Jewish Feminism Essay

1620 words - 7 pages

The topic of women praying at the Western Wall has been an ongoing debate not only among ultra-orthodox Jews and feminists, but now the Women of the Wall (WOW) are becoming divided on the issue of where to pray at the wall. While on November, 4, 2013, the group celebrated their 25 anniversary, it is at this moment in the group’s history that they are the most divided. In his article, “Women of Wall Deeply Split over Anat Hoffman’s Acceptance of Prayer Deal,” Nathan Jeffay discusses the issues WOW is currently facing both internally and externally.
In October of 2013, WOW decided to move their demonstrations from the Kotel's prayer gallery for women to a quieter piece of the wall known as ...view middle of the document...

Bonna Devora Haberman, a WOW founder, stated, “In 2003 we could have easily removed ourselves from the Western Wall plaza to Robinson’s Arch — it was there then and it’s there now...[w]e’ve not yearned 25 years to be displaced from the central gathering point of the Jewish people at the Western Wall plaza” (Jeffay). For women like Ms. Haberman, the group has worked too hard for too long to simply agree to move.
While many applaud the group’s political decision to opt to be involved in negotiations, it is far from the end of the issue. If the group does agree to leave the Kotel section and move to a separate section, they would become excluded from the most sacred place in Judaism.
This article furthers an understanding of gender relations in Judaism. In her article, “Engendering Judaism,” Rachel Adler states, “Non-orthodox Judaisms distinguish themselves from Orthodoxy by their belief that Jews beget Judaism; they reshape and renew Judaism in the various times and places they inhabit.” In other words, Judaism does not exist in a vacuum. It has been shaped and molded to fit cohesively with society and societal norms. But, there still remains the issue of relations between orthodox and non-orthodox Judaisms that disagree with each other. The Women at the Wall face protests and brutality from orthodox Jews.
Adler suggests that there two ways to address issues of gender in Judaism. “The critical task is to demonstrate that historical understandings of gender affect all Jewish texts and contexts and hence require the attention of all Jews” (Adler). Gender is simply not just a “women’s issue.” It is everyone’s issue. Every person on this earth has gender, and thus should be invested in taking a second look at gender relations within Judaism.
Another point Alder makes is that there is a gap between what the text says and what Jewish women actually feel. Alder makes this point by describing the lack of mention in the Torah about women’s presence at Mt. Sinai. Of course women were there, but why were they not mentioned. She states, “How can we ever hope to fill the silence that shrouds Jewish women’s past? If women are invisible from the first moment of Jewish history, can we hope to become Visible now?” (Adler). Alder then goes on to question how many victories were really just token victories. It is viable that women who signed the petition to remain at the Kotel feel that their invitation to be involved in the negotiations is only a token victory. How can real change happen when women would still be excluded from the holiest place in Judaism? In the comment section of the article, a man brought up a saying that often invokes images of the 1960s in America: separate but not equal. Many women feel that this would occur if they were forced to remain separated from the Kotel section.
Blu Greenberg, an orthodox feminist, has come up with solutions on how feminists can reconcile with their Jewish faith. Greenberg begins her article...

Find Another Essay On Jewish Feminism

Let My People Go Essay

1055 words - 5 pages In the Jewish Torah, not a single woman is ever born. Women lived during this time and were mentioned slightly, but they didn’t have rights or a voice. Christine de Pizan gave the idea in The Book of City of Ladies that the men were freed from Egypt, whereas the women were moved from Egypt but stayed in suffering. This radical idea suggests that the freedom of the Israelites was not beneficial for women. Though most believe that Moses led all

Democrats and Republicans Essay

898 words - 4 pages country: Americans.7) Have no respect for people who disagree with feminism. Women should have equal rights and protections, but that doesn't mean every woman should focus on a career above a family or be assertive and aggressive. Just as women should have a right to a career and to be assertive and aggressive, true feminism has respect for their right to act in traditionally feminine ways.8) Make your dope smoking habits a top political priority

Curiosity Killed The…

1173 words - 5 pages , sometimes eleven, hour days to keep their families afloat. The issue of female equality has been contested throughout the ages in multiple countries. The theory of political, economic and social equality of the sexes is defined as feminism (Feminism). Throughout history, males have been the predominant sex, considering themselves the alpha males of society, disliking contestation of their “rightful” place.As of today, many of the biggest

Messerschmidt’s Theory of Hegemonic Masculinity

2570 words - 10 pages and frequently requires considerable effort to maintain it.Messerschmidt states that "any attempt to understand masculinity and crime must begin with a comradely friendly scrutiny of the theoretical positions of radical and social feminism on men, masculine dominance, and crime" (Messerschmidt, 1993). It is important to examine both types of feminism because the hegemonic male intertwines, and is influenced by, a combination of these two

Messerschmidt’s Theory of Hegemonic Masculinity

2570 words - 10 pages and frequently requires considerable effort to maintain it.Messerschmidt states that "any attempt to understand masculinity and crime must begin with a comradely friendly scrutiny of the theoretical positions of radical and social feminism on men, masculine dominance, and crime" (Messerschmidt, 1993). It is important to examine both types of feminism because the hegemonic male intertwines, and is influenced by, a combination of these two

Carrie Brownstein: Blurred Lines, No Boundaries

1371 words - 6 pages The 1960s cultural movement in the United States sent shockwaves through American society. Nearly every aspect of traditional life was challenged and among these was the role of women. Following in the footsteps of suffragettes during the turn of the twentieth century, a new wave of feminism was emerging in the United States that aspired to take the women's right movement beyond the realm of constitutional rights. This movement, now known as

Sex isn’t Natural: A Deeper Look into Society’s Disgust - NKU/ENG 291 - Comparative Essay

1774 words - 8 pages may be shocking for some to realize a large part of this community contains women consenting to this sexual conduct, and a large portion of the viewers are also women. This huge concept is that is overlooked about pornography and can even extend to the understanding of intersectional feminism. Yet, while dissecting these pieces one must keep in mind the different time period and how it relates to porn and feminism. Susan Jacoby, author of “First

“The Final Rush for Suffrage” in the United States Through the Experience and Contributions of Working-Class Women from the Late 19th Century thro

1248 words - 5 pages prominent women’s groups, such as NAWSA. As the women’s movement began to focus on federal change with an incoming generation of suffragists, Colorado simultaneously gave women the right to vote in 1893. Despite discrimination throughout the women’s movement, it was clear to many that the power needed to achieve suffrage could not be obtained without working-class women being active participants. In 1911, together Rose Schneiderman, Jewish Union

Sarah Bernhardt- A Victorious Legend

1019 words - 4 pages , Sarah Bernhardt influenced a rapidly changing society as the social roles and cultural representations of women began to shift. The roots of modern feminism are buried in the theatre, and Sarah Bernhardt was certainly one of the women who influenced and helped to bring about societal change. Without the influence of Sarah Bernhardt, the modern feminist cause would be greatly altered. She has helped to mold and shape our society.Sarah Bernhardt was

Cultural Diversity - Traditions

1573 words - 6 pages Jewish TraditionPart of my textured past includes the movement from one religious sector to another, which, many may think, is at the other end of the spectrum. I was raised as a Christian growing up on various military bases as my father pursued his military career. My younger childhood left me memories of going to church and eagerly awaiting the cookies and punch in the reception afterwards. I can remember playing Joseph in a church pageant

Lorraine Hansberry

545 words - 2 pages kind." She married Robert Nemiroff, a white Jewish intellectual who she met on a picket line protesting the exclusion of black athletes from university sports. She worked as editor for Paul Robeson's radical black newspaper "Freedom" until her husband's songwriting success allowed her to devote herself to her playwrighting. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cover of A Raisin in the

Similar Essays

Impact Of Feminism It's About The Meaning Of Feminism And The Feminist Movement Around The 19th Century. There Is A Works Cited As Well As Notes At The End Of The Essay

5212 words - 21 pages Impact of FeminismThe word feminism is stated in the dictionary as the belief in the social, political, and economic equality of the sexes and the movement organized around this belief. Many individuals will understand the word feminism in different ways. There is no true set way to describe feminism for everyone has experienced it in a different way. The one important thing to remember about feminism is that it has impacted many things in

Women As Portrayed In Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code

1215 words - 5 pages Although Dan Brown does not make the subject of feminism the highlight of his novels, the women in The Da Vinci Code play an imperative role in the plot often overlooked by the readers. Furthermore, Brown claims that the treatment of women in the Catholic Church does not align with the teachings of Jesus. Brown reiterates historical events from many different time periods and cultures which must be understood to comprehend the view of women

The Success Of Judaism Essay

2121 words - 8 pages Jewish practice, be it through observance, prayer or habit. In combination to this, its capacity to be versatile and incorporate outside influence has served to maintain its popularity as a major world faith. In order to continue its future religious success, Judaism must persist upholding the traditions that it stands for. However, in the light of pressures of modernity that arise through social change, including feminism and assimilation it

Spirituality In Current School And Educational Settings, In Light Of The Aftermath Of Extremist Terrorist Attacks

522 words - 2 pages underpinnings of Israeli society. And although one might relate it to the idea that Israel is a Jewish state, and the religion is Judaism, it is not a complete explanation, because there is some similar process in the extreme left wing kibbutz schools. What might be learned is that when the educational process is defined by something that is "greater" than the individual, and not able to be broken down and scientifically analyzed, the overall motivate