Justification For Higher Education Essay

1542 words - 6 pages

Justification For Higher Education
After analyzing William A. Henry III s In Defense of Elitism and Caroline Bird s
College is a Waste of Time and Money , it is clear that Henry s argument concerning the
purpose of an education is more rational than Bird s due to the fact that Henry supports his claims
with credible statistics, logical insight, and uses current real world scenarios. Bird, on the
contrary, bases her argument solely on manipulated statistics, overly dramatic claims, and
ridiculously out-of-this-world scenarios.
While there are various viewpoints and perspectives on the subject of higher education,
Henry for one, has landed the conclusion that in America higher education for the masses has not
only been extremely costly economically, but it has also greatly lowered the educational standards
and therefore defeated the purpose of higher education itself.
Henry s primary grievance against higher education for the masses is that the influx of
mediocrities relentlessly lowers the general standards at colleges to levels the weak ones can
meet (335). Quite simply, higher education is by no means any higher if the standards keep
lowering just so some students can barely meet the minimum standards. For example, although I
am a full supporter of the bell curve in college, it is certain that this recent innovation has had its
share in lowering the university s educational standards. This practice of calculating the students
average score on an exam and then re-scaling grades to help those who didn t fare as well is a
clear example of bringing the standard of college down to everyone s level (336). I can certainly
attest to this claim because I was recently directly affected by the bell curve. In the first quarter of
my freshman year, I received a score of 44 out of a possible 100 points on my Physics 7A final
exam. According to the general 10% increment grading scale, this would mean that I earned an F
on the exam. However, thanks to the mediocrities earning even lower scores than myself and
the establishment of the bell curve, I fared quite nicely and escaped with a B- grade. Although this
is definitely good news for me, Henry s claim that the mediocrities tend to lower the educational
standard seems to prevail.
The influx of mediocrities flooding college campuses has also lowered the credibility and
status of a college degree. Henry acknowledges this and states that the trend in recent years has
been eliminating layers of middle management"much of it drawn from the ranks of those lured
to college a generation or two ago by the idea that a degree would transform them from the
mediocre to magisterial (334). Of course, this is no longer the case. Higher education does not
necessarily lead to higher income or status. For example, the median income for a stockbroker
who has a college degree is approximately $50,000 a year .A truck driver earns the same income
and potentially even more depending on the amount...

Find Another Essay On justification for higher education

Education Is a Necessity: Poor Students Deserve Equal Opportunity for Higher Education

1266 words - 5 pages $4000 (19). Since property tax is based on the value of homes, it is clear that the wealthy homeowners are able to contribute a larger tax base in proportion to its student population. However, for urban communities which mostly consist of poor families, the meager values of their home do not provide enough money to adequately pay for their children's education. To accumulate more money for schools, poor communities "tax themselves at higher

"Using Assessment in Higher Education to Improve Success for Minority Students"

1811 words - 7 pages assessment with feedback (Sherman, Giles & Greene, 1994).Since 1985, a political trail has been laid across the country that has made assessment a permanent part of higher education. A growing number of states, either through direct legislation or through actions of statewide governing or coordinating boards, have officially addressed the critical need for drastic changes in higher education, calling on colleges and universities to improve

Five reasons for pursuing higher education and how philosophy fits (or doesn't) into those reasons

723 words - 3 pages There are many reasons or purposes behind pursuing higher education, but these may change depending on each individual student. However many distinct reasons there may be, the majority of them can be grouped into five broad categories. The first of these categories relates to money, the second is the transmission of culture and history, the third has to do with esteem or social class, fourth comes education for the benefit of democracy, and last


640 words - 3 pages student noted for truancy got a “B” in a course, started going to class, a higher grade would be ensured because he is listening to lectures. Therefore, higher learning and understanding that would be achieved, would benefit not only the student and AUN as a whole, but encourage the parents as well. Being present in class doesn’t involve only listening to lectures but participating also. Asking and answering questions and student grouping for

Moral Luck

1124 words - 5 pages particular philosophy but against a common-sense view that morality is both immune from luck and a supreme value. Claim (1), that “there is one basic form of value, moral value, which is immune to luck”, implies that morality is not just “one kind of value among others” (Williams, 116), but rather that moral values possess “some… supreme, kind of dignity or importance” (116). Williams’ justification for this belief is that individuals require

European Justification of Colonization of Asia and Africa

802 words - 3 pages The principle justification offered by the Europeans for their colonization of Asia & Africa was the moral and technological superiority of the western world. As the Europeans saw it, the spread of the European way of life would substantially increase living standards for the colonized. While economic reasons were obviously the primary impetus for colonial expansion, the Europeans believed that they were not only improving the natives

Black Colleges and Universities

4360 words - 17 pages for their students. These academic institutions often waited for several years to offer college-level courses, in an attempt to allow students time to prepare for advanced studies. Regardless of delay, the objectives of these early schools reflected the ideals of classical liberal education that dominated American higher education in general in that period. Emphasis was placed upon ancient languages, natural sciences, and humanities. Blacks were

Theory Of Knowledge And Its Justification

1586 words - 6 pages themselves. Pure mathematics or formal mathematics does not seek for knowledge from the outside world. It is consistent within itself and within its axioms. The justificaton follows deduction. The axioms must be consistent with the other axioms. Deduction and logic have a higher value of justification than perception and memory. Without memory we will not remember the knowledge that we have already acquired. We have justified are previous true

Challenges Facing Adult College Students

1099 words - 4 pages were once available to high school graduates. When adults consider a post secondary higher education, they have the choices of reading lectures and listening to the lectures of experts in their fields of study. The United States is no longer just a mechanized based society; it is now a nation that has a market based on knowledge, and a college education is the key to this, that’s why its imperative for adults to be able to manage their education

Education in Sport

965 words - 4 pages sport, one substantive, the other organizational. First, although sport is a global concept, organised sport in educational settings is more evident in some countries than in others. For example, in Germany and some Scandinavian countries organised inter-scholastic athletes is almost non-existent. Furthermore, the issue of sport in higher education sis primarily applicable to the United States where the educational value of

Justification of a Plan to Assasinate John Howard.

581 words - 2 pages Justification Of A Plan To Assassinate John HowardFirst of all, I don't actually condone the killing of anyone, be it murderer, rapist, or terrorist. But for this English assignment I thought it would be interesting to try an justify the assassination of out Prime Minister, John Howard. I chose the PM as my target because of basically everything that he does, and partly because of his bushy eyebrows. I plain and simple just don't agree with the

Similar Essays

The Need For Higher Education In Brazil

2333 words - 9 pages Subject Line: The Need for Higher Education in Brazil This memo is divided into four sections. With the first three sections being informative regarding the current economic and educational landscape in Brazil and the opportunities for market penetration. The final section is unfortunately constrained given that Laureate is a private company, but we have included a cost analysis created by our analysts. Section I: Introduction Rough

A High Salary For Higher Education

1260 words - 5 pages A high salary for a high education America has become an economy where education is the key to success. In the economy where we live today, it is becoming harder to rub to nickels together. The job market is looking for qualified people to hire that can set them apart from the economic setbacks of today’s time. They want the best of the best, the cream of the crop, the elite. In order to raise the bar and set one’s self higher than the

Why Pay More For Higher Education

915 words - 4 pages In the article "Why Pay More for Higher Education", the author questions about the amount of local university fees being subsidized by the Singapore Government. Her stand is based on a couple of premises. She argues that an undergraduate should "pay for what they get" and by using comparisons with the systems with other countries, tries to convince the reader that her stand is right. However, her argument is flawed and the loopholes shall be

The Proper Use Of Technology For Higher Education Today, The

1519 words - 6 pages The Proper Use of Technology for Higher Education Today, the advancements and the spread of media and information technologies are bringing college students closer to new realities in contemporary society. Technology has become a crucial component in curricula throughout the nation. Every college in the U.S. is spending million of dollars to provide students with the best and the latest technological advancements. What are the best uses of