This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Jury Essay

2150 words - 9 pages

"Jurors will vote with their hearts, and then find the legal hook to hang their emotions on," a law professor advised me almost 20 years ago. In other words, rather than basing their decisions on the law, jurors vote according to their feelings - and then decide the law they will use to justify that decision. Perhaps the reason so many people were outraged by the O.J. Simpson case was because it was such a blatant example of his theory.I have always remembered his words and keep them in the forefront of my mind as I help clients map out strategies for the courtroom. So when I'm called in to assist on a project, my first question is: "What is the story?" I'm looking for a story to tell the jurors which will emotionally connect them to my client's case. But what happens more often than not, instead of getting a story, I get the law.An Inheritance Case: The Plaintiff's StoryFor instance, in a case involving an elderly woman suing the family of her 'gentleman friend' for part of his estate, I was informed the case was about a verbal contract. The plaintiff claimed that she had been the old man's caretaker for 10 years and that he had promised to financially compensate her in his will for her services . But he had left his estate to his family, instead. A new will, bequeathing her $100,000, had been drafted, but not signed. Plaintiff had to prove there had been an agreement and she should be compensated."Okay," I replied, "But what is the story?"Three hours later, after asking what seemed at times to my client to be irrelevant, dumb and exasperating questions, I got the answer to my initial query. The story was about Eloise, an 80 year old woman, who for 10 years had been Edmund Stacy's social partner, travel partner and in many ways, care provider. They lived in separate houses, but acted as a couple. She loved Edmund, looked after him and was there for him when his own family was conspicuously absent. "Where was his son when Edmund got sick and had to go to the hospital?" she lamented. "Where were his grandchildren when he had a birthday? Who was there to take care of his everyday needs? Nobody, but me."Edmund had wanted to leave her money when he died, but she didn't want him to talk about dying, so nothing was done until the last minute. A new will was drafted, but Edmund left this world before having a chance to sign it.This story, designed to fit the evidence(!), gives the jurors a reason to care about Eloise. They will award her money not because they believe she and Edmund had a verbal contract, or because they believe she should be paid for her services. They will give her money because she loved this man, was there for him, and deserves recognition for her efforts and loyalties.The important point here is that every case has to to be analyzed from two points of view: the legal case and the juror's case. The legal case involves the law. The juror's case involves the jurors' feelings. The legal case for the plaintiff in this situation was...

Find Another Essay On Jury

Jury Nullification Essay

1907 words - 8 pages Jury nullification is when a jury acquits a defendant who it believes is guilty of the crime he is charged (Hickey, 2010. p. 370). This is because the jury chose to ignore the facts of the case and the judge instructions, and based his or her decision on personal opinion. If we are going to allow jury nullification we may as well not take up the tax-payer’s money to even take it to trial. Nullification – The act of making a law null and void

Jury Duty Essay

682 words - 3 pages In the courtroom there are many jobs that have a big importance in the court. For example the judge he has to listen to all the evidence being presented and he decides the sentence, or the attorney's they help the defendant or the plaintiff. But the jury I feel I that has one of the most important jobs in the court. In this essay I'm going to talk about the jurors importance in the trial, duties, and qualifications for position, ECT.The jurors

Runaway Jury: Depiction of Jury Tampering and Jury Sequestering

1062 words - 4 pages Summary The movie Runaway Jury starts with a shooting in a business office. The movie then continues to people receiving jury summons and people taking pictures of them. It goes on to show Rankin Fitch and the defense committing electronic surveillance during the jury selections. This movie shows how Fitch and the defense attempt to influence the jury to vote for the defense. The movie continuously shows a person by the name of “Marlee” who

Jury Trial Analysis

1143 words - 5 pages A jury trial is not to be confused with a bench trial as it often times is. While a bench trial takes places only in front of a Judge who is then tasked with coming to a verdict on his/her own, a jury trial is one that is “composed of members of the community present at the trial to act as the finder of fact” (McGuigan, 2014). The constitutional trial rights that are sanctioned throughout a jury trial is called a trial by jury. This is in the

Research on Jury Bias

1540 words - 7 pages Jury Bias With jury bias we examined that the perspective taking, victim impact statements and race of the victim had no main effects with ps > 0.26 and no significant interactions either with ps > 0.64. Jury Race The race of the jury was divided into white and non-white participants. An ANOVA was then run with perspective taking, victim impact statements, and race of the victim as the between-participants factors to test against empathy felt

A Jury Etiquette Manual

578 words - 2 pages Jury Etiquette ManualThe following manual is intended to explain the proper etiquette and protocol for jurors who are participating in a courtroom trial. This manual will address the expectations of a jury, sequestration, communication among jury members, voting procedures, and impartiality and fairness. In no way is this manual intended to sway a juror's verdict or influence a juror's decision. Jurors are reminded that they should take their

The runaway jury

2459 words - 10 pages THE RUNAWAY JURY By John Grisham Takes place in Biloxi, Mississippi.MAIN CHARACTERS Nicholas Easter - (real name is Jeff Kerr) Juror that was a plant on the jury. He and his girlfriend Marlee had money motives. Nicholas molded the jury from day one to vote his way.Marlee - (aka Claire Clement - real name is Gabrielle Brant) Nicholas Easter's accomplice on the outside of the courtroom.Rankin Fitch - Ran the show of high-priced lawyers and

Community by Jury

1896 words - 8 pages health. Kouzes and Posner (2003) noted that cooperative relationships are more productive than competitive relationships. This may appear to be an obvious point, but it is especially important within a group. This paper will also explore how community has played a large part in my personal growth as a leader and how I would create a cooperative, productive, and moral community. Community by Jury Jury dynamics provides an emotional and intellectual

The Jury System and Democracy

1115 words - 5 pages This essay will explain how the jury system and democracy are interrelated. It should also be considered whether juries are intended to be, or indeed whether it is possible to describe and define what the public conscience could be. This essay would include also the consideration of public opinion and concerns justifying the use of juries in criminal trials. A group of people (typically twelve in number) when take an oath to give a verdict

A Jury of Her Peers

1125 words - 5 pages ). The popular author and play right Susan Glaspell was inspired by this court case. In her play "Trifles" and her short story "A Jury of Her Peers", she used two average, underrated housewives in the early 1900s to show a different perspective of the Iowa crime. Through many symbols, amusing irony, and illuminating dialogue, Glaspell shows how powerful and intellectual women could be despite the suppressive culture of their time.The most predominant

Jury Essay: Medea on Trial

757 words - 4 pages ' jury-like'. When deliberating, the jury and I could have discused more thoroughly of why some thought Medea was innocent and why others thought she was guilty, rather then just vote and have majority rule the decision. The defense did not use their power to object the prosecutor as much as they probably should have. The jury was talking most of the time during the trial and the judge could have silenced the court more to keep things in order and better the trial.

Similar Essays

Jury Nullification Essay

2169 words - 9 pages Jury Nullification Jury NullificationShannon CollinsCJA/423 - Criminal Diversity in Criminal JusticeInstructor: Kenneth Bitting, M.A.October 31, 2007In this weeks project we are to recapitulate the arguments that are both in support of and opposed to race-based jury nullification. Including recent examples of race-based jury nullifications and to conclude by making a choice if we are in favor of or against race-based jury nullification and to

Jury Nullification Essay

1456 words - 6 pages Jury NullificationJury nullification is defined as the power of the individuals on the jury to judge the law itself and to refuse to convict the defendant if, in their judgment, the law is unjust. Jurors may also believe a law to be unconstitutional, unfair, discriminatory or misapplied in the particular case. (Libertocracy). For a trial to be legitimate, the jury must be informed that they have the right and duty to judge both the law and the

Jury Duty Essay

1162 words - 5 pages Serving on a jury is a civic duty and an American tradition. However, some people view jury duty as a chore or as an event that negatively interrupts their lives. Some independent studies have shown that even jury duty has a devastating effect on married life. Due to this and other extraneous situations, there are only a few people who actually want to serve on a jury. This may lead to efforts by potential jurors to, in some way get out of

Jury System Essay

561 words - 2 pages There are two methods of determining whether a person being charged with a criminal offense is guilty or not guilty; they can be tried before a judge or before a judge and jury. Each of these methods has its advantages, but in my mind a trial by jury is a better way of determining whether someone is guilty or not. A jury trial includes more than one persons' decision and interpretation of the evidence, it offers a thorough review and analysis of