Judith Thomason View On The Issue Of Abortion

565 words - 2 pages

Judith Thomason is a pro-abortionist. . She allows for the sake of argument that fetus a full-fledged from the movement of conception. She agrees to identify fetus as a person, but she tries to disapprove of this conceptShe thinks that a new-born infant is a person, has a full right to life, among other things. But a new-born infant is very different from a fetus at the beginning of the ninth month........."Every person has a right to life; the fetus is a person hence has a right to life. The mother has a right to control her body, but the right to life is stronger right. Therefore, an abortion may not be performed." This anti-abortionist argument deals with particular case of abortion by reasoning from more general principle: if we have a choice between respecting someone's right to life and respecting someone's right to control their body, the right to life should always win out. That's what anti-abortionist seems to be saying. So if anti-abortionist is right, we can't kill the person whose life is in the balance in these cases. Thomason uses the violinist example to undermine this argument. In this example, Thomason asks you imagine that you find yourself hooked up to a famous unconscious violinist. If he can't use your kidney for nine months, he will die. You are in this position not because of you agreed to be but the Society of Music Lovers kidnapped you. All in the same, the violinist himself is perfectly innocent; he had no part in creating your predicament .Thomason thinks that this argument produces the wrong result when we apply it to the violinist...

Find Another Essay On Judith Thomason view on the issue of Abortion

The Christian View of Abortion Essay

904 words - 4 pages fetus, usually by assaulting and battering the mother; esp., the act of unlawfully causing the death of a fetus. 2. An intentionally induced miscarriage – Also spelled foeticide. – Also termed child destruction” (Garner, 2009). The abortion is the right of a woman over her own body (Roe v Wade) and feticide is an attack on a soon to be mother,” (White House, 2004). Based on the above, this writer does not understand the public policy rationale

The Controversial Issue of Abortion and Christianity

1124 words - 4 pages The Controversial Issue of Abortion Abortion is a very controversial issue in society today. Some people think that abortion is a good idea to solve problems and that it is justified yet the Catholic Church would argue this is not the case and that abortion is wrong. There are some very strong arguments both for and against abortion. There are two methods of abortion: 1) The Suction Method: This is used for

Roe V. Wade: The Issue of Abortion

1511 words - 7 pages Roe V. Wade: The Issue of Abortion Abortion is one issue that has polarized a nation and the battle lines were drawn forty years ago with time not easing the tensions between the groups on both sides of this issue. The abortion debate started in the middle of the 1800’s. However, the issue came to a head in 1973 with the Supreme Court ruling of Roe v. Wade which legalized abortion and the fight has been ongoing ever since. This paper aims to

Is the Issue of Abortion Justifiable

901 words - 4 pages the society, when does its life begin? The heart begins to beat at 22 days and even takes on the human form, and aborting it could be considered murder he concept of personhood is different from the concept of human life. Human life occurs at conception, but fertilized eggs used for in vitro fertilization are also human lives and those not implanted are routinely thrown away. Is this murder, and if not, then how is abortion murder? Another

Evaluate Judith Jarvis Thomsons' defense of abortion

2968 words - 12 pages her argument was based on the premiss that she was pretending that the foetus was a person from conception and therefore an early abortion would not be the killing of a person.All in all one is left as she assumes, feeling quite unsatisfied with her arguments as a whole due to the fact that she never gives a definite yes no answer to the issue. But this is quite understandable especially with a subject as controversial as abortion in which at times

Buddhist view on Abortion

678 words - 3 pages number of devoted Catholics and defended by at least a few. As a Buddhist, I would most likely still be for abortion. Buddhism itself speaks with more than one moral voice on this issue against abortion. The core belief in Buddhism is against abortion, but there are commonly people of this religion that don’t agree with that. For the time in which I will be writing this essay, I am one of those people. Most of my fellow Buddhists believe in the

Judaism's View on Abortion

1112 words - 4 pages Judaism's View on Abortion There are many different views on abortion and rabbis have given their opinions over the centuries. The Bible asserts that G-d created all things, but the issue of abortion depends on when life begins in the womb. Read Exodus 21 verses 22 - 23. What does this passage tell us about the mother's life and the unborn child's rights

Exploring the Abortion Issue

3867 words - 15 pages life. Almost 75% of pro-choice supporters considered religion to be unimportant to them while 69% of women that were pro-life reported that religion was very important to them (Luker). It can be concluded that abortion is also a very complex issue where individual circumstances have huge impacts on personal positions. In an analysis of a series of studies taken from 1980 to 2003, Greg Shaw of the Public Opinion Quarterly shows that people’s

The Abortion Issue

4889 words - 20 pages States (Abortiontv). In a state-by-state comparison in 1996, California and New York by far had the largest number of abortions, 280,180 to 152,991 respectively. (Abortiontv). When it comes to the general public’s view on of abortion, a clear pattern in their opinions can be hard to find. When asked whether abortion should be legal or illegal in a Gallup poll conducted in October of 2003, 26% of Americans felt abortion should be legal under any

The Book of Judith

1690 words - 7 pages Israelites understood that they were wrong and Judith then tells them she has a plan but they must follow her rules and not ask what she is going to do. They are to go to the gate that night and wait for her and her maid. Judith then falls on her face and repents of all her sins before God. She cries out to him asking him that he may protect her and help her as she follows through with her plan. She then takes off her widow’s clothes and bathes

The right to Life. On abortion from a religious point of view

644 words - 3 pages Life is a right held by all creatures on the universe, everything has life; however, everything also has it's own character or individuality. Every person is his or her own self and does what he or she wishes to do to a certain extent. Many people are opposed to an individuals decision on life they should realize that in America people have the freedom to do what they want.In Roman times, abortion ans the destruction of unwanted children was

Similar Essays

Develop Your Point Of View On A Controversial Issue In Society: Abortion

802 words - 3 pages putting it extremely mild. I have seen photographs of aborted babies. Those pictures were probably the most tragic and depressing images that I have ever laid my eyes on. It brings tears to your eyes to see the tiny, dissected forms of precious living beings that had no chance at life.The amazing thing is that the people involved in the abortion process have no remorse or shame for doing this at all. They think that it is okay and perfectly moral

The Issue Of Abortion Essay

870 words - 3 pages The Issue of Abortion People all over the world, especially those in American society, do not take the issue of abortion lightly. Dealing with ethics, religious beliefs and the law, it is one of the most controversial subjects of this time. Abortion poses a moral, social and medical dilemma that forces many individuals to react in very strong and unfortunately, opposing ways. Forty percent of the American people believe that the decision

The Controversial Issue Of Abortion Essay

1422 words - 6 pages Abortion is a very controversial topic. This paper will discuss the opposing sides of the issue as well as my own personal opinion. The basic question is when a developing person actually becomes a person or alive. The following articles: A Defense of Abortion, by Judith Jarvis Thomson and Opposition to Abortion: A Human Rights Approach, by Baruch Brody discuss the opposing sides of the abortion issue. I will be using and summarizing those

Common Ground On The Abortion Issue

1368 words - 5 pages province. This would take federal judges out of the mix completely, and make legislating on abortion a state's issue. States and provinces could then allow abortion, forbid it, or anything in between.   Since the above intermediate goals also remain yet unattainable, pro-life forces today are seeking more immediate goals, particularly so in the United States. These include parental notification and consent for abortion for minor daughters