Journal Critique Essay

1514 words - 6 pages

Research has suggested that people receive pleasure from success and competence. Two studies have illustrated that there is a positive linear relationship between pleasure (smiling) and difficulty level choice. This suggests that people receive the most pleasure in solving the most challenging task. However, Susan Harter has observed that children who were given the most difficult problem rated their performance negatively because of the increase in time and struggle. She suggests that the relationship between pleasure and challenge is curvilinear, not linear.Harter predicts that in the absence of grades, children will actively seek out optimally challenged problems. These problems are relatively difficult for children but when properly solved, also produce the most pleasure. She also suggests that in the presence of grades, children would choose to solve less challenging because of their desire to do well and get a good grade.A total of 40 sixth graders, 20 girls and 20 boys all from the same school, participated in Harter's experiment. The boys and girls were evenly assigned to the two conditions, "game" or "grade". In the first phase, all the children were exposed anagrams of four varying difficulties. They were given 120 seconds to make a word using all of the provided letters. In the second phase, the students chose which anagrams (level of difficulty) they wanted to do. The "game" group was told that it was a game, whereas the "grade" group was told they were going to be evaluated using a letter grade.The independent variable was grades: whether they received them or not. There were several dependent variables: difficulty choice, smiling, and children's reasons for choosing the anagrams they chose. The experimenters measured solution time and smiling. Participants also rated anagram difficulty and their own competence levels.Harter found that anagram difficulty is inversely related to children's subjective level of competence. She also found that there was a positive relationship between smiling and anagram difficulty for the first three levels of difficulty, and that smiling dropped significantly in the most challenging level. Harter also found that children in the "game" group chose more challenging anagrams and that these children also smiled significantly more. There was also significantly more smiling when the children solved the more challenging problems. The children in the "game" group also verbally expressed that had they been in the "grade" group, they would have chosen easier anagrams. The children in the "grade" group would have chosen more challenging anagrams had they been in the "game" group.These results support Harter's hypotheses that children would choose to solve easier problems in the presence of grades, suggesting that extrinsic rewards lower their desire to be challenged. It also supports her suggestion that there is a curvilinear relationship between pleasure and difficulty level. These finding support other...

Find Another Essay On Journal Critique

Research Article Critique: The Professional Adjunct The Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration

2051 words - 8 pages The Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration (ojdla) is a peer-reviewed journal which publishes articles from practitioners or researchers “with specific focus or implications for the management of distance education programs” (ojdla, 2009, Mission section). The need to recruit, train, and retain qualified online instructors is a concern for administrators of distance learning programs. This research article critique focuses on

Journal Article Critique - Bougainville Copper: A Case Analysis in International Management

2377 words - 10 pages ‘validity’ and ‘reliability’”. British Educational Research Journal, 13(1), 73–81.Hammersley, M. (1990). Reading ethnographic research. New York: Longman.Leininger, M. (1994). “Evaluation criteria and critique of qualitative research studies.” In J. M. Morse (Ed.), Critical issues in qualitative research methods (pp. 95–115). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Lichtenberger, E., O. (2004) Essentials of Assessment

A Journal of the Plague Year Critique

2111 words - 9 pages A Journal of the Plague Year is a first person account of what it was like living through the times of the plague. It recollects stories and other accounts of plague times heard by and collected by the Defoe from other involved individuals. Explains many aspects before, during, and after the plague of their ways of life and culture. Tells of tales of survivors of the plague but mostly off different tales of deaths and how they died in many

Offer a critique of an aspect of groupwork theory. An essential part of the essay is to draw and include excerpts from your learning journal and personal groupwork experiences

1997 words - 8 pages The aspect of groupwork theory that I have chosen to critique is that of Bruce Wayne Tuckman's theory put forward in his short article 'Developmental sequence in small groups' (1965) and amendments (1977). I will first describe what may be understood by the terms group, group work and process. I will then offer an accurate synopsis of Tuckman's theory of group stage development. Next will be a critical analysis of the theory by relating it to

A summarizing critique of: Organizational Predictors of Women on Corporate Boards By Hillman. A. J., Shropshire. C. , Cannella Jr. A. A. (2007) In: Academy of Management Journal, 50: 941 - 952

1177 words - 5 pages . 1996. Distinguishing the effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict on strategic decision making: Resolving a paradox for top management teams. Academy of Management Journal, 39: 123-148.BRYMAN, A. and BELL, E., 2007. Business research methods. Second edition edn. New York: Oxford University Press.Carter, D. A., B. J. Simpkins and W. G. Simpson: 2003, Corporate Governance, Board Diversity and Firm Value, Financial Review 38, 33-53Dalton, D

The Development of Karl Marx's Critique

2499 words - 10 pages . 3. Proletariat as the weapon Despise of the differences in Marx’s critical approach, the importance of critique itself is a constant in Marx’s work; as it is the notion of the proletariat as the weapon to change reality. In the early texts, we can identify a need of merging philosophy with society, in the same letter to Ruge we cited before, Marx insists about this: “So we can summarize the tendency of our journal in one word; self

Involuntary Treatment of Schizophrenia Patients in Denmark

972 words - 4 pages the article? How does it connect to other materials on similar topics? Evidence questions: Does the writers’ evidence support their argument? Is it believable? (Online, 2014; Online, 2014). By using having these questions formed I found that by the time it came to the second paper it was easier to critique as I had this guide and had discussed my first paper. Being involved in small groups I felt was a great way to discuss the journal articles

Educating Information Technology Staff

1318 words - 6 pages organizations. One such goal of the organization may be to reduce information security risks. Additionally, the section will identify recommendations for improvements to organizational training approaches. Positive Critique Organization face increased challenges in the protection of information and reducing risks. To assist in combating information risks organization employ various training strategies to educate employees. An organization that

Forgiveness Therapy

1054 words - 4 pages on alternative individualized treatment based on routine therapy techniques. This article was the first to question the effectiveness of Forgiveness Therapy as a main factor of relapse prevention. Critique of the Title Upon reviewing this article and evaluating the titles it can be determined that the title is sufficiently specific. According to Pyrcazak (2008), a title should not only be specific but concise. The title Effects of

A Critique: Web-based Orientation Materials and Information Processing

2574 words - 11 pages , such as hyperlinking and the easy for the user. On the other hand there are negative aspect such as information overload. Furthermore, this critique opened up the potential for cross-disciplinary collaboration within organization communication and cognitive psychology. Works Cited Alvesson, M. (2000). Social Indentity And The Problem of Loyalty In Knowledge‐Intensive Companies. Journal of management studies, 37(8), 1101-1124. Baddeley

Essay instructions on decriptive essay on gloabalization - GOVT 425 - Essay

686 words - 3 pages , since it must flow with the overall tenor of your own style and argument. · In the next section of the essay, offer a concise defense of the argument. Why is it at least plausible? There is always something rationally defensible about a peer-reviewed journal article on US foreign policy. · For the remainder of your response, offer a critique of the article. What are the limits, problems, or gaps in the author’s argument? There are limits, problems

Similar Essays

Journal Article Critique Essay

1883 words - 8 pages Research Article 1 Roberts, T. (2003). Effects of Alphabet-Letter Instruction on Young Children’s Word Recognition [Electronic Version]. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95 (1), 41-51. Title The title of the article gave a fair representation of the topic as it was clear and concise in the wording. The title encompassed the idea that alphabet letter instruction on young children’s word recognition would be explored through experiments

Journal Of Teacher Education Critique Essay

1380 words - 6 pages Introduction The Journal of Teacher Education has been in existence since March of 1950. According to the journals website ( it has an impact factor of 1.891 and is ranked 18 out of 184 in Education & Educational Research. The purpose of this paper is to critique issue 64 volume 3 of 2011. This paper is organized so that description of information is presented about the authors, institutions and topics of each paper

Journal Critique Essay

710 words - 3 pages The main purpose of this article, "Bringing Mental Health needs into focus through School Counseling Program Transformation” was to explained how a transformation of a program in a school setting can help tremendously the overall well-being of students. This transformation was done with the collaboration and effort of school counselors, administration, and teachers. This article focus on the need for school counselors to be

Journal Critique Essay

1532 words - 7 pages vehicle for teaching higher order thinking skills for both English and social studies in elementary and secondary levels. (Fragnoli, 2013) In this article, Fragnoli writes a rationale for bringing items into the classroom. I found this as an important aspect in her journal. Fragnoli’s rationale is that bringing objects into the classroom will allow learners to touch history first hand and at the same time allow for the use of higher order