Karl Marx's Contribution To Labor Theory Of Value

1263 words - 5 pages

Contrary to popular belief, the origin of the Labor Theory of Value (LTV), which states that the value of a commodity is proportional to the amount of labor consumed to produce it, is not attributable to Karl Marx. While this may be true, the LTV is most familiar to economists as the cornerstone of Marx’s argument against capitalism in Capital. In studying Marxism, it is important to understand the degree to which Marx expounded upon the preexisting LTV.
It is generally agreed that the primary theory of value was first put forth by Aristotle in Politics. He asserted that the value of a commodity is derived from its usefulness or utility. Being that Aristotle lived in a slave society, he observed labor itself as a commodity which could be owned and exchanged. This is why, Marx states, Aristotle had “no concept of value.” But Marx, who revered Aristotle, is careful to illustrate the reasoning behind Aristotle’s shortsightedness in the following passage:
There was, however, an important fact which prevented Aristotle from seeing that, to attribute value to commodities, is merely a mode of expressing all labour as equal human labour and consequently as labour of equal quality. Greek society was founded upon slavery, and had, therefore, for its natural basis, the inequality of men and their labour powers. The secret of the expression of value, namely, that all kinds of labour are equal and equivalent… cannot be deciphered, until the notion of human equality has already acquired the fixity of a popular prejudice… The peculiar conditions of the society in which he lived, alone prevented him from discovering what, “in truth,” was at the bottom of this equality. (Marx 69)
Regardless of Aristotle’s subjective theory of value standing in stark contrast to Marx’s labor theory, it is noteworthy that Aristotle makes a distinction between use value and exchange value.
Larger strides in LTV were made in the 18th century, when Marx would argue that “equality of labor” started to become actualized. This is when Adam Smith, the father of modern capitalism, and David Ricardo, a staple in Classical Economics, further developed the LTV.
Adam Smith mentioned the LTV when he analyzed the economic systems of primitive societies. This is the only case, he states, in which the exchange value of a commodity is determined by the amount of labor used to produce it. In more advanced capitalistic societies, in producing a commodity the laborer must compensate the owner of the means of production. Therefore, the entire value of the labor does not belong to the laborer, but some is owed to the employer. This means that the exchange value of a commodity, while not wholly determined by the labor embodied in it, is a function of labor, as in the exchange value is the value of the labor (wages) plus the payment to the owner of the capital (what Marx refers to as surplus value). As a result, Smith somewhat dismissed the LTV.
David Ricardo was the first economist to put...

Find Another Essay On Karl Marx's Contribution to Labor Theory of Value

Marx's Theory of Class Essay

2711 words - 11 pages way of looking at Marx's theory of class is how Elster attempts to define class interms of property, exploitation, market behavior, and power. Elster claims that Marx's 'class' isfrequently defined as 'a group of persons who stand in the same relation of property or non-property to the factors of production, that is labor-power and means of production.'11 By usingthis definition, the words 'property' and 'non-property' are too restrictive or too

Marx's Theory of Alienation Essay

1019 words - 4 pages Marx's theory of alienation has to do with the separation of things that logically belong together. According to Marx, alienation is a universal result of capitalism. Marx's theory of alienation is based upon his observation that, within the capitalist mode of production, workers consistently lose determination of their lives and fates by being deprived of the right to envision themselves as the administrator of their actions. Workers become

The Development of Karl Marx's Critique

2499 words - 10 pages , created a new vocabulary for it, new concepts or concepts that he took from others but giving them new meanings or at least new roles within his theory. For his meticulous study of capitalism he created new relations between the terms of political economy and built a conceptual apparatus with the notions of commodity, use-value, exchange-value, surplus-value, labour power, etc. Marx appropriately changed his framework understanding that to

"Das Kapital" -explains and analyzes Karl Marx's "Das Kapital" -Reccomends book to future students of my economics class

1173 words - 5 pages Capital or "Das Kapital", in it's original German form, continues to be one of the most important contributions to economics in history. Although Karl Marx wrote it in 1867, it is still just as relevant in our present time as it was 185 years ago. Too often Marx's writings are quickly discarded as simple communist propaganda and ignored by today's mainstream intellectual society. Capital is nothing of the sort. It is in fact an in depth

The Revolution of 1848 and Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto

1612 words - 6 pages relate to. The other significant view of importance in 1848 was communism. Karl Marx, the writer of the Communist Manifesto turned a lot of heads with his ideas. Communism can be defined as a “political and economic theory that rejects private ownership and maintains society should be classless.” Marx believed that social classes should be abandoned. He felt that many problems in Europe could be solved if there was not any division

The Contribution of Robert Merton’s Work to Criminological Theory

2269 words - 9 pages inability of individuals to gain societal goals, to Merton’s perspective that related to individuals and groups inequality of means, to Cohen’s definition that was manipulated to fit the time of sub-cultural delinquency, they all sought to explain why strain occurred in society (Akers & Sellers, 2007). Nevertheless, Merton’s contribution to criminological theory has been evidenced through to today. Because Merton took a different perspective to

Introduction to Philosophy: This essay is about my philosophy of human nature and a comparison and contrast with Karl Marx's view of human nature. Essay includes resources.

1650 words - 7 pages us, he loves us and judges whether we are condemned to hell or resurrected to heaven considering what sins we have committed.The philosopher I will compare and contrast with is Karl Marx, because he has many different as well as some of the same thoughts of human nature as I do. Marx was an atheist, and in the general trend of his thought was materialist and determinist. As a would-be social scientist, he proposed to explain all human phenomenon

Explore Durkheim's contribution to sociological theory

3102 words - 12 pages theory of suicide we see Durkheim's true sociological value. Because social forces that effect human behaviour are the result of previous actions, it is the role of sociology to expose and understand these as the foundations of societal structure. Suicide is a vital contribution to sociological theory, as it is the first effective combination of sociological theory, and empiricism to explain a social phenomenon.Durkheim's other great contribution to

Chinese Labor Contribution to the Central Pacific Railroad

1258 words - 5 pages Chinese Labor Contribution to the Central Pacific Railroad In port cities of China, leaflets distributed by labor brokers said, “Americans are very rich people. They want the Chinamen to come and make him very welcome. There you will have great pay, large houses, and good clothing of the finest description. Money is in great plenty and to spare in America.” And so thousands of Chinese flocked from China to America, in search for

The Refrigerator and Marx's theory of Commodification and Alienation

2131 words - 9 pages Refrigeration and freezing are two of the most common forms of food preservation used today. Virtually, in the kitchen of every home of the developed world, there is a refrigerator of one kind or another. This technological invention has become an irreplaceable and indispensable part of our life, which we take for granted.In this essay I will focus on the fridge freezer within its social and economic environment based on Karl Marx's theory of

Can Marx's Theory of History Be Truly Scientific?

2959 words - 12 pages when a systematic study gives knowledge of natural or physical phenomena. To see or not if Marx's theory is or can be scientific we need to look at, firstly at a fuller definition of science, and then at how much scientific method Marx used to formulate his study. Karl Popper provided one of the clearest and most comprehensive criteria for what makes something a science. In "The logic of scientific discovery"(1934) Popper talked about how

Similar Essays

Karl Marx's Theory Of Alienation Essay

579 words - 2 pages Few philosophers viscerally strike a chord with their readers, regardless of the subject in question. Yet there is something within Marx's essay, Alienated Labor, that is able to communicate directly to working people laboring even over one-hundred and fifty years subsequent to its publication. There is good reason for this: Marx elucidated a theory of labor in which workers become subservient to the objects they produce, a theory where people

Karl Marx's Theory Of Surplus Labour

1369 words - 5 pages Karl Marx's Theory of Surplus Labour For Marx surplus labour is the extra labour produced by a worker for his employer, to be put towards capital accumulation. The worker must do this work to keep his job but otherwise gains nothing by it. By helping the accumulation of capital he contributes to the cycle of mechanization and division of labour, which allow for fewer workers to do more work, thus adding to the competition between workers

An Account Of Karl Marx's Theory Of Alienation

1465 words - 6 pages Karl Marx's Theory of AlienationKarl Marx's theory of alienation presents us with a grim view of capitalist society and the dehumanising effect that this society has on the worker. Marx's theory of alienation refers to human beings becoming alienated from the society that, according to Marx, they created. As society develops human beings gradually begin to feel that it is not of their making and they do not feel at home in such a place. Marx's

Small Element, Big Difference: A Comparison Of Adam Smith And Karl Marx's View On Labor In A Capitalist Society.

1721 words - 7 pages capitalist system people cannot acquire the wealth produced by their labor due to the alienation between the laborer and his/her means of production. The result of this alienation is exponential division of wealth between the rich bourgeois and the deprived proletariat, leading to revolution in the capitalist economy.Although ownership of one's own labor is a key element in both Smith and Marx's theories, they have subtle dissimilarities, leading