Jean Elshtain And Susan Okin Essay

603 words - 3 pages

In the article Antigone’s Daughters, by Jean Elshtain, she identifies to two realms created by modern society, which is public and private. Traditionally society holds women restricted to the private life, additionally accepting little improvements into areas which have been formerly limited to men. Elshtain emphasizes that women need to be incorporated into the public life as equivalent to men. Elshtain states “armies, must be fully integrated as well as our national guard, our state troopers, our local sheriffs’ offices, our district attorneys’ offices, our state prosecuting attorneys’ offices, in short the nation’s entire lawful power structure” (p. 36, ¶1).
A common traditional presumption was that the conventional identities were entirely pressured upon women, where “women have been the unwitting victims of deliberate exclusion from public life and forced imprisonment in private life” (p. 366, ¶2). Because a woman's identities were wives, mothers, and grandmothers, which presented an essential function in the community in promoting the private field. The vital decisions were made from the public sphere, which in turn made the decisions produced in the private holding no legitimate power and constructed no real choices. Consequently, the private world instantaneously comprised a custom of powerlessness, necessity and irrationality.
In the man's public domain, administrative bureaus function in conformity. Men react toward others as a method to an end, and thus conduct actions to achieve personal interests in public. The complete opposite is attributable to women, Elshtain writes that women are “as the concrete, the particular, the bodily’, an identity with which women have traditionally beendefined; public-oriented behavior aimed at good for others but not reducible to interest for self” (p. 368, ¶1). Elshtain emphasizes that within the story of Antigone's Daughters is the...

Find Another Essay On Jean Elshtain and Susan Okin

Are the Values of Liberalism Universal

2595 words - 10 pages the Liberal bias towards men over women. I will look at the work of Susan Moller Okin and her criticism of a number of non-liberal minority groups and their subjugation of women. With the intention of assessing whether it is correct to be using liberal ideals to judge and change the activities of culturally different groups. Finally using the origins of the current strain of liberalism which has its roots in the enlightenment period, I will

The Unjust Theory and Iraq War

1122 words - 4 pages , Toby. "The Causes Of US Failure In Iraq." Survival 49.1 (2007): 85. Academic Search Complete. Web. 19 Oct. 2014.Elshtain, Jean B. "What Is A Just War." Reading The World: Ideas That Matter. 2nd ed. ED Michael Austin. New York: Norton, 2009. 303. Print.Enemark, Christian, and Christopher Michaelsen. "Just War Doctrine And The Invasion Of Iraq".Australian Journal of Politics & History 51.4 (2005): 561. Web. 19 Oct. 2014.Kaufman, Chaim. "Threat

The Proper Role of Government

1097 words - 5 pages government fails to secure, or violates those rights, then according to the social contract, we have the right to rebel and implement a new government that will secure those rights. Secondly, a government should actively encourage and raise its citizens to participate in civic work and contribute to their communities. After it succeeds in providing security for people’s rights, a government should then aim to improve families first, as Jean Elshtain

Democracy Individualism

4386 words - 18 pages Democracy Individualism There is growing consensus in the United States of the potential collapse of democracy, and many scholars question whether America will be able to address the challenges necessary to avert it. At the heart of the issue is the disintegration of civil society. In a remarkable book on the subject – Democracy on Trial – Jean Elshtain (1995: 5) notes, “As a civic question – and it is by no means a civic matter alone

Politics and the Art of Compromise

1186 words - 5 pages coalitions and find acceptable compromises." Also political philosopher Jean Bethke Elshtain (1995: 61) states "But compromise is not a mediocre way to do politics; it is an adventure, the only way to do democratic politics." II. Reasons why compromise is essential. Politicians need to be able to compromise and be good at bargaining with other elected officials. One reason is that in order to get what is important to

Social Constructionism and the Message of Feminism

687 words - 3 pages . Feminist pointed out that women were no more victims of their body than men were. Simone Beauvoir said, “It is often said that she thinks with her glands. Man superbly ignores the fact that his anatomy includes glands.” These ideals were put in place in order to keep the statues quo. In fact, Women weren’t destined to be the second sex. Feminist like Simone De Beauvoir, Susan Okin, and Betty Friedan began to explain why this was the case when

The Oppressed Female in Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre

978 words - 4 pages Eyre.  New York, Penguin Books, 1997. Gates, Barbara Timm, ed. Critical Essays on Charlotte Bronte. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1990. Okin, Susan Moller.  Justice, Gender and the Family.  United States of America: Basic Books, 1989. Wollstonecraft, Mary.  The Rights of Women.  Everyman's Library Edition.  

What is Third Wave Feminism, and How Does It Differ From Second Wave Feminism?

885 words - 4 pages problem."bell hooks", Jean Bethke Elshtain, see mothering as a strength rather than something to be overcome.Less academia based, founded much more in cyberspace and music. Challenges and subverts traditional ways of communication, such as academic press and newspapers.Second Wave FeminismAlso "Women's Liberation Movement". Began in 60s, lasted to 70s. Coined by Marsha Lear, arose from civil rights and anti-war protests.Simone de Beauvoir [women

Animal Rights

764 words - 3 pages tested on monkeys. Major diseases have been alleviated and have had major advances totheir cure, diseases such as leukemia in children among other types of cancerand tumors. Animals not only contribute greatly in medicine, but through out the history of human kind they have been consumed as food, being a majorsource for the basic nutrition.Unfortunately, some research has gone too far, putting many animals through unnecessary pain. According to Jean

War: The Inevitability of Society

1027 words - 5 pages are enacted because they see a threat emerging in an opposing community. This war is less controversial and seems more just to all the members of the society. A war is sometimes only considered just if it is used to” right a massive injustice or restore a right order where there is a disorder” as Jean Bethke Elshtain states in What is a Just War? (297). As long as there are people that oppose justice there will be a requirement for war and

Billie Jean King: Life Lessons and Gender Equality

1315 words - 6 pages . She also talks about learning values from childhood friends, like taking advantage and trying every new opportunity that comes your way. For instance, when King was in 5th grade, her friend Susan Williams asked her to come along for a game of tennis. Billy Jean was unsure, considering she never played tennis in her life and thought of it as a country club activity. She deemed tennis to be out of her comfort zone, but with a little push from

Similar Essays

Multiculturalism Essay

1415 words - 6 pages in diffusing in the majority groups. Susan Moller Okin in her article: "Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women?" makes numerous claims and assumptions about whether multiculturalism is bad for women in cultures. I believe that we should leave the cultures alone without giving them special treatment nor discriminating against them but rather enlightening and educating them. Multiculturalists see that every culture is important and deserves to be

The Lexical Priority Of Rights: Basic Capabilities Vs. Poverty Eradication

1211 words - 5 pages basic services, such as healthcare and education. Feminist theorists have attempted to analyze this phenomenon in order to further comprehend the fundamental causes for the vulnerability of women. Martha Nussbaum argues that the feminization of poverty is primarily due to the failure of governments to provide women with their basic capabilities. Susan Moller Okin argues that Nussbaum’s capabilities approach is insufficient in addressing the

The Pros And Cons Of Human Cloning

835 words - 3 pages "To clone or not to clone?" that is the question troubling the mind's of many Americans and citizens all over the world. Imagine how life would become when millions of people start looking alike, acting alike, and thinking alike. There would be no diversity what so ever in today's society. Ban human cloning!, Jean Bethke Elshtain author of "To Clone or Not to Clone", displays a strong argument as to why human cloning should be banned

Women Oppressed In Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre

1695 words - 7 pages .               Susan Moller Okin argues that family life is the first factor that has an influence on the socialization of children.  Her concerns about the subjugation of women center around the opinion that "gender-structured marriages make women vulnerable" (5), and that unjust families lead to an unjust society made up of members incapable of making decisions free of gender bias, "They (theorists of justice) take mature, independent human