Kennan, Nitze And The Nsc 68

1724 words - 7 pages

Question 4: “NSC 68 was written by Paul Nitze in the spring of 1950 and implemented over the course of the year. How does the definition of the containment policy in NSC 68 compare to George Kennan’s original ideas? How does NSC 68 show continuity with the earlier policy and what about is new?

I. BACKGROUND

“The Sources of Soviet Conduct” Foreign Affairs, 1947, explains the difficulty of summarizing Soviet ideology. For more than 50 years, the Soviet concept held the Russian nations hypnotized, discontented, unhappy, and despondent confined to a very limited Czarist political order. Hence, the rebel support of a bloody Revolution, as a means to “social betterment” (Kennan, 567). Bolshevism was conceptualized as “ideological and moral, not geopolitical or strategic”. Hoover declares that… “five or six great social philosophies were struggling for ascendancy” (Leffler, The Specter of Communism, 20).

Therefore, establishing anti-Bolshevism in the United States was Robert F. Kelley’s mission. Kelley an Irish Catholic trained by Russian refugees ran the Eastern European Affairs division in the State Department (Leffler, The Specter of Communism, 19). Kelley’s intense dislike for the Bolsheviks demands that his aides join actively in his views. One of his service officers is George F. Kennan who joins in the close observation of Bolshevik destabilizing and expansionist activities that cause unrest in Mexico, Nicaragua, Cuba, Spain and Greece (Leffler, The Specter of Communism, 19). Was Kennan’s containment strategy thinking set off with Kelley’s training? Was Kennan’s awareness of the ongoing Russian Communist activities the basis for his ideas? History proves that George Kennan’s ideas on containment were the basis of NSC-68 and that Paul Nitze drafted NSC-68, based on Kennan’s containment ideology.

II. KENNAN STRATEGY

Kennan was first to communicate in print his ideas about containment policy against Soviet expansionism (Gaddis, Strategies of Containment, 24). Yet, drafting NSC-68 once Kennan resigns his directorship in the Policy Planning Staff in 1949, falls to a small committee of State and Defense Department administrators under the chairmanship of Kennan’s replacement, Paul H. Nitze (Gaddis, Strategies of Containment, 88). Meanwhile around the globe, in 1942, Stalin witnesses the Battle of Stalingrad. Germany, Japan and Italy form the Axis alliance signing the Tripartite Pact, in 1943 (Leffler, The Specter of Communism, 28). In 1944, the Soviet Union demands a 216,000 sq. km area for a ”joint Soviet-Iranian oil exploration”. In 1945, the atomic bomb drops on Nagasaki and Hiroshima. On August 14, 1945, Japan agrees to a ceasefire. In 1946, the Turks request US support against Stalin in the Straits of Hormuz (Westad, The Global Cold War, 59-61).

While, Kennan’s reputation as the government’s primary Soviet expert leads him to write his most contradicting article “The Sources of Soviet Conduct,” of course in anonymity. Although,...

Find Another Essay On Kennan, Nitze and the NSC 68

The Cold War Essay

1427 words - 6 pages bears within the seeds of its own decay, and that the sprouting of these seeds is well advanced." (Graebrer 42-43). He was mostly correct, except the fall of the Kremlin did not occur until the early 90's, but the idea of their economy being no match for ours was a factor in the downfall. Our economic might was also shown in April 1950 when NSC-68 was passed. This policy increased the defence budget from $13 to $45 billion annually. A major

American Strategies for Fighting the Cold War

1424 words - 6 pages received on strategic policy and military programs, known as National Security Council Resolution Number 68 (NSC-68), proposed that the United States take a greater role in containing Communism by an active program of counterforce that required greater military spending. During the next three years, the US would increase their military spending from 13 billion to 15 billion. Japan had occupied Korea during World War II. and with Japan's defeat

The Impact of Radio Free Europe and Radio Liberty During the Cold War

1102 words - 4 pages listeners, which brought about the demise of Marxism and the Eastern Bloc. Puddington signified that the success of the stations goes to the grand architects: Allen Dulles, George Kennan, and General Lucius Clay, who were firmly committed to the success of the stations. He argued that, a 1949 RFE memo refers to Kennan as the “Father of our project,” where he drafted NSC 10/2, which authorized psychological warfare, and propaganda against the enemy. (p11

American Communist Containment Policy 1945-1953

2345 words - 9 pages establish its world domination. NSC-68 committed America to assisting any nation anywhere that seemed threatened by Soviet expansion. America's containment methods only sparked further disorientation between the United States and the USSR. Tensions between these 2 nations only surface as US advisers such as Kennan miss-interpertated USSR's determination to prevent the scenario of WWII happening again, as an attempt to

The Containment Theory

508 words - 2 pages The term containment describes the foreign policy strategy pursued by the United States after the Second World War. The term was introduced into the public debate by George F. Kennan, a diplomat and U.S. State Department adviser on Soviet affairs. In his famous anonymous X-article Kennan suggested a "long-term, patient but firm and vigilant containment of Russian expansive tendencies." The Strategy of Containment found its first application in

The Korean War And Its Origins

1032 words - 4 pages ://www.history.com/topics/korean-war) Many top decision makers in the US believed that the USSR was trying to spread communism throughout the world. In April 1950, a National Security Council report recommended that the U.S. use military force to “contain” communist expansionism anywhere it seemed to be occurring. “The NSC-68 called for significant peacetime military spending, in which the U.S. possessed "superior overall power" and "in dependable

Contemporary Foreign Policy in the United States

2025 words - 9 pages . As the only power left standing at the end of the Cold War, the US sought to complete its objectives from NSC-68 and cement its dominance. With a universal agenda, - it sought to fill the power vacuum left by the collapse of the Soviet Union (Kagan 2008, 2008). Imperial ambitions collided with the tenets of former US grand strategy - restraint, accommodation and institutionalism (Deudney and Ikenberry 2009, 58). In this way, it revolted against

Containment Of Communism

2197 words - 9 pages any attack on a member of the alliance is an attack on all constituents. In 1949 in response to NATO the Soviet Union formed the COMECON (Council for Mutual Economic Assistance) as a result of the Warsaw Pact, in 1955 that included Eastern European nations such as Poland, Romania, Yugoslavia and Soviet Union. To stay on top of the game Truman turned tot the National Security Council (NSC). The NSC delivered their report known as the NSC-68, to

Cold War

1749 words - 7 pages The Cold War, 1949-1963 25.1 American Commitment to Cold War: National Security Council Document 68 1.     How NSC-68 influenced America’s response to Communist North Korea’s invasion of South Korea in June 1950 and to Communist expansion in Southeast Asia in the 1960s. The NSC-68 called for military assistance programs that would meet the requirements of our allies. Since South Korea was an ally, we

The 1950 North Korean Invasion

1987 words - 8 pages …” (Trubowitz 2012, 10), and serves as a revisionist actors preferred strategy. The subsequent section examines primary, open source CIA ORE, NSA, and NSC-68 documents. The first ORE report on 3 January 1947, frames the assumptions and threat perception for later reports. The ORE 5/1 report underscores three major themes. Uppermost, the report remarks, the Korean people desire an independent, single Korean nation (ORE 5/11947, 1). Other major

This article expresses the differences and simularities of the way truman and eisenhowercarried out the containment policy

1996 words - 8 pages opinion. However, Truman (and his eloquent Secretary of State) ultimately led Congress and the populous to adapt his point of view and, unlike the Eisenhower administration, was not led by them. It must be said, though, that Truman was not totally unmoved by domestic politics, especially the need to cap spending. Regardless, under NSC-68 he increased military spending to $45-50 bill. a year. The perceived threat by the Soviets led Truman to pursue

Similar Essays

History Of The War Machine Essay

5458 words - 22 pages of Joseph Stalin that now occupied half of Europe. Although Russia had suffered well over 20 million dead after the German attack on 1941, and much of the country lay in ruins, many American leaders shared the same fear. In 1944, Nitze had met a man in the dining car of a train on the way from Washington to New York. They fell into a conversation on the postwar period and the USSR. The man's name was George Kennan, and he was on his way to serve

Robert R. Bowie, And Richard H. Immerman's "Waging Peace: How Eisenhower Shaped An Enduring Cold War Strategy"

1817 words - 7 pages NSC 68. Mr. Bowie an illustrious diplomat in the Truman and Eisenhower administration, had first-hand knowledge of the policy as it became part of the long term U.S. strategic plan. Likewise, Immerman who is a well known historian on the history of the war offers some remarkable perspectives on the major arguments during the planning stage between the various actors. Both authors agree, that NSC 68 was a legacy of the Truman administration

President Truman And His Policies Essay

1957 words - 8 pages : 231). For this reason, Paul Nitze from State Department created a draft known as a NSC 68 (Doc.150: 231). According to this plan, this manifesto contained a large exposition of the nature of “the free society” and claimed the Soviet Union was motivated by a “ fanatic faith” (Doc.150: 231). Furthermore, the most important feature of the plan in early cold war that it helps to spur a dramatic increase in American military spending (Forner, Ch

An Aggressive, Offensive Strategy Within Massive Retaliation

1793 words - 7 pages in which the United States had managed its national defense during peacetime. In response to the reactive nature of the current foreign policy outlined in NSC-68 that allowed communism to spread into Asia, the cost-effective solution of massive retaliation enabled the United States to rationalize and downsize its commitments to the Atlantic alliance while still retaining its military strength and without alerting the Soviet Union to its new