Juvenile Offenders Committing Felonies Essay

1319 words - 5 pages

At age 17, a juvenile Simmons planned and committed murder. He was convicted of the crime, which was undoubtedly premeditated. Simmons told his friends that he was planning to murder someone and would be able to get away with it because they were minors. The premeditated nature and heinousness of the crime led the jury to recommend a sentence of death. On appeal to the Missouri Supreme court, Simmons counsel argued that in light of Atkins v Virginia, juveniles under the age of eighteen could not be sentenced to death. The Supreme Court granted certiorari as the state court's decision directly went against the decision of Stafford v Kentucky.In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court affirmed Missouri's state court decision that under the Eight Amendment, a juvenile could not be sentenced to death because that would constitute cruel and unusual punishment. Notably, Justice Kennedy changed his position; now believing that minors cannot be sentenced to death.Justice Kennedy, writing for the majority, alleged that since Stafford v Kentucky, a national consensus had emerged because the majority of states now bar executions of those under eighteen. Furthermore, no state since the Stafford case had lowered the age below eighteen. Also, because of the imposition of the death penalty has become so infrequent, it is now considered both cruel and unusual.The majority also argues that only the worst offenders can be ever subjected to death. The lack of responsibility, maturity and development make it impossible for juveniles to be the worst offenders. Second, outside influences affect adolescents more than adults and therefore cannot have the same culpability as adults.The majority also stresses that amici briefs from the international community prohibiting the execution of juveniles prove the world's attitude against these practices. Being the only country still allowing these executions is detrimental to our international stature. Last, because of our close ties to the United Kingdom we must look at their laws and with abolishing the juvenile death penalty long ago, we can look at their precedent for our lawsThe biggest problem in cases being decided so randomly is the chance that controversial cases such as the Juvenile death penalty can change in the future. If tomorrow, two of the more liberal judges die and President Bush gets two new appointments to the Supreme Court, the constitutionality can once again shift. Therefore supposedly the "national consensus" can shift in one day. The Supreme Court legislating from the bench is now running the risk that their decisions on controversial opinions may be overturned as a direct result of the personal attitudes of those sitting on the bench. If this was to happen, the credibility of the most distinguished and honored court in the land will be forever lapsed both at home and in the international community.Thomas Graunger, in 1642 became the first juvenile known to be executed in America. Since that execution, 361...

Find Another Essay On Juvenile offenders committing felonies

Justice has to be made Treat Juvenile Equal as Adults

1085 words - 5 pages Prop 21, are generally no longer eligible for juvenile court and prosecutors are allowed to directly file charges against juvenile offenders in adult court...” (California Proposition 21). Under many circumstances juvenile at a very young age are committing certain types of crimes, and should be trial as an adult just because their teenagers committing crimes does not mean they did not know what they did. Many young teen are being let away for

Juvenile Crime Essay

2032 words - 8 pages largely outside of the law and court systems. It requires strengthening the basic institutions "" the family, education, religious institutions and community groups ("Juvenile Crime" 1).From the law enforcement standpoint, there are two groups of juveniles: The larger group who have only one or two brushes with the law and straighten up as they mature, and the smaller group who are the hardened chronic offenders, committing the majority of all violent

Should Juveniles be tried as Adults?

2023 words - 9 pages have higher recidivism rates after release than those tried in juvenile court (Youth Campaign).” In the documentary, “Juvies,” the people in charge explained how there is no rehabilitation in jail, and the mentality of many offenders is “If I hadn’t done this, I wouldn’t have gotten caught”. Some of the youth offenders understood that the education received in prison wouldn’t be enough to even get them an entry level job. One of the youth

Juvenile to Adulthood

2332 words - 10 pages four categories of offense for which juveniles of a certain age may be transferred: (a) any crime, (b) capital crimes and murder, (c) certain violent felonies, and (d) certain crimes committed by juvenile with prior records” (Redding, 1999). In this paper we will discuss those juveniles that fall into category B and C and why they should be transferred to adult courts. Category A and D could be non-violent crimes and no juvenile should be sent to

Controversial Issues Regarding Juvenile Death Penalty

2073 words - 8 pages One of the most controversial issues in the rights of juveniles today is addressed in the question, Should the death penalty be applied to juveniles? For nearly a century the juvenile courts have existed to shield the majority of juvenile offenders from the full weight of criminal law and to protect their entitled special rights and immunities. In the case of kent vs. United states in 1996, Justice Fortas stated some of these special rights

Juvenile Justice Systems

1521 words - 7 pages Policy, 19(2), 147-175. Archwamety , T., & Katsiyannis, A. (2000). Academic remediation, parole violations, and recidivism rates among delinquent youths . Remedial and Special Education , 21(3), 161-170. Steinberg, L. (2001). Should juvenile offenders be tried as adults?. USA Today, 129(2668), 34. Crawford, A., & Newburn, T. (2002). Recent developments in restorative justice for young people in england and wales. The Centre for Crime and Justice

America's Juvenile Justice System

3719 words - 15 pages , most of them after careers of crime, had their ?just deserts? coming based on the objective qualities of the crime, not the criminal. This type of approach, they felt, also promoted consistency in waiving juveniles. In Humes, the California waiver law is a strict one. If a juvenile over sixteen committing certain felonies does not meet five broad fitness criteria defined by statute, he must be waived. In the case of John Sloan before Judge Dorn

A Bad Decision

843 words - 4 pages Young teenagers don’t realize the trouble they can get into when they don’t consider their behaviors. Juvenile offenders do not measure the consequences of committing a crime and how a bad decision will dramatically change their lives, as well. I think juvenile offenders should not be sentence nor tried as adults because of their young age and their lack of maturity. One reason, why I think juvenile offenders should not be tried as an adult is

Juvenile Offenders

1777 words - 7 pages increased availability of drugs and alcohol, and the growing incidence of child abuse and child neglect. All these conditions tend to increase the probability of a child committing a criminal act, although a direct causal relationship has not yet been established Most theories of juvenile delinquency have focused on children from disadvantaged families, ignoring the fact that children from affluent homes also commit crimes. The latter may commit

Transfer to Adult Criminal Court

1025 words - 5 pages There are times where a juvenile may be eligible for transfer to adult criminal court. There are certain criteria that must be met for this to happen, and there is a strong belief that juveniles who commit serious offenses would be more appropriately dealt with by criminal (or adult) courts (Elrod & Ryder, 2011). Juveniles are capable of committing the same serious offenses that adults do. Therefore, with the requirements of a transfer being met

Juvenile Delinquency: Is there a solution?

1860 words - 8 pages trained the juvenile offenders. For example, they teach the youth to focus on education, and help the youth to avoid indolence by making them do military drills and physical exercise. The House of Refuge caused similar institutions to arise all over the United States. Due to the fact, juvenile delinquents differed from adult delinquents separate courts had to be established. The first juvenile court was established in Chicago, Illinois towards

Similar Essays

Juveniles Tried As Adults Essay

575 words - 2 pages increasing. For example, around 1900, the Juvenile Court was to provide help and treatment for juveniles who were running away, truant, or petty theft. By the 1950?s many teens were stealing hubcaps, brawling, and drinking. By 1974, nearly half of all serious crime in America was committed by offenders under 18. By 1984, juveniles were committing 1,130 acts of murder, and accounting for 592,372 arrests for serious felonies such as rape, robbery

Juvelines Tried As Adults In Court

819 words - 3 pages minors. Juvenile offenders are not only a threat to a town doing ?small crimes? or misdemeanors but are committing more serious crimes as time goes by and yet still no efforts has been made to keep criminals where they belong. In the Kent Vs United States Trial a young offender 16years of age was charged with rape and because juveniles do not get the same rights as adults Kent?s attorney was not allowed to review any files that where obtained

Teen Vs. Adult Essay

1162 words - 5 pages under the age of 18. Many of the adjudicated juvenile sex offenders reported committing their first offense between the ages of 12 and 15.”(Crump) There are several classification groups for juvenile sex offenders ranging from fondling to serious. According to the ¬ Encyclopedia of Juvenile Justice: Naive experimenters are usually between the ages of 11 and 14. They use no force, have no history of any type of offense, and engage in

Juvenile Crime Essay

2537 words - 10 pages with an onslaught of children who were not simply wayward youths, but hardened repeat offenders. The 1980s witnessed an increasingly desperate outcry for courts to take more extreme measures to contain juvenile crime, which is assuming ever more serious forms. It is almost a daily occurrence to turn on the nightly news and hear stories of ever increasing youths committing crimes. Even more alarming are the ages of these offenders. In Lake