There have been numerous opinions on what would be considered a success o Jamestown settlement. As we know Jamestown was one of the “late comers” colonies developed in the New World. As time goes on archeologist and those who specialized in studying the colonial times has continued to express their opinion of a successful colony. Professor Edward S. Morgan historian at Yale University and Professor Karen Kupperman analysis of The Jamestown Project is a perfect example these archeologist. Morgan and Kupperman shared different views and resulted in difference in opinion on the success of Jamestown.
Author Edward S. Morgan described the Jamestown colony as a group that had many opportunities for success but failed to succeed due to their own negligence. Edward Morgan describes Captain Christopher Newport’s experience to the new world as he journeys through the coast of the what is now known as North America. According to author Morgan, Captain Newport was able to survey the land and establish English rule through communication with the neighboring indian tribes. Morgan describes the attack from the Powhatans on the English tribe of Jamestown. He exclaims jamestown was attacked and viciously forced into an uneasy truths with the natives. Throughout the early inhabitants of the Englishmen in the new world, Morgan believes many mistakes were made in their efforts to develop a relationship with the Native Americans. As a result of constant fighting between the Native Americans and the English Settlers neither side was able to plant crops or preserve needed material to survive the harsh cold weather that was soon to come. Nearly all of the Englishmen died off due to starvation and was left with about sixty settlers out of the original five hundred.
The Englished continued to send over more and more settlers to replace the deceased; the Englishmen learned to live through the exploitation of the agricultural skills of the Indians. Governor De la warr had fallen sick due to winter conditions and was replaced by Sir Thomas Dale who recognized the Englishman's dependency on the Native Americans agricultural skills. Sir Thomas Dale observed the Indians knowledge of the dependency of the English; but, choose not to flee because the land surrounding Jamestown was considered too valuable to Native Americans. Morgan continued to explain the experience of settlers at Jamestown which ended in the eruptive discovery of the cash crop tobacco ten years later which gained a huge amount of economic success for the English. changing the manner in which English depended upon the Indians.
Author Karen Ordahl Kupperman describes Englishmen and women as a success story through the trial and error theory. Kupperman states the English came across numerous difficulties that nearly wiped them out but has always managed to rise above the challenges they faced. She exclaims the common view of the Englishmen are untrue and misleading she believes the colonist were just simply...