Justification By Reflective Equilibrium Essay

2685 words - 11 pages

Justification by Reflective Equilibrium

Famously, John Rawls is regarded as using reflective equilibrium (RE) to justify his principles of justice. But the point of justification by RE in Rawls's more recent work is not easily established since he regards his own work as still contractarian. In order to clarify matters, I distinguish between wide and narrow RE, as well as show that wide RE consists of several kinds of narrow RE: RE as a plea for (re)consideration, RE as a constructive procedure of choice, and safe ground RE. The connection of these REs is shown in order to reach justification. The point of introducing RE for justification is seen in opening the range of possible revisions to allow for consensus. However, (the lack of) wide RE for itself is not enough to bring about revision. Rather, an additional causal link between two kinds of RE is proposed to be necessary.

1. Famously, John Rawls uses the method of reflective equilibrium (RE) to justify his principles of justice. (1) But the point of justification by RE in Rawls's more recent work is not that easy to establish, since he regards his own work still as contractarian. Accordingly, it is peoples', citizens', or rational deciders' acceptance of the basic notions, methods, and results of Rawls's framework at its different stages (2) that is to establish his Justice as Fairness. Since every single one of us supposedly has already accepted a moral view of the world, though not the same one, it is in the end with regard to that moral view of the world, (3) or in Rawls's terms, that comprehensive theory of the good, (4) that the principles of justice have to be justified. (5) From the point of view of every one of us who reads Rawls's work or from the point of view of any particular citizen engaged in a discussion of a just society nothing else matters (6) - or so it seems. What, then, can be the point of justification provided for by RE that is not provided for by our comprehensive theories of the good? (7) Imagine we are discussing what kind of society is just. Here the plurality of views is likely to foreclose easy agreements. I take RE in Rawls's more recent works to widen the range of possible agreements in that situation, and, hence, facilitate agreements otherwise impossible to arrive at.

The request of RE may facilitate aggrements in two ways: first, by asking us to reconsider initial refutations (in this case) of Rawls's proposed principles, and, second, on settling what may be seen as the second best solution of what a just society is like from the point of view of the single comprehensive views. I take Rawls to have both of those requests in mind when he asks us to go back and forth between a set of principles of justice and our existing considered judgments (8) - or so I want to argue.

2. Let's begin the argument with the concept of RE. Clearly, what Daniels expounded in general as "narrow reflective equilibrium" (9) could only be a method for the first of...

Find Another Essay On Justification by Reflective Equilibrium

To What Extent Does Religion Affect the Characters in "Measure for Measure?"

2468 words - 10 pages juxtaposes Isabella's religious extremity with Mistress Overdone, who is shown to be the opposite of Isabella in ever way. Despite this, she is not shown as a positive role model, which is also Shakespeare showing that whatever the extremity in a character, it is a negative thing, and that people should be balanced. This idea is reflected by the title of the play, Measure for Measure as it represents a sense of equilibrium and balance. Even the

Tolerance, Liberalism, and Community Essay

3297 words - 13 pages : coercion cannot create belief and unbelieving conformity is in itself of no value when only the worth of one's own way of life is at issue. Liberal neutrality in controversies about the worthy life is here justified by an argument that does not claim moral neutrality about the justification of coercion. So from this viewpoint, there is only misunderstanding in communitarian attacks on the principle of tolerance as inconsistently based on moral

The Rhetoric of Christopher Marlowe’s Tamburlaine

883 words - 4 pages divine precedent. This comparison serves to glorify his bloody path, and subtly clarifies him as a mighty persona in majestic uprising, not simply a violent, sheep-herding rebel. Tamburlaine’s bolstering of his own person is followed by a justification of the very act of ambitious conquest by means of logos, a logical appeal to reason. He argues that “Nature…Doth teach us all to have aspiring minds,” a conclusion that can be

I need help with this essay, read the end to understand

1365 words - 5 pages speak to the PCP and I'd repeat the above steps. *If I couldn't get to the PCP, I'd see whether she was still visiting her husband and whether he could come in to the hospital for a conference. *I'm almost done, but perhaps I would take other steps, until I had reached reflective and emotional equilibrium [2] about my responsibilities. Reflective and emotional equilibrium means that I continue to entertain all the new thoughts and feelings that I

Compare and contrast Anne Hathaway and Frau Freud in Duffy’s

913 words - 4 pages he was alive, justification of Shakespeare’s will. There is a reflective theme in the poem and homage to Shakespeare as it is written in sonnet form, Shakespeare wrote one hundred and fifty four sonnets so acts a vice in which Anne Hathaway can keep her love for Shakespeare alive in the immortal art of poetry. Also throughout the poem there references to Shakespeare’s plays, when Duffy describes their bed as the centre of their fantasy


1241 words - 5 pages Belief in the existence of an omnipotent God is the fundamental foundation upon which monotheistic religions depend. Without this conviction, there would be no justification for religious thought; religious texts would be meaningless and actions rationalized by religious belief would be nonexistent, altering history and society in unimaginable ways. This God – while not associated with a specific religion here – is theoretically a perfect

Manage change in business

844 words - 3 pages resistance to change is from 'fear of the unknown'. By building employee trust and offering support greater confidence is placed in management and thus resistance to change from employees is considerably smaller. In addition, if the change is supported by new training, and these changes are open to criticism and participation from the business' internal stakeholders, concerns which may have caused grievance and resistance can be laid to rest

Planetary Nebulae

978 words - 4 pages Nebula or the plural nebulae is derived from the Latin word for cloud(s), and is a term traditionally used by astronomers to describe the vast gaseous structures which exist throughout the universe. Nebulae now have been divided into five major categories due to their reflective and observational characteristics, these being emission nebulae, reflection nebulae, dark nebulae, supernova remnants and planetary nebulae. In fact, the term

Evaluation of Dworkin's and Habermas's Approach to Civil Disobedience

1608 words - 6 pages ?threadbare? majority.# Habermas argues that the stance of majority rule should function as a justification for outlawing certain forms of civil disobedience only when the following conditions are met. These conditions are that there should be no minorities by birth, the majority cannot make irreversible decisions and further that majority rule decisions should be taken with a grain of salt so to speak if those decision are made by a slim majority

Australian Economic Issues

1879 words - 8 pages . Justification of Government Policy The reason for the government’ decision of expansionary fiscal policy to stimulate economic growth is evident with an understanding of Keynesian economic theory and the Keynesian Transmission Effect. This is a theory of macroeconomics, developed by John Maynard Keynes , based on the principle of aggregate demand being the major determinant of economic growth. 1) Equilibrium level of National Income: Keynes’ theory

Democratizing the Globe: The Global Village

2196 words - 9 pages . Justification of trade barriers such as dumping duties need to be assessed by neutral bodies in order to ensure prevention of ridiculous allegations by lobbyist-prone democracies. Such an establishment will also be helpful in offsetting the drawbacks of the retaliatory provision by WTO, thus, ensuring that naive democracies of the world do not eventually end up at a low level equilibrium. The above mentioned points may not be enough to encompass

Similar Essays

Audi Essay

3238 words - 13 pages development of the concept of foundationalism in his epistemology according to which he can defend a view of “modest-foundationalim”. As it is stated in the last chapter, modest foundationlaism is a form of foundationalism which is compatible with the method of reflective equilibrium. Also, the kind of justification which acquired by intuition, in the modest-foundationalism, can be prima facie or initial and defeasible, and at the same time intuitively

Defining And Implementing Reflective Practice Essay

2233 words - 9 pages as teacher, reviews the entire course as it pertains towards his personal pedagogy and asks himself four questions, “What went well about his teaching, what went bad about his teaching, and what was learned, and what can be adjusted.” The Adopted Reflective Practice Technique, its justification, and its execution into the Writer’s own Reflective Practice The intended focus of all education must be directed towards the development of the

"For Love Of Aviation" Close Reading Of Yeats’s Poem, “An Irish Airman Foresees His Death"

1035 words - 4 pages Untitled Allison Arcos Eng 205 Higgins February 13, 2010 For Love of Aviation "An Irish Airman Foresees His Death" is a poem by Yeats that occurs during the First World War. This poem was written in memory of Robert Gregory, the son of Yeats's patron, Lady Gregory. Robert Gregory was a member of the British Royal Flying Corps. He was killed in 1918 in battle. The title of this poem informs the reader of the reflective

Game Theory As It Relates To Abortion In Canada

2075 words - 8 pages a structurally induced equilibrium. A structurally induced equilibrium is a forced outcome obtained by directing options into a binary choice (Flanagan 130) The parliamentary procedure forced the resolute pro-lifer’s to choose between the status quo and the gestational resolution in the final vote, when they clearly preferred a different option: amendments two and/or three. It was during the final vote that the ninety-six pro-lifers did