This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Juveniles Or Criminals Essay

1177 words - 5 pages

Prior to the establishment of the modern juvenile justice system, children could be made to stand trial in criminal court for crimes committed, and if found culpable, they could be sentenced as an adult would be sentenced for similar crimes, with sentences resulting in prison time or even death.
The juvenile justice system was developed in a large part due to the developing belief that youth offenders were incapable of criminal intent and should not be held to the same criminal standard adult offenders are. Therefore, it was considered appropriate to exempt juvenile offenders that were considered incapable of intent to commit a criminal act from prosecution and punishment.
“Parens patriae” ...view middle of the document...

Unfortunately, for various reasons the juvenile justice system has recently begun to regress to a system that goes against the entire core values that led to its creation. As a result of Kent v. United States 1966, In re Gault 1967 and In re Winship the juvenile justice system has regressed into a system that has began to resemble the adult criminal justice system with lawyers, prosecutors, and judges. The focus has once again shifted back to the way it was prior to juvenile justice reform. The system has trended to focusing on offenses, and not the offenders, to punishment, or retribution and not rehabilitation.

My question is? Did juvenile offenders suddenly develop the capability of having criminal intent, or develop higher moral and cognitive capacities at a younger age than previous generations. The capabilities which limited their ability to be held criminally responsible for the crimes that they committed before are now going to be considered sufficient enough for them to stand trial in an adult criminal court.

The erosion of the core values of the juvenile justice system, and new legislation has morphed the juvenile system into one that closely resembles its adult counterpart. In most cases the only differences between the adult criminal court and the juvenile justice system is the terminology used in the system. A push for “abolishing” the juvenile justice system has resulted from a perceived failure by the juvenile justice system in its rehabilitation efforts and in the perception that the juvenile justice system was too lenient in punishing serious criminal behavior by young people. As America gets tougher on what they perceive as “violent juveniles” the line that separates the juvenile court and the adult court is further blurred.

I demand that legislators and lawmakers develop some empirical evidence that abolishing the juvenile court would result in a better justice system. Do tougher policies on juvenile crimes actually harm or hurt the probability that a juvenile will desist from criminal activity and not fall into a life course of crime. The impact that abolishing the juvenile justice system would have on youth could possibly be negative with fewer chances for rehabilitation and exposure to older, wiser, more influential adult career criminals. Furthermore, would you send a juvenile to adult court in order to correct status offenses such as skipping school, unruly behavior, or curfew violations?

American society, has somewhere along the line,...

Find Another Essay On Juveniles or Criminals

Juvenile and Adult Courts: A Comparative Analysis

1833 words - 7 pages life was spared this still leaves a question whether juveniles' murders are criminals who deserve to die or whether or not they can be rehabilitate to learn to live a productive life. The issue is more conservational for executing juveniles then adults (Allard, Young. 2002).Despite the rights secured by the case Gerald Gaullt, juveniles can still de deprived of some freedom for actions that would be considered criminal if an adult. Some of these

Juvenile Criminals and their Mental Health

1519 words - 7 pages Mental health treatment among juvenile is a subject that has been ignored by society for far too long. It has always been one of those intricate issues that lead to the argument of whether juveniles should receive proper treatment or imprisoned like any other criminals, and often trialed as adults. Many times, young people are often deprived of proper help (Rosenberg) However, we often overlook the fact that while they are criminals, they are

Juveniles Treated Like Adults

1776 words - 7 pages criminals are out there. And juveniles take a large part of fearing the public. Some say there is a negative side to treating juveniles like adults. It is possible that young teens are not fully developed yet and do not know which road to take to lead them to their future. Maybe they give up and decide their future is worthless, or maybe they have a psychological issue. The minds of the young teens are questionable as to what thoughts are being

Juvenile Crime

543 words - 2 pages crimes by juveniles. Many of these juvenile criminals have been abused or neglected and they also grew up in a single-parent household. Research has found that 53% of these children are more likely to be arrested, and 38% more likely to commit a violent crime as an adult, then their counterparts who did not suffer such abuse. The symptoms of child abuse are "high levels of aggression and antisocial behavior" and these children are twice as likely

Does Juvenile Justice System Work?

605 words - 3 pages programs. The lack of funding for these programs has led to the factors that limit the effectiveness of The Juvenile Justice System. There are many differences between adult corrections and juvenile corrections. Juveniles are categorize from 18 years of age and down. In the U.S. some states cut off limit for being a juvenile could more or less. “States recognize that children who commit crimes are different from adults: as a class, they are less

The Death Penalty and Juveniles

796 words - 3 pages that administer the death penalty, 24 allow juveniles to be executed, or about 63%. That means nearly two out of three death penalty states allow juvenile execution. If the administration of the death penalty on juveniles is so inhumane, then why do the majority of states that administer the death penalty allow it?While the opposition says that juveniles do not possess the mental capacity to understand what they are doing when they commit a

juvenile violence

879 words - 4 pages Juveniles Tried As Adults 1 Juveniles Tried As Adults 2 Trying juvenile criminals as adults is unfair. Juvenile offenders are not as cognitively developed or mature as adults and, therefore, should not be held accountable for their crimes in the same way adults are. Many tough-on-crime advocates call for certain juvenile crimes to be automatically heard in adult criminal courts with convicted criminals subject to

Juvenile Crime

2032 words - 8 pages criminals into their lives, so by standing more juveniles on trial as adults, the juveniles will learn a valuable lesson (Emerson 11). In addition, society takes advantage of those minors who allegedly commit certain crimes. Juveniles that have been tried as minors and released without penalty or even with a small penalty become prime bait for gangs because the system has failed to teach a lesson to the minor (McPolin A8). Lastly, society often


939 words - 4 pages Every year, in the U.S alone, approximately over five hundred thousand violent crimes are committed. In 2008, seventy-three thousand of these violent crimes were committed by juveniles. When you hear about murderers, rapists, and other criminals, automatically, your mind set wants these criminals sentenced to prison for a very long time. There is no second guessing when it comes to these extreme criminals, they should be punished for the

Juveniles and Adult Time

2313 words - 10 pages For years now it has been a big controversial argument on whether or not juveniles should be treated like adults in the judicial process. Both sides have very strong arguments as to why it should or should not be legal. There are many pros and cons dealing with this topic. There have been many different cases that have occurred that has struck up debate on whether or not juveniles deserve the same treatment. This judicial system had not always

Juveniles Tried in Court

1628 words - 7 pages in some cases under certain circumstances (SENTENCING 1 of 2). The most dangerous thing about trying juveniles as adults is placing them in the same prisons and detention centers as adult criminals. Minors who are placed with adults are more likely to be raped or sexually assaulted in some way (Auriana Ojeda 136). Some individuals believe that a young person capable of committing a crime as harsh as murder like an adult, there should be no

Similar Essays

Treat Juveniles Differently Than Adult Criminals

1472 words - 6 pages Treat Juveniles Differently than Adult Criminals I do not think it is a good idea to lock juveniles up in prisons with adults. For a child to set down and plan a murder for instance, there would have to be some kind of deep emotional problem. On the other side of this, if the child knows right from wrong and he can sit down and plan a murder, then you could say if he is old enough to kill someone then he is old enough to die. The

Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults?

989 words - 4 pages offenders who commit an adult-like crime can face years and years of prison if the offender is considered an adjudicated delinquent. Doing this can make the situation of the Juvenile even worse other than helping him or her. According to Francine Keifer in “More States Correct the Mistake of Trying Juveniles as Adults,” “Treating juveniles as juveniles is better for young offenders and society. Young people are physically and emotionally

Persuasive Essay About Why The Juvenille Justice System Isn't Harsh Enough

1004 words - 4 pages manage the creation of opportunities for the child to have a family where he or she experienced love and development.The Juvenile Justice System was created with the goal of rehabilitating the offender. However, there is no 100% way to rehabilitate a juvenile. Juveniles are released to their parents with a bundle of paperwork. It is almost a headache to the police officer to even report the incidents. If the juvenile gives the officer an attitude

Juveniles Essay

1077 words - 4 pages Juveniles The Chambers Dictionary defines juvenile as "young; pertaining to or suited to youth or young people. Having or retaining characteristics of youth, childish." The Texas judicial system defines a juvenile as one between the ages of 10 and 16. Juvenile courts have been established to provide justice for anyone classified as a juvenile who commits a crime. Although some argue that juveniles are well served in these courts, it is