This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Useful Is ‘Structural Functionalism’ Or ‘Society As An Organism’ As Theoretical Frameworks In Considering The Problem Of ‘Death’ As A Sociological

2159 words - 9 pages

The essay will critically analyse theoretical accounts of society, in particular how useful they are in understanding how death is viewed socially in the West. It will be argued that all different theoretical models of society can be useful, but that the model ‘society as an organism’, which emphasises symbolic interactionism, is often more useful than structural functionalism on its own. My analysis will start with a look a critique of structural functionalism, using Durkheim’s analysis of suicide (1953) as an example. I then look at ‘society as an organism’ in the thought of Rousseau (1913), before turning to consider these models specifically in relation to the problem of death. I discuss our Western fear of death, and suggest, drawing on Eagleton (2003), that any solution must involve facing this fear on a social level.
There are sociological theories in which society is conceived of as a total structure made of functioning parts: this is structural functionalism. Rigney (2001: 17) describes structural functionalism as follows: “society is a system of independent parts working together to produce a vital functioning whole”. For example, as there are many roles played in society, good and bad, it can be likened to a theatre, in which our life is one big stage with many different parts being and acted out (Goffman, 1969). Yet it could be argued that this approach is too simplistic because it does not take into account when people and events go outside the norms and values of society, for example in crime and disorder. In short, we might say structural functionalism cannot explain where structure is ‘dysfunctional’. It may highlight dysfunction and disorder, but it does not easily account for them. To make an example of this, we can look at Durkheim’s structural functionalist analysis of the problem of suicide, where he describes suicide in rational, structural and functional terms, but not the irrational which must also be a factor in at least many if not most suicides.
First, Durkheim emphasises the rationality within suicide (1952 : xlii):
“The common quality of all these possible forms of supreme renunciation is that the determining act is performed advisedly; that at the moment of acting the victim knows the certain result of his conduct, no matter what reason may have led him to act thus.”
Second, Durkheim recognizes, through statistics, how the rise of suicide correlated with changes in social structure: “statistics……prove that the structural characteristics of society have simultaneously suffered profound changes. It is interesting to note that they do not take place with the extreme slowness that quite a large number of observers has attributed to them, but are both abrupt and progressive” (1952: xlv). In other words, sudden social structural changes cause a change in rationality, which is functional – the subject decides rationality that suicide is preferable. However, as stated in our earlier criticism, while Durkheim offers...

Find Another Essay On How useful is ‘structural functionalism’ or ‘society as an organism’ as theoretical frameworks in considering the problem of ‘death’ as a sociological

Analyse the Potential Applications of Solid Waste as an Aggregate in Structural Concrete

6654 words - 27 pages strength of structural concrete will range from 20 MPa (3000 psi) for residential purposes and 34 MPa (5000 psi) and higher for commercial structures. Other mechanical factors such as soundness, freeze/thaw, durability and porosity weren't considered as a part of this study.2.0 Waste Materials2.1 PolystyreneMillions of tons of waste polystyrene are produced in the world yearly. Polystyrene is an organic polymer derived from oil which can be ridged

'Every sociological perspective has its limitations. However some are more useful than understanding society.' Assess this view. (40 Marks)

1133 words - 5 pages Marxism, Functionalism and Feminism are sociological theories alongside several others, they are fundamental to the whole discipline of sociology.Functionalism is a structural theory they argue that society is made up of interrelated and interdependent institutions such as education, work, religion, law, the family etc. The main function of these institutions is to maintain social equilibrium.They see society similar to a human body with all the

The Kite Runner: An essay analyzing Hosseinis illustration of Bad Parenting as a universal problem of society

1679 words - 7 pages honor, but only responsibility. It is only in how a parent rises to meet this new responsibility that determines how much honor the parent is deserving of." According to Freitag then, Amir initially does not do what he should as a paternal figure. In his attempt to be a parent to him, Amir ends up emotionally destroying Sohrab further when he leaves him at an orphanage. Eventually, Amir does do what should earn him respect, however, and instead of

This esay is about Coca-Cola as an American symbol. It describes how Coke fits into American society as a symbol of various things

1105 words - 4 pages ...Have a Coke...or an American custom as seen in Italy." The picture is of a group of Italians standing in what looks like the town square, drinking Coke. "An American custom as seen in Italy," another sentence in the ad copy, captures the essence of this ad perfectly. Coke was made in America and had its meager beginnings in America. Then it spread all over the world. Since many other countries had never had a common, widespread soda drink before

The Realization of death can change an Individual as in Lord Jim, JIM changes when death is immenient

1672 words - 7 pages The Realization of death can change an IndividualLord Jim, written in 1900 by Joseph Conrad is a tragic heroic novel portraying the main character's attempts to escape his cowardice past. Marlow Jim's friend (and narrator) tells of the quest for Jim's youthful dreams of the sea. After Jim becomes a seaman he abandons a ship when it hits an underwater object, he leaves his crewmates and pilgrims behind. The Patina never sinks and he is summed to

Ding Dong, Communism is Dead! Or is it?: How Marxism, as a Criticism of Capitalism, is Still Relevant in the Twenty-First Century

2044 words - 9 pages . And if the movement is strong enough, that in its best sense of the word is a revolution, and that is what we need” (Robinson n. pag.). There is a succinct resounding call within the twenty-first society, that a revolution is needed. Whether it is fighting against a tyrannical oppression or against the selfish modern education, Marxism still rings clear as a theoretical explanation to the twenty-first century’s capitalist calamities. Most

Is military force becoming less useful as an instrument of policy?

1341 words - 5 pages nuclear policy can be seen as a perfect example of this. Also in some cases (Second World War and First Golf War) there are situations where diplomacy has failed and military force is the best option available to resolve the problem. There are four types of military force that can be pursued, the defence, deterrence, compliance and the posturing policy. They can either be applied as separate policies or as the one policy.Self defence is enshrined in

Can a definition of “Religion” be academically useful? Pick yes or no, and provide an argument as to why or why not?

763 words - 4 pages A definition of Religion is and can be academically useful. It’s the same as with science as it is with religion, the ability to have a definition, creates academic validity for the subject. One has the ability to point to a certain section or a topic of a book and then support themselves with a fundamental definition. Now the problem that arises in religious studies is that the definition is not always accurate or consistent. Many different

Can a definition of “Religion” be academically useful? Pick yes or no, and provide an argument as to why or why not?

996 words - 4 pages participate in it, without name or history, it is an impersonal God (totemic principle). Different symbol, different totem but worshipping the same kind of thing. The totem is the visible image of the clan, it is the flag for example, it is the concrete object of the social contract that they are held by and that they adapt to. They may think of it as a God but it is simply the social, so in a sense we are worshipping ourselves. We do not question what we

Living as a Sikh or Muslim in Secular Society

1483 words - 6 pages their job, are they not considered people? Not only is this purely wrong and an infringement to human rights, people who have spent years working in their profession and now are tied between following their religious obligations or their source of earnings. A hijab, turban, nor kippah does not affect or harm anyone physical or psychology at all, thus why must it be removed? Has society become that intolerant to possibly find the sight of a

Is Femininity as Much of a Threat in "Paradise Lost" as It Is in "The Aeneid"?

3203 words - 13 pages successful in frustrating Jupiter's plans in favour of maintaining her "secret love" (IV, 236). Milton's belief that women were an interference with God's plan is also implicit in his depiction of the character of Sin as female who breaks out of Chaos with her son, Death, in order to cause havoc on earth, "to destroy, or unimmortal make/All kinds" (10, 611-12). Sin is described in Book 2 as: "a formidable shape; The one seemed woman to

Similar Essays

Culture As A Personality Or An Organism?

1063 words - 5 pages . This is a very idealistic view of the bond between peoples of a culture or group, focusing on the internal bonds holding members together rather than the external environment and material world that constitutes a specific region. Rappaport, on the other hand, would like to focus on the broader territory, mainly the environmental and materialistic aspects that make up a culture. He views culture as an organism constantly being affected by its

Economics As " Is The Study Of How A Society, Or A Country, Or A Business Or Even An Individual Or A Family Allocates Its Scarce Resources.”

598 words - 2 pages Article Analysis pg. PAGE \* Arabic 1 In the lecture for week one it defines an economics as, "is the study of how a society, or a country, or a business or even an individual or a family allocates its scarce resources." Throughout history, every society has faced the basic economic problem of deciding what to produce, how to produce it and for whom it will be produced. A country's leader has been responsible at the forefront of the ultimate

How Useful Is Archaic Greek Poetry As A Historical Source

1518 words - 6 pages itself to be incredibly useful as a historical source. In both passages I have quoted, we see how the poets recount past events with an intention to present the truth. Scholars working in this area have therefore identified the truth about the past to be the archaic poets' predominant concern. This encourages us as a critical audience to view archaic poetry with a reliability or at least as a source of apparent truth for its time. As the daughters

How Useful Is The Bayeux Tapestry As A Source For The Events Surrounding The Norman Invasion Of England?

2285 words - 9 pages and his army routed. The start of the Tapestry is bordered on three sides, so it's likely the end would have been the same. It is almost universally believed that the end of the Tapestry is missing. It could be presumed that the Tapestry finished as it started - with a rightful king seated upon his lion throne. However, these panels were either lost or never existed and as such the tapestry is not useful at all as a source for the events after