This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Karl Marx Vs. Max Weber Essay

1036 words - 4 pages

After class I go home to check my e-mail. A concept such as e-mail would have seemed absurd to Karl Marx and Max Weber. It is accepted as just another part of life in our high-technology society, however. Max Weber and Karl Marx had a difference of opinion over what was the driving force behind changes in society.Marx vs. Weber, in a 12 round decision its Weber's rationalization of society over socialism. The essential difference in these two theories is what drives a society towards its advancements. Marx believed that the inequality between the haves and have-nots would lead to a revolt from the proletariat. (The proletariat are easily described as the workers who are employed by the capitalists.) According to Marx, the proletariat and capitalists were class descendants of masters and slaves, and nobles and serfs. When the Industrial Revolution came to Western Europe in the mid 1840's, Marx saw that the capitalists who owned the factories, and the workers who filled them, were growing further and further apart in class standing. The very rich could afford great luxuries, while the lower class worked full weeks to feed their families. He summed up that an eventual revolution was the next logical step. When the proletariat gained "class consciousness," recognition of their strength in unity, they would overthrow the shackles of the capitalists, and eventually capitalism itself.And what of the capitalists? The capitalists vast wealth, protected by the institutions of society, made them strong, indeed. Marx believed they would be slow to band together like the proletariat. He summarized that capitalists were afraid of competition from other capitalists, out of a desire for personal gain. Furthermore, he reasoned, because the capitalists kept employee wages low, the workers drive to turn against them would be all the greater, contributing to the capitalists downfall. In Marx's theories, this conflict between proletariat and capitalist was to be the driving force that shaped society into a cooperative socialist society that met everybody's needs.Max Weber's ideas were formed about 50 years after Marx's work. He shared many of Marx's views on social conflict, but they differed on what was essentially driving society. In Weber's sociological theory, there are two different views of the world, tradition and rationality. Weber recognized the power of new technology and its abilities to shape people's ideas. He saw modern society as a product of not only technology and capitalism, but of a new way of thinking. Weber argued that as technology advanced people were less inclined to live their lives according to tradition; they moved toward a more rational view, meaning matter-of-fact calculation of the most efficient method to accomplish a goal. Sentiment and tradition have no place in a rational world view, which treats tradition as merely one type of information. Modern rationalists typically act and think on the basis of present or future...

Find Another Essay On karl marx vs. max weber

Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx Essay

955 words - 4 pages Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx, living in the typical capitalist community in the United States, it is much easier to relate to the thoughts of Adam Smith. This is not to say that I do not agree with some of the precepts of pure Communism, but like the old adage says, Communism looks good on the outside.Adam Smith states his opinion on the mercantile system and its faults, while he dissected, clarified, and revolutionized the mercantilist economy and

Comparing Lenin vs. Marx by mundeazy. Lenin's views were heavily influenced by Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto

727 words - 3 pages Lenin's views were heavily influenced by Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto. Lenin along with his close friend, Leonid Trotsky, took key theories from Marx's writing and adapted them to help revolutionize Russia. The Bolsheviks principles were a mold of Marx, filled with the toughness of Lenin. By manipulating these theories he changed Russia, the ideology, and power.Lenin's close friend Leonid Trotsky was a very important part in the Russian

Idealism and Materialism as General Approaches to Understanding Society

550 words - 3 pages Idealism and Materialism as General Approaches to Understanding SocietyBoth Karl Marx and Max Weber had very different ways of looking at thesocieties economic system. Marx's strong beliefs in what would make society thrive werein the materialism approach and Weber's was in the idealism approach.Karl Marx believed that the majority of societies problems came from the industrialcapitalist system; this is the system that was making the rich

Modern bureaucracy

529 words - 2 pages Modern bureaucracyBy the mid-19th century, bureaucratic forms of administration were firmly in place across the industrialized world. Thinkers like John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx began to theorize about the economic functions and power-structures of bureaucracy in contemporary life. Max Weber was the first to endorse bureaucracy as a necessary feature of modernity, and by the late 19th century bureaucratic forms had begun their spread from

modern bureaucracy

529 words - 2 pages Modern bureaucracyBy the mid-19th century, bureaucratic forms of administration were firmly in place across the industrialized world. Thinkers like John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx began to theorize about the economic functions and power-structures of bureaucracy in contemporary life. Max Weber was the first to endorse bureaucracy as a necessary feature of modernity, and by the late 19th century bureaucratic forms had begun their spread from

modern bureaucracy

529 words - 2 pages Modern bureaucracyBy the mid-19th century, bureaucratic forms of administration were firmly in place across the industrialized world. Thinkers like John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx began to theorize about the economic functions and power-structures of bureaucracy in contemporary life. Max Weber was the first to endorse bureaucracy as a necessary feature of modernity, and by the late 19th century bureaucratic forms had begun their spread from

Weber’s Inquisitive Ethos Built on the Shoulders of Marxist Capitalist Theory

1732 words - 7 pages goals. These authors criticise capitalism in very similar ways, yet Weber actively works against Marx. Like the naturalised divides set between workers, how may labels and rhetoric of different disciplines affect the ability of academics to question larger, naturalised institutions? Works Cited Marx, Karl & Friedrich Engels. 2008 (1848). The Communist Manifesto. Introduction by David Harvey. London: Pluto Press. ISBN: 978-0745328461 Weber, Max. . The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. London: Routledge.

Max Weber

1777 words - 8 pages THE LIFE AND THEORIES OF MAX WEBER The Life and Theories of Max Weber Jordyn Visscher Dordt College THE LIFE AND THEORIES OF MAX WEBER Abstract This paper is about the early life, studies and the christian perspective on the teachings of the 19th century German sociologist, Max Weber. He was a man of many skills, developing theories, and a new way of business. He became one of the founders of modern sociology, was one to argue against Marx

Conflict Theory

1241 words - 5 pages method over functionalism. (Wolf & Wallace, 2006) The concept of the conflict theory was developed during the classical period of Sociology, when the only contributors to the field of study were scientists and theorists. Karl Marx happens to be the theorist whom developed the conflict theory. In correspondence with Karl Marx, Max Weber was considered the other historical influence to the modern conflict theory because of their writings

How the Industrial Revolution Changed Society in the 19th Century

631 words - 3 pages such socialist countries such as the Soviet Union (1922) and the People's Republic of China (1949). Many labor unions, all across the world, are influenced by Marxism. Marx is typically grouped in, with Émile Durkheim and Max Weber, as one of the three principal founders of modern social science.

Marx, Weber and their Critique of Global Capitalism

1739 words - 7 pages , political ideas, values, meaning and social action. Many say that Weber "spent his life having a posthumous dialogue with the ghost of Karl Marx." (Cuff, p. 97). While Marx sees capitalism purely from economic need, Weber states that capitalism is a combination of economic, political and social strata. Weber's analysis indeed had a similar scope to Marx, not surprising as he came from the same German tradition of thought and faced many of the same

Similar Essays

Similarites Between The Theories Of Max Weber And Karl Marx

1029 words - 4 pages Max Weber and Karl Marx has often been regarded as influential theorists who both analyzed in how the society is constructed in relationship to its economic conditions, more specifically on the division of labour. Both the labour and economics create a force on how societies are shaped and because of that Weber and Marx each developed a unique theory on how individuals react and how societies are formed. Many individuals say that, Marx and

Comparing And Contrasting Sociological Theorists Max Weber, Emile Durkheim And Karl Marx

1711 words - 7 pages Emile Durkheim, Karl Marx, and Max Weber are all important characters to be studied in the field of Sociology. Each one of these Sociological theorists, help in the separation of Sociology into its own field of study. The works of these three theorists is very complex and can be considered hard to understand but their intentions were not. They have their similarities along with just as many of their differences. The first theorist to

Social Theories Of Karl Marx And Maw Weber

945 words - 4 pages There are many sociological issues in the world today that can relate back to the concept theories that Karl Marx and Max Weber formed many years ago. Although there are too many for us to go further in depth on, I chose to primarily focus on Racism and Classism. With the perspectives of these theorists in mind I can explain how Racism, Classism, in conjunction with Feminism are among the largest social problems human beings face in the world

Marx Vs Weber Essay

1745 words - 7 pages statement presents Weber's main argument in The Protestant Ethic in a slightly different view than what many scholars think . Does Weber's essay merely criticize the theories of Karl Marx? Or is Weber simply trying to deepen the understanding of the cultural origins of capitalism, which includes Marx's materialist conception of history? In this paper, I will explore the ways in which Karl Marx and Max Weber might actually be compatible. By examining the