This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Japan And The A Bombs, Was It Really Necessary? A Reaction To Paul Fussell's 1981 Article, "Thank God For The Atom Bomb."

715 words - 3 pages

On August 6, 1945, an American plane dropped one of the world's first nuclear bombs on Hiroshima. Three days later, another plane dropped a second bomb on the city of Nagasaki. These two bombs killed roughly 200,000 Japanese civilians, and, according to Paul Fussell, they ended the war, but did they really? Were the nuclear bombs actually necessary? The answer to this question is, undoubtedly, no. The United States had no right or reason to cast the world into the age of nuclear warfare, and doing so was wrong not only politically and militarily, but also morally.Politically, the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki should never have happened. Fussell, of course, fails to mention this, but the Japanese government began seeking peace as early as April 1945, their only stipulation being that the Emperor, who they feared might be humiliated, or even tried as a war criminal, was not to be touched. The United States, however, was out to "avenge Pearl Harbor." They ignored the Japanese governments' continual attempts to end the war and, keeping the whole affair secret from the American public, kept the war going, determined on "unconditional surrender." Forcing the Japanese into unconditional surrender, however, was not the purpose of the atomic bombs; they were used to establish the dominance of the United States. Using the bombs against Japan before the Soviet Union had even entered the war was supposed to prove America's power and determination; also, they wanted to observe the effects of the bombs in an actual attack.From a military standpoint, Japan was defeated by June 1945. The country's Imperial Navy, air force, and land parties were almost nonexistent, and, due to American air raids, most of the cities were in ruins. Not only was the transportation system near collapse, but millions of people were homeless and starving. Fussell tries to say that the Japanese would fight to the death, but in actuality the Japanese people were in no condition to defend themselves.Dropping the A-bombs was wrong not only politically and militarily, but also morally and ethically, though Fussell waves this notion away, implying that the United States had more important...

Find Another Essay On Japan and the A-Bombs, was it really necessary? A reaction to Paul Fussell's 1981 article, "Thank God for the Atom Bomb."

Was it necassary to drop the bombs on Japan in 1945? YES!

840 words - 3 pages question was it necessary to drop the atomic bombs on Japan?. Although many civilians were killed, the bombs were necessary tools to end the war. The most obvious reason for the dropping of the Atomic Bombs was to end the war and minimize both American Troops casualties and Japanese civilian casualties. The Americans had weighed up the casualties from previous battles and rightly decided the bombs must be dropped. The American authorities saw

This is a reaction paper i did for my speech class and the purpose was to inform someone about a time in my life that really affected me. there is no title for it. enjoy :D

664 words - 3 pages through it. The relationship was young, only been dating for 9 months, but it felt like i knew him forever. But like the saying goes " Good things must come to an end".In any mutual partnerships, there are its ups and downs. Everyone gets into little petty arguments or discussions that they try to avoid. i still remember "The talk" all too well. It was in the summer before I began my junior year of high school. At that time he was finishing up at

Was It Necessary to Drop the Atomic Bomb to End World War II?

781 words - 4 pages Professor Robert James Maddox who says that the atomic bomb was necessary to force the Japanese army to finally surrender and avoid a costly and heavy casualty war with Japan. The Japanese army is very fierce and will continue to fight regardless of how many casualties they have. It would take an extreme act such as dropping an atomic bomb to really drive the point across that the United States is serious. I believe the atomic bomb proves how

Was Truman Justified in dropping the atom bomb?

2312 words - 9 pages decision was, a brief history of the bomb itself is necessary. The Manhattan project, the United States code name for the program developing the atomic bomb, began in 1940 . The project was led, in all scientific manners, by Dr. J. Oppenheimer, an American physicist, who ironically became very opposed to its use and campaigned actively against the creation of the hydrogen bomb . The estimated costs of the Manhattan project, through 1945, are $2

Was Truman right to drop the atomic bomb on Japan?

1307 words - 5 pages atomic bomb was just tested and people didn't now what are effects of it and Truman didn't know about it a lot but he believed this to stop Japan's leaders and make Japan surrender because from the evidence here we now that Truman didn't like that way that women and children had to suffer all this bombing which gave very bad causes for the next long time of period.ConclusionIn my opinion Truman was right to drop the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagarski

Was the Bomb Dropped on Japan Justified?

637 words - 3 pages Japan before Hiroshima was inadequate. One flaw of the United State's warning issued to Japan was their failure to inform of Russia's possible invasion. By the end of the war, Soviet Union had rebuilt their army and was looking to gain land. If Japan had been aware of the Soviet's plan to invade, then they would have known a loss is unavoidable. With a weakened navy and air force, it was almost impossible for Japan to win in a two front war against

Decisions to Drop the Bombs on Japan

850 words - 3 pages after all is said and done America was simply defending her land and right for freedom. America was under attack in a war fought on foreign soil. No one wanted the war to be brought on American soil and all American's wanted the war to be over to assure safety of the American people. The atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were necessary to bring the war with Japan to an immediate halt. Dropping of the A-bomb took thousands of

Is it really necessary to use gender-neutral language? A short essay discussing the importance of non-sexist language

550 words - 2 pages Is it really necessary to use gender-neutral language?It is very important to use non-sexist language, even if a person does not have any discriminative intentions at all. Everyone, consciously or not, tends to assign masculine gender to terms, such as "man", even when this word is used for "human beings". "Man", amongst other expressions or grammatical constructions, should be avoided.Every language reflects the prejudices of the society in

Was the 1950s really a good time for the people?

939 words - 4 pages hardly achieve recognition as leaders of the free world if it practiced segregation at home (Norton et al 808). Segregation laws and the South's unwillingness to cooperate with the Supreme Court's rulings set back a lot of action that was taking place on behalf of the Civil Rights Revolution. Even with the President Truman's support, white supremacist groups, such as the Ku Klux Klan, and other conservative folk, set the fight for equal rights

How successful was the prohibition and was it necessary?

1458 words - 6 pages , beverages, cooking, and as a way of making a living. It is quite difficult to try to change something rooted into American culture with just a law. Certain recipes require alcohol as an ingredient; women who served these types of food to their families are technically breaking the law. But for these people to change the recipe because of a law would be considered depriving them of their cultural rights. Alcohol was a way for people to earn a living

The Atomic Bombs in Japan

1708 words - 7 pages atomic bombs] were done to save 125,00 youngsters on the American side and 125,000 on the Japanese side from getting killed and that is what it did. It probably also saved a half million youngsters on both sides from being maimed for life.” (“Harry Truman on Dropping of the Atomic Bomb”). As President Truman asserts, the bombs technically did save lives as the estimated number of death casualties of American soldiers was approximately 5,000,000

Similar Essays

Was The Atomic Bomb On Japan Necessary

1570 words - 6 pages bombs has created a mass uproar of controversy, regarding the justification of the use of nuclear weapons and/or the primary necessity of it. The dropping of the atomic bomb may be referred to as the incident. When justifying the pointless and irrational decision to drop the atomic bomb, the following situations have to be analyzed: the surrendering of the Japanese, what condition Japan (the country as a whole) was in at the time, and the views of

Was Is Necessary To Drop The A Bomb On Hiroshima?

565 words - 2 pages it was necessary to drop the devastating blast in World War II. Although it is hard to predict what would have happened if it wasn't, it is almost certain that the casualties that would result in continuing battles would have been greater. Thus I strongly believe that the Atomic bomb was necessary. USA had been fighting a fierce war with Japan since 1941 and the morale as well as the resources of the military was extremely low. It was an

How The Atom Bomb Was Developed         The Events Leading To

1153 words - 5 pages Hahn and Strassmann of Germany learned that they had split the uranium atom. Lise Meitner and O.R. Frisch identified the splitting as nuclear fission. Excitement was great in the scientific world. Each fission was found to release about 200,000,000 electron volts of energy. In addition, it was found that neutrons were thrown off in the fission process. These Could be used to set off a chain reaction of nuclear fissions. The next step could be a

How The Atom Bomb Was Developed         The Events Leading To

1153 words - 5 pages Hahn and Strassmann of Germany learned that they had split the uranium atom. Lise Meitner and O.R. Frisch identified the splitting as nuclear fission. Excitement was great in the scientific world. Each fission was found to release about 200,000,000 electron volts of energy. In addition, it was found that neutrons were thrown off in the fission process. These Could be used to set off a chain reaction of nuclear fissions. The next step could be a