Journal Article Critique Essay

1883 words - 8 pages

Research Article 1

Roberts, T. (2003). Effects of Alphabet-Letter Instruction on Young Children’s Word Recognition [Electronic Version]. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95 (1), 41-51.

The title of the article gave a fair representation of the topic as it was clear and concise in the wording. The title encompassed the idea that alphabet letter instruction on young children’s word recognition would be explored through experiments and analysis. Reading on through the article it was evident that the effects of alphabet letter instruction on you children’s word recognition were addressed.

Experimental studies have been undertaken throughout the years in relation to alphabet letter instruction. The first of these experiments were undertaken with kindergarten and year one students in the late 1960s and early 1970s. The purpose of these early experiments was to examine the hypothesis that letter-name knowledge played a causal role in the relationship between letter-name knowledge and early reading. If knowledge of letter names was a causal factor, then instruction that increased children’s letter-name knowledge should increase early reading performance. It was concluded from these early studies that there was little educational benefit to be gained from letter-name instruction.

A man by the name of Ehri in 1983 critiqued these early studies and concluded they suffered from a number of methodological flaws. The concluded flaws included training may have been too short and not thorough, treatment groups differed, training did not include instruction in how to use letter-name knowledge for word reading and training the children in small groups resulted in insufficient learning.

Since the early studies and Ehri’s conclusions a great deal of research has demonstrated that letter knowledge is integrally involved in word recognition. The hypotheses and purpose of this later study was to examine anew the effects of letter-name knowledge associated with instruction on beginning phonetic word recognition with methodology correcting for the flaws of previous studies. After instruction the children’s ability to learn 3 types of word spellings was examined. An argument was then formulated that efforts to increase children’s attention to letter information are needed, given its clear importance in early reading.

The subjects for this study were thirty-three preschool children whose language was predominantly other than English. The mean age of the participants was 52.82 months old. The participants included 3 three year old children and 30 four year old children. The participants were enrolled in a state funded, half day pre school program which served children from rather low socio economic status families and backgrounds. The mean English oral proficiency score 0f 1.86 indicated that the children were on average classified as non English speaking.
The children in this study were blocked by language and oral proficiency. They...

Find Another Essay On Journal Article Critique

article review on how bone health affect althetes - kin - assignment

937 words - 4 pages PSK4U Article Review Assignment Use the outline below to complete the journal assignment for each unit. Topics for each journal will be given to you ahead of time. Article Title: from article Author(s): from article Publication: from article Publication Information: Date, Page Numbers – from article Keywords: These should be keywords that define the major topics of the article. I.e., if someone were searching a database of these articles, then

What is the Relationship Between Media Use and Academic Performance?

1038 words - 5 pages piece of societal interaction (Stollak et. Al., 2011). This critique paper has allowed me to become aware of what to look for in a press article that refers to a journal article. It was easier to critique this journal article and press article because the press article took the most important information from the journal article. The press article did not stray away from the original document and there was no exaggeration. The press article even

Essay instructions on decriptive essay on gloabalization - GOVT 425 - Essay

686 words - 3 pages , since it must flow with the overall tenor of your own style and argument. · In the next section of the essay, offer a concise defense of the argument. Why is it at least plausible? There is always something rationally defensible about a peer-reviewed journal article on US foreign policy. · For the remainder of your response, offer a critique of the article. What are the limits, problems, or gaps in the author’s argument? There are limits, problems

Article Critique

747 words - 3 pages Fastest Growing Occupations This review will critique the article ‘Fastest Growing Occupations’ by Daniel E. Hecker in the journal Monthly Labor Review in the book Everyday Arguments by Katherine Mayberry (Mayberry, 2009). The brief analysis of the articles author, the point of view, and the evidence provided to prove a claim, is the evidence factual, and sources utilized. Finally the conclusion will be my viewpoint on the article and my

Corporate Culturism. Critical Thinking Assignment

546 words - 3 pages Corporate CultureismHugh Willmotts article, "Strength is ignorance; slavery is freedom: Managing culture in modern organizations", is a harsh critique of corporate culturisms' totalitarian attempt of 'controlling and winning the hearts and minds of their employees, in order to secure unusual efforts.'(1993 )The article, which was published in the Journal of management studies in 1993, tests existing theories of management, and enunciates the

A Perception and Motivation Study Among Married Adults

1426 words - 6 pages Research Article Critique: Forgiveness: A perception and motivation study among married adults Abstract The article is endeavors to observe the possible correlation between general forgiveness (actually forgiving) and perceptions of forgiveness (a belief in the concept). This is a summary analyzing the credibility of the article. The summary includes a brief overview and critique of the title, abstract, literature review

Issues that Affect Educational Outcomes for Indigenous Australians

1093 words - 4 pages leadership, education in very remote areas, community based health programs and new educational systems. Lyons and Janca have argued that although there has been improvement over the past 10 years, it is recommended that monitoring and evaluation components are implemented for future policies and programs. Annotation/ critique The Australian journal of Education, a highly regarded publication for an international audience featured this article

Educating Information Technology Staff

1318 words - 6 pages approaches. Conclusion The strategic implementation of an organizational training plan focusing on information security is instrumental in educating employees on security risks. Notwithstanding technological methods, the end user is influential in the reduction of security risks. Throughout the article, we discussed methods that organizations use to educate employees and a critique of those methods. Furthermore, we examined strategies

After Apple Picking, by Robert Frost

1413 words - 6 pages Apple Picking” along with many of Frost’s other poems in an attempt to understand and interpret them better. In summary, Phillips wrote an article about how uncertainty leads to restlessness and how restlessness and ambition tend to inspire poetry. He then went on to critique “After Apple Picking” by noting the influences of restlessness and ambition found in the apple picker. This led Phillips to claim that “After Apple Picking” was a poem

Critical Analysis of an Article on HIV/AIDS Prevention Issues for Women

1135 words - 5 pages Introduction: This review is about the main points, gaps and critique of the article. The main information provided in this review will help you gain new insight on women HIV/AIDS prevention issues. As a society, we focus on individualist ways of prevention. We try to enforce and educate individuals on HIV/AIDS prevention on an individual level but it’s more complex because women have a lower status compared to men, this disempowerment can lead

Influence of Media in the Public

2460 words - 10 pages questions asked were the secondary and tertiary questions focused on by each of the articles. These differed because of the unique aspects to each of the studies. Article one asked questions concerning the critique of the participants’ bodies such as how they felt men viewed them, and how certain pieces of clothing made them feel (Oliver, 2001, pg. 143). These types of questions were very important to the study because the critique of certain

Similar Essays

Journal Article Critique Bougainville Copper: A Case Analysis In International Management

2377 words - 10 pages company operated in Papua New Guinea. (“The case of the Bougainville mine: Success and failure in the management of a multinational corporation.” Journal of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management, vol. 8; pp70-85).This essay focuses on the article in terms of the clarity of ideas, adequacy of literature review, specification of research goals, adequacy of data collection and data analysis, assessment of empirical methods, and

Research Article Critique: The Professional Adjunct The Online Journal Of Distance Learning Administration

2051 words - 8 pages The Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration (ojdla) is a peer-reviewed journal which publishes articles from practitioners or researchers “with specific focus or implications for the management of distance education programs” (ojdla, 2009, Mission section). The need to recruit, train, and retain qualified online instructors is a concern for administrators of distance learning programs. This research article critique focuses on

Involuntary Treatment Of Schizophrenia Patients In Denmark

972 words - 4 pages the article? How does it connect to other materials on similar topics? Evidence questions: Does the writers’ evidence support their argument? Is it believable? (Online, 2014; Online, 2014). By using having these questions formed I found that by the time it came to the second paper it was easier to critique as I had this guide and had discussed my first paper. Being involved in small groups I felt was a great way to discuss the journal articles

Forgiveness Therapy Essay

1054 words - 4 pages on alternative individualized treatment based on routine therapy techniques. This article was the first to question the effectiveness of Forgiveness Therapy as a main factor of relapse prevention. Critique of the Title Upon reviewing this article and evaluating the titles it can be determined that the title is sufficiently specific. According to Pyrcazak (2008), a title should not only be specific but concise. The title Effects of