Justice Or Love Essay

1000 words - 4 pages

In the short story, A Fathers Story by Andre Debus, a man named Luke Ripley is challenged by a decision that effects himself, the people he loves, and his faith. The author, Dubus, uses what a man named Paul Fussell describes as "the literary-artistic-historical sensibility"
Luke Ripley loves his daughter very much. He wishes that he was closer with his daughter but has an awkward relationship with her. She is the youngest of his four children and the only daughter. When him and his wife got divorced she took the children with her. Because they lived far away he was only able to see his children when they visited. The three boys did not visit much but his daughter would come for the summers. Luke speaks a lot about his daughter and how strange it is for him to watch her grow from a small child into a young woman. Although you can tell Luke loves his daughter he has a strange distant relationship with her.
Luke is also a very religious man. He goes to church every single Sunday. His closest and only friend is named Paul Leboeuf. Paul is also the minister at the church Luke attends. Being a religious man, Luke feels guilty about moving on and finding someone new to love because it goes against the wedding vows he made to his wife. Being a faithful and moral man is another example of how Dubus created underlying problems in the story.
Dubus then takes the fundamental issues and uses events in the story to bring those out. One summer night when Lukes daughter was visiting, she and her friends went out. They had a few drinks and on the way home after dropping off her friends she hits a young man crossing the street with her car. She rushes home in a panic to get her father. After sometime and a little alcohol she tells her father what happened.
Luke and his daughter share a beautiful movement when she comes home and tells him what had happened. Luke sends her to bed and immediately rushes out the door and goes to the stop were his daughter had hit the man. On the side of the road in a ditch he finds the young man dead. Luke then makes the choice between being the moral faithful man he was by turning his daughter in or be the father that loved his daughter more then anything and protect her against the law. He was forced to make a decision that impacted all the people he loved. Despite the fact that he was a religious man and valued truth he choose to protect his daughter.
The fact that Dubus made him a religious man makes the story more complicated. He choose his daughter even though his God could punish him for doing the wrong thing. Because he is a religious man he choose his daughter over possibly loosing or upsetting his God. I also think that having Luke and his daughters...

Find Another Essay On Justice or Love

Examine four six fundamental principles - Religious Studies - Essay

605 words - 3 pages should be. The four out of the six fundamental principles that will be covered include: love only is always good, love is the only norm (rule), love and justice are the same and love justifies the means. The first proposition as Fletcher puts it, only one thing is intrinsically good; namely love: nothing else at all. Fletcher (1963, pg56). This is the assertion that love is only intrinsically good. Therefore, actions are extrinsically benevolent or

Justice is in our starts not hands

1189 words - 5 pages . Justice is blind and we are unable to close our eyes. Think about it. Have you ever tried to get justice before? It turns into revenge. People try to give others back what they have felt but you simply can’t. You can’t measure suffering and pain. How do you know how much you received in relation to what you give? The point is you don’t. You never know how much something will impact someone or who is connected to who. Everyone is connected as if

Revenge Through Fraudulent Justice

1014 words - 5 pages though it is fueled by her love for Bassanio, is not biased and best represent the limits that justice should have. When Portia speaks of law at the courthouse, she shows Shylock that she believes in justice and can help him get what he wants. Portia believes that mercy is the best solution to the problem at hand. Regarding mercy, she says “It blesseth him that gives and him that takes”(4.1 193) meaning that mercy is the only way out that does

Justice is Served in Antigone by Sophocles

1001 words - 5 pages makes it clear she does not care about the law Creon has established; “I’m still going to bury my brother.” To explain Antigone and Creon’s relationship, Matthew S. Santirocco, author of “Justice in Sophocles’ Antigone,” states, “ [Antigone and Creon are a lot alike] both are isolated, both are stubborn, both respond to others, including those who love them, in the same imperious way, and both doom themself and others by their actions. The

The Count of Monte Cristo: Revenge and Justice

1194 words - 5 pages Revenge is best served cold or so says the well-known expression. This idea of revenge that they seek is usually to restore a balance and take an “eye for an eye” as the bible says. Revenge, if by chance everyone were in Plato’s perfect utopia, would be in a perfect form, where justice and revenge would be one, and the coined phrase an “eye for an eye” would be taken literally. By taking an eye for and eye, and punishing those who did wrong

Women's Perspectives

1610 words - 6 pages of the community. Unfortunately, in order to teach a child this, one must punish said child for bad behavior to properly form them; this requires justice intermingled with care. The woman still cares for her child but she must decide how to punish them using justice. In addition, like I mentioned before, every person has his or her own sense of duty and obligation. Of course, women choose to raise their children right because they love them

Heatcliffe vs. hamlet

1005 words - 4 pages this lifetime. Other instances like King Hamlet's ghost appearance in Hamlet, and Heathcliff and Catherine's passionate love for each other in Wuthering Heights shows that a higher form of justice still prevails, even beyond the grave. Although the two novels portray higher form of justice taking place, Hamlet is a better representation of it then Wuthering Heights.Evidence is given in both books about justice taking place in this lifetime

Justice Portrayed In Agamemnon

1689 words - 7 pages ethic, I believe that we can all understand the feelings which makes us seek to take revenge, especially when someone has done any kind of violence or has wronged any member of our own family. I think we should remember those feeling while we evaluate if there is justice in our main characters actions. In Agamemnon, revenge is the central issue. We realize that in this play what the consequence of revenge is and that it emerges as something

GLC Scholarship

1021 words - 5 pages In my life, there was always three things certain in my mind. Firstly, family is always first, secondly that your academics allow you to reach new heights and lastly, that one should always help those in need. The Bible tells us that humans are called to "do justice, love, kindness and walk humbly with God." What is justice? There are many forms of justice including the justice pertaining to law and the justice towards others. For me, justice

Christianity: True Justice

1532 words - 7 pages Zechariah 7:9-10, “Execute true justice, show kindness and mercy to each other. And do not oppress the widow or orphan, the sojourner or poor. And do not plot evil against each other, says the Lord.” This is true justice. God calls us on this earth to love, care, show kindness and mercy to one another. As i saw on a picture with a little boy holding up a sign saying “When the power of love overcomes the love of power, then the world will know

Social Justice

817 words - 4 pages background or group membership (Toowoomba Cathloc Education, 2006). For the most part, social justice is equated with the notion of equality or equal opportunity in society. The elements of social justice really vary from person to person, and can have different meanings. Some people may feel there are more. One very important one is Self-love and Knowledge. It is important for people to learn about who they are and where they come from. A sense

Similar Essays

Basis Of Justice In Scripture Essay

620 words - 2 pages Christians are called to, “In everything, do to others as you would have them do to you; for this is the law and the prophets.” This rule of doing unto all others with love and charity as if he were your brother or sister is in my opinion the foundation for justice in the scriptures. Jesus says in Matthew, 5 43-44 “You have heard that it was said, ‘You should love your neighbor and hate your enemy’ But I say to you, love your

Justice In The Legal System Essay

668 words - 3 pages assault, petty theft or vandalism, committed against them or ones they love we hope that our idea of justice is served. We hope that the people who commit the crimes “get what they deserve” and we have a common belief and hope that justice can occur in the form of a jail term, a fine, probation, etc. We have this “hope” for others because we know that if the same situation occurred in our lives, we would like to have some comfort in that the

The Eucharist Essay

1202 words - 5 pages equality, but also in ‘brotherly love.’ This love and equality is mentioned again in Catholic social justice doctrine, by Pope Benedict in his encyclical letter ‘Caritas in Virtitate’. He states that ‘charity is at the heart of the Church’s social doctrine’ (Benedict XVI, Caritas in Veritate, 2). In speaking of charity, denoted by love for fellow man, the Pope is creating (or restating) the hypostasis of social justice. Pope John XIII authored an

Skewed Justice Essay

875 words - 4 pages “We live in a world in which justice is skewed.” Justice is when someone gets what they deserved due to an action that they executed. Due to justice not being fair, it is skewed in one way or another when solving a mystery, weather a murder or any other case that may require the detective/officer or the criminal to do something that my be illegal. It may be for the good or bad but, it does not change the fact that an action is illegal