Julius Caesar Brutus & Cassius: Who Is The Better Leader?

2281 words - 9 pages

In William Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, Brutus and Cassius are very influential characters. Each character makes many mistakes with the assassination plans and the strategies at Philippi. Each man has his reasons for their mistakes, if it is either their idealism, being uncompassionate or not, fully thinking for their actions. Brutus and Cassius are very contrasting people; one man is better suited to be a leader of a battle and an Empire, than the other. That man is: Marcus Brutus. Although Brutus makes many consequential mistakes, his errors are made because his nobleness outranks his intelligence. Whereas for Cassius, his mistakes are made from poor decision making. Brutus himself knows that he is often too honourable and not as realistic as he should be. ?I am not gamesome; I do lack some part / Of that quick spirit that is in Antony? [Act I, Scene II, L 28 ? 29]. By knowing this, that makes Brutus a better and stronger leader, since he is able to admit to his weakness.Cassius is a very mischief person. His reasons to assassinate Caesar are far less noble than them of Brutus. Cassius?s intentions to kill Caesar are of jealousy. He is jealous that has become more powerful than Cassius. As well he is selfish in his reasons for the killing. Earlier in the times of Pompey, Cassius fought against Caesar. Which demonstrates him wanting Caesar dead. He shows his jealousy/selfishness towards Caesar to Brutus. ?For once, upon a raw and gusty day, / The troubled Tiber chaffing with her shores, / Caesar said to me ?Dar?st thou, Cassius, now / Leap in with me into this angry flood, / And swim to yonder point?? Upon the word, / Accoutred as I was, I plunged in / And bade him follow; so indeed he did. / The torrent roar?d, and we did buffet it / With lusty sinews, throwing it aside / And stemming it with hearts of controversy; / But ere we could arrive the point propose?d, / Caesar cried ? Help me, Cassius, or I sink!? / I, as Aeneas, our great ancestor, / Did from the flames of Troy upon his shoulder / the old Anchises bear, so from the waves of Tiber / Did I the tired Caesar.) (Act I, Scene II. L 100 ? 115). There he was indicating that one day Caesar was drowning and asked Cassius to save him. Cassius tries to use this to persuade Brutus, that Caesar is not a good leader. As we all know, physical strength/abilities does not make a leader any better. Once again he uses another ?cheap shot? to try to convince Brutus. ?He had a fever when he was in Spain, / And when he fit was on him, I did mark / How coward lips did from their colour fly, / And that same eye whose bend doth awe the world / Did lose his luster; I did hear him groan; / Ay, and that tongue of his, that bade the Romans, / Mark him and write his speeches in their books, / Alas! It cried, ?Give me some drink, Titinius?, / As a sick girl. / Ye gods, it doth amaze me, / A man of such a feeble temper should / So get the start of the majestic world, / And bear the palm alone.? (Act I, Scene II, L....

Find Another Essay On Julius Caesar- Brutus & Cassius: Who Is the better leader?

Cassius and Brutus in William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

4191 words - 17 pages Cassius and Brutus in William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar Julius Caesar is set in 44 BC were Rome was a republic. Roman influence had spread beyond Italy and through the Mediterranean and some of North Africa and also parts of Germany, Belgium and Britain. Rome was governed by a senate. The main objective of all this meant that not one person was solely in charge and had absolute power and were king like. Marcus

The Ways Shakespeare Reveals the Characters of Brutus and Cassius in the Play Julius Caesar

1761 words - 7 pages conspirators are Marcus Brutus and Caius Cassius, Shakespeare presents them as very different characters who have their own and very different reasons for murdering Caesar. In the start of the play Brutus and Cassius are attending the feast of Lupeical, celebrated by the people of Rome. Brutus is a very close friend of Caesar and admires and loves him as a leader and a friend. "I love him well." Brutus asks about shouting from the

The Difference Between Brutus and Cassius in William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

1393 words - 6 pages lives. Cassius has the better plan but he submits to Brutus. Finally, when Brutus and Cassius are arguing with each other about everything from taking bribes to who is the better soldier, Brutus again shows his superiority. When they near the end of the long argument, Cassius gives up and begins to ask Brutus to kill him: "Strike as thou didst at Caesar, for I know when thou didst hate him worst, thou lovedst him better than

The Changing of Brutus and Cassius Throughout William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

4397 words - 18 pages The Changing of Brutus and Cassius Throughout William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar William Shakespeare's play, Julius Caesar, is one of his most inspirational, influential and greatest tragedies. Although Julius Caesar is set in Rome over 2000 years ago, it explores themes that are relevant to our own modern times and would have been relevant to Elizabethans in Shakespeare's England. One of the main issues explored in

Brutus is the Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

932 words - 4 pages The tragedy “Julius Caesar” by William Shakespeare should be renamed “Brutus” because Caesar is not the tragic hero. He is only in a small portion of the play and does not possess a major tragic flaw; however Marcus Brutus fits the description of tragic hero much better than Julius Caesar. Typically, tragedies are named after the tragic hero, which Aristotle describes as: a person of noble birth with a tragic flaw that leads to his or her

Julius Caesar versus Brutus

697 words - 3 pages The title of the historic tragedy Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare implies that Caesar is the tragic hero. Although Caesar is a universal character, William Shakespeare’s play Julius Caesar should have been titled Brutus because he is the real tragic hero. The classical definition of a tragic hero is a person who is neither completely virtuous nor utterly villainous and falls from great status caused by a tragic flaw or error in judgment

Julius Caesar Essay: The Character of Brutus

1243 words - 5 pages The Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar      “Et tu Brute?” Caesar’s simple statement sums up Brutus’ round character in the development of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar. Brutus was thought to represent no threat due to his nobility and his loyalty; however, these qualities are precisely why the story is such a catastrophe.  What stemmed from these traits is the last expected outcome.  Caesar’s surprise was so immense, he could only mutter

Why Cassius is the Greatest Manipulator in Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare

987 words - 4 pages their king, then Brutus could also, making Rome a better place. Cassius also uses self-gain as manipulation. He wants Brutus to rule the land and he says to him that it is Brutus who should control Rome and not Caesar. “Men at some time are masters of their fates: 
The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves that we are underlings.” (I.2.140) Cassius says “underlings” to tell Brutus that if he does not proceed to take

The Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar

898 words - 4 pages !           Speak no more of her. Give me a bowl of wine.           In this I bury all unkindness, Cassius."           ( IV, iii, 141-158)         The people of Rome respected Brutus greatly. The conspirators thought very highly of him and wanted him to be part of their scheme against Julius Caesar. If they could get Brutus to join in on the plan the people might think it was all right that they killed the great Caesar

Who Is The Hero In Julius Caesar By Shakespeare?

382 words - 2 pages vie for the title of hero, including the namesake of the play, Caesar, himself. But could the hero be loyal best friend Marc Antony, the crafty Cassius, or virtuous Brutus.My first thought is that Brutus is the hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar. He is in a powerful position in the Roman government and seems to have the best interest of the Republic at heart. Even though he agrees to the assassination plot, he is torn between loyalty to Rome and

Cassius' Words in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

722 words - 3 pages Cassius' Words in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar        In William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, the importance of Cassius and Brutus' dialogues in Act 1, Scene 2, lines 135-78 to the play is that it enables Cassius to deceive Brutus to join the conspirators. Cassius' words in this passage show that he is a very cunning individual who persuades Brutus to join the conspirators to rid Rome of his so-called " tyranny."   Cassius

Similar Essays

Julius Caesar: Who Is The Better Tragic Hero, Caesar Or Brutus?

1572 words - 6 pages as a character of great reputation and prosperity whose misfortune is not due to depravity or vice, for the hero is a virtuous man or woman but to an error in judgment resulting from a tragic flaw. Sometimes this flaw is an excess of virtue. In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare people are arguing over who is the perfect tragic hero Julius Caesar or Marcus Brutus. They both fit the criteria of a tragic hero, but Marcus Brutus

Julius Caesar Would Have Been The Best Leader Between; Brutus, Antonius, Cassius, And Caesar

1042 words - 4 pages Irony- incongruity between the actual result of a sequence of events and the normal or expected resultIt is 101 BC, the Roman Empire is at its zenith, and a man named Julius Caesar has the power of it within his grasp. Unwanted till now, he soon realizes the influence he now holds over so many lives. Perhaps he is naïve. However, if choosing who out of Marcus Brutus, Marcus Antonius, Cassius, and Julius Caesar; I choose whom the people

Julius Caesar Contrasts Between Brutus And Cassius

3691 words - 15 pages front of the conspirators. Initially Cassius was the leader when at the start of the scene he lead the conspirators into Brutus` home but there has been a violent rebellion by Brutus and a violent verbal assault as a result, him being the sole leader, "To kindle cowards, and to steal with valour", Here Brutus is saying the only person who needs an oath would be a coward despite this Brutus is being very abusive towards Cassius` practical

Julius Caesar A Comparison Of Brutus And Cassius

1783 words - 7 pages ourselves dishonorable graves" (Julius Caesar, 551, act 1, scene 2). Cassius confides to Brutus how he despises Caesar's immense pride and power. Cassius testifies that Caesar believes himself to be a `Colossus', better then everyone else, even his companions who grovel below him. The Colossus is an immense statue that guarded the harbor of Rhodes and is one of the Seven Wonders of the World. This implies that Cassius believes Caesar thinks he