Justice In Antigone And A Doll’s House

1448 words - 6 pages

Before comparing these two pieces of works, the definition of justice is needed to address the question as fully as possible. Justice is a concept which involves fair and ethical treatment for everyone. It is usually seen as the continued effort to do what is right. In most cases this is done by making use of logic. This is the premise which is going to be used for justice when comparing the two works. Sophocles’ Antigone differs largely from Ibsen’s A Doll’s House since they were written in different centuries and different cultures, but at the same time both works share similarities. Ibsen does not identify a direct problem and he chooses to develop his characters and the problem as the play unfolds. Sophocles begins Antigone with a challenge directed at the power of the king. This directly identifies a problem and source of tension from the start of the play in contrast to Ibsen’s A Doll’s House. Tensions arise in both works when the female protagonists disobey laws which they find contradictory to their values and beliefs. The protagonists stand by their beliefs throughout unlike their counter parts who continue to change their beliefs.

Ibsen chooses to create and develop his characters at the same time as developing the source of the dilemma. We see the problem later on when Nora and Christine hold their first discussion. Ibsen does not disclose the precise nature of the loan during this discussion. Nora presents the issue vaguely with a simple question, “Is it imprudent to save your husband’s life?” With the question presented in such a way, the audience is placed in a position where they agree with Nora since saving someone is usually considered to be heroic. The audience discovers later, however, that although Nora’s actions were just, they were still done illegally thus creating a moral dilemma. When Krogstad asks her whether or not she knew she had committed a crime, she replies in the negative to which Krogstad replies that his own crime was “nothing more or nothing worse” then what she has done. Through Krogstad, Ibsen verifies the point that despite the law being just or not, it is “the law by which” Nora “will be judged” and that “the law cares nothing about motives”. Nora’s arguments are presented with an emphasis on moral absolutes. When she cries, “No, it’s impossible! I did it for love’s sake”, it shows us that no matter what the reason was for breaking the law, the law does not care and the person has to bear the punishment. Ibsen treats the law with an intuitive sense of right and wrong. Like Sophocles, Ibsen argues that rather than the law themselves, the premises on which they are based are of more importance. This way of presenting the problem begs the question of whether or not the law is just in punishing Nora for her actions. This question is similar to that of Sophocles but he presents the dilemma in a different manner.

Sophocles opens Antigone by having his titled character challenge the power of the king which...

Find Another Essay On Justice in Antigone and A Doll’s House

Infiltration and Withdrawal in A Doll’s House

1245 words - 5 pages Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House, a play originally written in Norwegian during the nineteenth century, provides an excerpt of the life of Nora and Torvald Helmer. Throughout the play, the characters experience struggle with situations such as emotional conflicts, keeping secrets, conversational exploitation, and physical distractions. Ibsen manipulates clothing to signal infiltration and withdrawal with the characters. The expressions of

Symbolism in A Doll’s House Essay

949 words - 4 pages Henrik Ibsen’s “A Doll’s House” is a controversial play focusing on the marriage of Nora and Torvald Helmer. The play is filled with symbols that represent abstract ideas and concepts. These symbols effectively illustrate the inner conflicts that are going on between the characters. Henrik Ibsen’s use of symbolism such as the Christmas tree, the locked mailbox, the Tarantella, Dr. Rank’s calling cards, and the letters allows him to give a

The Use of Nature in Siddhartha and A Doll’s House

1570 words - 6 pages The Use of Nature in Siddhartha and A Doll’s House Herman Hesse and Henrik Ibsen make extensive references to and use of nature in their respective masterpieces, Siddhartha and A Doll’s House. This includes the use of nature as imagery, symbolism, and to create a motif. While the objects in nature do differ because of the location of the stories, there is also overlap. In Siddhartha Herman Hesse refers to two symbols of nature, birds and

Themes and Symbols in Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House

1482 words - 6 pages “I’ve been your doll-wife here, just as at home I was Papa’a doll-child” (Ibsen 1491). Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll House tells a story of scandal and deceit set in the Victorian era. Nora Helmer is married to Torvald Helmer and she feels more like his toy than his wife. Nora had to have Torvald to be able to do anything, because of when she lived. Nora borrows money behind her husband’s back (which is illegal at this time) and tries to cover up

A Doll’s House and Fathers and Sons

1499 words - 6 pages Ibsen’s A Doll’s House and Turgenev’s Fathers and Sons reflect two unique societal struggles. While both texts deal with a main character attempting to overcome society’s resistance to progress, they delineate from each other in the characters’ relative successes as well as divergent societal implications. The formal cause of these differences is ultimately societal mores as well as contrasting aims: Ibsen deals with feminism, whereas Turgenev

Gender Roles in Ibsen’s A Doll’s House

856 words - 3 pages Henrik Ibsen’s famous play A Doll’s House was first published in 1879 and contains elements and characters that appear to support feminism, and drew attention from the women’s rights movement. However, Ibsen himself said that he was not a feminist; rather, his play is about the human nature in general, and is not specifically about women’s rights. Over the years, this was the view that most scholars used to interpret the play, but more recently

Facades in Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House

1309 words - 5 pages When a young girl plays with her doll house, she imagines a make-believe world full of enchantment. However, little does she realize the false and unattainable image of perfection that lies before her. With every miniature doorway and elaborate bookcase, the doll house disguises reality with a mask of flawless excellence. Similarly, Henrik Ibsen describes many appearances in A Doll House as mere façades of deception. These images

The Cherry Orchard and A Doll’s House

1437 words - 6 pages People bring their downfalls upon themselves. Do certain habitually practice leave them wondering what wrong they did? Torvald from Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House and Madame Ranevsky from Anton Chekhov’s The Cherry Orchard are left to start afresh at the end of the plays after they neglected a key element in their lives. Torvald toys with Nora, his wife, fulfilling only his wants and only his needs and abases her; never considering her his

Examining a Doll’s House

854 words - 4 pages leave Italy after publishing Brand in 1865. This five-act tragedy depicted a clergyman losing his family and life due to his devotion to faith. This play made him famous in Scandinavia despite losing prestige in Italy. Ibsen still managed to challenge the higher orders with his works such as The Pillars of Society (1868), Ghosts (1881), An Enemy of the People (1882), Hedda Gabler (1890), and A Doll’s House (1879). He moved to Germany, ventured

A Doll’s House - Nora

1372 words - 5 pages Nora is the central character in the book A Doll’s House and it is through her that Ibsen develops many of his themes To what extent is loyalty shown by the lead female characters characters? What are the consequences of this? Within these two books loyalty is a minor theme and one that is easily missed, indeed it is narrow. However, it is still one which weaves a thread through both of the books encompassing major and minor

Limits Placed Upon Women in Antigone and A Doll's House

1193 words - 5 pages Stephen Schwartz’s song, Defying Gravity, contains a very bold statement. “I’m through with playing by the rules of someone else’s game and accepting limits because someone says they’re right.” This is something that many women have the audacity to think but never to speak aloud. However, there are two women who, even though they’re only in the play, did have the courage to say. In the plays Antigone, by Sophocles, and A Doll’s House, by Henrik

Similar Essays

Antigone And A Doll’s House: Women In Patriarchal Societies

1218 words - 5 pages ”Women have been taught that, for us, the earth is flat, and that if we venture out, we will fall of the edge”(Kramarae, Treichler). This notion is exemplified through both novels, Antigone by Sophocles, and A Doll’s House by Leo Tolstoy. Both novels provide a different look at women, with the two main characters showing qualities that weren’t common in this era such as determination, intelligence, rebellion, hubris, and stubbornness. In both

Unfair Treatment Of Women In Antigone And A Doll’s House

1668 words - 7 pages beyond just the workforce as displayed in the plays Antigone by Sophocles and A Doll’s House by Henrik Ibsen. Antigone is a Greek tragedy written before or in 442 BC. It is the third of the three Theban plays by Sophocles. Antigone tells the tale of a young adult woman, Antigone, who must choose between following the laws of the state or the laws of the gods. A Doll’s House takes place in the late 1800s in Norway and depicts the life of a young

Powerful Women In Antigone And A Doll’s House

1427 words - 6 pages Doll’s House, written by Henrik Ibsen, demonstrate the interaction and roles with men and women during the 18th century. The main characters in both plays, Antigone in Antigone and Nora in A Doll’s House, show how women have struggled to find their place in the social order. They had to fight for what they wanted and face dire consequences if they disobeyed the law. Sophocles and Ibsen display the constraints placed upon women in patriarchal

Limitations On Women In A Doll’s House And Antigone

1710 words - 7 pages independence that both Nora and Antigone have, each of the literary works would have been unremarkable. Independence serves as an enduring theme when writing about women due to the many struggles women remained challenged by throughout time. It is not only a theme that can be seen when Antigone was written, but also thousands of years later, when A Doll’s House was written. In both of these works, countless numbers of quotes can be found that are said