Killing With Concern Essay

629 words - 3 pages

“Help, my daughter has stopped breathing!” she cried out entering the emergency room. In Sickened the autobiography written by Julie Gregory shares her abusive childhood to enlighten her readers about Munchausen Syndrome by proxy. With all the attention to protect children from abuse, how can child abuse not be recognized?
Child abuse is usually recognized by a pattern of physical injuries or outward appearance of neglect. From RelayHealth, Munchausen Syndrome by proxy is a mental disorder, causing illness in others, usually children, to get sympathy and attention for the abuser. With the mental disorder of MSBP documented, the behaviors of the abuser and victims should be easy to identify, but it is not. Any parent/guardian entering the emergency room insisting on immediate care for their child would be considered a suspect. According to RelayHealth, dishonesty is a key part of the ...view middle of the document...

Unfortunately, medical experts still have not determined if MSBP is a psychologically basis or a medical condition. (Nielsen) The cause for MSBP is unknown. (RelayHealth) Since many times there are no physical injuries of the abuse, there is a lack of evidence to protect the child. (Mcnatt) Julie Gregory summarizes it best of how elusive this abuse is to society by comparing her parents, a father who had a mild case of paranoid schizophrenia after returning from the Vietnam War and a mother who was affected by MSBP. “…wonder if perhaps the woman who is your mother is actually crazier than the man who is your father only without the paperwork to back it up.”(Gregory, 13)
Paperwork is the key to identifying the abuse although stopping the abuse it not as easy even with paperwork to back it up. In the movie, A Child’s Cry for Help, the boy who is abused is saved only because there was a history of medical abuse from an earlier sibling who died. Only in the movies is there a clear path for each character, life itself is usually messy. For one hearing, records show 150 emergency visits over four years for three girls whose mother insisted the girls needed treatment or tests for cerebral palsy, cystic fibrosis, headaches, seizures, use of feeding tube, wheelchair, leg braces and safety helmet – none were needed testified the pediatrician. (Nielsen) The mother lost custody of her children but she was not charged with child abuse. It should be easy to prosecute with so much evidence, but the 150 records were in various counties in North Texas as well as other states, Nebraska and Iowa. According to the prosecutors, the problem is jurisdiction. (Nielsen) Records in various locations are a common characteristic for abuse cases involving MSBP. (Mcnatt)
Imagine accusing a parent of child abuse because they insisted on the medical professionals to treat their sick child. Which sounds crazier the abuser or the accuser? The abuse is deceptive; presenting itself as a concerned parent instead of the true motive to get attention for the abuser by making their child ill.

Find Another Essay On Killing with Concern

The ethics of abortion Essay

1316 words - 5 pages are not rational agents nor are they social beings. This creates the first of many stand-offs in Marquis writings. Marquis suggests that by analysing both arguments in depth, one may loose its plausibility and this can break the standoff. The analysis exposes faults with both the pro-life and pro-choice arguments. The anti-abortion argument, which states that basically killing living things is wrong, is too broad. Marquis uses the example of

"Killings" by Andre Dubus's, Essay

643 words - 3 pages control and he is angered by the fact that she was seeing another man so quickly after the separation. There appears to be no feelings of regret or remorse from Strout after the murder. He seems to feel completely justified in the killing and even makes the statement, "He was making it with my wife" (Dubus 90). Strout's lack of moral character is a key element in his being able to live with himself after committing this crime. His personal consequences

Brutus is the Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

932 words - 4 pages make him thing that killing Caesar is the right thing to do. Cassius is basically playing with Brutus’s head because he knows Brutus will listen. So, Brutus joins the conspirators in killing Caesar. Cassius tells Brutus that it is for the good of Rome, and that he is saving them from a dictatorship. Cassius is going for Brutus’s weakest point, his care and concern for Rome. He knows that if Brutus believes the people distrust Caesar, then he will

Justifying Murder Through Non-consequentialist Means

1045 words - 4 pages Killing one person to save the lives of millions seems easily justified from a utilitarian standpoint. However, I reject consequentialism and thus consider the highly desirable outcome insufficient to morally legitimate the murder, and thus hope to align myself more with a Kantian framework. It is right for the doctor to kill the president because the president has chosen to be responsible for the slaughter of millions, which separates him from

Environment and Kangaroos

928 words - 4 pages rights activists argue that the killing raises more ethical concerns; concerns for the environment, animal wellbeing, social justice and Indigenous rights. The Australian Alliance for Native Animal Survival has indicated that Indigenous elders have expressed concern about non-commercial and commercial killing. Native animals are rarely environmentally problematic in their natural habitat unless they have ventured to a place with an altered

Katherine Mansfield

658 words - 3 pages his manhood and courage in saying "When you durst do it, then you were a man, and, to be more than what you were, you would be so much more the man" ( Act Scene ). In other words, Lady Macbeth was saying if you act like a man, then I will come to admire you, which was a main concern for Macbeth in his relationship with Lady Macbeth. Although Macbeth is very in love with Lady Macbeth in the beginning of the play, he begins to become less dependent

Euthanasia Should Approve in this World

2473 words - 10 pages . Discussion There are various terms associated with the concept of euthanasia. It is also referred to as 'physician assisted suicide', 'mercy killing' and 'death with dignity'. Despite the fact all these terms justifies the main reason for euthanasia even then there is opposition to this concept and this led to raise the people to ask for their right. These are the people who became completely dependent on others for their necessities and

Pop-Music - Beating and Killing Women

984 words - 4 pages readers, he challenges the reader to examine themselves by saying, “If the beat is good and the chorus has a catchy hook, we don't need to concern ourselves with things like meaning...right? We can simply dance on and ignore the violence around us (243). I agree with Hamerlinck when he says that these songs don’t cause violence. Hamerlinck doesn’t support this statement in his article, so I will expand on it. Of course it is not the songs that are

Slaughter of Animals and the Law

2384 words - 10 pages legislation governing the religious slaughter of animals in national law is the Welfare of Animals (Slaughter or Killing) Regulations 1995 with its Schedule 12. Later, the Welfare of Animals at the time of killing (England) Regulations 2013 was brought into force and extended to activities which were not covered by the WASK 1995. The European Regulations 1099/2009 on the protection of animals at the time of killing is now in force and replaced in

Capital Punishment Essay: Christians and Capital Punishment

601 words - 2 pages human life. This revolutionary value is implicit in the Judeo-Christian revelation and emerges into political visibility with the systems of justice that bestow the right of equal protection of the law to all persons. At a more primitive level in history this is the value underlying the ancient commandment that forbids the deliberate killing of another human being.   Second, we hold that the Christian purpose of punishment is reformatory

Comparing Revenge in Aeschylus' The Oresteia Trilogy and Sophocles' Electra

835 words - 3 pages Revenge in Aeschylus' The Oresteia Trilogy and Sophocles' Electra   The act of revenge in classical Greek plays and society is a complex issue with unavoidable consequences. In certain instances, it is a more paramount concern than familial ties. When a family member is murdered another family member is expected to seek out and administer revenge. If all parties involved are of the same blood, the revenge is eventually going to wipe out the

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Grapes Of Wrath

918 words - 4 pages reunited with the larger Oversoul. It is through Casy’s beliefs in the concept of the Oversoul and his prison experience that reveals to Jim that only through the unity and concern for the entire human race will the migrants succeed.      Rose of Sharon is another character which can be used to trace the progression of the Joads from a concern for themselves and their own personal welfare to a concern for all the people

Beowulf Vs. Captain Miller Of "Saving Private Ryan": Comparison Of Hero Characteristics

769 words - 3 pages leader to lead his people. In Beowulf and Saving Private Ryan these leader are evident. Beowulf, the protagonist in the epic poem by the same name, fights many monsters in order to protect his village. He accomplishes his goal with unparalleled bravery and fights against all odds to his death. Similarly, Captain Miller, in the movie Saving Private Ryan, is willing to die to save a soldier he has never met. He demonstrates unmatchable courage to

Is Abortion Moral Or Immoral? Essay

1302 words - 5 pages reason of killing a human being is wrong. Marquis explains the killing is not just cause of pain and perceive of loss to the victim’s family, moreover it includes the basis loss to the victims themselves as “the loss of one’s life deprives one of all the experiences, activities, projects, and enjoyments that would otherwise have constituted one’s future”. With the respect of Marquis’s theory, it is the loss of a valuable future like ours that

A Non Pacifist Argument Against Capital Punishment

2756 words - 11 pages several things wrong with this argument. The most obvious and frequently mentioned disanalogies are (a) "Society" (whatever that might mean) is not in eminent danger of destruction, as individuals and nations must be for killing to be justified, (b) Deadly force is not the only reasonably available means for Society’s self-preservation, as must be the case for killing to be justified, and (c) the death penalty is not effective at achieving the