How Brian Clark Avoids Senintimentality In Whose Life Is It Anyway

1633 words - 7 pages

‘Whose life is it anyway?’ follows the story of ‘Ken Harrison’, a man who tries to exercise a choice over his own life or death after being completely paralysed from the head down. Harrison received these horrific injuries after being involved in a car accident 4 months before the story starts. He is now in constant care within the hospitals walls being treated and cared for by the medical profession. The play centres on Harrison’s determination to exercise a choice over his own life or death with the medical bureaucracy fiercely opposing. The play leads as he takes the medical staff to court to try and exercise this right officially.
This play is seemingly unsentimental in which Harrison responds to his plight with wit and clarity and argues his case with power and persuasion. As this play focuses on ones mans wish to die and the issue of euthanasia we as the audience would expect the play to be very emotional. With the storyline, Clark could have easily made this play the opposite of what it actually is, powerful and fast moving. As Harrison had been though such a terrible ordeal we would expect him to be full of self pity and self indulgence and therefore make the play emotional and miserable.
Ken is first seen in Act 1, the first impression he makes on the reader is one of a happy and untroubled man. ‘I used to dream of situations like this… lying on a bed being massaged by two beautiful women.’ This is the first of many comical references Ken makes throughout the play, this is a very strong tool that Clarke uses to avoid sentimentality in his play. It shows that Ken isn’t self indulgent but rather making the best out of his current situation. He is expressing how he feels in the form of humour. This is less emotional than saying what Ken really does feel inside. For example ‘I’m afraid I can’t offer you my hand. You’ll have to make do with my backside…’ Ken could otherwise just have said ‘I can’t give you my hand because I’m paralysed’ this would have made the audience feel great sympathy for ken which Clarke has purposely avoided throughout his play.
The use of humour that Ken uses varies, there is the sexual humour between him and the female nurses ‘Have me on the floor sister please. Have me on the floor.’ And then we see the black humour ‘We went midnight skateboarding…I was the skateboard’ all these types of humour avoid Ken from actually telling other people how he feels. Ken is a very proud man and has a strong desire to keep his ‘dignity’ in tack ‘… mine is to die quietly and with as much dignity as I can muster…’ Ken knows that someday is going to die but because of his own self indulgence he wants to be the one in control of his death. This shows the audience that Ken isn’t a weak character that just wants to be put out of his misery, on the contrary, he is a character that wants to fight for his dignity and his own personal choices, and this once again distracts the audience away from feeling any kind of sympathy for him and...

Find Another Essay On How Brian Clark avoids Senintimentality in Whose life is it Anyway

Columbine whose fault is it Essay

1125 words - 5 pages On April 20, 1999 in Littleton, Colorado, Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris turned the hallways of Columbine High School into a killing field. Starting in the school yard and ending in the library, they went on a shooting rampage which resulted in 15 deaths, including their own. Who is at blame for this tragedy? This is now the topic of debate across the nation.Klebold and Harris were both seniors at Columbine High School. According to students

Physician assisted suicide: Whose Choice Is It?

1292 words - 5 pages Euthanasia: Whose Choice Is It?Most people in North America die what may be called a bad death. One studyfound that, "More often than not, patients died in pain, their desires concerningtreatment neglected, after spending 10 days or more in an intensive care unit."(Introduction 1)Is a painful death a natural and acceptable fact of life? It is my belief that aperson with a terminal disease enduring uncontrollable pain who has the desire toend

Climate change in australia What is climate change? How will it affect life in Australia?

1343 words - 5 pages Honours Programme Principal's Essay 2007Topic: What is climate change? How will it affect life in Australia?StudentMentor teacherHonours Programme Principal's Essay 2007What is climate change? How will it affect life in Australia?World wide, we are facing a severe problem known as climate change, climate change is caused by global warming, this doesn't mean that the whole earth will become hotter, in some areas the climate will become colder

Conway's childhood and how it made her into the person she is later in life

1607 words - 6 pages children around her age and many of the people she was around were adults. Being placed into a school where most of her life was not brought up around children her own age must have been hard trying to adapt.The way that drafts one and two work to show how it made her into the person she is later in the book, is when she describes her intellectual development and the way in which society holds back women. For example, Conway describes her experience in

Pornography in America: How Bad Is It?

2338 words - 9 pages Pornography, the dark side of America and the world. The kind of thing that is regulated to hushed talked in bars and strip clubs. Nothing creates more disgust or debate in America than porn. Mothers and lawmakers say that it is demeaning to women and a threat to a stable families. The porn industry and its viewers claim that it is a harmless activity not much different than other more main stream activities. So is porn truly that bad or is it

Whose role is it to develop the skills needed by future professionals?

1396 words - 6 pages "It is …commonly asserted that students are ill-prepared for the future workplace and that they need new kind of skills to perform well" Stasz et al. (1996:1).In the light of this statement, whose role is it to develop the skills needed by future professionals?Develop the Generic SkillsRecently, the generic skills are become more and more important. People always want to become more valuable and secure. The future workplace has been

Leadership and how it plays a role in life.

546 words - 2 pages anyone can approach and speak to. Overall, I believe that I act as a leader towards other because I am a normal young girl who everyone can relate to, and because I can relate to everyone else.Another leadership quality I possess and have great appreciation for is my captainship for my swim team. Swimming is a huge part of my life that I could never live without. It affects everything I do from the type of mood I am in to my work and commitment

Describe the Lewis and Clark Expedition. What were the problems encountered? How did Lewis and Clark prepare for it? What were the results of the Expedition?

1741 words - 7 pages THE LEWIS AND CLARK EXPEDITIONThe Lewis and Clark Expedition was a result of the Louisiana Purchase. Thomas Jefferson, the president of the United States in the early 1800s, bought this territory from the French in 1803. It was a huge piece of land that Jefferson wanted to get explored. Thus he planned the first exploration by the United States government of the Northwestern Wilderness. To lead this expedition into the wilderness, Jefferson

This is a semiotic Analysis of how to make easy mac... I took this paper off this site and changed to make it an A paper.. well I got an A on it anyway.. I added many parts and also deleted a few

514 words - 2 pages a cup of water into the bowl. I am anexpert at judging how much to put in by now. I watch the water splash against andconsume all the noodles, some of them even floating on top.Even though this is all so routine for me, I always read the back of the packet tosee how much time it should be in the microwave--three and a half minutes. I pop thedoor open and place the bowl on the glass plate in the microwave. I excitedly push thebuttons for the time

how is life

1244 words - 5 pages . ! ! 16 are milk chocolate. ! ! 8 are dark chocolate. ! ! (a) Write down the ratio of white chocolate to milk chocolate to dark chocolate. ! ! Give your ratio in its simplest form. ............... : ............... : ............... (2) ! ! Rachel has some apples and bananas. ! ! The ratio of apples to bananas is 2 : 3 ! ! She has 14 apples. ! ! (b) Work out how many bananas Rachel has. ......................... (2) 2. ! ! (a)! a × a × a

Translations(Brian Friel)is best read as an elegy for a doomed culture. The only response it elicits is to mourn that culture depicted in the play as forever lost. Do you agree?

1623 words - 6 pages to engage the audience giving them a place in history to relate to. They are also used for dramatic irony, Maire remarks 'Sweet God did the potatoes ever fail in Baile Beg? ' She talks about how people sniff around for disaster waiting for the potato crop to fail. The audience knows the play is only set a few years prior to the potato famine. This thought is with us all the way through the play. It adds a sense of futility to their lives and

Similar Essays

How Does Brian Clark Make His Play Whose Life Is It Anyway?

1269 words - 5 pages How does Brian Clark make his play Whose life is it anyway? Interesting, Memorable and Dramatic for a modern audience. Brian Clark makes “whose life is it anyway?” an interesting memorable play for a modern audience by using a wide variety of techniques that are available when writing plays. The play addresses a range of modern day issues. Recently Charlotte Wyatt’s case and Christopher Reeves’ death have broadened the awareness of the

Brian Clark's Play Whose Life Is It Anyway?

1160 words - 5 pages Brian Clark's Play "Whose Life Is It Anyway?" The play "Whose Life Is It Anyway" by Brian Clark was made into a stage play and film. The television play was made in 1972 and the stage plays in 1978. In the play,” written by Brian Clarke, the intense argument of committing Voluntary Euthanasia is discussed. The main point of the play, Ken Harrison, once an imaginative, devoted sculptor, is involved in a terrible car crash. Following a

Whose Life Is It Anyway? Essay

4522 words - 18 pages writer so that the first impression the audience gets of the situation is totally on Ken's side, and has to be challenged by the medical staff's point of view, as apposed to Ken's argument, having to challenge the medical staff. Mainly Clark does want a general feeling that euthanasia should be legalised and this is the overall effect Clark wants 'Whose Life Is It Anyway?' to have on its audience. I think that in 'Whose Life Is It Anyway

Whose Life Is It? Reasons For Legalizing Euthanasia

1976 words - 8 pages "Whose life is it, anyways?" Life itself is complicated but allowing people to die by assistance is far more complex. Euthanasia is still a controversial issue in North American society, in particular Canada. Euthanasia comes from the Greek word euthantos literally meaning "well death." In modern English, it is defined as "bringing about of a gentle death in the case of incurable and painful disease." There are two basic types of euthanasia