This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

King Versus Mc Closkey: Does God Exist?

2070 words - 9 pages

H.J. McCloskey wrote a journal article in 1968 called “On Being an Atheist” which denounced the existence of the Intelligent Designer. He uses different tactics to try and prove that there could not be a God. McCloskey shows that his argument for atheism is not sound as the evidence he proves in his article can be combatted with well-thought responses provided by philosophers and Christians in order to show there is the possibility God exists.
To illustrate the weak points in McCloskey’s article, I will start with his use of “proofs”. McCloskey uses “proofs” in his arguments when combating against whether God is real. He believes since it cannot be proved that God exists that anything that cannot be proven is invalid and should be omitted (On Being an Atheist, 1968). Dr. Mark Foreman says when arguing if something is true, do not use “proofs” as no matter what nothing can be proved including God (Foreman, 2012). Nothing can be positively proved throughout the universe, so the method of proving is invalid. For example, I cannot prove without a doubt that I am truly sitting, but that does not mean that I nor the chair do not exist. There still is the possibility that I exist and so does the chair, just as there is the possibility that God exists as well. McCloskey should be careful using “proofs” in order to establish a case that God does not exist as other methods can be brought to light as to whether they can be accurately proven to be real.
Additionally, McCloskey claims that since the universe exists that there cannot be a being who created it (On Being an Atheist, 1968, p. 51). C. Stephen Evans and R. Zachary Manis in Philosophy of Religion: Thinking About Faith suggest, when discussing the non-temporal form of the cosmological argument, that that God is necessary in order for the universe to be created as it gives a cause. In order for contingent beings to exist, there must be a necessary being as there has to be an ultimate cause for a contingent being’s existence (Evans & Manis, 2009, pp. loc. 654-680). Evans and Manis bring a strong argument against McCloskey’s claim to further that McCloskey’s points are weak and not well-thought through to make a strong stance for atheism.
Subsequently, Evans and Manis continue to show an opposite side to McCloskey's statement which he says that the argument does not claim that the cause is all-powerful and all-perfect as the most this could entitle is that the cause of the universe is simply powerful and imperfect enough to create the universe (On Being an Atheist, 1968, p. 51). Evans and Manis state that the argument at its simplest form shows a necessary being has to exist in order for the cause to create the world (Evans & Manis, 2009, pp. loc. 762-766). This alone opens up the door for people to ask questions about God which is opposite from what McCloskey feels will happen.
Furthermore, McCloskey goes on to write “to get the proof going, genuine indisputable examples of design and purpose are...

Find Another Essay On King versus McCloskey: Does God Exist?

Does God Exist? Essay

1552 words - 6 pages Does God Exist? Since the beginning of time, man has been struggling to answer the question, how did we get here? What or who was responsible for the creation of life and the cosmos? It seemed natural to conclude that there must have been a higher power that created the reality known by man. However, how does one prove the existence of such a God? This has been the major preoccupation of theologians and philosophers which began several

Does God Exist? Essay

1412 words - 6 pages aperfect being. The ontological argument says that a "being whichdoes not exist can hardly be considered a perfect being" (Stumpf,390). The outstanding flaw in this proof is that there is nostatement way it is a necessity to have a God. A contradictionoccurs when everyone agrees that a perfect being does exist butwas not all knowing. Kant's argument establishes the fact thatby simply saying a supreme being is all knowing does not proveGod's

Does God Exist

1804 words - 8 pages development alone does not completely illustrate the introductory wellspring of the eye or the cerebrum - the beginning of living creatures from nonliving matter. We know God exists because he pursues us. He is constantly initiating and seeking for us to come to him. For Christians our faith is based on the atonement work of Christ which is refer to the atoning death of Christ through which the sinner is reconciled to God, restored to His faith

Does God Really Exist?

2264 words - 10 pages The existence of God or rather an intelligent being with define abilities has been a contentious issue of discussion since time immemorial. There are as many people advocating for divinity in the creation of the universe as there are people doubting the existence of this Supreme Being with unique and really frightening capabilities who designed and created the universe. Among the chief advocates of the thought of the existence of God

Does God exist!..Atheists dont believe in God. This is a proof that God does exist! - My personal document - Does God exist!

1832 words - 8 pages HELLO Everybody Does God exist? 1) Yes 2) No 3) Probably This is very fundamental and very important question. If you are a religious person, and your belief on God is weak , you probably are not a good believer. Because of this weak faith on God you probably will not follow any God’s scripture from your heart. I personally believe in God almighty. The purpose of this PDF file is that, I am going to give you some evidence that YES indeed God

Does God Exist? ; Philosophical Positions on God’s Existence

2156 words - 9 pages something does not exist. By taking away the cause means taking away its effect. And just like the first way, it is finite and cannot go on to infinity. There would be no ultimate or intermediate cause if there would be no first cause among efficient causes. Therefore, it is acceptable to believe that there is a first efficient cause which Theistic understands as God. Third – the contingency and necessity. It is the argument from possibility and

If God does not exist, then everything is permitted

1377 words - 6 pages these two polarized incidents that had the same social setting is nothing short of a duel between the “sense” and the“nonsense”.Likewise, Dostoevsky’s claim, although adequately lamenting the fickle shades of the soul, does not represent the case for humanity because it challenges the years of experiences which have shaped it. Human nature is governed by the whip of social stimulus, and no God (or its fear) has a more potent effect than

Does God exist?

849 words - 3 pages leaf some mark. Everything was destroyed by this flood except the ark holding the animals and Noah. God guarded the ark from harm so the would of survived. But if God had the power to do that, why didn't he just stop the flood all together and save the time and trouble?If God did exist, I'm sure if he was any sort of God he would prevent natural disasters and famine in the world. If God cannot stop evil in the world, he is not all-powerful

Does god exist? : An Argumentative Paper on the Existence of God.

1080 words - 5 pages It has always been a question asked by many “does God exist” there are some that say yes and some that say no. Presented today are three statements arguing against the existence of God. First being the existence of the theory of Evolution. Second being that God is omnipotent, omniscient and benevolent, but how can he be if evil exists? Finally is god gives us the power to be virtuous and moral, are we actually or do we simply follow these rules

Proving God Does Exist in This is Why We are Here by John Piper

691 words - 3 pages chose to see God, as longest you know God Does Exist. With this being said in the article, “Does God Exist” the author Aquinas begins with two people explaining why they believe God Does not exist. In response to the question Aquinas begins to prove them wrong by giving us five ways in which God Does Exist Such as: God is the cause of change, God is the cause and effect in change, exist to nonexistence, ultimate good, and finally intelligence

Does God Exist? Debate Dr. William Lane Craig and Dr. Austin Dacey

871 words - 4 pages The existence of God is quite controversial issue. God has different names in the world, and a lot of people, strongly believe in his existence. While, on the other hand, there are also people who don’t believe in his existence. In their discussion entitled “Does God Exist?” William Lane Craig, who is the supporter of the idea of existence of God, debates with Austin Dacey, who is an atheist, on the idea of existence of God. They provide the

Similar Essays

Does God Exist? Essay

1140 words - 5 pages Proof Of The Exsistence of God Either God exists or He doesn't. There is no middle ground. Any attempt to remain neutral in relation to God's existence is automatically synonymous with unbelief. The question for God's existence is really important. Does God exist? Theology, cosmological, teleological and ontological arguments are all have ways to prove the existence of God. With all of these great arguments how can one deny that there is a God

Does God Exist? Essay

994 words - 4 pages JennaDoes God Exist?There are many different theories about God around the world, whether or not he exists, in what form he exists and what he expects of people on Earth. His existence has long been debated, and many celebrities such as Stephen Hawking and philosophers have all expressed their views on this topic. I believe that God exists, but not in the forms that many people on Earth believe.Many people argue that God does not exist. God was

Does God Exist Essay

1178 words - 5 pages Title Does God Exist? Research compiled for The Paper Store, Enterprises Inc.By R. Anastasia Tremaine - November, 2001 VISIT www.paperwriters.com/aftersale.htm -- for more information on using this paper properly! Does God Exist? : This 5 page paper explores the question, using Descartes argument as a springboard for discussion. Lack of scientific evidence of God's existence is discussed.Bibliography lists 5 sources. SA148God.rtf I. Introduction

Does God Really Exist? Essay

1405 words - 6 pages . Before I asked my parents, family members and friends I told them that this is all because of the essay I am writing and, I want them to answer the question without getting mad that I am asking that kind of questions to a bunch of God fearing Christians and that they should give me there answers with any proof they can think of or any proof they have. After they have agreed to my terms I went ahead and asked the question, does God really exist