This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Julius Caesar Versus Brutus Essay

697 words - 3 pages

The title of the historic tragedy Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare implies that Caesar is the tragic hero. Although Caesar is a universal character, William Shakespeare’s play Julius Caesar should have been titled Brutus because he is the real tragic hero.
The classical definition of a tragic hero is a person who is neither completely virtuous nor utterly villainous and falls from great status caused by a tragic flaw or error in judgment ( As all heroes do, tragic heroes often fall in line with archetypes. Tragic heroes repeatedly enjoy free choice, endure a punishment that exceeds their crime, undergo a course of enlightenment, and harvest a catharsis or a purging of human emotions in readers (Crowther). Tragic heroes are never perfect and are either killed by the end of the story or have fallen so far from their previous high status that they have nothing left from their old life.
More powerful than Brutus, Caesar is a tyrant that ...view middle of the document...

ii). Again, he uses his free will to postpone personal matters when he is on his way to the senate meeting and a citizen bestows a letter that could possibly save his life. While being stabbed to death by the conspirators, Caesar suddenly undergoes enlightenment and proclaims, “et tu, Brutus? – Then fall, Caesar” (lll.i). Et tu meaning you to. Caesar also falls from his high status of emperor when he is killed. Caesar does not fit the bill of a tragic hero in my eyes because he shows no true signs of being a good man during his life.
The true tragic hero, Brutus is a courteous, kindly senator who is concerned for others and wants nothing more than to preserve the Roman Republic. He is compelled by Cassius, who has false intentions in killing Caesar, to participate in the assassination of Caesar. This is Brutus’s tragic flaw, he is too unsuspecting. He lets Cassius manipulate his mind. Also, Brutus is too innocent to comprehend that by allowing Antony to speak at Caesar’s funeral, he is sealing his fate. Likewise, Brutus has a choice. A choice to kill Caesar for the good of Rome or not kill Caesar and risk the future of Rome under a tyrant. Brutus defends his actions by saying, “Not that I loved Caesar less but that I loved Rome more” (lll.ii). Brutus’s fate produces a catharsis in readers when he runs onto his sword held by Strato. In killing himself, he has fallen from his high status to the status of death. He became aware of his mistakes and admits to them saying, “Caesar, now be still. I killed not thee with half so good a will” (V.v). Brutus was not all bad and not all good. He possesses more traits of the classic tragic hero.
Both Caesar and Brutus possess traits typical of tragic heroes. To me however, Brutus is the character that best exemplifies the classical definition of a tragic hero. Brutus is a character that more readers can identify with. Caesar dies before we really get to understand his character. Readers learn most of what they know about Caesar through the other characters while with Brutus readers get to observe his true nature. Brutus was more of an honorable man than Caesar. When comparing Caesar and Brutus, Brutus seems to be the rightful owner of the title of tragic story told by William Shakespeare.

Find Another Essay On Julius Caesar versus Brutus

The Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar

898 words - 4 pages The Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar         Brutus was a very important character in the play Julius Caesar written by William Shakespeare. He helped plan a plot against one of the most powerful people in Rome and killed the king to be. Brutus was well renowned for his deep thinking, his honor, and most importantly, his belief in stoicism.         Brutus's stoic qualities played a major role in his

Brutus for Ruler in Shakespeare's "Julius Caesar"

652 words - 3 pages In the play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare there are several people who would be good rulers of Rome. Out of them all Brutus would have been the best choice to lead Rome. Brutus would be the best chosen leader for Rome for several reasons. Brutus was a very smart man and smartness is a very good quality for a leader. Another feature Brutus had, was he had very little or maybe even no emotions, and if he did he did a very good job of hiding

Brutus, Caesar, and Antony as Protagonists in Julius Caesar

1333 words - 5 pages leader who is depicted in many different ways. Brutus friend of Caesar, loves Caesar greatly but does not think he possess leadership skills. Antony is loyal, trustworthy, and a devoted follower of Caesar, and proves to be a required character in Julius Caesar. All three of the protagonist must go through many highs and lows throughout the play. Brutus, Caesar, and Antony all qualify as protagonists in Julius Caesar because they all exhibit the

Julius Caesar - A Comparison of Brutus and Cassius

1783 words - 7 pages Julius Caesar - A Comparison of Brutus and Cassius       In the play Julius Caesar, written and preformed by William Shakespeare, there are many characters, but two, Brutus and Cassius, stood out. The play begins in Rome where a celebration of Julius Caesar's victory over the former ruler of Rome, Pompeii. The victory leads to Caesar's betrayal by his jealous companions. Senators and other high status figures are jealous of Caesar's

Marcus Brutus as Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

797 words - 3 pages Marcus Brutus as Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar      In many stories there is a tragic hero. The hero finds out about himself and the people around him in the story. In Shakespeare's play, Julius Caesar, Marcus Brutus is the tragic hero. The play Julius Caesar is about politics and betrayal in ancient Rome. Brutus is part of the senate, which is below Caesar, who is soon to be crowned. The senate wants to overthrow Caesar

Brutus’ Love for Rome in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar

897 words - 4 pages Brutus was a well-known person who loved Rome. His love for Rome led to him helping someone murder Julius Caesar, his leader. As a person do you love and care about your state or country so much that you would kill your leader to protect the people in it? Brutus cared so much about Rome and his people that he did just that. He lost his life for Rome, and it truly showed how much he cared for the people, which showed his level of honor. An

Marcus Brutus as the Protagonist of William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

1062 words - 4 pages Marcus Brutus as the Protagonist of William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar      All men have the power to reason.  Some men can reason better than others, nonetheless, all men can reason.  In order to reason, one must clear his mind, be completely impartial, and understand the situation to the best of his ability.  The play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare, is the story of a man trying his best to make reasonable

Brutus is the Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

932 words - 4 pages The tragedy “Julius Caesar” by William Shakespeare should be renamed “Brutus” because Caesar is not the tragic hero. He is only in a small portion of the play and does not possess a major tragic flaw; however Marcus Brutus fits the description of tragic hero much better than Julius Caesar. Typically, tragedies are named after the tragic hero, which Aristotle describes as: a person of noble birth with a tragic flaw that leads to his or her

Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar: Superseding Brutus, Even in Death

693 words - 3 pages Marcus Brutus’ effort to thwart tyranny appears to be a noble and admirable endeavor, but does Brutus’ willingness to oppose Caesar merit admiration? Should Brutus be designated as the tragic protagonist of Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar? Although applauding Brutus may seem appropriate based on his sincere affection for his fellow Romans, Shakespeare’s play is not a tale of a victorious underdog; therefore, Brutus is not a tragic

Sympathizing with Brutus of William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

1771 words - 7 pages Sympathizing with Brutus of William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare is an interesting and complex play based on historical events that took place in Rome in 44 BC. The plot revolves around the assassination of Julius Caesar by his closest 'friend'- Marcus Brutus, and Marc Antony's attempt to avenge his death. The play portrays many important themes that are still relevant in today's

The Assassination of Julius Caesar by Marcus Brutus

1118 words - 4 pages On 15 March 44 B.C.E the Roman dictator Julius Creaser was murdered. There are multiple accounts on what took place that day. However all account came far after the day of the incident. When reading the accounts, “The death of Caesar”, written by Caesar's biographer, Gaius Suetonius Tranquillus (c.70-c.135), “The Assassination of Julius Caesar” from Marcus Brutus, and In “The Assassination of Julius Caesar” by Nicolaus of Damascus, all accounts

Similar Essays

Julius Caesar Essay: The Character Of Brutus

1243 words - 5 pages The Character of Brutus in Julius Caesar      “Et tu Brute?” Caesar’s simple statement sums up Brutus’ round character in the development of The Tragedy of Julius Caesar. Brutus was thought to represent no threat due to his nobility and his loyalty; however, these qualities are precisely why the story is such a catastrophe.  What stemmed from these traits is the last expected outcome.  Caesar’s surprise was so immense, he could only mutter

Julius Caesar Contrasts Between Brutus And Cassius

3691 words - 15 pages JULIUS CAESAR COUSEWORK ESSAY Julius Caesar is set in 44 BC were Rome was a republic. Roman influence had spread beyond Italy and through the Mediterranean and some of North Africa and also parts of Germany, Belgium and Britain. A senate governed Rome. The main objective of all this meant that not one person was solely in charge and had absolute power and were king like. Marcus Brutus is the most complex character in this play

Justification Of Brutus’ Betrayal Of Julius Caesar

2970 words - 12 pages Justification of Brutus’ Betrayal of Julius Caesar In William Shakespeare’s tragedy Julius Caesar, the character of Marcus Brutus is tasked with making a difficult choice: either kill one of his most beloved friends, or risk the corruption and downfall of Rome. Though Brutus acknowledges the ethical and moral concerns of his actions, he commits to the conspiracy against Caesar, and carries it out with conviction. The question, however, is

Brutus: Tragic Hero In "Julius Caesar"

831 words - 3 pages The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare centers on Caesar, a Roman dictator, and his demise in 44 B.C. Brutus, along with seven other conspirators, assassinate Caesar to prevent him from becoming king. The Romans then wage war with these conspirators, and all eight are either murdered, or commit suicide. At this point in the play, the audience realizes who the tragic hero is. A tragic hero is a character in a high social standing who