This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Jurors On A Death Penalty Case

1210 words - 5 pages

One of the most intense group task experiences in the United States is that of serving on the jury of a death penalty case. This forces a group of complete strangers to come together and determine the fate of another’s human beings life. The court case of the State of Ohio v Mark Ducic, was of no exception. Ducic a 47 year old drug addict white male, was accused of committing a double homicide. In accordance with Ohio state law, murdering more than one individual is considered a mass murder and therefore the accused is subject to the possibility of the death penalty. Ducic’s victims included Barbara Davis, his domestic partner and drug addict, as well as a drug user that Ducic was an acquaintance with. The death of Davis was at first believed to be due to an overdose, but police informants identified Ducic’s voice on a recording claiming that he killed her. The other victim, the drug addict, was thought to be eliminated by Ducic for fear that he would inform the police that he killed Davis. Investigators believed that Ducic gave both victims a deathly amount of drugs that would make it appear as though they both simply overdosed. Ducic was found guilty on both occasions, yet a second trial in regards to his sentencing had to occur and another hearing had to be conducted on whether or not to remove the death penalty.
As one of the seven jury deliberations documented and recorded in the ABC News television series In the Jury Room the discussions of the jurors were able to be seen throughout the United States. A transcript was also created by ABC News for the public as well. The emotions and interactions of the jurors were now capable of being portrayed to anyone interested in the interworkings of jury deliberations. The first task, as instructed by the judge of the court, was for the jury to identify if the death penalty should be used. The jury had to unanimously agree that the state prosecution team left no doubt that the accused was guilty and that his crimes called for the use of the death penalty. After this first task the jury could not agree to a death penalty they would have to choose the following three options. First, that Ducic should receive a life sentence with no opportunity to parole. Second, a life sentence with the chance to parole after 30 years served. Or third, that Ducic serve 25 years before having the chance to receive parole.
Early in the deliberations it was increasingly apparent that a handful of jurors had the goal to identify factors in the case that would not allow the death penalty to occur, whereas a many other jurors believed immediately that Ducic was guilty and deserved the death penalty. Surprisingly, many jurors appeared to already have their minds made up without the sharing of information or conversing with other jurors to see where they were currently standing. Many jurors claimed that the use of illegal drugs had strongly influenced the defendant’s critical thinking ability, while others believed that the...

Find Another Essay On Jurors on a Death Penalty Case

The Death Penalty on Trial Essay

2509 words - 10 pages punishment for offenders” (Dieter). Nothing about a 2 percent execution rate per year says swift. States with the death penalty have continually produced higher homicide rates than those without the death penalty. From 1991 to 2011 the average homicide rate for states with the death penalty was 6.74—the highest being “9.94” (1991) (Death Penalty Information Center)—the lowest being “4.89” (2011) (Death Penalty Information Center).   On the other

Arguementative Essay on Death Penalty

892 words - 4 pages Argumentative Essay on Death PenaltyThere is a controversy over whether capital punishment works or not, or if it is even morally right. Capital punishment is used only in felony cases such as murder or any criminal activity with the outcome of unintentional acts of murder ("Crimes" 1).There are now 38 states that employ the death penalty (Williams-Harold 1). This high numbers alone shows that the majority of the people have a strong belief in

The Death Penalty on Trail

897 words - 4 pages capital punishment is purported as if it exacts swift justice on a daily basis, thereby deterring criminals every second, this is not the case. Even if we were to consider a positive outlook on capital punishment, for a criminal, “The chance of being executed in America is so remote that it cannot plausibly be a significant deterrent” (The Economist). On average, “the chance of being put to death in any given year is only about 2%” (The Economist

Opinion on the death penalty

1015 words - 4 pages I'm really for the death penalty but it was just easier to be againstOpinion on the Death PenaltyThe death penalty, also referred to as capital punishment, has been abolished in Canada since 1976, but still exist in a few American States. The last execution in Canada took place in 1962.I disagree with the death penalty for several reasons. My first reason is that I find it extremely inhumane to take someone's life in order to demonstrate the

Furman v. Georgia: The Death Penalty Case

2166 words - 9 pages . The murders weapon was still in his pocket,” (Herda 9). Furman tried to plead guilty by insanity and the psychiatrists described him as legally insane. But then, several days later one of the psychiatrists revised their medical opinion. Because he was not insane, the case would go on. The state of Georgia charged him with murder and issued the death penalty. This was because Georgia state law stated that any form of murder issued with a felony was

The Case Against the Death Penalty

1446 words - 6 pages data, making up motives, until he was convicted and later executed. His family is still fighting to clear his name even after his death; he maintained his innocence until the day he was executed. Years passed, and people were asking themselves “What if Todd was really innocent?” On 2009, the Texas Forensic Science Commission reviewed the Willingham case, they found the following: “A finding of arson could not be sustained by a scientific

Furman v. Georgia: The Death Penalty Case

1039 words - 5 pages was still in his pocket,” (Herda 9). Furman tried to plead guilty by insanity and the psychiatrists described him as legally insane. But then, several days later one of the psychiatrists revised their medical opinion. Because he was not insane, the case would go on. The state of Georgia charged him with murder and issued the death penalty. This was because Georgia state law stated that any form of murder issued with a felony was punishable by

Death Penalty: A Cruel and Unusual Punishment

983 words - 4 pages . This punishment gives rise and sets as an example of barbarousness and cruelness in the society. Alternative punishments should be considered before sentencing the convict to death. There are sufficient punishments like life imprisonment to replace death penalty which will keep the anti-social elements away from the society. Works Cited Bedau, H. A. (2012). The case against the death penalty. Retrieved from https://www.aclu.org/capital

A Paper Against the Death Penalty

1183 words - 5 pages like cops alone on the streets." (Time, Inc). Kane, on the other hand, stated, "An ideal sphere in which everybody's rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness are being respected." (Time, Inc). In this case, I agree with Kane. I think that everyone deserves to have the right to live and not put to death, even if he is a cop killer.Turow suggests that, "Murder victim family member oppose the death penalty, even in the ease of their loved

America Needs a Tougher Death Penalty

1067 words - 4 pages the criminal justice system. Two reasons why the death penalty should be enforced are saved time, by the court system through limited appeals, and saved money, by taxpayers due to reduced court and imprisonment fees. Much of the court's time could be saved if death row inmates were limited to a set number of appeals in a reasonable amount of time. Facilitating numerous appeals results in many unforeseen costs. In 1992, expenditures on

The Death Penalty: A Necessary Evil

845 words - 3 pages committed. The worst crime possible should therefore receive the worst penalty possible. That penalty is the death penalty. Take, for example, the case of a man who is caught shoplifting. He does not deserve the same punishment as someone who is convicted of assault and battery. Most people would have no problem agreeing with this. Yet many of these same people believe that a cold blooded killer deserves the same life sentence as a convicted kidnapper

Similar Essays

A Case In Favor Of The Death Penalty

1665 words - 7 pages determining which method is effective between the different punishment models. With this is the debate on the issue of the death penalty as a form of punishment for high-profile crimes. Should the criminal justice system adopt a more lenient approach and abolish the use of the death penalty for capital offenses, or should it embark on a more restorative form of justice? This paper argues for the use of the death penalty in the criminal justice

The Juvenile Death Penalty: A Case For It

2151 words - 9 pages that a juvenile offender never sees life outside of the prison walls ever again, which would be a true life sentence would be the juvenile death penalty. Rehabilitation is a great aspect of the juvenile justice system, however it does not apply to all cases. Some cases, like in the Austin Sigg case, the offender has committed a crime so terrible that they simply cannot be rehabilitated from it. When the offender reaches the point where they feel no

The Death Penalty: A Discussion On Its Pros And Cons

1293 words - 5 pages The death penalty, a constant source of controversy and divided opinion, is the punishment of death given to criminals who commit severe crimes. As the severity of crimes that attract the death penalty is debatable, so is its correctness and effectiveness. The justice system is based upon punishment for crimes committed with emphasis on the punishment fitting the crime. Countries such as China and Singapore have used it to punish drug

This Is A Persuasive Essay On The Death Penalty

1413 words - 6 pages spend a few years in jail before being released to return to our neighborhoods? Or should the taker-of-life have his or her life also taken? This is a complicated moral question, especially for a country like ours which values mercy, morality and justice.Some people say that the death penalty is immoral, that killers have a right to live since they are human beings, too. People against the death penalty ask why killers should lose their right to