This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Justice: Who Knew It Could Be So Complicated

1313 words - 6 pages

The term justice is used in some of America's most treasured and valued documents, from the Pledge of Allegiance, to the Constitution, and the Declaration of Independence. Everyone wants to be treated justly whether it's in the courtroom or the local bar. Most people would feel confident giving a definition for justice, but would it be a definition we could universally agree to? Given that justice is a very common term, and something we all want, it's important to have a precise definition. For hundreds of years philosophers have argued, debated, and fought over this topic. Justice can clearly be defined as the intention to conform to truth and fairness. This is true justice.
In Plato's, "The Republic", Thrasymachus and Socrates debated on the topic of justice. Thrasymachus seemed to be very sure of himself when he defined the idea. He claimed justice was "nothing but the interest of the stronger." He is asserting that because the wealthy and powerful create the laws and inflict penalty for an offense, then we must define justice as whatever the wealthy and powerful want it to be. Socrates had a different idea as to how to define justice. He seemed to define justice in terms of pure selflessness and a constant and unwavering desire to do what is right. He described a ruler who makes decisions without regard for himself and thinking only of the best interest of the people under his rule. Thrasymachus expresses a harsh and negative view of society and the people in charge, while Socrates described a nearly perfect human being. Both views are extreme; the answer must lie somewhere in the middle. Socrates' definition of justice would in fact be true if it could actually exist. I can imagine this just person Socrates creates the same way I can imagine a unicorn. Defining justice in terms of something that does not exist in reality will not do, but we could say there is a sort of mythical justice that can only exist in our imagination and a true justice that can exist in the world.
At this point it makes sense to consider the fact that a person is capable of being just in one circumstance and then unjust in another. Our justice system regularly makes decisions that would be universally considered just and in the very same day makes decisions that are universally considered unjust. Based on this, justice must be more about the intention. For the sake of argument imagine a judge who intends with every fiber of his being to be just, makes a decision that in the end turns out to be unjust. I would say this man could still be considered just. Regardless of the outcome, the intention should determine the question of just or unjust. If that same judge admits his mistake and does his best to rectify the situation, he would certainly be considered just. On the other hand if he realizes the mistake and does nothing then he is most unjust. Human beings are incapable of unfailing justice, but when you intend to be just, you should then be considered a just...

Find Another Essay On Justice: Who Knew It Could Be So Complicated

imaginative staffing inc case solution if so, who should be on the team?

765 words - 3 pages more large accounts and do it more quickly with a well-orchestrated team effort.2. If so, who should be on the team?There are only 25 people on the staff, so it's a pretty finite group to choose from. Obviously the team needs a leader (or orchestrator). This should probably be the sales rep assigned to the account. The size of the team should be related somewhat to the number of contacts it is necessary to make in the prospect's organization in

Who owns DNA, and how it can be patented

3459 words - 14 pages known all around. Of course, the details of the pathway is getting more and more complex as technology improves, but the general rule of central dogma still holds truth. It is believed that DNA base pairs sequence so called genetic codes when can be related to amino acid sequence is nearly universal to all living organisms. As the physical structure of genes was first established by work in bacteria it soon became evident that transcription of DNA

Social Media and How Bad could It be for Young people?

1111 words - 4 pages Nguyen 4Tran NguyenMrs. AmyENG 111/ENF 3 - 027NOctober 20, 2014Social Media and How Bad could It be for Young people?There is no point in denying that social networking has taken control of almost every young people's life. Everywhere you look, you will undoubtedly find a teenager girl who is gluing her eyes on her phone as she is carelessly avoiding nasty collisions with several people on her way to class while busily updating her Facebook

Why did it take so long for the Vietnamese Veterans to be recognized in Australia?

661 words - 3 pages government.But why did the public harass the returning soldiers so much? In previous wars soldiers had major parades and were considered heroes by all. What made Vietnam so different? There are some notable differences between the two. In both the First World War and the Second, there was a definite and major enemy and threat, like Hitler. You could see the threat and evidence that his regime had to be stopped, but with Vietnam there was only a slight

Is there a democratic deficit in the EU and if so, how might it be reduced?

1525 words - 7 pages Is there a democratic deficit in the EU and if so, how might it be reduced? One of the most controversial debates in the history of European Union (EU) is if there is a democratic deficit in the EU. On the one hand, many scholars argued that the democratic deficit exists in the EU. On the other hand, there are other scholars who claimed that there is not a democratic deficit in the EU. In this essay, the writer will support the argument that

Your DNA: Who Has Access to it and How it Should Be Used

731 words - 3 pages concern as to who, where and how this information is passed along? When people agree to be screened for certain conditions, other results may also show up. For example, you get screened for breast cancer, but amidst that test they also find that you have the gene that could predispose you of heart conditions. The question that arise would be whether or not this information should be disclosed to the patients. Having the genes that could cause an

"The Constitutional Monarchy and Absolutism" --Improvements: Im not particularly a good closer. So a more elaborate conclusion could be in order...depending on what your specific question is

1648 words - 7 pages defy them was to defy God. A statement by Louis the 14th "I am the state", could be taken as Louis implying that he was France itself. It was not until the 1640's with the War of Fronde, that France saw the first uprise by the nobility against the crown to gain back power. The Parlement was introduced Absolutism died off with the French Revolution and in the few years following 1789.Socially and Economically, In England, the constitutional monarchy

Heroes, the topic was are there real-life heroes today and if so who are they? Be sepecific

702 words - 3 pages whether famous or just an average person doing their job. A real-life hero can be divided into three groups, "visible heroes", "action heroes" and "family heroes."A "visible hero" is a hero that is commonly seen and their acts of heroism are far more publicized. These are people who worked very hard to become the best at what they do. In addition to working hard they have became public figures and have strengthened and inspired many people. One

Is It True That Justice Is A Good ? And If So, Does It Mean That We Have Good Reasons To Act Justly?

2228 words - 9 pages define justice like they have tried for the other important values like morality, virtue which is related to people's life and nature. In my essay I will explain these terms according to the Republic and the question which is the subject of this essay, also my thesis which is justice is good because it makes people happy and we want to be just because of its benefit, the benefits make people happy in the society. If so, it means that people have

A dercription of Gout how it can be treated, what causes it, and who is affected by it,

611 words - 2 pages salicylate and corticosteroids can be prescribed, or a corticosteroid may be injected into the affected joint. The acute phase is managed with anti-inflammatory drugs, such as colchicines or indomethacin which although Colchicines is effective it can often cause diarrhoea, vomiting, and nausea. Agents that promote excretion of uric acid, including probenecid, and agents that inhibit production of uric acid, such as allopurinol, usually treat chronic

We were told we could write a story roughly 1000words and it could be any devolpment of ideas.... i did it in script format which i think gave me bonus marks

1722 words - 7 pages Cast List:Malcolm McDowell DavidMichael Gover Sergeant CooperMiriam Karlin RebeccaPatrick Magee Fuel GuyIntention:My intention with this story is write a story in script format giving me a challenge and that if it was to be made into a play or movie it would not require time to convert it. The story is about a guy 'David who is in love with a girl 'Rebecca' who in return does not love David, at first. She quickly has a change in her heart and

Similar Essays

In What Ways Could It Be Said That Community Is Exclusive And If So, In What Ways Could It Be

676 words - 3 pages patterns of the nineteenth andearly twentieth centuries, some of the early social thinkers developed ideal type, or modelsocieties. These ideal types highlight distinctive features and reflect the basic 'idea' of what isbeing described. These typologies have been used as analytical tools and have enabledcomparisons over time to be distinguished. For example, the German sociologist and politicalscientist, Ferdinand Tonnies (1855, 1936), who was a

Could It Be Addiction? Essay

1109 words - 4 pages shifts in focus result in less deep thinking and induces a superficial thoughts. Another study by Mr. Merzenich, Professor of University of California in San Francisco found out that the brain is adaptable to whatever situation it is put in, therefore it can adapt to our technology habit which could be deadly to our intellectual lives. In other words, the individual “become signal processing units, quickly shepherding disjointed bits of info and

If I Could Interview Anyone, Who Would It Be? Jesus And Why? What Questions Would You Ask Him/Her, And Why?

682 words - 3 pages If I could interview anyone, who would it be? JesusIf I could interview anyone, dead or alive, it would have to be Jesus. I would want to interview him because he was a man different from you and I. He was the son of God, a man without sins. Being of the Christian faith, there are many questions that are unanswered concerning God, Heaven, and the Bible.What impresses me is how he endured the hostility that came to him without going sour on

Propaganda: Definition, It's History, Who Uses It, And So Forth

1194 words - 5 pages people. 3. treating other people as one's equals) from education in democratic societies. But education in a dictatorship can involve teaching children and youth by techniques, which could be classified as propaganda. Educators in democratic societies teach people how to think, but propagandists (a person who gives time or effort to the spreading of some opinion, belief, or principle) tell them what to think. Experts disagree about what is