Kabuki, The Japanese Art Vs. Puccini´S Madame Butterfly.

2874 words - 11 pages

Lisa Silberhorn10/27/02Classical Asian TheatreDr. Debra MartinKabuki vs. Puccini'One fine day' in 1854 an ominous black ship sailed into Nagasaki harbor, prying open the wall that stood between the East and the West. On another 'fine day' in 1904 European audiences saw the premiere of what was to become one of the most beloved operas ever known, using a combination of music from both east and west. Puccini's Madama Butterfly has captivated opera lovers through its exotic sounding music. Said music, is actually a western interpretation of the music found within the treasured Japanese art of Kabuki. This is not so far fetched as one might think. Both cultures have a love of melodramatic musical dramas. Kabuki and Opera are each cultures form of drama, music, and dance combined. When looking at them 'under the microscope' they are not so different from each other. Perhaps the most difficult reconciliation between the two is their music, as both Western and Eastern Music can sound totally different from each other, yet when listening to the music of Madama Butterfly one can find a common ground between the two cultures.Before discussing the opera itself, one must first 'orient' themselves with the music of Kabuki. The orchestra that performs alongside Kabuki is called the Nagauta. It is said that, "The growth of nagauta is intimately connected with the evolution of the kabuki theatre in Tokyo." (Malm 205) The first recorded performance of Kabuki occurred in 15 96 when Okuni, a priestess performed a lively version of a Buddhist festival dance, accompanied by the drums and flute used in Noh theatre, as well as a small gong which she, herself, played. As Kabuki's popularity grew it became a form of entertainment and advertising used by brothels and geisha houses.Most Geishas and prostitutes were already proficient in the samisen genre of kouta or "short songs." These were lyrical yet sometimes erotic poems accompanied by the samisen, a double stringed instrument played similarly to a banjo. Most likely, the samisen was first used in a kabuki performance sometime before 1629, when women were banned from the stage, in order to incorporate kouta within a performance. As dances within kabuki were being extended, these "short songs" became insufficient. Thus, longer pieces were written and by 1740, the samisen had become one of the principle instruments of the nagauta. In addition to kouta, the nagauta began to incorporate several other genres of samisen music including joruri, which is where the role of sung narration or commentating began within kabuki. Thus, "the nagauta emerged from combining the lyricism of shorter songs with the sustaining power of longer, narrative music." (Willoughby, 165)Today the Nagauta consists of the samisen, the Noh flute, the bamboo flute (taken from folk traditions,) and various drums and other percussive instruments borrowed predominantly from Noh or religious rituals. During a performance the Nagauta can be classified into...

Find Another Essay On Kabuki, the Japanese Art vs. Puccini´s Madame Butterfly.

The Role of Art vs. the Role of Science

1609 words - 6 pages The Role of Art vs. the Role of Science “art upsets [and] science reassures.” - Georges Braque Before beginning, it is important to clarify that the quote is referring to shock as causing anger or upset. In using reassuring, Georges Braque is referring to comforting. That said, this statement by Braque is true to a point, because the statement also works in reverse. Throughout the history of man, art has been a method for

The Odyssey vs The movie "O Brother Where Art Thou"

757 words - 3 pages The Odyssey, is a legendary tale written by David Adams Leeming. This epic tells the story of a wise man named Odysseus who struggled to return back to his homeland, Ithaca, after the fall of Troy. In comparison to the text, the movie "O Brother Where Art Thou," has a similar plot and is based on The Odyssey. In the movie, Ulysses Everett McGill is the main character played by George Clooney. Everett and Odysseus both encounter different

tempnature Art vs. Nature in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1295 words - 5 pages Art vs. Nature in The Tempest    The debate between Art and Nature in The Tempest is very much based on the Renaissance debate, on whether “civilized man” or the "natural man" was superior. The advocates of  “civilized man” presenting the "natural man" as being savage, intemperate and brutal in contrast to the nobility, self-control and high-mindedness of the  “civilized man”. The advocates of "natural man" presenting him as what

Summary of the fine art of japanese taiko drumming and how it has influenced to western culture.

1059 words - 4 pages sought a new musical outlook in a place called America. The early 1950's America was a melting pot for new forms of music and a perfect inspiration for Taiko's rebirth. Taiko as an ensemble piece, as we know it today, is the direct result of one such dreamer. Daihachi Oguchi was a multi-percussionist who had embraced the western art of jazz. He was content in his profession as a jazz drummer when he came across some old Taiko sheet music. He was

Clash of the Titans: A History of Nationalism in the Southeast Asian Region, and how Nationalism has perpetuated the Sino-Japanese Disputes over the S

1958 words - 8 pages the Nagasaki conference, taking place in the 1920’s, two major obstacles to a united Asia were revealed: lack of political support, and the competing differences of Japan and China. The latter, being more concerning, could be equated to Japan’s concern with Korea’s involvement in the conference – where Korea was supported by China. Furthermore, there were disputed over Sino-Japanese treaties such as China’s condemnation of the Twenty-One Demands

American Art Of The 20's and 30's

642 words - 3 pages I made this essay using art biographies on WWW Good ReportTwentieth-century art is almost indefinable, and ironically we can consider that as its definition. This makes sense, as we live in a world that is in a constantly changing. Not only is science changing the outward forms of life, but we are beginning to discover the strange centrality of our subconscious desires and fears. All this is completely new and unsettling, and art naturally

Magical Realism in House of the Spirits vs. Realism in Madame Bovary

1264 words - 5 pages Through the application of Realism, Gustave Flaubert demonstrates Emma’s detachment of the death of the characters in Madame Bovary, which contrasts to Isabel Allende’s demonstration of Clara’s attachment to the death of the characters in The House of the Spirits by utilizing Magical Realism. In The House of the Spirits, the characters all share a spiritual bond, which leads to emotional and spiritual connections for Clara during the death of

Washington Irving´s Rip Van Winkle vs. The Revolutionary War

675 words - 3 pages They say “don’t judge a book by its cover.” This is implying that there is more to something than meets the eye. This is the same case with Washington Irving’s “Rip Van Winkle.” You have to read between the lines of the short story to understand the passion and meaning that Irving has so, intelligently, woven into his story. In the beginning of the story Irving talks of how Dame Van Winkle would basically nag her husband to death. He never

Women´s Role in Society in Antigone, Aeneid, and The Art of Courtly Love

1272 words - 5 pages , more roles within the church became available to women. Women were given opportunities to escape child bearing, acquire literacy and learning and play a more active religious role in society. From my point of view Catherine did not rebel against the laws of society. She just grabbed the opportunities that came her way and showed the world that women can also be good rulers. In The Art of Courtly Love written by Andreas Capellanus and in The Lais

Art Analysis of The Luncheon of the Boating Party vs A Sunday on La Grande Janette

878 words - 4 pages very pleasing to the eye. Renoir reflects the theme is this painting because the impressionist style was new to the art field, just as the advances from the industrial revolution were new to the people of the world.      A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte by Georges Seurat is a vibrant piece, that reflects his pointillism style. This painting displays elegant, emotionless people taking a leisurely walk on a nice Sunday

War vs. Art: The Significance of Fighting Before Fiddling in Creating the Peace

897 words - 4 pages In the poem "First fight. Then fiddle." Gwendolyn Brooks argues for the necessity of brutal war in order to create a space for the pursuit of beautiful art. She uses Petrarchan sonnet structure and a conflicting, controversial turn to keep reader's close attention, create lyrical quality and influence the reader through her message. It is a wonderful example of a sonnet that follows the traditional rules, while adding a bit of a modern twist to

Similar Essays

Onnagata: The Art Of Woman In Japanese Kabuki

3481 words - 14 pages Japan, is the ideal perfect woman who surpasses all women, but they are the contradictory, male representation of the male fantasy. The manner in which, the Onnagata, essentially is in Japanese society has created a new ideal of gender in Japan and a new form of repression. "Kabuki would have died had not increasingly believable, instead of merely pretty, female characters begun to appear in the mature male kabuki that emerged in the 1650s … an

How M. Butterfly Uses The Art Of Illusion To Foster Stereotypes Among Its Main Characters.

1394 words - 6 pages relationship with someone for twenty years and not have known that the object of his desires was, in fact, a man. In reality, he pretended not to know because he did not want to impinge upon his desire to have a Madame Butterfly of his very own. It has been suggested that Gallimard was indeed blinded by his Western fantasies--the fantasy of the oriental women as a submissive servant. (Ebert 2)The level of satisfaction we achieve for out sexual

Pop Art Of The 1960's Essay

2038 words - 8 pages Pop Art of the 1960'sWhat started as a rebellious art form against the conservative 1950's, the Pop Art movement of the 1960's set the stage for the social reform of an entire decade. A strong sense of conservatism embraced the society of the 1950's. Conservatism, defined as "an unwillingness or slowness to accept change or new ideas," 1 manifested itself in many facets of the 1950's society. Along this conservative line, art displayed itself as

Womens Movement And Emergence Into Art In The 1920's (Art/History)

595 words - 2 pages role in political issues and women began to have some say in the direction of their lives. This all happened due to two reasons. One was the thinning of the male population due to World War I and two, the continuing awareness of the feminist movement.Before World War I, women had not been involved with visual arts very much. If they were involved with it, it was mainly as a hobby. By the 1920's, women started to take art more seriously. This was