John Barsad And Monsieur Defarge In A Tale Of Two Cities

1183 words - 5 pages

A Tale of Two Cities, involves many complicated situations in which the characters must choose between chance or death, career or family, honor or revenge. As a result, ambiguity has evolved in multiple characters because of these difficult choices. Two prominently ambiguous characters are John Barsad and Monsieur Defarge. While Barsad recognizes the importance of career and honor, Defarge sees more prominence in family and revenge.

John Barsad’s ambiguity is demonstrated by two contrasting qualities: devotion to his job as a spy and neglect for his family. His devotion to his job as an English spy causes him to appear as a heroic figure. In order to protect his identity, for instance, he accepted Sydney Carton’s offer to help rescue Darnay. During the process of Carton’s changing into Darnay’s clothes, Barsad could have denounced Carton and Darnay for rebelling against authority, which would diminish all hope of ever returning Lucie Manette’s husband to her, but Barsad kept his word by risking his life to help Carton and Darnay. If he denounced Carton, Carton would denounce his identity as a spy, but if Barsad kept silent and helped Carton, Carton would in turn keep silent about Barsad’s identity. Although Barsad’s decision to keep silent involved the risk of being suspected as a French traitor, his decision indicates his devotion to his job; He would risk death rather than fail as a spy. Despite his inclination to his occupation, however, Barsad is portrayed as a “heartless scoundrel” (A Tale of Two Cities pg 100). He neglects his sister and “stripped her of everything she possessed” (pg 100), claiming that he is “busy” (pg 307) working as an “official” (pg 307). His devotion for his job over his family illustrates his selfishness and lack of love for family, which causes him to appear to the readers as a villain. Barsad’s heroic quality of devotion for his occupation combined with his cruel quality of neglect for his family causes Barsad to be interpreted as an ambiguous figure.

Barsad’s ambiguity contributes to the theme of loyalty to the nation. His commitment to his job as an English spy demonstrates his loyalty to England. Barsad was faced with the situation of risking death or denouncing Carton to gain the upper hand in their “desperate game” (pg 311-312). He chose to risk death over gaining the upper hand because he would prefer to die as an honorable man of England who did his best to perform his duties for England rather than die as a coward who stood for himself. His decision indicates his devotion to England; he would give his life to England rather than save himself.

Barsad’s neglect of his sister demonstrates another level of loyalty to the nation. He is more protective of his identity and his job than he is of his sister’s state of welfare. In this situation, he is faced with the situation of choosing two important aspects of life---his family or his pursuance of his career as an English spy. His cruel...

Find Another Essay On John Barsad and Monsieur Defarge in A Tale of Two Cities

Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities

1258 words - 5 pages Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities     In A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens, many characters are given second chances as their lives are resurrected. The central heroine woman, Lucy Manette, is responsible for the resurrections of Sydney Carton and Dr. Alexander Manette's lives. She gives them inspiration and love to help them recover from their seemingly hopeless states. In turn, Carton gives up his own life in order to save

Foreshadowing in A Tale of Two Cities

735 words - 3 pages Foreshadowing in A Tale of Two Cities   How does diabolically spilt blood and mysterious footsteps become important in a historical fiction novel? What makes these murder-mystery traits relevant? Charles Dickens, author of A Tale of Two Cities, creatively foreshadows future events using suspenseful topics: A forbidden declaration of love, a tragically beautiful sunset streaked with crimson, echoing footsteps of a past that will

Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities

1048 words - 4 pages Frightening horror movies often illustrate disturbing scenes of removing corpses from the ground; and some religions, including Buddhism and Hinduism, strongly believe in reincarnation. Imagining digging up bodies or getting recreated may seem unusual, but the act of resurrection happens frequently in Charles Dickens’ famous novel, A Tale of Two Cities. The novel revolves around the settings of both England and France during the unorganized

'Love and hatred' in 'A Tale of Two Cities'

958 words - 4 pages what danger she was in; while Madame was only thinking of denouncing the Manettes to death.The death of Carton and the lost of hearing of Miss Pross were the cost of defeating Madame Defarge. Besides showing the power of love was always stronger than that of hatred, Dickens also conveyed that sacrifices were needed to be made when people wanted to protect their love from harm. Throughout the novel, Dickens conveyed the message that, love and hatred would affect its owners’ fate, loving might deserve a better and fruitful life, while hating could only bring pain and death.source: full version of 'A Tale of Two Cities'

Stereotypes and Stereotyping in A Tale of Two Cities

710 words - 3 pages Stereotypes in A Tale of Two Cities        Charles Dickens stereotypes many of his Characters in A Tale of Two Cities. Among these stereotyped characters are The Marquis D' Evremond, Lucy, and Miss Pross. These particular stereotypes were probably intentional, for Dicken's was not a skilled writer.            The Marquis d' Evremond was probably intentionally stereotyped. His character is basically used to

A Tale Of Two Cities

1523 words - 6 pages      “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.” This is the famous starting to the book “A Tale of Two Cities,” by Charels Dickens. Charels Dickens is one of the most famous writers of his century. This book tells about the main characters, Lucie and her father.      The story starts out with Mr. Jarvis Lorry, a representative of Tellson's Bank in London, who is sent by his firm

A Tale of Two Cities

933 words - 4 pages Lucie and her family. The shadow’s representation of the evil that was Madame Defarge showed one of the cruel and murderous dark side of the Revolution and how people were not safe from anything . Throughout A Tale of Two Cities, Dickens very well symbolizes the themes and ideas that were relevant in the Revolution. When he uses symbols like the mill, the fountain, and the shadow to represent the theme of inhumanity it helps the story to become

A Tale of Two Cities

753 words - 3 pages e.g. Madame Defarge good human nature is disregarded and vengeance is all that can subdue the feeling of rage. In times of chaos humans can turn violent in search of order and what they believe to be justice. In the case of Sydney Carton he can be viewed as a martyr -good nature- giving his life for one he believed to be of more value.The part of "A Tale of Two Cities" I most enjoyed was when Sydney Carton carried Lucie Manette after having

A Tale of Two Cities

2234 words - 9 pages setting. Since the story takes place during the French Revolution, this is much disarray in France. It is often compared with the ocean and the seas. This is contrasted with the order of England, an example being the peaceful house located in Suho, owned by Dr. Manette (Telgen). The last theme would be memory and reminiscence. In A Tale of Two Cities memory is treated as a trap. Dr. Manette and Madame Defarge are characters that fall for this trap

A Tale of Two Cities

668 words - 3 pages to answer for those things descends to me!” (Dickens 366). Madame’s intentions for justice turned for the worst when the revolution started, she only planned to have the remaining Evremonde family to be killed at the time she was unaware of Charles, Lucie, and little Lucie. When she family came to know of their existence it sparked a fire in her bosom to desire for the rest of the family to be killed. Another example would be the Grindstone Scene. The grindstone, prior to the revolution, was used to grind wheat for the people to eat. Works Cited Dickens, Charles. A Tale of Two Cities. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1906. Print.

A Tale of Two Cities - 1368 words

1368 words - 5 pages A Tale of Two Cities Jarvis Lorry, an employee of Tellson's Bank, was sent to find Dr. Manette, an unjustly imprisoned physician, in Paris and bring him back to England. Lucie, Manette's daughter who thought that he was dead, accompanied Mr. Lorry. Upon arriving at Defarge's wine shop in Paris, they found Mr. Manette in a dreadful state and took him back to London with them. Mr. Manette could not rember why he had been

Similar Essays

Resurrection In A Tale Of Two Cities

1310 words - 5 pages resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities.  He is taken away from his pregnant wife and then imprisoned for eighteen very long years.  Over the years, his condition deteriorates until he forgets his real name and mindlessly cobbles shoes to pass the time.  In "Book the First", he is released by the French government and then put in the care of Monsieur Defarge.  He is suddenly "recalled to life"(19, 35).   However, his rebirth has

Irony In: A Tale Of Two Cities

668 words - 3 pages This paper is to explain the use of irony of a phrase from A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens. The story is set during the time of the French Revolution and the phrase was the slogan of the revolutionaries: “The Republic One and the Indivisible of Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, or Death.” Each term of this phrase will be defined and once defined one will be able to see the extreme irony of it. First, the definition of Republic

Moral And Immoral Conversions In A Tale Of Two Cities

1837 words - 7 pages reaches the climax of morality, Dr. Manette grows morally and he is no longer the hermit stuck in the prison cell, Madame Defarge converts to immortality which in the end kills her. In conclusion, it is evident that in this novel those who had a moral conversions were rewarded with true happiness earthly or otherwise, while those who had immoral conversions were doomed to eternal damnation. Bibliography: Dickens, Charles. A Tale of Two Cities. New York: Pocket Books Inc., 1957. Hardy, Barbara. "The Change of Heart in Dickens Novels." Dickens Ed. Martin Price. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1967: 10.

Profound Secret And Mystery In A Tale Of Two Cities

830 words - 3 pages shouldn't judge a book by its cover, but one of Dickens's characters in A Tale of Two Cities had obviously never received this advice. When Madame Defarge came after Lucie, little Lucie and Doctor Manette in their temporary home in Paris, she probably expected to get what she wanted easily and quickly. She definitely didn't expect to be met with a great resistance from a single Englishwoman. When Miss Pross stopped Madame Defarge from entering