students at that school able to access the same facilities? Couldn’t they also have exploited the same bug that Joy exploited? I believe it was Joy’s passion for programming and desire to improve that led him to put in more hours than everyone else. “He wanted to learn” (46). He worked long hours and even

It’s All In An Hour’s Worth: Mrs. Mallard’s Awakening

2037 words - 9 pages Discrimination against women has been prevalent for centuries now. From the nurturing/emotional stereotype, housewife status, lower pay in the workforce, to sexual abuse and more, women have suffered it all. However, Kate Chopin goes to the heart of what women have been deprived of most, a personal right without which freedom would have no meaning or value: self assertion, reflection, and independence. According to Harold Bloom, “Chopin offers

All In A State Of Mind

677 words - 3 pages Thompson 2Thompson 1Amber ThompsonProfessor NokesEnglish 11018 September 2014All in the State of MindSetting can be defined as a specific or general time or place; however, in Fahrenheit 451 it's more broadly established as a state of mind instead. A world of war, violence, and death is all the characters of Fahrenheit 451 know about their own setting. Some members of society choose to establish their own setting, some adapt to the setting at

1984 & It’s Presence In The Modern World

997 words - 4 pages history of depriving its citizens of personal liberties. One of these violations being the Military Commission's Act. When Obama was running for president for his first run, he made promises to “shut down Guantanamo”. Early in his career as president, Obama places a executive order to halt commissions at Guantanamo. This order allows the review of all people in Guantanamo. However, only a few months later after pressure from officials of both the