How Does Aristotle’s View Of Politics Differ From That Of Plato’s? Do You Consider That They Are Wholly Opposed?

1847 words - 7 pages

How does Aristotle's view of politics differ from that of Plato's? Do you consider that they are wholly opposed?Political philosophy for both Aristotle and Plato was of reasonable concern. One's character, virtues, vices, desire and especially education were relevant to determine a correct system of government. They both opposed relativism, scepticism as well as individualism in sophism (which was gaining popularity at that time) equally both Plato and Aristotle were opposed to democracies (to varying degrees) and more so for Aristotle; monarchies and aristocracies. However they both agreed governments and politics are both crucial fundamental characteristics of mankind. With Plato taking a more Oligarchical/Totalitarian approach by suppressing the individual and emphasizing what one is born with and their limiting capabilities deduced from that. Whereas Aristotle a much more progressive thinker, valuing the individual and protracting the promise of virtue and intelligence beyond what one starts out with, and more focusing on what one can become. I will first discuss Plato's idea of ideal politics, then Aristotles concluding with a comparison.For Plato politics must be based on the study of human nature. He wanted a well ordered society, based mainly upon reason and logic. It was the ideal city of Plato that consisted of the four virtues of wisdom, moderation, courage and justice. It needs wisdom to have a wise city, bravery from courage against rivalling cities, justice for control of the masses and instilling the differences between right and wrong, as well as moderation; in that each role throughout society is shared, that each understands their role or as he puts it: "harmony that results when everyone is actively engaged in fulfilling his role and does not meddle with that of others" (Plato 85)Plato said that the soul is in three parts; desire, spirit and reason. It was these three ideas he based his Plutocracy on. Plato's tripartite class structure involved the three classes; productive, protective and governing. The productive or 'desire' class contained workers of trades, farmers and merchants. These citizens were considered the least intelligent and less educated than the rest, and therefore delegated the task of the easiest and least intellectual difficulty. The protective section of society Plato calls the 'guardians' are essentially the armed forces or protectors of the city. The governing rulers are the intelligent, rational, self-controlled, wise (knowledge of the Good or 'right relations' between all that exists) the leader of this group Plato labels is the 'Philosopher-King'.For Plato only philosophers had the correct attributes to govern the people. Only the philosopher king would know the best for the city and its members, he should be the one making the decisions. However on the contrary Aristotle believes that the city should be governed by many and through laws. For Aristotle; laws represent all that is reasonable and just,...

Find Another Essay On How does Aristotle’s view of politics differ from that of Plato’s? Do you consider that they are wholly opposed?

How Could You Do That? Essay

819 words - 4 pages remember what you have done or what they have done to themselves. Damaged. How does an abuser reason with what they have done? “Psychiatrist Brandt F. Steele… established himself as a groundbreaking expert on child abuse…” (Martin Claire, 1) Steele believed that “…victims’ parents often had their own history of abuse and neglect…” thus, leading to a vicious cycle passed down to their children. Also, in Sickened by Julie Gregory, Julie’s

Discuss the view that understandings of politics are always based on conceptions of human nature

2072 words - 8 pages rationalism does not dictate the ends of human conduct, it certainly suggests how these ends should be pursued. In this view, human beings are essentially rational creatures guided by intellect and a process of argument, analysis and debate. Rationalist ideas are prominent within early liberal and socialist doctrines.Early liberals such as J.S.Mill argues that if human beings had the capacity for rationalism and reason then individuals should be given

How did the ideology of the Whigs differ from that of the Working Men's Party? From that of the Jacksonian Democrats?

661 words - 3 pages understand who the Whig Party were, and what they stood for. The Whig party arose in 1834, when a group of congressmen banded together to oppose Andrew Jackson’s policies and his high-handed, “kinglike conduct”.[out book-p312] Their name came from the American Whigs who like them, also opposed tyranny. During the Whigs tenure in mid-nineteenth century politics, they had achieved in having four Presidents elected to office. In the religious

Discuss the extent to which you think that goals are determined by the overarching culture of a society as opposed to smaller social groups or subcultures

1106 words - 4 pages result or an achievement toward which efforts were focused. People have certain goals that they may want to achieve in life. These goals might include but not limited to getting married, Education, employment, a house, means of transportation and so on (Settergren, 2003). The question is to know where these goals come from. Do individuals set them up? If so, based on which criteria's? How do people know what is best for them? Or are people obliged to

Study the evolution of armor throughout the Middle Ages. How did the armor of the barbarians differ from that of the Carolingian period?

1272 words - 5 pages Study the evolution of armor throughout the Middle Ages. How did the armor of the barbarians differ from that of the Carolingian period? Describe the armor of a knight depicted on the Bayeux Tapestry. What tactical and technological factors in the thirteenth century led to a transformation in armor construction? Describe the benefits and liabilities of full plate armor in warfare.As DeVries notes, the most dramatic impact on Roman armor was not

How do the foundation myths of Rome, that of Romulus and Aeneas, fit together, if they do at all?

2730 words - 11 pages elements. These elements are found in foundation myths and legends from cultures around the world. However it is unlikely that this folktale structure was imported somehow from these other cultures into Rome. It is more likely that they emerge from some common human belief, held in the minds of all humans, and they myths are then created when the people desire to how their past. This makes the twins story indigenous.There is debate over how Remus came

How Far Do You Agree That the Policy of Appeasement Was the Main Cause of WWII?

1949 words - 8 pages Czechoslovakia. Hitler did not keep this agreement and in March 1939 he invaded Czechoslovakia. Despite Czechoslovakian government requesting help from the Allied Powers, neither Britain or France and the League of Nations did anything to prevent or stop the invasion. Britain and France later promised that if the Germany invaded Poland, they would declare war on Germany. Britain and France thought that this would stop Hitler’s aggressive

Discussion of the View that Morality and Religion are Linked

962 words - 4 pages view is deontological because it based on golden rules and does not look at present consequences before it is considered moral or right. This view makes morality objective as it lays down certain rules for humans to live by. The Euthyphro dialogue is what the issue of religion and morality is based around. This dialogue by Plato portrays the view that morality and religion are linked. In this dialogue, Plato’s

What should the government do about segregation in our public schools today? Does it matter to you, that students often attend public schools that are populated only by students of their own race?

665 words - 3 pages removed.National governments can try to do what they did not do back in the seventies. The national governments should pass laws to give state and local governments' power to try to help desegregate the public schools. One of the laws could be for example, that all state governments have the power to come into the public schools and see how the classes are sorted. If they come in and see that some classes are only filled with a single race then they can go

It has been suggested that “stress is in the eyes of the beholder?”. What does this mean? Do you agree?

2262 words - 10 pages truth, but it does help on making you a sophisticated human being and making your life healthier. Laugh and make jokes. Build yourself a sense of humour. Start by being around people who are funny and outgoing, just laugh along with them. Like they say, “laughter is the best medicine”. This term is telling you that when you laugh, even if it’s a fake laugh, you can somehow bring that little joy and also loosen up that stressful burden that is being

Critically identify and discuss how stars produce meanings? You may research a star that you are interested in: Consider researching films, promotion, publicity, criticism and commentary et al

1036 words - 4 pages Films are sold on star image. They are not just labour but they are a form of capital too because they create an advantage for the film that it would not have if it just had an ordinary actor in the role, so they will hopefully get good profits.Not all film actors are stars though. Stars have to do extra publicity for films, interviews and premieres and do not usually have to audition for parts. Ordinary actors will have to audition and do not

Similar Essays

How Does Our Understanding Of The Life Course Differ From That Of Earlier Historical Periods?

1524 words - 6 pages ). Naturally therefore the stage of social belonging that we currently identify with is subject to change as we progress through our life course. However, these stages are also structured by classes such as ethnicity and gender which are fixed and do not change. This essay will look at how our understanding of the life course has changed over time and now differs in comparison to that of earlier historical periods.According to Berger and Luckman, "All

How Do Mentally Retarded And Intellectually Disabled Kids Affect Their Families And Siblings, And How Does Their Development Differ From That Of

1568 words - 7 pages event? How do the second-born children learn to interact and in a way accept the differences of their siblings? This paper will focus on discussing the effects that children with mental retardation and learning disabilities have on their family's adaption to their unique approach at the developmental stages. The aforementioned questions will be considered throughout this paper via the aid of personal anecdotes from my family and individual

How Far Do You Agree With The View That The Tragedies In ‘Ethan Frome’ And ‘A View From The Bridge’ Are Brought About By Individual Characters Rather

2216 words - 9 pages to that of other communities as they seem to have a negative opinion of the law. They prefer to keep things personal and discuss as well as solve their problems between themselves behind closed doors. Their view of justice differs from the law as it does not follow any written rules as they’re determined by society. Eddie's downfall to tragedy had a lot to do with the community he was brought up in. Both his own and the community's views of

Are Odd And Cd Real? And How/Do They Differ?

969 words - 4 pages own mistakes or misbehavior, being touchy or easily annoyed by others, being angry and resentful, or being spiteful or vindictive.” In order to be diagnosed with ODD you must exhibit at least 4 of these characteristics. Commonly you will find that the diagnosed child will have frequent temper tantrums, persistent anger and much more. These characteristics can and often do lead to problems with school and social interactions. Conduct Disorder on