It's Time To Tear Down The Chinese Firewall

1006 words - 4 pages

The great firewall of China is a manifestation of the oppressive regime that denies the Chinese people their basic rights to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness. The recent action taken by Google to leave China is a move in the right direction. However, Google, like other U.S firms in China, played a deceitful role in abetting the injustice perpetrated by the Chinese government. Google as a company enjoyed the rights guaranteed by the U.S constitution, while they helped an oppressive regime deny it to billions of citizens. Furthermore, abetting an oppressive regime suppress and subjugate its citizens is unethical from any moral standpoint. Therefore, it is a moral imperative to help bring down the firewall and give China access to free and fair information.
However, considering different ethical theories, the issue at hand is certainly a grey area. The three main ethical theories, ethical relativism, utilitarianism and deontological, come into a clash. It is understandable that Google, as a company, tried to tap into a wider market of more than a billion. However, it is not a morally commendable act. Helping others perpetrate an unjust act is never morally acceptable. Although not practical, the moral high ground would be to help Chinese citizens fight against the firewall. Instead of stooping to the demands of the Chinese government, U.S firms should wage a war for free information. If all the U.S firms unite in fighting the firewall by setting up proxy servers, outside of China, the great firewall will soon crumble.
The solution of stopping business with China altogether is a permissible act because it prevents the firms from participating in the wrongdoing. The other solution of continuing and complying with the Chinese policies is impermissible. It is a good business strategy to tap into the Chinese market of more than a billion people. Even commendable from a deontological perspective, it is the duty of the company to maximize revenue at all costs.
Ethical relativism could also be used to justify the participation of U.S firms to comply with the Chinese government. Each culture has its own moral guidelines. Chinese culture and values differ from that of the western civilization by a wide margin; hence, such a firewall can be seen as imperative and justifiable. One can certainly argue that the Chinese government has the best interests of its citizens. Hence, a strict regulation of information is needed to better the condition of Chinese people of more than a billion. The increasing economic prowess of China in recent years does shade light to such an idea. However, the double faceted policies that U.S firms exhibit by working in unison with the Chinese government are not easily justified.
On one hand, Google has the motto of “do no evil” and promotes free and open policies for information interchange. On the other hand, it participated in the unjust perpetrated by the Chinese government which is hypocritical. It is a moral...

Find Another Essay On It's Time to Tear Down the Chinese Firewall

It's Time to Pick Favorites! Essay

1046 words - 5 pages woman that should be looked up to. In conclusion, my three favorite characters from The Canterbury Tales: The Prologue is the Knight, the Pardoner, and Wife Bath. The Knight is my favorite character out of the three because he is the most honorable and respectful knight in this tale. The pardoner, although greedy, reminds me of the selfish part of myself which reminds me to keep myself in check and put myself before others a majority of the time

It's Time to Legalize Drugs Essay

3019 words - 12 pages and expecting different results.” Yet despite the failures of the current policy in deterring drug use that is just what the government is choosing to do. It’s time to consider a different approach to the drug issue. An approach that will address drug use in an innovative way while solving the problems which drug prohibition has created while also bringing societal, health, and economic benefits but most importantly it will also give back the

It's Time to Declare English the Official Language

1348 words - 5 pages It's Time to Declare English the Official Language "In no way would having English as the official language intrude upon anyone's private life, business, or day-to-day living. Official English applies only to the conduct of government business." -S.I. Hayakawa America today is a melting pot of different societies. Everywhere, in every city and in every state, there

Privacy - It's Time to Control the Use of Electronic Surveillance

1633 words - 7 pages It's Time to Control the Use of Electronic Surveillance       How would you feel if every move you make, every word you say, every number you dial on the telephone, could easily be accessed or monitored by just about anyone in the world? Well, chances are that you and me and many others are currently, or have been, victims of this infringement on privacy. With today's ever growing technology, there is little one can do to ensure

It's Time to Toughen the Laws on Teen Drivers

1235 words - 5 pages to do or say, they are more willing to do it just for the sake of "fitting in."So can teenagers' behaviors be changed? Larry Murdo, a writer with "The FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin", writes on the prevention of teen driving accidents, and sites an article from the San Francisco Chronicle which says that, "when a teenage audience perceives a safety message. . . even when presented by their favorite sports icon, they summarily discount it's content

It's Time To Lower the Legal Drinking Age

2104 words - 8 pages slows down the body reactions and the brain therefore alcohol is considered to be a depressant. The effects of alcohol can impair your vision, slurred speech and unconsciousness leading to death. “In 2002, 2.3% of Americans 18 and older surveyed reported alcohol-impaired driving, including 3% of 18-20 year olds and 4.1% of 21-34 year olds” (MADD). In many states there is a certain amount of alcohol that can be in the driver’s system. In Texas the

It's Time To Break the Fast-Food Addiction

2467 words - 10 pages unsatisfying meals.  The deadly tag team of fats and sugars from fast foods damage weight regulators in your brain so that you have a harder time losing the weight that you put on from eating there the last time.  The younger generation’s obesity rates are not a joke, and neither is depression, fast food addiction, or malnutrition.  “The FTC found that in 2006, food companies were spending some $1.6 billion a year to market products specifically

It's Time to Update the Unified Command Plan (UCP)

1477 words - 6 pages The Unified Command Plan (UCP), as originally described in the “Outline Command Plan” of 1946, established in the National Security Act of 1947 and later amended by the Department of Defense Reorganization Act of 1958, sets forth basic guidance to all combatant commanders (COCOMs). The UCP also establishes combatant command missions, responsibilities, and force structure; delineates geographic areas of responsibility for geographic combatant

It's Time to Stop Child Trafficking

2003 words - 8 pages child trafficking by we are known. Nowadays, most countries have better laws to protect their own citizens. Moreover, as time goes by, people are receiving a higher quality education and are more protected by the state and government, so it would make sense that there would be fewer criminals involved in human trafficking. However, the UNICEF website shows that “Every year, thousands of Beninese children and 1.2 million young people across the

It's Time to Allow Medical Marijuana

509 words - 2 pages It's Time to Allow Medical Marijuana Think of the word cannabis. What immediately comes into your mind? Druggies out on the streets, totally out of it and swaggering around like drunks? Many people are under these false images. Cannabis users are classed as the lowest of the low, drug abusers and criminals. Well, here is the truth about Cannabis. It is also known as Marijuana, Dope, Grass, Ganja, Weed, Puff, Gear, and Hash, is a

It's Time to Stop Global Warming

1296 words - 5 pages It's Time to Stop Global Warming (Minor Formatting Problem) Global warming is cused by the "greenhouse effect". The importance of the greenhouse effect was just conceived in the mid-twentieth century. 'For billions of years, cosmic forces shaped Earth, and land and air coevolved at an almost inconceivably slow pace to create a climate in which human beings and other creatures could flourish.' (Franscesca Lyman). Now, for the first time

Similar Essays

Society And The Media Build Up Of Celebrities To Tear Them Down

768 words - 3 pages Woods, Shaquille O’Neil, Charlie Sheen, Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston, Mary J. Blige, Barack and Michelle Obama, Chris Brown, and the King siblings are just examples of how we build these people up only to tear down all of their accomplishments. Tiger has been in the media every day, but not for being the best athlete of the decade. His affairs, mistresses and the fact he made millions from endorsements is the focus of the media. There have

It's Time To End The Drug War

2727 words - 11 pages It's Time to End the Drug War Uhh, uhhh B.I.G., P-O, P-P-A No info, for the, DEA Federal agents mad cause I'm flagrant Tap my cell, and the phone in the basement -Notorious B.I.G. lyrics from “Mo’ Money, Mo’ Problems” In Christopher Wallace’s (a.k.a. Notorious BIG) “Mo’ Money, Mo’ Problems”, the late rapper from Brooklyn mentions his run in with the police earlier in his life. Christopher Wallace came to be known as arguably the

It's Time To Update The Catholic Mass

1625 words - 7 pages billion people around the world are apart of the Catholic Church, making it the largest organized religion (Catholic Data, Catholic Statistics, Catholic Research). Active Catholics practice their faith by attending mass every Sunday to worship the Lord. This time taken out of the week should be a time for Catholics to reflect and pray to the Lord; however, many people find this difficult when much time is spent speaking and listening to words and

It's Time To Lower The Working Age To 13

608 words - 2 pages saving at an early age. Therefore, if they got a job at the age they were at now, they’d be on their way to college by the time they graduate high school. Or, another example would be, if a teen wanted to get their first car on their sixteenth birthday. As you may know, many teens don’t get things handed to them on a silver platter, so they’d have to buy that car themselves. They might be old enough to drive, but they just turned the legal