This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

It’s A Hard Knock Life For Them

1714 words - 7 pages

In both Katherine Porter’s “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” and Eudora Welty’s “Why I Live in the P.O.”, the main characters deal with family members they frankly do not like. Due to both of their being jilted by men, they are full of resentment and anger causing these women to leave their families on bad terms. Porter and Welty are presenting through the character’s flashbacks and memories that we should pick our battles wisely when it comes to our families because one day they will be gone and, some of us might miss our deceased loved ones, like Granny from “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall”, or be filled with a hatred towards them, like Sister from “Why I Live in the P.O.”.
Porter and Welty both provide flashbacks and memories in their stories to help the reader see what Granny and Sister’s lives were like before everything fell apart with their families. Porter’s “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” is packed of the flashbacks and memories of Granny’s past relationships with the only people she loves even though are all dead. She reminisced about her youthful days when she was strong, independent, and with John, the man who stood her up at the altar and died when Granny was young. She still loves him and wants to see him, but “John would be looking for a young woman with the peaked Spanish comb in her hair and the painted fan,” (Porter 81) she believed he would not recognize her. Granny also lost one of her daughters, Hapsy along with her newborn who also died. When Granny brought those memories to the surface a fog of darkness, clouds reality and she gets lost and recalls that, “there was the day, the day, but a whirl of dark smoke rose and covered it, crept up and over into the bright field where everything was planted so carefully in orderly rows” (Porter 82). These vivid memories are what egged on Granny’s anger and attitude towards her still living caretaker/daughter Cornelia, whom she did not like. She believed that Cornelia is always talking about her and that “She always kept things secret in such a public way,” (Porter 80). Even though Cornelia cared for her mom and loved her tremendously, Granny’s mind was consumed with mournful thoughts and explains why Granny feels and acts the way she does towards her. She believed Cornelia was “so good and dutiful that I’d like to spank her,” (porter 80) then imagined that, “she saw herself spanking Cornelia and making a fine job of it,” (Porter 80). Cornelia’s dutiful help went unnoticed, because Granny did not want her, she deeply longed for her deceased grandchild and daughter, Hapsy. The sudden death of the two caused Granny to experience upsetting illusions during her moments leading up to death. In fact, while she was being spoken by Doctor Harry she zoned out and thoughts had seemed to have Granny in a comatose, but she was only dreaming, and in this dream Granny was able to see Hapsy with her grandchild. Granny “had to go through many rooms to find Hapsy standing with a baby on her...

Find Another Essay On It’s a Hard Knock Life for Them

It’s a Hard Enough Life (An analysis of Alfred Tennyson’s life influences on his poetic work)

1086 words - 5 pages Being rich and famous doesn’t mean that you are happy. In fact some of the poorest people in the world can be the happiest. For one, money doesn’t buy happiness; happiness is sought through a person’s feelings. In the life of Alfred Lord Tennyson, even though he holds expanses in the rich world, his life is ruled by unhappiness. According to the website, “” Alfred’s early life was consumed with grief and anxiety. His father suffered

Women in a Man’s World: Why it’s Hard for Women to Get Ahead in Sportscasting

1600 words - 6 pages the people that apply. These odds are discouraging but to hear them every time you admit to wanting to be a sportscaster, it feels even worse. Although ESPN hiring rate for women seems to be the highest in the sports business, it’s very hard to get there if you have no encouragement from peers. Authors Marie Hardin and Stacie Shain explain this phenomenon once women get hired, how discouraging it can be in the work place when your peer’s don’t

When it’s Time for a Remedial Massage

711 words - 3 pages sessions. If you have these six conditions, it’s time to call a reliable remedial massage therapist. Studies have shown that a therapeutic remedial massage can effectively treat these conditions and many more. A back pain may have been bothering you for a while now or arthritis may have been sporadically appeared in your life. A simple massage won’t ease your pain. A customised remedial massage that will treat both the symptom and the cause of these disorders will leave you feeling relaxed and allow you to enjoy a pain-free future.

It’s Time for America to Build a Moonbase

2025 words - 8 pages It’s Time for America to Build a Moonbase On May 25, 1961, Congress met in a joint session to hear the American president, John F. Kennedy, address them in a speech he referred to as a second State of the Union. In his speech, the young president geared America for a race that would send men to the moon. Kennedy challenged America to “take longer strides” and to take a “leading role in space achievement, which, in many ways, may

A Good Man Is Hard to Find: Selfishness That Doomed Them All

1131 words - 5 pages Selfishness occurred many times throughout Flannery O’Conner’s A Good Man Is Hard to Find. Every character except for the baby show signs of selfishness, some more severe than others. The worst person in this story is the grandmother. She is the center of all the conflicts in the story and were many of them ended. Other characters have selfish parts but those have a minor effect on the story. Without selfishness in A Good Man Is Hard to Find

“Purely Mercenary”: A Study of Capital in It’s a Wonderful Life

858 words - 4 pages Although they are staged in two different continents and published nearly one hundred years apart, A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens and It’s a Wonderful Life are remarkably similar works in plot and purpose. In A Christmas Carol, Ebenezer Scrooge, an old miser, is visited by the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future on Christmas Eve. These spirits ultimately help Scrooge transform himself from a stingy, unwelcoming person into a more

Robert Frost: A Hard Life, Biography and Reflection

1503 words - 6 pages and married her soon after.(Frost, Robert 24). Now that Frost was responsible for Elinor's well-being he decided to take on two jobs. He taught and continued to farm. They had six children. The sons were Elliott (b.1896-d.1900) and Carol (b.1902-d.1940) and their daughters were Lesley (b.1899-d.?) Irma (b.1903-d.?), Marjorie (b.1905-d.1934), and Elinor Bettina (b.1907-d.1907) ( the continuing hard times and a family to

Life is Hard, Without a Diploma it is Harder

1613 words - 7 pages current technology are not able to compete with those who completed high, nor are they able to take advantage of the programs that are necessary to make a profit. Children who make the unwise decision to drop out of school when they reach the age of sixteen, are not competent enough to make adult decisions that could alter their way of life completely. The decisions that they make could also destroy their chance at prosperity for themselves and

"The Good Earth" essay. A Chinese book of a farmer's hard life working on the land

1035 words - 4 pages puts the dead body by a grave. Wang's uncle and 2 other men cometo buy Wang's land for some money, but he refuses and instead sells somefurniture.Chapter 10: Wang and his family leave for the south. It is very hard for them towalk and Wang's has to carry his father. A man tells Wang about the 'firewagon'or train going to the south and they decide to take it.Chapter 11: Wang and his family get on the train with many others. Wang buyssome food for

A reflective paper on the four functions of management. And applying them to real life

1102 words - 4 pages manager we can learn that they are carried out continually in society and it is in fact managers that implement them. French managerial scholar Henri Fayol identified the roles of a successful manager. The "process approach" identifies these. It states that managers perform four main roles, those of planning, organizing, leading and controlling (Robbins, Coulter, 2003). Every management decision is a result of the application of one or more of

"The Life and Hard Times of Grantly Marshall" A fictional story

617 words - 2 pages Could anyone imagine having no money, few friends, and no chance to succeed in life? Well, for one individual this situation is all too real.Grantly Reed Marshall, a 18-year-old high school student from Franklin Square, Ohio, had big dreams but little money. Grantly had reached a crucial time in his life. He desperately wanted to attend college. Grantly's siblings were much smarter than he was, as were his parents. None of his classmates

Similar Essays

It’s A Hard Knock Life Essay

947 words - 4 pages The Victorian Age in England was a time when crime was rampant, people were starving, and life was generally difficult. In these times, there were really only two social classes, the upper class, and the lower class. Everyone in the lower class had troubles, but children had it the hardest. While most everyone had a difficult life, it was worst for children; forcing them towards crime and leading them into the arms of prison. People who

It’s A Hard Knock Life For The Female Elites In The Great Gatsby

813 words - 4 pages “It’s a hard-knock life for us!” cries the orphans of Hudson Street’s Home for Girls in the Broadway musical Annie. Indeed, it is a tough existence for the women in F. Scott Fitzgerald's timeless novel, The Great Gatsby, but most specifically for the main character, Daisy. Throughout the novel, Daisy faces the choice between the fantasy life with her love, Gatsby, or a stable but superficial marriage to Tom. Daisy's fortunate wealth and

Is It A Hard Knock Life?

1269 words - 5 pages Is It A Hard Knock Life? In her hit movie Annie, Aileen Quinn sings “No one’s there when your dreams at night get creepy, no one cares if you grow or if you shrink, no one dries when your eyes get wet and weepy…it’s the hard knock life!”(Strouse). Adoption may not always be roses, but it is better to have a loving family one day than to have no family at all. Therefore, adoption is a wonderful opportunity for many families and children

"Hard Knock Life" Essay

848 words - 3 pages country, to the store or fast-food shop? The only form of transportation my family owned was a broken down car that we could hardly ever get up and running. As an early aged teen, I found myself involved in smoking pot. The pleasure quickly lost its simplicity when I couldn't go one day without a joint. My problem intensified to the question of getting money for this horrible habit instead of my every day life. Some of my friends