This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Justification Of Death Through Utilitarian And Aristotelian Means

1041 words - 5 pages

Justification of Death through Utilitarian and Aristotelian Means
Alexandra Guinan
PHI 1103: Critical Thinking
14 April 2014

Justification of Death through Utilitarian and Aristotelian Means
The justification of death in a Utilitarian or Aristotelian scenario rely on omissions from the norm or however seems fit the individual. the gray space between the rules of either theory allows for interpretations (misguided or educated guesses) and keeping facts only between the parties involved. Although Utilitarianism is a way to control the masses and allow for best possible performance out of the people following it, Aristotle’s Virtue Theory allows for the emotional understanding of a situation, as well as an individualized decision per scenario, without disrupting the norm.
Utilitarianism cares more for the whole of society than the individuals that make it. This theory breeds the idea that death can be helpful for the whole. It could be in the forms of executions, murder, suicide, assisted suicide, etc. Peter Singer quotes in his article “Decisions about Death” John Stuart Mill’s bridge example: if you see someone crossing an unsafe bridge, you may stop them and warn them. If they continue anyway, you must step aside and let them cross.” The idea that people have free will, and use it to make decisions about themselves in their own best interest can go on to create a slippery-slope mentality - Because we executed one murderer, we can execute every murderer, no matter their reasoning!
Singer’s article focuses on classic hedonistic utilitarianism, and questions why patients are not given the option for assisted suicide in some states and countries. His question is a double edged sword for the philosophy; ending the ability to let an individual think freely is irrational, yet taking away someone’s autonomy is just as bad.
The struggle of doing what one ought to do, while strengthening the utility of the action, with respect to the law and strengthening the law’s utility comes with a price. The balance between law (“rule”) and actions (“act”) means one’s actions will sway more towards act-utility or rule-utility depending on which one gives more utility overall. The flaw of utilitarianism is now present: are people able to trust the utilitarianism theory when its justifications for actions is only because the action brought greater utility? In the cases of murder and suicide, a dead end is reached. Utilitarianism seems to only work at its best when in a situation of possession or labor.
The Aristotelian theory seems to base itself less off how the masses are doing things, and more off each individual’s case. “The basis of Aristotle’s theory of justice is that justice requires restoration of the fair balance of goods when an individual wrongfully takes what belongs to another. The practice of following societal laws is one of the most prevalent aspects of Aristotelian justice.” So in the case of medical malpractice, or unwanted assisted suicide,...

Find Another Essay On Justification of Death through Utilitarian and Aristotelian Means

Elements of Aristotelian Tragedy Depicted in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

1811 words - 7 pages ” because “it is too perfect and too passionate for their world” (79). He is saying that Romeo and Juliet’s love is too big for anyone in the play to handle. That is why Juliet is blinded by her love, and is changed by it, because she simply cannot handle the thought of being without Romeo. Thus, Juliet’s blindness of love exemplified through the many ways in Romeo and Juliet, results in her death. Romeo’s tragic flaw, impetuousness, is what leads

The Platonic and Aristotelian Conception of the Soul

2456 words - 10 pages offers new insights into the attributes and properties of the soul. The argument of opposites tells us that everything comes from its opposite (e.g. hot from cold, tall from short), that death is the opposite of life and that death comes from life and life from death (Phaedo, 70b-72d). This belief that nothing can come from nothing is similar to the Permenidean philosophy of coming to be, that 'what is' cannot come out of 'what is not'. This

The utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill

2070 words - 8 pages happiness is intended pleasures and the absence of pain, by unhappiness, pain and the privation of pleasure. All desirable things (which are numerous in the utilitarian as in any other scheme) are desirable either for the pleasure inherent in themselves, or as means to the promotion of pleasure and the prevention of pain'(Shimomisse, 1999, online: www.csudh.edu/phenom_studies/ethics/lect_3.htm).Mill expanded on Bentham's account of what

Love through life and death

2260 words - 9 pages For Time Magazine, by Stephen Lowe You’ve probably heard of the Indian vs. emigrants shootings, the drowning of the Applegate family, and starvation on the Oregon Trail, but do you honestly know to what extent how hard the journey was for the emigrants to make this 2,000 mile journey (McGill; Wagner, 10-15, 109-110; Life and Death on the Oregon Trail). The emigrants had to go through endless hardship, varying from walking the entire journey

Representation of Death through Texts

1841 words - 8 pages A universal fascination with death is not something newly discovered; in fact there is scarcely any other matter upon which our thoughts and feelings have changed so little over time . As humans we have the unique ability to be aware of our own mortality. This awareness means a preoccupation with death is never far from our minds, it only takes the opening of a newspaper to reveal how obsessed with death we are. However, whilst being an

Theory Of Knowledge And Its Justification

1586 words - 6 pages commonality, knowledge, and the justification of our own beliefs that hold to be true.Olen considered the levels of certainty, and the levels of justification. Can we prove something to be truer than the other? He explained the ¡®justification¡¯ of thoughts through ¡®Justification Chains¡¯ and ¡®Webs of Belief.¡¯ However, there were some inconsistencies in a ¡®justification chain

Leadership and Ethics Course, Through Military Discussing Ethical Decisions as They Relate To Utilitarian Teleologist, Kantian Deontologist and Decision Making,

3080 words - 12 pages protection. Additionally the Kosovo Liberation army is pressuring a male interpreter for information regarding the police. The threats have been entirely directed at the interpreters and not towards the other locally employed staff.AimThe aim of this essay is to discuss the morally right thing to do from the aspect of a utilitarian teleologist, Kantian deontologist and the reasoning behind their decision whether or not to obey the order or to

Death as Analyzed through Socrates and Hamlet

2343 words - 9 pages “Death, the one appointment we all must keep, and for which no time is set” (Charlie Chan). Although many believe it to be ominous, death, signifies an end to this earthly and material life; the life of which we are sure of. Plato’s Phaedo and Shakespeare’s play Hamlet offer different perspectives on the life we are unsure of, namely death or the afterlife. Through the characters of Socrates and Hamlet, readers are offered two contrasting

Transhumanism: Learning of Death through Videogames

2158 words - 9 pages an unexpected method of learning about death in a transhumanist setting, and that is through video games (vg). The creatively unbound nature of the content and player choices of vg can closely simulate not only real life, but also transhumanism settings and worlds difficult to experience otherwise. One of those experiences would include death in a transhumanist world. Despite being commonly considered as hobbies, vg are actually a viable and

The Iliad: Homer's Views of Life and Death through Achilles and Hector

1071 words - 4 pages The Iliad: Homer's Views of Life and Death through Achilles and HectorThe Iliad takes place in 1200 B.C. on the North West coast of present day Turkey. Homer of Greece put the epic on paper for the first time in the ninth century. From that moment on the Iliad and Achilles would be known around the ancient and present day world as the epic of the warrior. People referred to Achilles for centuries as a great hero, who lived for the warrior code

Immanuel Kant's Ethics Of Pure Duty and John Stuart Mill's Utilitarian Ethics Of Justice

2730 words - 11 pages welfare with their utility. It would then be possible, for instance, to justify sacrificing one individual for the benefits of others if the utilitarian calculations promise to be more beneficial. Doing so would be the worst example of treating someone utterly as a means and not as an end in themselves. Another way to consider his objection is to note that utilitarian theories are motivated by the subjective inclination in humans for pleasure and

Similar Essays

Justification Of Death In Hamlet Essay

2769 words - 11 pages Justification of Death in Hamlet         Beginning with the Greeks, tragedy has been an essential form of entertainment. Although it has changed slightly over time due to different religious and social values, it is still written and performed to this day. Perhaps the most well known tragedy of all time is Shakespeare's Hamlet. Hamlet is perhaps the epitome of all tragedy. Not only does the tragic hero Hamlet meet his demise, but all

Justification Of Torture As A Means To Save Lives

1690 words - 7 pages brutal but necessary tool.The first thing that we must ask ourselves to specify is, What is Torture?According to, the International Statuette, Torture is any kind of use of force, mental or physical used on a human being to gain third party information or self-confession. No country prefers to use it but is forced to do in order to safeguard the lives of its citizens and smoothen justice. Most criminal suspects go through some level of

The Justification Of Andy Lopez's Death

1500 words - 6 pages The Justification of Andy Lopez’s Tragic Death On October 22, 2013, Andy Lopez, a young teenager at the age of thirteen years old, was shot and killed by a Sonoma County deputy named Erik Gelhaus. The community has taken sides either criticizing the officers actions, or supporting them. Whether the arguments are based on race or police abuse of power, we can clearly see step by step why officer Gelhaus did what he did from the first

Serving Students Through Education What It Means To The Underdogs And The Future Of America

1128 words - 5 pages demonstrates this through the ABCD model. In simplistic terms, the old saying is that if you give a man a fish, you feed him for a day; if you teach him how to fish, you feed him for a life time. This is not the most beneficial means of servicing change. “Local leadership is judged on how many resources are attracted to the community, not on how self-reliant the community has become” (Mathie & Cunningham, 2003). Once the fisherman becomes skilled