King Lear Vs. The Stone Angel

1839 words - 7 pages

     It has been said that, “Rivers and mountains may change; human nature, never.”(worldofquotes.com) This is a quote that can be deconstructed when examining William Shakespeare’s King Lear and Margaret Laurence’s The Stone Angel. When reviewing the two books the main characters, King Lear and Hagar, are easily comparable. The first similarity becomes apparent when King Lear and Hagar are both developed as flawed characters. Secondly, because of their flaws the two characters become blind to reality. Thirdly, after being deceived by themselves and others as a result of their blindness, both characters seek refuge outside of their own homes. By leaving their homes the characters are able to gain perspective on themselves and their pasts. Finally, despite these similarities between King Lear and Hagar, a significant difference prevails after the characters experience their epiphanies and are awarded a chance to redeem themselves. When exploring King Lear and The Stone Angel it becomes clear that although both main characters engage in similar journeys to self discovery a critical difference between the two books exists in the character’s ability to redeem themselves after their epiphany.
     It first became clear that Shakespeare’s King Lear and Laurence’s Hagar Shipley were similar main characters when their personalities were developed with flaws. King Lear was immediately revealed as an imperfect character when he was shown in his somewhat conflicting roles as a father and a king. After resolving to divide his kingdom amongst his three daughters Lear develops a way to decide how his power and land will be divided. Looking to his three children Lear probes, “Tell me, my daughters/ (Since now we will divest us both of rule,/ Interest of territory, cares of state),/ Which of you shall we say doth love us most?/ That we our largest bounty may extend/ Where nature doth with merit challenge.”(I.i.49-54) It is at this point in the play that King Lear reveals himself as superficial. Knowing he had already divided his land in three Lear could have presented it to his daughters as each receives one third of the kingdom. However, Lear is flawed in that he is superficial and rather than hand over his land and power he would rather hear his daughters competitively praise him for it. Similarly to Lear’s flaw Hagar is also an imperfect character in The Stone Angel. Hagar, an elderly woman living with her son Marvin and his wife Doris, demonstrates the flawed qualities of being both too prideful and irrational. These qualities become apparent when Marvin and Doris talk to Hagar about selling their house. Being older themselves, Marvin and Doris decide that they can no longer provide Hagar with the care she requires and that it would be in her best interest to move into the Silverthreads Nursing Home. When Hagar finds our she quickly states, “Doris--I won’t go there. That place. Oh you know all right. You...

Find Another Essay On King Lear vs. The Stone Angel

Margaret Laurence's "The Stone Angel". Essay

1185 words - 5 pages In Margaret Laurence's The Stone Angel the main character Hagar Shipley refuses to compromise which ultimately shapes the outcome of her life as well as those around her. As an older woman faced with death, Hagar comments that, "pride was my wilderness and the demon that led me there was fear... [I was] never free, for I carried my chains within me, and they spread out from me and shackled all I touched."(292) Hagar's stubbornness and pride are

Hagar's Redemption in The Stone Angel

701 words - 3 pages In a series of illustrations, The Stone Angel is a story of a 90 year old woman, Hagar Shipley, struggling with life. Hagar Shipley is the most cynical old woman in human history, always torturing those around her. This woman is always pessimistic and looks on the bad sides of things and later realizes how being so gloomy-eyed she has withered into nothingness. By treating everyone so badly she has never made any friends and family does not want

"The Stone Angel" by Margaret Laurence's

942 words - 4 pages In Margaret Laurence's The Stone Angel, the main character Hagar Shipley refused to compromise which shaped the outcome of her life as well as the lives of those around her. 'Pride was my wilderness and the demon that led me there was fear... [I was] never free, for I carried my chains within me, and they spread out from me and shackled all I touched.' (Laurence, 292). Hagar's pride and stubbornness were the causes of her failed relationships

The Symbolism of the Stone Angel and Hagar

983 words - 4 pages The stone angel is a symbolism for Hagar Shipley in the form of her character, and the way she displays no emotions, similar to a stone angel. Also, the position of the angel in the cemetery reveals Hagar’s high self-esteem and pride by the towering position of the angel overlooking the town. Moreover, the stone angel’s features represent Hagar in other ways; they include the missing eyes, the hardness of her personality, and Hagar’s lack of

The Character of Marvin Shipley in the Novel Stone Angel

840 words - 3 pages Marvin Shipley is a very interesting character in Margaret Laurence's novel, The Stone Angel. The story is written from the point of view of Hagar Shipley, who is Marvin's mother. We see Marvin as he is portrayed through his mother's eyes. Hagar never loved her son much and it is possible her view of him is bias because of this. In this novel Marvin Shipley is portrayed to us as being timid, reserved, weak and unmannerly.Marvin is a softhearted

The Character of Hagar in The Stone Angel

1430 words - 6 pages The Character of Hagar in The Stone Angel Death is a subject that everyone fears because they associate death with their end and not a new beginning. In The Stone Angel, by Margaret Laurence, Hagar is no different. When she faces the reality of the implications of growing old she is faced with a journey, not one of her choice but one of destiny. Through her journey Hagar goes through the five different stages leading up towards death

The Character of Hager Shipley in "The Stone Angel"

878 words - 4 pages In Margaret Laurence's novel, "The Stone Angel", Hagar Shipley is the main character. Born the daughter of Jason Currie, she is one who possesses incredible depth in character. Mingling past and present, we observe the very qualities, which sustained her and deprived her of joy such as her lack of emotional expression. As well, inheriting her father's harsh qualities, she exhibited pride that detested weakness in any form. Despite of her

The Use of Symbolism in Margaret Laurence's Stone Angel

815 words - 3 pages The Use of Symbolism in Margaret Laurence's Stone Angel The statue of the stone angel is symbolic of the Currie family pride, Hagar's inability to relate and share her emotions, and the blindness and ignorance that comes from constantly refusing to see things from another point of view other than your own. The Stone angel is symbolic of the Currie family pride because it does not seem to serve it's purpose, which is to honour Hagar's

Discussing Imagery in Margaret Laurence's novel "The Stone Angel".

1136 words - 5 pages Discuss Laurence's use of three of the following images to develop characters/ themes in The Stone Angel.-flowers/earth -stone -animals -water -journey(physical/spiritual) -Scottish lineage______________________________As in any literary work, imagery is an essential element in accenting characters, and giving a better understanding of events as they progress. Of course, the novel "The Stone Angel" by Margaret Laurence is no exception. Imagery

Comparison Shakespears plays: King Lear vs. Hamlet

1107 words - 4 pages William Shakespeare is probably the greatest dramatist of England. I think everyone has read one of his great plays or at least has seen one of the movies which are based on Shakespeare's work. In this essay I will compare two of his tragedies 'Hamlet, Prince of Denmark' and 'Tragedy of King Lear'.King Lear is perhaps Shakespeare's most psychologically dark tragedy. The naive and pitiable Lear with his children, Goneril, Regan and Cordelia

The Nature of King Lear

1071 words - 4 pages insanity, the symbol of Lear's rage, the disturbance of nature as Lear and other characters have disturbed the natural order. For W.H. Auden, the true theme of King Lear is man's nature vs. the elements, the physical world of the universe. As Auden states, "The real counter-pointing in the play is the world of passion, of man's nature, versus the elements, the physical world of the universe. The storm is infinitely strong compared to man, and is of

Similar Essays

"The Stone Angel" Vs "King Lear": Blindness,Insight

1458 words - 6 pages Blindness; a flaw with insight`It was once said, "What you lose in blindness is the space around you, the place where you are, and without that you might not exist. You could be nowhere at all."(Kingslover) This is a quote that can relate the characters in The Stone Angel and King Lear. In the tragedy King Lear, written by William Shakespeare and in the novel The Stone Angel, written by Margaret Laurence, the term blindness has an entirely

Hagar, The Stone Angel The Stone Angel By Margret Laurence

1438 words - 6 pages Hagar, The Stone Angel. The main character in Margaret Laurence's novel 'The Stone Angel', Hagar, is one of deep complexity, instilled in her from early childhood. Raised by only her father and the maid, Auntie Doll, Hagar develops an ignorance towards emotions, her own, and other's. In Laurence's novel the stone angel introduced at the beginning, is a strong symbol of Hagar's personality and traits in many aspects. The stone angel is a direct

Symbolism In The Stone Angel Essay

698 words - 3 pages Margaret Laurence is one of Canada’s most critically acclaimed writers. She wrote short stories, as well as novels. Her best known novel is, without a doubt, The Stone Angel. This novel has many symbolic references, physical items showing emotions. The stone angel, the flowers and the pins are only a sample of the important symbols in the novel. The first and most important symbol is that of the stone angel. It’s a memorial statue for Hagar’s

The Stone Angel Study Guide Essay

9751 words - 39 pages English 3201 Novel Study The Stone Angel Student Handbook Overview of the Novel The story is told from the viewpoint of Hagar Shipley, the protagonist in the novel. Hagar is seen at the age of 90 years attempting to come to grips and understand her life, as she reminisces about her childhood, her marriage, and her struggle with life through flashbacks in the novel. The story reveals Hagar's attempts to release her inner emotions and feelings