This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

What Gives Us The Privilege? : Animal Rights

2077 words - 8 pages

After an incident in 1933 involving the blinding of seventeen women from a mascara product, the U.S. congress passed the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act of 1938, which stated that products must be deemed safe for human use before being sold. This was the beginning of animal testing (Cruelty-Free Labeling). Most companies use animal testing, which ensures their product is safe for consumer use. Animal testing is a very controversial topic due to the fact that the knowledge and research gained through the tests is tremendous. On the other hand, there are millions of animals forced to endure these painful experiments. Those in favor of testing, due to the fact that it is reliable, argue that it is benefitting the health of society, and all experimentation on animals allow scientists new research and provide information for the betterment of mankind. All of those against animal testing argue that inflicting pain on a living creature when alternative methods are available is cruel. Putting a halt on all forms of animal testing is next to impossible. If animal testing started as a means to protect living creatures from being harmed, then how is the solution part of that very problem? Humans have laws to protect them from being blinded by mascara, yet animals do not deserve the right to live an abuse and pain-free life? Giving animals basic rights is by far the best solution. Animals deserve basic rights due to the fact that pain is a punishment to all living creatures, animals are beneficial to society, and lastly, animals have mental abilities equal to that of humans in certain ways.
If humans have the right to be protected from pain, then any living thing deserves this protection. Inflicting pain on another living creature is evil, and most societies understand this simple truth. Some humans feel that they are privileged to better treatment than animals with the assumption that animals do not posses a soul as humans do. In the book Animal Rights and Human Morality, author Bernard E. Rollin explores this idea that humans feel they have been placed at the top of the food chain, and therefore can determine what creatures are or are not worthy of possessing a soul. He cleverly and sarcastically remarks on the ludicrous argument that animals are better to test on than humans due to the fact that they do not possess a soul, when it cannot be scientifically proven in any way that humans themselves have souls either. “Even if we suppose that animals do not have a soul while humans do, the key question is this: What does the possession of a soul have to do with being an object of moral concern?” (Rollin 45) Rollin continues to elaborate his frustration on this idea, stating that lacking a soul has nothing to do with ethical consideration towards animals (Rollin 45). Humans have no right to determine the existence of a soul from other creatures. The possession of a soul in animals, or lack thereof, cannot be the determining factor in whether it is...

Find Another Essay On What Gives Us the Privilege? : Animal Rights

Women's rights in the US Essay

2699 words - 11 pages many differences between the countries regarding women's rights, it is of great importance to know why women's rights in Iceland are significantly better than in Egypt.First I am going to describe what I am going to research and why. After that, I will describe the results of my research. My findings are going to be followed up by a discussion of the results. Finally, I will write the conclusion. The topic I am going to write about is very broad

Women's rights in the US Essay

2364 words - 9 pages established, and goes on until 1997.CNN Library. 2013, 'Roe v Wade fast facts', CNN, retrieved from: http://edition.cnn.com/2013/11/04/us/roe-v-wade-fast-facts/: Facts regarding the Roe v Wade case.Guttmacher Institute, 2014, 'An overview of abortion laws', retrieved from: http://www.guttmacher.org/statecenter/spibs/spib_OAL.pdf. This website gives an overview of the major law provisions for abortion in the United States. It also shows an overview of

The Importance of Animal Rights: Product Testing

813 words - 4 pages animals with respect and it is not against animal rights to have them in the zoos. Product testing is against animal rights and should be stopped; products can be made without testing them on animals. Animal rights is an issue that has been controversial for decades and will remain controversial over time.  Works Cited “Animal Testing 101.” Peta.org. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, 2013. Web. 16 November 2013. Isacat, Ben. “Zoos.” Animalethics.org. How to Do Animal Rights, April 2008. Web. 16 November 2013. Lin, Doris. “What are the Arguments For and Against Keeping Pets?”. About.com. About, 2013. Web. 16 November 2013.

Animal rights and the food industry

2852 words - 11 pages Ethics 400Ethical Treatment of AnimalsThe issue of animal rights is very complex. When referring to the ethical treatment of animals, it seems as though everyone has an opinion. Some people are "meat eaters" and consume meat at nearly every meal. They may argue that this is survival and is justified; they would further argue that animals are not humans and were put on this earth for the benefit of man. Many also believe that it is necessary to

What the Nuns Taught Us

1208 words - 5 pages concept of living by the ways of nature or grace, mimic those of Plato’s idea of what a just, aristocrat, and unjust, tyrannical, man look like showing the similarities and differences in Malick’s and Plato’s conceptions of virtue and evil. In the beginning of the movie, Mrs. O’Brien talks about what it is to live in the way of grace verses the way of nature. The way of nature “only wants to please itself. Get others to please it too. Likes to lord

The History and Purpose of The Animal Rights Movement

977 words - 4 pages its roots to the settlers. According to the US History Encyclopedia in 1641, Body of Liberties laws, Massachusetts Bay Colony Puritans came up with the first animal protection laws when they included two provisions prohibiting cruelty to animals. After the Civil war is when animal rights became a public issue. “Henry Bergh organized the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in 1866 (Encyclopedia).” Bergh came from a wealthy

The Implications of Different Views on Animal Rights

1331 words - 5 pages Should animals and humans have the same rights? Or, the same penalty for their abuse? Have you just sat back and wondered how we got where we are today? Should animals be lower than humans or the same? With the advancing of new technology, medications and medical advancements haven’t we gained this knowledge by animal testing/ animal cruelty? Do we, as humans, think animal testing/ animal cruelty and domestic violence all have similarities and

Animal Rights and the Dominant Worldview toward Animals

1890 words - 8 pages for animals? What rights should animals have? This paper will be showing two different worldviews - the dominant and the biocentric worldviews with respect to animal rights. It will explore the moral and ethical issues raised by human superiority over animals. I will argue for the biocentric worldview, in favour of animal rights as I will focus on two main ideas: equality and suffering. This paragraph will be showing the dominant worldview

The Other Animals - an essay about animal rights

1014 words - 4 pages the other hand, animals do not seem to form the same independent thoughts but instead rely solely on their birth given natural instincts. While most of us have the inherent desire to go forward in life and excel to greater things, animals instead seem content with only doing what they know and have relied on their entire life just as ones that existed before them have done. With this being said one must look into whether or not humans are superior

Animal Rights, Human Wrongs vs. The Damned Human Race

503 words - 2 pages Animal Rights, Human Wrongs vs. The Damned Human Race “Animal Rights, Human Wrongs” by Tom Regan and “The Damned Human Race” by Mark Twain are more similar than different. Both of the authors are informing the readers about the mentality of some human beings in regard to animals. One of the authors, Tom Regan provides several examples of the tactics man uses to harm animals. Mark Twain’s method compares so called lower animal to the human being

The Cove: an Analysis of Argumentation for Animal Rights

1076 words - 5 pages the filming efforts and worked directly with dolphin trainer Richard O’Barry in drawing light on the events occurring in a private cove in the city of Taiji, Japan. The documentary is, of course, very biased towards the topic, with obvious pro-animal rights leanings supported indirectly with a strong utilitarian basis. When analyzing documentaries such as this it is vitally important to take as objective a perspective as possible, though humanity

Similar Essays

The Animal In Us Essay

1102 words - 5 pages using organs from animals genetically more similar to us reduce the problem of rejection," (Cooper 44) is the pig better suited for transplant rather than a chimpanzee or baboon? Several factors need consideration when selecting a potential donor animal. The environment in which the animals live in and the availability of the animals are two of the most important factors. Because the apes are an endangered species, they are off-limits to any

The Fight For Animal Rights Essay

882 words - 4 pages Animal rights are a fragile issue that goes back and forth between people often with so many different beliefs and ways of viewing things. A major question in animal rights is; are animals entitled to the possession of their own lives and their everyday basic needs? With opinions on this topic based on research and tests, opposers to animals having rights over their life are not taking into consideration that animals live just like us humans

Animal Rights Across The World Essay

1851 words - 7 pages are difficult to enforce, what hope is there for animals? What rights should animals have? This paper will be showing two different worldviews - the dominant and the biocentric worldviews with respect to animal rights. It will explore the moral and ethical issues raised by human superiority over animals. I will argue for the biocentric worldview, in favour of animal rights as I will focus on two main ideas: equality and suffering. This

Life Gives Us Problems, We Are The Solution

2250 words - 9 pages We live in a world we didn’t choose, became a member of a family we didn’t pick and grew in a community we may not want. Who we decide to be or what we want to become is not entirely a product of our own decision, but most likely influenced by the external trends of how the world told us to be who we are. I agree with what Karl Marx has said: “Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please; they do not make it under