Justice Alone Isn't Sufficient Enough To Live Life Morally

1090 words - 4 pages

Socrates and Polemarchus argue the idea of Dikaisune in the beginning of Plato's book, The Republic. Dikaisune translated into English means justice. Justice is one of the four virtues in the group with courage, self-control, and wisdom, which are proposed as being sufficient to live a moral life. Polemarchus considers justice to be the only virtue necessary to live a moral life. Polemarchus adapts the idea of Simonides' concept of Dikaisune, and argues with Socrates that Dikaisune is sufficient to live a moral life. Socrates disagrees if only for the sake of argument. While Polemarchus might have had a great idea by thinking that the idea of Dikaisune is enough to live morally, in reality, justice alone is not sufficient to live a moral life.Simonides does not create the idea of Dikaisune. Before it was a moral idea, it was a Greek word meaning justice. Polemarchus agrees with Simonides. Simonides believes that justice is the only virtue needed to live a moral life. To this end, he thinks that when justice is honored in the correct manner that a person is essentially paying their debts. A debt is defined as owing a favor to a friend or harm to an enemy. While Polemarchus agrees with Simonides, Socrates unfortunately decides that he will argue the idea of Dikaisune. But in the end, it was really Simonides' ideas that Socrates was debating and in actuality, Socrates put Simonides to shame not Polemarchus.Polemarchus' main flaw with his argument is that he defines morality with justice only. Polemarchus believes that Dikaisune, giving people what you owe them, is the truth behind morality. Justice succinctly means giving people what you owe them. The word "you" can be substituted with many other words such as government, judge, friend, or enemy. Dikaisune and justice are one in the same and as justice is one of the four virtues, justice is a very good thing. However, Polemarchus overanalyzes the four virtues essentially drawing the conclusion that justice is the main virtue and the only one needed. In respect to courage, justice governs it because someone wronged will find a great deal of strength when justice has to be served. In respect to self-control, justice governs self- control because whenever a situation is in jeopardy of exploding out of proportion, justice steps in and brings the situation down from the boiling point. In respect to wisdom, a great deal of wisdom comes from an intimate knowledge of Dikaisune. Wisdom is not just pure knowledge but also the intelligence to makes correct choices and decisions. Justice only adds to wisdom, as a decision is made easier with a firm sense of justice. Through Polemarchus' perspective, the only virtue needed to live a moral life is justice because justice governs all the other virtues.The other part of the argument that Polemarchus dictates is all about the interactions that justice has with people. Polemarchus believes that there are essentially two kinds of people. There are people that help...

Find Another Essay On Justice Alone isn't sufficient enough to live life morally

Something to Live for: Life Itself

1028 words - 4 pages "It is not death that a man should fear, but he should fear never beginning to live" (Aurelius). For Monsieur Meursault, it is not until he faces death, that he truly begins to live. In The Stranger, Camus portrayed Meursault as a nihilistic man, devoid of concern for social norms that govern others. He was a character who had no beliefs, ideals, or morals; however as life progresses, Meursault changes in that he begins to recognize the

How to Live a Long Life

1308 words - 5 pages Do you dream of living a long, healthy life? Fortunately, it is much easier to achieve this dream today, in a world that is more technologically and medically advanced than ever before. Because of these favorable advances, the life expectancies in most countries have increased. It is not enough, however, to solely rely on technology and medicine to increase your life expectancy. In order to make your dream a reality, you need to take a few

Live Your Life to the Fullest

739 words - 3 pages a stuffed animal, and being a Disney Imaginer. He explained the ways he made most of his dreams reality. I especially liked how we accomplished experiencing zero gravity. I’m not sure I would have been courageous enough to fly in the “vomit commit,” I would have thrown up for sure, which would be embarrassing. Pausch inspired me to try and live out my childhood dreams. I would like to be a singer, not as a career but maybe as a hobby. I’ve loved

Aristotle's Beliefs on Elements Needed to Live a Happy Life

872 words - 3 pages According to Aristotle, there are three basic kinds of goods that are necessary to possess in order to live a happy life. “These three goods are: bodily goods, external goods, and goods of the soul also known as psychological goods”. Bodily goods are non-tangible, and they would be considered anything that would lengthen a human beings life expectancy. Good health, no or very few illnesses, vitality, freedom from pain, and no or few injuries

Hopelessness Is An Obstacle Not A Way To Live Life

1789 words - 8 pages We often have times when we lose every shred of hope in our lives and we feel like we have lost everything, including our emotions or our future. The hardest thing to do at that point is to be optimistic, which is the only way to get the enough motivation and hope to get back on our feet and keep fighting until we reach the desired state of comfort. Jeannette Walls’ novel, “The Glass Castle”, is based on her true life story about her

You don't need money to live a happy Life

1811 words - 8 pages In both Andy Mulligan’s Trash and Christopher Paul Curtis’s The Might Miss Malone, the authors show the significance of family & friends and how important they are instead of money to live a happy life. Both novels take characters that show how even without money there life goes on. The authors of both novels clearly present the challenges these characters go through to get money but are still happy without it. By doing this the reader can see

Meaning to life, Ability to die or to live forever - Phil 101 - Essay

870 words - 4 pages life where there is no -KG final destination but only karma then thats what defines your life and if you consider that there is a sole purpose which completes after death then thats what brings meaning to your life. She was clear to explain that people are open to explore what brings meaning to them and even if there isn't anything then that is you live for. As said by Thomas Nagel in his writing “On the one hand it can be said that life is all

Criticism of Democracy as a Criticism on How to Live One’s Life

1090 words - 4 pages is the root of democracy. Socrates’ reasoning why the lack of self-control corrupts the soul is that free people are ultimately suppressed by their desires. For example, Socrates’ definition of justice is one performing their natural function, but in a democracy the citizens, “embrace the life of philosophy…where they can say and do anything that comes into their head” (317). While this appears to be liberty, Socrates argues that these people

I live my life a rebel, a vigilante, devils try to get at me

836 words - 3 pages Zachary Kincaid Anne Flanagan English 102 4 May 2014 I live my life a rebel, a vigilante, devils try to get at me Intro:Paul Laurence Dunbar was an African-American poet, novelist, and playwright of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Born to parents who had been slaves in Kentucky before the Civil War, Dunbar started to write as a child and was president of his high school's literary society. He published his first poems at the age of 16

The Sun Also Rises: How Not to Live a Fulfilling Life

1505 words - 6 pages To live a fulfilling life, one must approach it with the right mindset. Although this may vary depending on the individual, one can assert that a few characteristics are common. These include living a life with purpose, staying strong to one's values, and being secure with one's choices and circumstance. In The Sun Also Rises, the main characters display personalities that are opposite to these traits. Cohn, Brett, and Jake seem to live

A Life Ended Before it Even had the Opportunity to Live

1241 words - 5 pages of pregnancy” (Operation Rescue). Having an abortion is wrong because life begins at conception so its murder, there are better options, and it can cause serious medical complications later in life. First and foremost, having an abortion is murder to the most vulnerable being in the world. An abortion is the same as taking away a humans ability to live which is immoral. Professor Paul Campos at the University of Colorado explains it by saying

Similar Essays

Persuasive Essay About Why The Juvenille Justice System Isn't Harsh Enough

1004 words - 4 pages the Criminal Justice System were the same "kids" in the Juvenile Justice System. Now why would this ever possibly happen? The Juvenile Justice System isn't hard enough to deter juveniles from committing another crime. Juveniles are not adults and are not responsible for their decisions, but they know what is right and wrong.The Juvenile Justice System originated in 1899 in Illinois because people expected the court to act in a parental role for

This Is An Essay On The Life Of John Paul Jones. It Is Hard To Find Information And/Or Essays On Him. Essay Isn't Very Long But You Will See It Is Sufficient For Most Teachers

577 words - 2 pages mutinous crewman at Tobago in the West Indies and, rather than stay in prison and wait for trial, he fled to North America. From that point the British considered him to be a pirate. A fugitive from British justice, he attempted to conceal his identity by adding the surname of Jones.At the outbreak of war with Britain in 1775, John Paul Jones went to Philadelphia, and, with the help of two friendly members of the Continental Congress, obtained a

Live Life To The Fullest Essay

1331 words - 6 pages still live life to the fullest nothing has changed. When I get sick with the common cold I stay sick. I have to take antibiotics, and take get the flu shot once a year and ammonia vaccine every three years. One of my biggest accidents was in 2011. It was a cold day on November 6th and I was driving home from my brother’s house in the am. I was driving down Lake Wheeler Rd right after Ten Ten Rd. There are a lot of fields in that area and all of

Devotion To Life And To Live

773 words - 3 pages Devotion to Life and to Live Willa Cather grew up living on the plains of Nebraska. The plain prairies helped influence Willa Cather into using her memory as well as her realism frame working to create the familiar stories we know today such as My Antonia, O Pioneers, One of Ours, and many more. Cather’s fiction is characterized by a strong sense of place, the subtle presentation of human relationships, an often unconventional narrative