This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Kant's Conception Of Genius Essay

2413 words - 10 pages

Kant's Conception of Genius

As part of his Critique of the Aesthetic Judgement, Kant sets out to
explain what constitutes a fine work of art, and in doing so he asserts
that "fine arts must necessarily be regarded as arts of genius." (page
168, 'The Critique of Judgement', Immanuel Kant). He then goes on to
justify this, and to explain what genius consists of, and how a work of
genius is arrived at.

Kant begins by stating that for the representation of any work of art
to be possible, it must have certain rules at its foundation. However,
with fine art, the beauty of the object is judged independently of any
concept, and therefore a work of fine art cannot have been derived from
any rule which had a concept as its basis. From this it follows that "fine
art is only possible as a product of genius", where "genius is a talent for
producing that for which no definite rule can be given." (page 168). It
follows from this notion of genius that as no definite rule can be given,
the author will not be able to explain how the ideas that created the fine
work of art came to them.

Kant now goes on to make an important distinction between the
work of a genius and the work of what he terms "a man of brains." (page
169). As rules cannot be laid down to enable others to create works of
genius, the work of genius differs crucially from the work of a scientist.
We may refer to Newton as "a man of brains...[but] all that Newton has
set forth in his immortal work on the Principles of Natural Philosophy
may well be learned...but we cannot learn to write in a true poetic vein."
(page 170). Scientists can explain the steps that they followed and
methods that they used to reach their discovery, but no fine artist can
show how their ideas came to them as they themselves do not know.
We can therefore see that no matter how important the work of a
scientist, it can never be termed the work of a genius.

So what is the rule with no concept as its basis that is behind a
work of fine art? As we cannot actually set out this rule due to its lack
of a concept, Kant feels that the only way in which it can be understood
is by experiencing the works of geniuses directly. In this way the works
become exemplary models, which a pupil can then use for following,
though not for imitation. Alternatively the work of a genius may inspire
other geniuses to create their own original works of genius.

15/06/93 However, Kant does not want to say that a work of genius
is devoid of any rules whatsoever. "Genius can do no more than furnish
rich material for products of fine art; its elaboration and its form require
a talent academically trained, so that it may be employed in such a way
as to stand the test of judgement." (page 171-172). In other words,
without experience and technique, a genius will not produce a fine work
of art. A genius needs the best training and conditions possible to
flourish, and only...

Find Another Essay On Kant's Conception of Genius

Kants Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysics Of Moral

744 words - 3 pages Kant's Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Moral The central concept of Kant's Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals is the categorical imperative. “The conception of an objective principle, in so far as it is obligatory for a will, is called a command (of reason), and the formula of the command is called an Imperative.” (Abbott, 30) An imperative is something that a will ought or shall do because the will is obligated

Kant, and Causal Laws Analysis

1844 words - 7 pages the other hand Arthur Melnick (1973) and Paul Guyer (1987) defend the strong view in the second analogy but they hold that the epistemic status of such laws, as far as the Second Analogy is concerned, can only be broadly inductive8. In the next section, by using Kant's example in the Prolegomena, I argue that what Kant means by causal laws in the second Analogy is compatible with the strong reading and it is not inductive. The Prolegomena

Questioning the Effectiveness of Affirmative Action Policies

2384 words - 10 pages will be interpreted by taking Mill's utilitarianism as an example of the former and Kant's categorical imperative as an example of the latter. Finally, a personal analysis of the issue under discussion will be established and a conclusion as well. Briefly, the essay will argue that affirmative action can be defined as a good public policy as it can lead to beneficial and constructive outcomes. As mentioned in the previous paragraph, affirmative

The Critical Philosophy of Immanuel Kant

2526 words - 10 pages The Critical Philosophy of Immanuel Kant Criticism is Kant's original achievement; it identifies him as one of the greatest thinkers of mankind and as one of the most influential authors in contemporary philosophy. But it is important to understand what Kant means by'criticism', or 'critique'. In a general sense the term refers to a general cultivation of reason 'by way of the secure path of science' (Bxxx). More particularly, its use is not

analysis of Kant's Categorical Imperative

2079 words - 8 pages imperative mean by Kant? In Kant's opinion, everything in nature works according to laws. Rational beings alone have the faculty of acting according to the conception of laws, which also means according to principles. In other words, the conception of an objective principle, in so far as it is obligatory for a will, is called a command (of reason), and the formula of the command is called an imperative. Kant divided imperatives into hypothetical

The Beautiful in Kant's Third Critique and Aristotle's Poetics

3413 words - 14 pages associated with depth and truth, is not a form of beauty that fits into Kant's categories of the beautiful and the sublime as he lays those categories out in the Critique of Judgement. I will argue that Kant's analysis of the concepts of the beautiful and the sublime yields a more complex conception of beauty than Kant himself ever articulated and I call this more complex conception of beauty philosophical beauty. I will conclude with some

Major areas addressed by the Traditional Philohers of knowledge and personal response

1501 words - 6 pages moral necessity, wasacceptable to many people who were tired of the many claims mademetaphysicians and theologians who were looking for legitimaterole in the modern world. Kant's critics, however, accused himof merely marginalizing God (Dryer,1996)Looking at Kant' s statement that "metaphysicians andTheologian are looking for legitimate role in the world," itcannot be disputed that there is no logical necessity toconceive the world in terms of


1257 words - 5 pages rich as possible enjoyments (Utilitarianism Chapter 2).Looking broadly, both Kant and Mill share an ambitious conception of ethics as the straightforward, algorithmic application of a universal rule to common moral questions. Mill saw that the utility principle, which states that people should always act for the greatest good for the greatest number of people. This sounds similar to Kant's system, but with one very distinct difference: while Kant

Kant and MacIntyre: What determines morality?

1960 words - 8 pages Can one be moral by merely attempting to be moral? Or must one adhere to strict moral laws at all times in order to be truly moral? Two philosophies on this issue come from Immanuel Kant's writings in "Good Will, Duty, and the Categorical Imperative" and Alasdair MacIntyre's writings in "Tradition and the Virtues". The Kantian approach to morals is one of law. He states:The pre-eminent good which we call moral can therefore consist in nothing

Does God Exist?

1412 words - 6 pages Guanilon. He argued thatthe proof Anselm offers is inadequate. He disputed that thefirst part of the proof was literally impossible. "It requiresthat there be in the understanding an idea of God, that uponhearing this word the fool is expected to have a conception ofthat which there is no greater" (Stumpf 374).Guanilon continues to state that a fool could not possiblyfrom such an idea. A fool does not have the previous experiencesor realities to

The Nature of Existence and the Existence of Nature

1863 words - 8 pages Pure Reason carry principles found hidden in the subterfuge of today's society, making Kant one of the most advanced human beings during the Enlightenment. Europe's Enlightenment era happened to run its course at the same approximate time as the American Revolution, which largely explains why Kant and Rousseau's philosophies are so commonplace today, especially in our country. Immanuel Kant's philosophies rivaled that of the typical social

Similar Essays

Kant's Moral Constructivism And His Conception Of Legislation

4270 words - 17 pages him to speak of what he calls "Kant's moral constructivism". In "Themes" Rawls begins with an outline of the "CI-Procedure" (where CI is an abbreviation for "categorical imperative"), which he sees as something given or laid out, based on the conception of free and equal persons as "reasonable" and "rational". The procedure specifies the first principles of right and justice, and through the procedure the content of the doctrine is constructed

Aristotelian Versus Kantian Ethics Essay

1780 words - 7 pages Aristotle's and Kant's ideas of the means and ends of moral ethics are in sharp contrast. Both have strengths and weaknesses in their arguments, but Aristotle's is superior to Kant's because it is more realistic. I will first give the basis of both philosophies, Aristotle first, Kant second. Next, I will expand and question points of both philosophies, Aristotle's end, and Kant's means. Lastly, I will explain the reasoning behind why I favor

Rousseau And Kant On Law Essay

1007 words - 4 pages Kant and Rousseau share many similar viewpoints regarding how laws should be created, but when it comes to the concept of law itself, they differ greatly. Both Rousseau and Kant agree that laws which are agreed by everyone within the state are the only which can be bound to. However they take very different paths in order to reach this agreement. Kant's universal law is his categorical imperative, whereas Rousseau's uses his general law in his

Analyze Lyotard's Reworking Of The Kantian Sublime

2559 words - 10 pages According to Kant in The Critique of Judgement (1790) 'the sublime moves, whilst the beautiful charms.' Kant's theory of the sublime relates strongly to that of the sublime in nature, however Kant doesn't see that it is the object in nature, which is purely sublime, but rather our minds superiority to reason over the 'unpresentable' in nature. Lyotard whilst developing and reworking this Kantian model, stipulates rather that the sublime is not