This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Juvenile Case Essay

1274 words - 6 pages

The Tragic Case of Larry and Brandon
The tragic case of Larry and Brandon is a compelling story. It is a reality that stunned the city of Oxnard California when a 14-year-old boy named Brandon McInerney fatally shot a fellow classmate, Larry King, twice in the back of the head. The incident occurred in a computer lab where Brandon ran off after committing the crime. As a result of his actions Brandon McInerney was tried as an adult and was sentenced to 21 years in prison with no chance of parole. He will be released at the age of 39. Now the underlying question is was Brandon’s sentence a just resolution or should he have received more or less years in prison. The truth is that I believe Brandon’s verdict was a fair and just punishment, however I don’t believe that he should have been tried as an adult. There’s no question about it what Brandon did was horrible. He killed a kid in cold blood and ran off after doing it. He knows what he did and now he has to suffer the consequences. But Brandon was only 14 years old when this had taken place.
To start off Brandon was in many ways provoked by Larry. Attorneys for Brandon McInerney argue that their client, who was 14 when he gunned down Larry King in an Oxnard junior high school computer lab, was so humiliated by King's flirtation that it provoked him to kill his classmate. Larry approached Brandon numerous times upsetting him in different ways. There are even rumors about King blowing kisses at McInerney and asking him to be his valentine. On the day before the shooting King loudly said “Love you, baby!” to McInerney as they passed in a corridor. King’s sexual advances fueled his anger towards Larry. Brandon saw that Larry was allowed to come to school wearing girls clothing and makeup. He saw that the situation was acceptable in school and he saw that some teachers reinforced this behavior. This puts McInerney in a tough position and it puts him to an emotional breaking point. He saw that the only way out of this situation was to end King’s life right than and there. Basically King shouldn’t have made Brandon the focus of unwanted attention when he wasn’t gay.
Along with King’s provocation Brandon grew up in a very distressing environment. Defense attorney Scott Wippert says, “Brandon is a good kid that grew up in a stressful environment. “Brandon was raised in a house full of drugs and violence. Both of his parents were addicts and both had been incarcerated for crimes they had previously committed. Brandon’s father, Billy McInerney, would constantly shift from smoking crystal meth in one instance to beating his boys in the next. If his kids misbehaved he would beat them and if he had a bad day he would use his kids as punching bags. James Bing, Brandon’s half brother, says that he would physically abuse us in any possible way that you could think of. “He hit us, kicked us, slapped us, threw us around,” said James Bing. “He punched us in the face, and threw us into walls." Brandon even...

Find Another Essay On Juvenile case

Juvenile Courts Essay

2445 words - 10 pages balance of rights. Juvenile’s rights in the court setting were limited and significantly handicapped compared to adults. Feld believes that juveniles should have access to the same rights in order for proper justice to be served. In addition, the lack of adherence to civil rights created civil disabilities for juveniles. Some of these issues were addressed in the case In re Gaul. In this case, Gerald Gault challenged the juvenile code of

juvenile delinquency Essay

2297 words - 10 pages system to deal with criminal behavior (Esbensen et al., 2011; Forgays 2008; Krebs et al., 2010; Kurtz et al., 2006; Lipsey, 2009; Tarolla et al., 2002). Programs such as Boot Camps, Wilderness programs, G.R.E.A.T programs, Juvenile Intake and Assessment Case Management, Juvenile Breaking the Cycle, Probation and Teen Court are set in place to reduce juvenile involvement in the juvenile justice system by providing substitutes to incarceration

Juvenile Crime

931 words - 4 pages robbery).      Since      1995 the overall crime rate for people under 17 has dropped by 39 percent. In 1999, there were 7,928 arrests for every 100,000 youths in the United States. The rate of juvenile crimes involving a firearm is higher on school days than non-school days. Statistics on Juvenile Court Case Flow Of every 1,000 petitioned adjudicated delinquency cases handled in 1997, 177 resulted

Juvenile Courts

1931 words - 8 pages differs from that of the adult court in that it is less formal. When juveniles are involved in criminal activities, they are detained but not arrested as in the case of adults. The records of the juvenile are maintained in a private manner and cannot be accessed by any person. The protection is meant to ensure that the mistake done by the juvenile doesn’t follow him for the rest of his life. Incase the juvenile has satisfied the set standards

Juvenile Crimes

1414 words - 6 pages up back in detention or prison after release, but they also end up brutalized by the guards or other inmates while serving that time. When a juvenile enters the juvenile justice center special rules govern their case. Offenders enter them as a juvenile if they have not reached 18 years of age, but it is also based on the crime that was committed. When a minor get in trouble with the juvenile justice system parents have to pay the state the

Juvenile Delinqunecy

939 words - 4 pages case, juvenile delinquency. Children and teenagers are young which means they are easily influenced by what happens around them. If a minor grows up in an environment that offers negative impacts they would most likely grow up behaving the same way because that was how life was for them. There are hundreds of risk factors that if presented to a minor they would be at risk for juvenile delinquency but in this case the leading causes of youth

Juvenile justice

1927 words - 8 pages those who are at risk. According to a member of the Juvenile Crime panel focusing on prevention, treatment, and control, many of the contacts are not documented, and many of those documented never result in a court case. Cases that do reach the juvenile courts represent only a fraction of the contacts that juveniles have with the police (McCord 2000). Therefore, most of the interactions of police with juveniles are below the surface and relatively

Juvenile Probation

728 words - 3 pages Juvenile Probation: Historical Tensions and Contemporary Convergences. Social Work, 56(4), 355-365. Urban, L. (2008). Issues in Juvenile Program Implementation: A Case Study. American Journal Of Criminal Justice, 33(1), 99-112. doi:10.1007/s12103-007-9023-x Whitehead, J. T., & Lab, S. P. (2013). Juvenile justice: An introduction (7th ed.). Waltham, MA: Anderson Publishing.

Juvenile Delinquency

1172 words - 5 pages experienced a traumatic event in childhood, mostly related to the consumption of alcohol by a relative. Each traumatic event increased 35 percent to 144 the risk of committing a criminal act. Among girls the risk of committing violence increases between 1.7 and 5 times compared to those who had a happy childhood, regardless of how off the event. In the case of boys the risk is 77 times larger. Discussion In common parlance, there is an

Juvenile Offenders

1777 words - 7 pages criminal court. Juveniles may become "legal adults" through judicial waiver, prosecutorial discretion, or statutory exclusion. A judicial waiver involves the juvenile court waiving jurisdiction over a case and sending it to criminal court for prosecution. In all but three states, juvenile court judges have been entrusted with the power to waive juveniles to criminal court. Prosecutorial discretion (also known as concurrent jurisdiction

Juvenile Recidivism

3227 words - 13 pages relatively as recidivism and juvenile criminal activity increases, our nation’s standard of living will consequently lower. For those who are simply interested in the costs, it may be fairly surprising. It is a common and misconceived ideal that incarceration is a cheap and easy way to contain criminals, in this case juveniles. However, due to the fact that the incarceration itself has not in any way hindered criminal activity rates or decreased

Similar Essays

The Juvenile Death Penalty: A Case For It

2151 words - 9 pages that a juvenile offender never sees life outside of the prison walls ever again, which would be a true life sentence would be the juvenile death penalty. Rehabilitation is a great aspect of the juvenile justice system, however it does not apply to all cases. Some cases, like in the Austin Sigg case, the offender has committed a crime so terrible that they simply cannot be rehabilitated from it. When the offender reaches the point where they feel no

Can Age Be A Good Excuse In A Case Of Juvenile Delinquency?

1015 words - 5 pages rapes and one-half all sexual child molestation can be accounted for by juveniles.” (1999) But what juvenile delinquents get for the punishment is less than a year in juvenile detention. There was one suicide case in northern California. According to aljazeera.com, 15-year-old girl was sexually assaulted and photographs of the assault were circulated to her classmates. The girl couldn’t hold humiliation and ended committing suicide. The court

Juvenile Delinquency Case Studies In Justice System

1485 words - 6 pages The continued rise in juvenile crimes is becoming a threat to society as years go by. Crimes committed by children below age 15, have been reported as early as the 19th century when they faced about the same punishment as adult criminals: public shaming, incarceration, even execution by hanging. At least 10 juveniles who were 14 at the time of their offense were executed during the 1800抯 including two 10 years old, according to the

Juvenile Rights Essay

1251 words - 5 pages in order to keep the offender detained.Once a juvenile offender is "detained" he or she must be read their Miranda rights, just as police are required to do when they arrest an adult. In 1967, the U.S. Supreme Court heard the case of In re Gault; this case was based on a fifteen year old boy, named Gerald Gault, who was taken into custody for making a prank phone call to his neighbor. At the time of the crime, Gault was on juvenile probation for