This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Jury System Essay: Whether Or Not Jury Systems Should Be Used In Australia Legal Studies Essay

1019 words - 5 pages

Jury System Essay
Chelsea Watts
Jury System Essay
Chelsea Watts
A jury is a body of people, which consists of twelve citizens who must apply their common sense to deliberate and determine a verdict of guilty or not guilty during a trial1. Having the jury system involves the community in the administration of justice2 and works as a barrier between the state and the accused to reduce the possibility of tyranny3. It has been stated that juries are inconvenient, unrepresentative and an expensive system that should be abolished. The fundamentals of the jury system will be researched, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of having a jury to determine whether this statement is correct.
As Section 80 of the Australian Constitution states, The trial on indictment of any offence against any law of the Commonwealth shall be by jury, and every such trial shall be held in the State where the offence was committed, and if the offence was not committed within any State the trial shall be held at such place or places as the Parliament prescribes7. William the Conqueror originally introduced juries to England in 1066, but it wasn’t until the 14th century that they fulfilled their current role as determiner of fact in a case2. Juries have adapted over time, and now, a jury is a group of 12 citizens between the age of 18 and 70, which have been selected at random off the electoral roll for the House of Assembly2. These people can then be disqualified, ineligible, or challenged by a lawyer2. Juries are only used in indictable offences, which are heard in the District or Supreme Court2. Juries are only used in a minority of criminal cases, because most cases are heard in the Magistrates Court, defendants had pleaded guilty to the crime or the defendant had chosen to be trialled just by a Judge2. A jury’s role is to listen carefully to evidence in court, and deliberate a verdict of guilty, or not guilty.
As mentioned previously, having a jury system makes the community participate directly into the administration of justice, and connects citizens to the constitution3. It also spreads the weight of responsibility, and individual bias can be ruled out when sharing the decision making, rather than having one judge6. The jury system simultaneously reflects the community’s values. Having ordinary community members make the decisions theoretically exhibits broad community values, and is likely to be accepted by the community6. Furthermore, jury trials educate jurors about the justice system. Generally people who serve on juries have a greater respect for the system when they leave. It gives people an insight into the justice system and their community, as well as it corrects any misinterpretation about what happens in the courtroom3.
The guarantee of trial by jury reflects a profound judgement about the way the law should be enforced, and justice administered4. It is a right to be trialled by jury in order to intercept any oppression by the Government. It gives the...

Find Another Essay On Jury System Essay: Whether or Not Jury Systems Should Be Used in Australia - legal studies - Essay

Should Bicycle Riders Be Able To Choose Whether Or Not They Wear A Helmet? (Australia)

1053 words - 4 pages helmets. Many believe that compulsory helmet legislation is beneficial. Whether this is true or not depends on your perception of the many detailed studies about helmets and helmet testing methods. Helmets have been proven to work and dramatically reduce the chances of a skull fracture in a crash. Helmet laws can be effective because it raises the awareness that helmets can save lives, which many cyclists have attested to. Like seatbelts and smoke

The Jury System and Democracy Essay

1115 words - 5 pages This essay will explain how the jury system and democracy are interrelated. It should also be considered whether juries are intended to be, or indeed whether it is possible to describe and define what the public conscience could be. This essay would include also the consideration of public opinion and concerns justifying the use of juries in criminal trials. A group of people (typically twelve in number) when take an oath to give a verdict

Essay on "Les Miserables" by Victor Hugo and whether or not it should be included on a summer reading list

1204 words - 5 pages historical context without taking on the tone of a textbook. The only concern with the novel is its size, approximately 1500 pages unabridged. The abridged versions lose much of the detail and history while condensing the novel to about 300 pages (yeah, I read both).Bibliography:This was done a couple of years ago. It's sort of a persuasive writing projects on your opinion of a book of your choice and whether or not it should be included on a summer reading list for some AP english class or another. I think I used sparknotes and wikipedia as well as the novel itself as sources.

Should Torture be legal or not

1187 words - 5 pages Should Liberal Democracies use Torture?The use of torture has been around for generations, used as a means to punish criminals, or get useful information, or confessions from criminals. Although in ancient times the methods of torture were never questioned, today the topic of using torture in a liberal democracy is a highly debated topic amongst government and military officials. Since the tragedy of 9-11, the question of whether or not torture

Abortion. Should it be Legal or Not?

1413 words - 6 pages difficult and vulnerable time after the separation. Also for victims of rape cases, it may be very difficult to even have the baby. After going through such a horrible situation, having the baby of your own rapist is a constant reminder.The government should not have a say on what a woman should do with her reproductive system. In end, it should be the woman's choice whether or not she wants to have an abortion. There are many reasons why women

Deciding Whether a Case Should be Prosecuted or Not

1254 words - 6 pages evidence is reliable and can it be used in court. This means carefully assessing the quality of the evidence from all related witnesses before reaching a final decision. Grand jury indictments will be presented by the prosecutors only when and if a criminal case has not been diverted, downgraded, or dismissed. In order to compose a Grand jury citizens are selected from tax lists drivers license and voters registrations. In order to formally

Toulmin argumentative essay about whether humans should eat animals or not - university - essay

1109 words - 5 pages deprivation. Another possible objection is that the anatomy of the human body, particularly the mouth, is meant for the consumption of both plants and animals. By avoiding meat, it may be pointed out that vegetarians are essentially going against their natural functions. If that is the case, some might claim that vegetarianism is unnatural and should thus be avoided if the aim is to be healthy in a natural way. To be sure, not a single plant can

Advantages of Jury Trials in the Canadian justice system

2082 words - 8 pages procedures to ensure that during a "charge to the jury", a judge is unable to bias the jury either unintentionally or inadvertently. Even if the judge follows protocol, if the case goes before an appellate court, the court will look at "the general sense which the words used must have conveyed, in all probability, to the mind of the jury, not whether a particular formula was recited by the judge" (Linney. v. R). This fact of looking at the effect of the

animal research whether we should do it or not - english - essay

1547 words - 7 pages ENG 112 April 2, 2017 Should Animal testing be banned or not Animal experimentation has been a controversial topic for many years. Testing animals has played an imperative role for new discoveries and human benefits. Animal testing has contributed to many life-saving cures and treatments, animal research is protected by laws, animals also benefit from research too, and Animals are good for research because they are like us in many ways. Some

The History of the Jury System

678 words - 3 pages facts in a jury trial, the accuracy of the testimony, the guilt or innocence of criminal defendants, and liabilities in a civil litigation. Today, many countries such as Britain, United States, Brazil, Canada, Japan, Australia, France, German, India, and so on practice jury trials. These countries will be the issue of discussion in this paper. In almost all the countries where jury system is practices, juries have been seen as the best tool for

Smacking-Should it be Outlawed? - Bachelor of Legal and Dispute Studies - RMIT University - Essay

2243 words - 9 pages insurance under the law on attack instead of the same as grown-ups (Braiker, B. n.d.). As far as abusive behaviour at home between grown-ups we would not acknowledge for a wife or spouse to give their accomplice a tap or smack, and it ought to be the same for youngsters. You may think, "What damage can a smack do?" Well as late studies have demonstrated, you may not understand exactly how hard your "smack" is. It could and here and there leads to

Similar Essays

Discuss Whether Trial By Jury Should Be Abolished In The English Legal System? Critically Analyse The Advantages And Disadvantages Of The System

2010 words - 8 pages be critically analysing whether trial by jury should be abolished in the UK legal system plus evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of the system.Lord Devlin was quoted as saying the jury system is "the lamp that shows that freedom lives". A Jury can decide cases on their idea of fairness, e.g. R v Ponting [1984] civil servant leaked info to a MP on the ground of public interest, jury refused to convict despite no legal defence. Juries are

Jury System Essay

561 words - 2 pages There are two methods of determining whether a person being charged with a criminal offense is guilty or not guilty; they can be tried before a judge or before a judge and jury. Each of these methods has its advantages, but in my mind a trial by jury is a better way of determining whether someone is guilty or not. A jury trial includes more than one persons' decision and interpretation of the evidence, it offers a thorough review and analysis of

The Jury Selection Procedure In The English Legal System

1718 words - 7 pages The Jury Selection Procedure in the English Legal System The theory behind modern day trial by jury can be traced back some eight hundred years, to the sixty-three clauses of the Magna Carta (1215). One of these clauses reads; “ No free man shall be arrested, or imprisoned, or deprived of his property, or outlawed, or exiled, or in any way

Statement Of Contention On Whether Or Not Medicinal Marijuana Should Be Legalised In Australia English Year 11 Statement Od Contention

655 words - 3 pages Statement of intention to accompany my oral speech on whether or not “Medicinal cannabis should be legalised in Australia” I chose to begin my oral presentation with an imaginary scenario to set the scene for this issue, and to gain my audience’s attention. I decided to use the second-person ‘you’ for this scenario to emphasise its relevance to my audience. To enhance credibility to my speech I chose to incorporate a true story of a Brisbane