What Makes A House A Home, Judy Brady

1341 words - 5 pages

The two essays, “I want a wife” (Brady, 1971) and “Homeless” (Quindlen, n.d.) both resonate with readers on different levels yet cover much of the same topic. While both of these essays discuss traditional values and home, they do so in vastly different ways. “I want a wife” focuses on the mechanics and operations of a household. The wife personifies the home. However, the descriptive essay “Homeless” concentrates on the emotions that personalize a home nearly to the point of giving the house itself living characteristics. This essay will compare and contrast the narrative and descriptive essay forms and argue that although “I want a wife” uses humor in an effective narrative style, the imagery used in “Homeless” evokes more powerful feelings in the reader regarding stability and belonging making it a more compelling essay.

Judy Brady’s narrative style in “I want a wife” uses sarcasm quite effectively to portray her experience as a wife. Brady graphically details the conventional marital division of labor while subtly highlighting the inequities. However disparate these spousal duties seem to be, they form a nearly universal representation of a traditional household. Brady enumerates all the elements of a working household: the cooking, cleaning, organizing, scheduling and nurturing of family. The author clearly implies that without a wife, the household would cease to function. Also, that the very label of “wife” brings with it all the duties and responsibilities listed.

Throughout the essay, only action words are used in relation to the wife. In fact, it is as if the word “wife” were actually a verb instead of a noun. The wife in question will work, pay, wash, mend, arrange, clean, iron, and plan. The one thing the wife does not do is emote. The home described by Brady is comprised of activity alone. It is the sum of these activities that creates the home. The wife clearly embodies these duties, ergo, an argument can be made that the wife is the home. Without the wifely function, there would be no substance to hold the home together. While the essay is a dispassionate narrative, it relates an essential household component. As Brady says, “who wouldn’t want a wife?”

In the descriptive essay “Homeless,” Anna Quindlen relies on common experiences instead of humor to engage her audience. Her vivid depiction of what a home symbolizes, and what being without one means, evokes a wellspring of emotions in the reader. A home is a place to keep your things safe, to have your own space, to paint your walls blue. In “Homeless,” it is the tangible items that prove worth. For a person with no home to touch, the permanence of walls and household furnishings, even if only a memory, give durability to their existence. Just a photo or a memory of having belonged to such a place makes one “someone.” Yet, those physical objects are mere representations of more vague notions like “certainty, stability, predictability, privacy”...

Find Another Essay On What Makes a House a Home, Judy Brady

What Makes a Friend? Essay

790 words - 4 pages more meaningful so that they develop into friendships. A select few of those will continue on to develop into true friendships that will stand the test of time. Do you ever wonder what makes up a true friend? Friends are people that you can feel free to speak about your most intimate thoughts and they will not judge you. Friends are people you can be yourself around. What characteristics comprise a good friend? In my opinion, I think trust is

What Makes A Leader Essay

1157 words - 5 pages What makes a good Leader? Brad Carlson March 25,2001 What makes a leader? This question has been posed in many areas within our everyday lives. This question is asked in the business, religious, social, and most often in the political world.Throughout our world's history, even if you look back to the beginning of man, you will see that there have always been leaders. Some of these leaders were natural leaders, and others were born into the

What Makes a Hero?

787 words - 4 pages “The only thing to fear is fear itself.” A quote from F.D.R stating that the fear that is found in most humans is all-inclusive just the basic thought of fear itself. Not always being a big obstacle in your way, but occasionally the thought of overcoming a challenge can be far too much. But what heartily makes a hero, is stability, knowledge, and the willingness to help others and have others help you as well. To be a hero you must

What Makes a Hero?

818 words - 4 pages they are and how long they have been there. When Odysseus found out what the lotus blossom can do he announced, “No one taste the Lotus, or you will lose your hope of home”, (Homer line 104-105). Saying this was a warning to his men that if you taste the blossom, you will forget about home and never want to leave the island. As a result, they sailed away from the island. As the crew sailed on they came to the island Thrinacia where the Sun God

What makes a family

766 words - 4 pages American family in my eyes is what you make it. Times are changing and what was not accepted back then is now not as much of a big deal so more and more people are opening their eye to the big picture and doing what they feel makes them happy and construction their own traditional American family. Work Cited Beam, Cris. “The Changing American Family.” American Baby. Parents. 2005. Web. 17 Dec 2013. Bidwell, Allie. “Study: The American Family is No More.” U.S. News and World Report. U.S. News and World Report. 11 Sept. 2013. Web 17 Dec 2013.

What Makes a Psychopath?

839 words - 4 pages What Makes a Psychopath? Depictions of psychopaths today have become exaggerated based off of what you see in movies and films. The psychopaths in movies are believed to be dangerous or have an anti-social personality disorder. Not all psychopaths can be defined in that manner. Psychopaths are identified as people who are emotionally unstable. They are ultimately suffering from a chronic mental disorder with abnormal or violent social behavior

What Makes a Terrorist?

642 words - 3 pages What Makes a Terrorist? The rising of terrorism due to the September 11, 2001 tragedy issued a simple key question by the people across the world of different backgrounds; what would make the people masterminding and participating in the attacks willing to perish their precious life in creating a massive destruction in a foreign land? What makes a terrorist? In short, terrorism is viewed as the threat designed in influencing the characters and

What makes a Hero

2185 words - 9 pages is a spectrum that has been developed on one end you have the basic hero something that would ordinarily get overlooked that person who helps someone across the street, the guy who passes meals out to the homeless. The other end is home to what has been deemed the high stakes hero like saving someone from a burning building. Each has its part in the place of a hero, I was in the department store last week and a presentation was placed upon a

What Makes A Hero

1096 words - 5 pages if you have a power to help others, then it is your responsibility to help them when you can, however you can. Since everybody can be brave, and can show courage when they want to that makes everybody heroes, even if people think that they don’t have the characteristics of what it takes to be a hero but one thing is for sure, everybody can be a hero. A hero can be anybody. As was stated in the last paragraph a hero can be anybody that shows grate

What Makes a Hero

2700 words - 11 pages What Makes a Hero When most people think of a hero, they think of some extraordinary, not an ordinary person with a heart. Oskar Schindler was one such person. The movie Schindler's List, directed by Steven Spielberg, is the story of how one man, Schindler, saved over 1,000 lives, and is a cinematic masterpiece. Spielberg truly brings Schindler to life, with all his good and bad points intact; the movie is very true to life, and gives

What Makes a Hero?

761 words - 4 pages What makes a hero? Is it the sharp, wide eyes; the perfect, slicked back hair; the toned, muscular body? Is it the cape, tights, or symbol etched in the material sprawled across their broad chest? What about the heart the hero has; the traits that make them a hero? The true characteristics of a hero are not their superpowers or excellent ability to fight, but their willingness to save others and help those who cannot defend themselves. Their

Similar Essays

What Makes A House A Home

900 words - 4 pages activities creates the home. The wife embodies the duties, ergo, the wife is the home. As Brady says, “who wouldn’t want a wife?” In the descriptive essay “Homeless”, Anna Quindlen relies on common history instead of humor to engage her audience. Her vivid depiction of what being without a home means plays a symphony of emotions in the reader. In “Homeless”, it is the tangible items that that prove worth. For a person with no home to

What Makes A House A Dream House?

657 words - 3 pages , in the country or a metropolis might be a dream house for some, but for me that modest, cozy house in town with just a hint of country does it for me. It is the sight of my family current and generations past in those pictures, the smell of the lilacs and roses grown from cuttings taken from my grandmother’s yard, a porch from which to watch my grandchildren play and the sounds and smells of our Sunday family dinners that makes this house a dream home.

The Journey Home: What Makes A Hero

2522 words - 10 pages The Journey Home: What Makes a Hero What constitutes an epic story? Certainly, literary expectations have come to define a story as a series of events revolving around one or more characters. An epic, however, must possess one attribute that a story may or may not contain; a hero. The Odyssey is an epic and therefore, it does contain a hero and perhaps even more than one. A hero cannot simply just exist, though, he or she must be shaped

Commentary On The Article: I Want A Wife By Judy Brady

985 words - 4 pages In I Want a Wife by Judy Brady, the author generates a captivating argument concerning a wife's responsibilities in a family household. The article was published in Ms. magazine in 1971, this magazine was a feminist which makes this biased. The article becomes visible to be leading towards women, married audience. Nonetheless, her message also goes to clueless men. In Brady's short story the main argument was of the writer wanting eagerly a