Jean Jacques Rousseau's The State Of War

1096 words - 4 pages

Jean-Jacques Rousseau's "The State of War"

Jean-Jacques Rousseau's "The State of War" elegantly raises a model for confederative peace among the states of Europe, and then succinctly explains its impossibility. Rousseau very systematically lays out the benefits of such a "perpetual peace" through arguments based only in a realism of pure self-interest, and then very elegantly and powerfully turns the inertia of the self-interest machinery against the same to explain why it can never come to be. However, this final step may be a bit too far; in his academic zeal for the simple, I will argue that he has overlooked the real, or at least ignored the possible. His conclusion may be appealingly reasoned, but it is still insupportable.

The perpetual peace that Rousseau treats is that proposed by the Abbé de Saint-Pierre, a fact that doesn't become clear until the latter end of the piece. Rousseau tells us that the Abbé has, over time, advanced a fair number of plans for peace and prosperity, all to the ridicule of contemporary thinkers (125). That Rousseau takes up this one plan, in particular, may simply be masturbatory: as a writer, Rousseau was not averse to cutting his teeth on the works of others that he found to be disagreeable, as evidenced by his disdainful treatment of Hobbes (112). However, before criticizing Rousseau's work or speculating as to why he carried it out, it serves first to understand it properly.

From his figurative window, Rousseau sees a Europe ravaged by conflicts resulting from supposedly peaceable and civilized institutions (111). He posits that the essentially problematic flaw, the cause of conflict, is a contradiction in modes of relating: while individuals live within a framework of enforced norms ("laws"), states exist in an anarchic and unregulated structure with no central authority ­ a state of nature (112). While refuting the possibility that this international state of nature is a Hobbesian war of all against all [which would tend to the destruction of the species, an aim he finds both logically and religiously untenable (114)], he certainly acknowledges that conflicts occur even among actors whom we would call naturally virtuous ­ those seeking peace (112).

This contradiction is problematic because the boundaries between the civil and the natural, the domestic and the international, overlap at times (112). For instance, war on the outside invariably affects the civic order on the inside. Because of this contradiction, we are forced to bear the burdens of supporting both orders separately, thus negating the advantages brought by either. We are subject to the vagaries of the international system when it affects civil life, and yet as individuals our hands are tied and we are unable to enjoy natural freedom ourselves because we are also subject to the authority, at times oppressive, of the civil domestic structures (which, as we have seen, fail to protect us from all international affects) (112). Even a state...

Find Another Essay On Jean-Jacques Rousseau's The State of War

The Life and Philosophies of Jean-Jacques Rousseau

841 words - 3 pages . While semi-civilized humanity looked to itself for its values and happiness, civilized human beings live outside themselves in the opinions and authority of others. The price of civilization is human freedom and human individuality." (Hooker, European) In addition, he believed that "man is good by nature and made bad only by institutions." (Scruton, 205)Jean Jacques Rousseau's beliefs of child development were that children should be free to

Jean-Jacques Rousseau and The Essence of Human Nature

1757 words - 7 pages . But, he does not necessarily persuade the reader man is good. He needs not persuade the reader in truth. He needs only to create doubt in the minds of the readers so that the individual may question the need for society. In this purpose, Rousseau accomplishes his task. He created a natural world in which the natural man is good leaving the societal man to question his role in society. Is equality necessary? Is authority necessary? These are the questions the reader must answer. Works Cited Rousseau, Jean-Jacques and Victor Gourevitch. The Discourses and Other Early Political Writings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.

Jean Jacques Rousseauand Education - The Enlightenment - Essay

1183 words - 5 pages In most all of Jean Jacques Rousseau's writings concerning education, he stressed his belief that “negative education,” that is education derived from man's interaction with the natural state, was vital to the moral development of humans, as opposed to “positive education,” which was seen by him as established, traditional education delivered by societies. Rousseau's theoretical beliefs, were contradicted by his own writings and the end result

Edmund Burke and Jean Jacques Rousseau Concerning the Justification of the French Revolution

651 words - 3 pages Edmund Burke, who is often regarded as a spokesman for modern conservatism, believed that human rights were based on tradition and could only be inherited. Burke strongly opposed the French Revolution, which in his view, attempted to break from the traditions of France and destroy their contemporary society. On the other hand, Jean-Jacque Rousseau believed that general will would always be correct and that it would unshackle humans from their

Hobbes and Rousseau's view on a "State of Nature"

529 words - 2 pages Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau both used experiments that involved imagining what human beings would be like without laws, to help them understand the idea of ?the state of nature.? This essay will give accounts of why people should avoid returning to a state of nature.Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679), lived in a time of political and social upheaval during the English civil wars. He made his living as a tutor to aristocrat young men travelling

Inferring Freedom and Equality. Speaks of Jean Jacques Rousseau

992 words - 4 pages Many of Earth's organisms and processes depend on each other to survive the natural world. Jean Jacques Rousseau employed this aspect of natural dependency to connect the ideas of freedom and equality together. Rousseau theorized many ingenious ideas for an upcoming legitimate government. The American Constitution and the basis of this nation's bureaucracy adopted many of his opinions, along with John Locke and Thomas Hobbes, into the making of

Comparison of Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau

1269 words - 5 pages entered into civilization. Works Cited: Hobbes, Thomas, and Crawford B. Macpherson. Leviathan. Harmondsworth, Middlesex [u.a.: Penguin, 1985. Print. Rousseau, Jean-Jacques, Donald A. Cress. Basic Political Writings: "Discourse on the Sciences and the Arts", "Discourse on the Origin of Inequality", "Discourse on Political Economy", "On the Social Contract", “The State of War”. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1987. Print.

Questionaire: Jean- Jacques Rousseau and The Social Contract

1266 words - 5 pages though, a man gives up some of his rights, he is protected by the rights given to him by the state, which cannot be taken away such as proprietorship. Between the balance of individual rights and rights of the general will, man still remains free because of the choice he makes to reside in that territory.   Work Cited Cottingham, John. "Society and the Individual: Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the Social Contract." Western Philosophy: An Anthology. Oxford, OX, UK: Blackwell, 1996. 647-53. Print.  

An Illustration of Monastic Life in the 14th Century: Jean-Jacques Annaud's The Name of the Rose

1154 words - 5 pages Jean-Jacques Annaud, The Name of the Rose historical fiction murder mystery illustrates monastic life in the 14th century. This medieval film takes place in a remote Benedictine abbey in Northern Italy. Annaud is historically successful in recounting monastic life during the Middle Ages. The enriching backdrop of this film presents the culture of monastic life. The setting is beautifully examined and replicated to show the distinct and

Comparison of Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau

1147 words - 5 pages almost constantly because war and the desire for power are part of humans and all humans are born with it. As far as equality goes, Hobbes believes that inequality is al stemmed from the fact that humans are born with the want and need for power and because of this some people are going to have more power and riches than others. While both Hobbes and Rousseau’s views on human nature, the state, and inequality have valid points within them

Differing Views on Humans as Portrayed by William Golding in Lord of the Flies and Jean Jacques Rousseau

716 words - 3 pages In the book “Lord of the Flies” written by William Golding, Golding has a certain type of philosophy that he applies throughout the book. The main idea of Golding’s philosophy is that people were naturally cruel and that if there were no rules people would fight, rob, and kill. A little later on there was another philosopher named Jean Jacques Rousseau. Rousseau’s philosophy opposed Golding’s philosophy by believing that humans in their normal

Similar Essays

Jean Jacques Rousseau's The Social Contract Essay

3546 words - 14 pages The problem is to find a form of association … in which each, while uniting himself with all, may still obey himself alone, and remain as free as before.’ Does Rousseau have a convincing solution to the problem he poses? The opening line of Jean-Jacques Rousseau's influential work 'The Social Contract' (1762), is 'man is born free, and he is everywhere in chains. Those who think themselves masters of others are indeed greater slaves

The Significance Of Reason, Discussed In John Locke's "The Second Treatise Of Civil Government", And In Jean Jacques Rousseau's, "Emile"

1353 words - 5 pages The significance of reason is discussed both in John Locke's, The Second Treatise of Civil Government, and in Jean-Jacques Rousseau's, Emile. However, the definitions that both authors give to the word "reason" vary significantly. I will now attempt to compare the different meanings that each man considered to be the accurate definition of reason.John Locke believed that the state "all men are naturally in ... is a state of perfect freedom" (122

Jean Jacques Rousseau's Influence On Mary Shelley's Creature

1216 words - 5 pages “advanced” and before any society, there was a time when nothing mattered except self preservation. But things have changed; things always change and evolve. Throughout humanity society was developed into what it is today. Jean-Jacques Rousseau describes these steps in detail. He describes how society came about and how it has created evil. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, shows the evolution of human society through the Creature according to Jean

Biography Of Jean Jacques Rousseau Essay

2216 words - 9 pages ; but it is for them to prolong as much as possible the life of the state by giving it the best possible constitution. (Rousseau, Jean-Jacques 1997) Bibliography McCllelland, J.S, (1996). A History of Western Political Thought. London: Routledge Rousseau, Jean Jacques (1997), The social contract and other later political writings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://www.constitution.org/jjr/watkins.htm