Justice: By Any Means Necessary Essay

1583 words - 6 pages

Both Agatha Christie and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, in their respective novels, explore the relationship between detective and criminal. Many mystery novels employ this opposition, but in ‘Sherlock Holmes: The Major Stories with Contemporary Critical Essays’ and ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd,’ the authors, while spending appropriate time with this juxtaposition, add additional elements by spending a majority of their time investigating the idea of justice. Justice is the central theme of both respective novels because both Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot attempt to discover the truth regarding their respective cases by any means necessary.
Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot are the central detectives in their respective novels. Both men employ the method of deduction, scientific investigation, and the idea of logic to solve cases. In addition to employing their respective talents, both men must contend with their respective places in regards to the investigations. Much of Sherlock Holmes’ work is conducted outside the realm of the local police. Opposite this fact, Hercule Poirot, while somewhat independent of the police must contend and assist mainly with police assistance.
The idea of justice is explored when Poirot is invited to join the Ackroyd murder investigation. In a broad sense, justice is the pursuit of truth, by any means necessary. It appears that the police resisted assistance, any sort of assistance at first; thus, they reject justice. For example, in ‘The Murder of Roger Ackroyd,’ after the body of Roger Ackroyd had been discovered, the initial investigator was quite acidic toward the employed staff of Roger Ackroyd. Ackroyd’s butler, in an attempt to ascertain facts declares, “I don’t think so, sir, but I’ll make inquiries.” The inspector responds “No, thanks. I’ll do my own inquiring.” This line of dialogue is repeated when an inspector on the Ackroyd murder quips, “Not the least need for amateurs to come butting in. You’d think any fool would have seen the way things were last night, and then we shouldn’t have lost twelve hours.”
In addition, after the butler is chastised and before the Inspector makes his remarks about “amateurs” Hercule Poirot is invited to join the investigation by Flora Ackroyd, “They [the police] might make a mistake now, I think. Please, M. Poirot, won’t you help us?” All these remarks emphasize the idea of justice or lack there of because the police contend that a person not associated with the police force could not be intelligent enough to solve the crime. Of course, the fact that Dr. Sheppard is never sought by the police as a suspect and only exposed as the murderer of Roger Ackroyd highlights several themes in their own right.
While the remarks to the butler and Poirot, respectively are there to add drama and antagonizing factors to the novel, in “The Speckled Band,” Sherlock Holmes is free from that type of critical eye from law enforcement. Helen Stoner approaches Holmes and...

Find Another Essay On Justice: By Any Means Necessary

Plato's Concept Of Justice Essay

2203 words - 9 pages "the interest of the stronger". In the other words, might is right. For while, every man acts for himself and tries to get what he can, the strongest is sure to get what he wants and as in a state the Government is the strongest, it will try to get and it will get, whatever it wants for itself. Thus, for Thrasymachus justice means personal interest of the ruling group in any state or we can further define it as "another's good". Laws are made by

Justice And Injustice Essay

1261 words - 5 pages . Thus the unjust lives a life of fear and anxiety, the fruit of being out of control. Socrates asserts that only the man of reason has pure pleasures. All others have varying degrees of unhappiness. By equating the philosopher with the man of pure reason, he sets up a situation where proof is not so much necessary for any of his points as it is to say that the philosopher, the only one who sees clearly, says so. Amazingly so, Socrates molds a form

Justice in the Legal System

668 words - 3 pages “system works.” This is why justice is important and sought after it give the community a common ground and to some degree a sense of security. While not all justice is delivered conventionally via a jail sentence or any means the courts deem appropriate it is a comfort to know that there are those willing to give their time and energy to help attempt to reach the goal of justice. Justice can be hoped for and occasionally achieved, even though

The Function of Punishment

2114 words - 8 pages when innocent men would have to be punished for the sake of the greater good - for example, in that case where an atrocious crime has been committed and the authorities failed to find the perpetrator (This scenario is by no means hypothetical - the "Birmingham Six" is just one example). One may only speculate as to how many miscarriages of justice there have been for the sake of maintaining "apparent justice". Thus, there

The significance of Reparations in the context of mass atrocity

5086 words - 20 pages reparative justice can hope to aim for in situations which involve mass murder, torture, or any other atrocious act that can be deemed beyond the scope of full compensation. I will start by discussing what constitutes a relevant relationship when considering reparative justice and suggest that the passage of time and state-continuity have a significant impact on perpetrator - victim based relationships. I will use arguments made by Thompson

Can justice be achieved on earth?

1144 words - 5 pages think justice can definitely be achieved on earth but not all the time and these are things we have learnt to live with. Philosophers have debated over what justice actually means and how it should be applied. We are certain that justice is implicated to do well and achieve what is right in any circumstance. Justice is fair treatment or moral rightness to do good on earth and it is proven that justice can be achieved on earth but there are

Significance of Justice

856 words - 4 pages death. Untouched by justice, she persists by committing even more evil deeds. Such was the case when she plotted against her sister. As long as she gets what she wants, she does not care about what happens to her country. Offering Regan any mercy or forgiveness is pointless. Only being poisoned by her sister Goneril, a somewhat harsh form of justice, stops her. This shows how justice is more essential than mercy, as it actually resolves the conflict

What Justice Means to Me

515 words - 2 pages with the rulesIntroductionJustice is the idea behind how laws are to be enforced. Justice means that we have the right to be protected and to be treated fairly by the law. If a person breaks the law or does something wrong in the eye of the law, than the Justice System steps in to prove or disprove their innocents or guilt, fairly What one perceives as justice, another may see as unjust, therefore laws are designed to ensure that all people

Justice: Who Knew It Could Be So Complicated

1313 words - 6 pages . Still someone could argue that we do lock up more guilty criminals than innocent ones, so the ends justify the means. When we have innocent people in jail the utmost injustice has been committed. Any person who can stand silently by and take part in this is most unjust. On the other side of this coin in recent years our society has seen people who are universally believed to be guilty set free based on ability to afford the best legal defense or

Justice Alone isn't sufficient enough to live life morally

1090 words - 4 pages Socrates and Polemarchus argue the idea of Dikaisune in the beginning of Plato's book, The Republic. Dikaisune translated into English means justice. Justice is one of the four virtues in the group with courage, self-control, and wisdom, which are proposed as being sufficient to live a moral life. Polemarchus considers justice to be the only virtue necessary to live a moral life. Polemarchus adapts the idea of Simonides' concept of Dikaisune


1238 words - 5 pages fulfillment and happiness. Those who conform to an inherent, higher form of good would like to be happy and fulfilled by following those concepts. Those who believe in following by the letter of the law will like to become happy and fulfilled by becoming a "model citizen" based by that standard. Human desires are highly sought-after. Anyone would do any necessary needs to fulfill them.Fulfillment By my personal belief, I think that a sense of fulfillment

Similar Essays

Augustus Absolute Power By Any Means Necessary

1003 words - 5 pages Augustus to command the absolute power bestowed upon him, he must eliminate any threats by any means necessary. This took the form of massacre. The justification for Augusts' campaign against any threat came from propaganda spread against him and its potential to undermine his rule. One of the primary methods of belittlement came in the form of slander against his family name. No individual utilized this tactic more cunningly than Marc Antony. The

Justice In The Eye Of The Beholder

954 words - 4 pages experienced first hand what it means to be caught in the middle of a cause that was ,and still is, considered just by some and unjust by others and having lived in a country forced to regularly justify the defense of it's citizens, it's not so easy to give justice an exact definition." During the most recent conflict between Israel and Gaza, it is easy to see how the concept of justice is clouded by perception and self-interest. Under the guise of

Affirmative Action Vs. Equal Opportunity Essay

1018 words - 5 pages there is both equal opportunity and fair distribution of education and advancement to all Americans, affirmative action is necessary. But expanding opportunities for people of minorities means not only expanding their access to existing jobs and education but also removing the obstacles that causes them from obtaining their goals. Giving an equal chance to all individuals based on their qualifications and not on gender or racial preferences is what Aristotle desires, and in doing so acquires a state that exists on justice.

Violence In Of Mice And Men By John Steinbeck

654 words - 3 pages . Lennie was not capable of understanding the idea of consequences for any of his actions. This can be seen when he kills mice or even when he crushes Curly's hand. If Lennie wouldn't have been shot by George he would have continued to cause more harm on the ranch. George killing Lennie was necessary to serve justice among the ranch hands. He was incapable of understanding the result of his actions, and the violent act of killing Lennie was