It's Time For A More Responsible Approach To Animal Research, Testing, And Experimentation

1442 words - 6 pages

The debate about using animals for medical testing has been ongoing for years. The struggle is usually between extreme animal rights activists and scientists. The animal rights activists believe animals should never be used for research, and the scientists believe any use of animals is acceptable. Listed below are factual historical accounts of animal use, statistics, and arguments against the use of animals.
In ancient Greece animals were used for the study of life science. To learn about body functions scientists would cut into a live animal to observe vital parts in action. “Animals have been used for centuries to help researchers understand the various organs of the body, and their functions as well as to hone their surgical skills.” (jhsph). In the nineteenth century a rise in biomedical research subsequently increased the number of animals used in experiments. In the 1970’s the animal rights movement erupted on a grand scale. Bentham's question of whether or not animals suffer became the rallying cry of the animal protection movement at the time. The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in Great Britain and in the United States was created in the nineteenth century. Animal use skyrocketed again after World War II with developments in the chemical industry and increased government regulation.
Millions of animals are used each year for medical research, product testing and education in the United States. The animals listed below range from the highest to lowest used animals for scientific experiments; mice, rats, birds, rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, "farm animals" such as pigs and sheep, dogs, primates and cats. The most common of these, rats and mice, are not protected under the Animal Welfare Association. No accurate figures are kept on the exact number of rats and mice used regardless of the fact they make up eighty-five to ninety percent of all animals used (hsus).
The most common arguments against animal use testing question the morality, necessity and scientific validity of these studies. In other words, do we have the right to perform such tests, need such tests, and whether these tests provide us with any useful information?
The moral aspects of the animal use testing argument involve the view of animals as sentient beings. It is argued, we have a responsibility toward animals and a moral obligation to not cause them pain or distress (jhsph). Singer argues "...experimenters often seek to justify experimenting on animals by claiming the experiments lead us to discoveries about humans; if this is so, the experimenter must agree human and non-human animals are similar in crucial respects (p. 65)." Singer challenges his opponents to the hypothetical question "would [they] be prepared to perform their experiments on orphaned humans with severe and irreversible brain damage if this were the only way to save thousands? (p. 67)" Singer
Another argument is necessity, which is closely linked to...

Find Another Essay On It's Time for a More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

The Cruelty of Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

1391 words - 6 pages The Cruelty of Animal Testing and the Need for Alternative Methods In his book Inhumane Society: The American Way of Exploiting Animals, Dr. Michael W. Fox estimates that twenty-five to thirty-five million animals are used in the United States each year for laboratory testing and research (58). Research involving tests done on animals is unnecessary and cruel. More humane methods of research need to be employed. Fox states that animal

It's Time for More Bible and Less Welfare

1940 words - 8 pages It's Time for More Bible and Less Welfare      Government has considered and tried many plans for dealing with poverty in the United States, from all different points of view-welfare, workfare, charities, economic interference, and the like. There is one method, however, which has fallen out of popularity in this age. This is the biblical method.   What God says about the poor The Christian, or biblical, view of poverty is

It's Time to Sin More, and Hate Less

1063 words - 4 pages   It's Time to Sin More, and Hate Less     My soul is embedded with classic Catholic-sin like crimson rubies buried in a sandbox. And I'm not just talking about eating two helpings of double-decker chocolate cake (although I do that, too) - I swear, I lie, I mock the Bible, I use the Lord's name in vain (to name a few). I love the very term "sin" - never has there been a three-letter word with so much power, such

It's Time to Limit Animal Rights

1091 words - 4 pages . Torturing or harming animals for no specific purpose certainly seems wrong. Any pain or death inflicted on an animal should only be done when there is a practical need, and the pain inflicted should be minimized to the fullest extent possible. I could even listen to a convincing argument that animals always have a right to a natural life, if such an argument existed. However, I think that the method for granting rights to living things is more

It's Time for Mandatory Drug Testing in Major League Baseball

1390 words - 6 pages mass, promote aggressiveness, and increase body weight”(“Anabolic Steroids”). By 1990 Rick Helling, a pitcher for the Texas Rangers stood up at a meeting of the Executive Board of the Major League Baseball Player Association and reported the issue of players using steroids. “There is a problem with steroids,” Helling said “"It’s happening. It's real. And it's so prevalent that guys who aren't doing it are feeling pressured to do it because they're

Animal Experimentation and Research

2622 words - 10 pages is available, it should be used as often as possible. With continued research and practice, we may come to an age of technology where animals will no longer be needed for experimentation. Until then, consider the rats that have saved more lives than 911. Is that a powerful enough of a reason for animal experimentation to continue? Perhaps with time and education, this issue will be able to be solved and a general understanding and agreement

Alternatives to Animal Experimentation

2951 words - 12 pages their own programs to validate alternatives. Although some critics are doubtful that replacement methods will ever be able to take the place of hands-on animal experimentation, the struggle continues for avid animal rights supporters to find alternative testing procedures. The question of whether animals have the right to be protected from such research experiments is a hard one to answer, and has been disputed for many years. The question

Animal Experimentation in Scientific Research

2561 words - 10 pages chemicals in the future. It is only a matter of time until alternative research modes will outnumber and be more successful than animal experimentation. With animal testing currently being the favored means of research for most companies, there are few regulations for this type of research that is meant to regulate the care and use of animals in laboratories. The Animal Welfare Act, AWA, is currently the only federal law in America that manages

It's Time for Girls and Boys to Plays Sports Together

1146 words - 5 pages It's Time for Girls and Boys to Plays Sports Together On the athletic field, in the gym, or on the ice, there have always been standards for the athletes to follow. These standards range from what type of athletic equipment is not only necessary but appropriate, to who can play when, where, and how. This last standard is the one that is being challenged the most; can men play not only on women’s teams, but can they also participate in

We Must Stop Animal Research and Animal Testing

2051 words - 9 pages What if I told you that more than 100 million animals are killed each year due to animal testing? What if I told you that these animals are burned, crippled, abused and poisoned on a regular basis? What if I told you that in order to obtain your favorite shampoo, hand sanitizer, lotion, etc. that innocent animals must be tortured? Throughout history animal research and experimentation has played a key role in scientific benefit

It's Time to Stop Waiting for Superman

1114 words - 4 pages film, we are also acquainted with Emily, an 8th grader who attends a middle-class high school in the affluent Silicon Valley. She views Summit Preparatory Charter High School as the stepping stone to her academic success by providing her with more opportunities and increases her chances of getting into university. Lastly, we are presented with Bianca, Bianca, a Harlem kindergartner whose mother Nakia pays $500 every month for her to attend the

Similar Essays

A More Responsible Approach To Animal Research, Testing, And Experimentation

1628 words - 7 pages It’s Time for a More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation The debate about using animals for medical testing has been raging for years. The struggle always seems to be between extremist animal rights activists who believe that animals should never be used for research, and scientists who believe that any use of animals is acceptable. There are a growing number who argue that there must be a reasonable

We Need More Animal Research, Testing, And Experimentation

1477 words - 6 pages We Need More Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation   A life can be taken or created in a matter of seconds and with that has come the miracles of modern medicine. People have come to expect science to save lives, prevent illness, relieve suffering and improve the quality of life. The means of curing, treating and preventing diseases are not achieved by magic or accident. Medical advances are gained through years of intensive

Let's Put An End To Animal Research, Testing, And Experimentation

2006 words - 8 pages uncounted millions of rats and mice are experimented upon and die each year, as living fodder for the great human scientific machine. Some would say that animal research is an integral part of progress; unfortunately, this is often true. On the whole, animal testing is a necessary evil that should be reduced and eliminated whenever possible. Since the time of Aristotle, animals have been used to further human progress. When Galen pioneered the

Needless Animal Research, Testing, And Experimentation Is Wrong

964 words - 4 pages Needless Animal Experimentation is Wrong   If penicillin had been tested on guinea pigs, it might never have reached the public. It is lethal to guinea pigs, deactivates the blood system of rabbits and is deadly to cats ("Bio-Medical Research"). Scientists are pushing for more experiments regardless of the cost to the animal's life. "One expense is the involvement of killing animals in the pursuit of a pine-scented air freshener"(Vergoth