This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Korean Dog Eating Tradition Essay

1191 words - 5 pages

Korean Dog Eating Tradition

The Korean practice of eating dog meat has always been considered a peculiar tradition by foreigners. In recent years, this tradition has come under increasing pressure from animal rights activists, including Bridget Bardot, who wish to see the practice outlawed altogether by the South Korean government. This controversy came to a head in 2002, when activists convinced FIFA to put pressure on South Korea, the co-host of the World Cup, to ban dog meat. William Saletan discusses this controversy in his article ?Wok the Dog,? in which he makes an interesting and well crafted argument supporting the Korean practice. In this article, Saletan effectively deconstructs the opposing arguments and makes the strong counter-point on logical, moral, and emotional grounds, that the movement to outlaw dog meat in South Korea has an undercurrent of cultural arrogance and even racism.

The strongest argument against the dog meat industry centers on the treatment of the dogs that are often killed by ?beating, strangling, [and] boiling? instead of more humane methods such as electrocution. Unnecessary cruelty against animals is universally considered wrong, and is in many cases illegal, and that is what makes this argument effective. Saletan addresses this argument logically, with the simple fact that in the interest of humane treatment of dogs ?South Korean lawmakers are proposing to legalize, license, and regulate the industry.? This simple fact exposes a fundamental hypocrisy within the opposing viewpoint. Saletan argues that it is the same activists who base their arguments on ending cruelty against dogs who are trying to keep new, more humane methods from being adopted. The activists condemn and deplore cruel treatment of dogs, but when given the opportunity to see humane treatment of dogs become institutionalized, they reject it. He supports this argument with a statement from the Korea Animal Protection Society, which was backed by FIFA, attacking the decision of the South Korean legislature by stating that ?[South Korean officials] think it would be okay as long as dogs are not killed in a cruel manner.? In effect, Saletan illustrates how the anti-dog-meat activists negate their own strongest argument.

Another argument that Saletan deconstructs is that dogs share a special bond with humans, as ?friends, not animals? and thus it would be immoral to kill these companions. This argument is furthered by Bridget Bardot with her claim that ?Cows are grown to be eaten, dogs are not.? Saletan attacks the accuracy of this argument, as well as the validity of its premise, using simple facts and logical reasoning. If it is morally wrong to kill companions, but morally justified to kill livestock, he argues, then the Korean dog meat industry should not be a problem because ?in Korea, until recently, dogs haven?t been pets.? Saletan goes on to explain that the modern Korean culture views dogs as belonging to two separate grades,...

Find Another Essay On Korean Dog Eating Tradition

Assessment of Levi Advertising Campaign Essay

1829 words - 7 pages the care of his dog whilst we assume he goes surfing. A man who eyes up the jeans whilst eating an ice cream receives defensive and excessive barking from the dog, so the man carries on walking. The next cross cut action of the camera is a medium shot of an attractive young lady wearing a bright yellow bikini. She spots the jeans and begins to put the jeans on with the dog watching her every move. As the girl turns her

Everyday Use Essay

948 words - 4 pages . Mama describes herself as a "large, big-boned woman with rough man-working hands" who can't even look at a white man's eye, and whose "fat keeps her hot in zero weather". She is so stout that it is a struggle for her to even get up from a chair. Maggie is no better than her mother. She walks like a "lame dog" and her body is covered with burnt scars. Her best outfit is "pink skirt and red blouse". Even her mother calls her "homely". They

Childhood Obesity an Epidemic

1840 words - 8 pages stick with it for the rest of their life. “Start a tradition by taking a walk together after a meal. Try walking kids to school instead of driving.” (Marshall). Exercising alone can be difficult because it is boring or uneventful, engage others in exercise contact friends with children and get them together regularly. A person can even take their dog on a walk or run, dogs need exercise too. Most likely one of those people will be an exercise

Field sports or blood sports? Which title does fox hunting deserve

861 words - 3 pages , the hunter saboteurs, and the hunters point of view.A great problem to farmers or any business that has to be with any field or outside the country with animal, for example the chicken for eating , sheep keeping , or even cows for milk have a great problem that are called " foxes " the kill the chickens and their eggs , the foxes eat or hurt the sheeps and cows, but is this a really good reason to kill thousands of foxes for fun?The hunters said

Discuss the Minority Presence in Contemporary British Art

3146 words - 13 pages major galleries, but finding information on them can be utterly impossible when the current focus of British art revolves around what it means to be British. The only minority artists that are visible are artists who either play up white stereotypes or allude to a Western artistic tradition. An examination of these artists and the current art climate, indicate that the visible presence of minority artists is controlled by preconceived traditions and

Culture Essay

1266 words - 6 pages were very welcoming and considerate towards me, as I was the only non-American member among the party. They paid attention to my eating preferences, constantly engaging me in conversations, and were even concerned if I was fine with having the dog in the room while we ate, because of the fact that I was new to the American way of treating pets almost like a family member. I felt quite at home with the atmosphere, and enjoyed myself through the event

Cultural Traditions in Japan

2946 words - 12 pages amounts of information about Japan and the Japanese people not just through my experiences with others in class, such as Thean or David, but through my studying and my interview with Itsuko, as well. Japan was an active importer of culture during the period between the fifth and the ninth centuries (“Tradition and Culture.” 1). Japan’s culture came particularly from China and the Korean Peninsula. In many ways, the Japanese

Red Firecracker Green Firecracker

810 words - 3 pages time while he was eating lunch, made Niu Bao get him a bowl of noodles and then fed Niu's rice to the dog. Whenever Mann gets the chance he whips Niu with his belt. At one time during the movie, Niu Bao throws firecrackers at the building to get the masters attention. He is then apprehended. And the punishment is up to the master. Now she doesn't want to punish him at all, but knows that she will then be just as wrong as him. Therefore she gets

Of Frogs and Traditon

1749 words - 7 pages common men, acquire a new method of capturing frogs, which breaks the sense of tradition in the hunt. In Cannery Row, Steinbeck establishes that the frogs have an expectation of what methods are to be used for their capture, but Mack breaks that tradition. And in doing so, the frogs are sent into a paralysis while they are stolen away in sacs. The collective minds of the frogs focus on what was established: the game of wait, wait, dodge. They have not

Decision Making

3035 words - 12 pages 10 8 7 7 As can be seen clearly, taste and safety capabilities are the most important criteria in their estimation; price and service style are at the same place.After choosing the criteria, the managers figured out all the alternatives of their choice. There are many kinds of food suitable for meetings, parties and enjoying the delicious meal like chicken, such as fast food, Pho, dog meat.Then, they assign the weight to each alternative to

The History of the United States Marine Corps

1775 words - 7 pages Florida. During the Mexican-American War, Marines seized enemy seaports along the Gulf of Mexico, and the Pacific Coast of Mexico. A single battalion of Marines fought with an entire army belonging to General Winfield Scott. Together they fought all the way to Mexico City; this is now referred in the Marines’ hymn “Halls of Montezuma.” The victory of “Halls of Montezuma” is forever part of the USMC tradition. (Wallechinsky, 2013) For nearly 40 years

Similar Essays

The Morality Of Eating Dog Meat

824 words - 3 pages The World Cup finals to be held in Seoul, South Korea have ignited a debate as to the morality of eating dog meat, a Korean delicacy. Many nations, including the United States, have voiced a protest over the Korean and Asian tradition of eating dog meat. Many Americans feel that eating dog meat is tantamount to cannibalism, and this attitude is easily understood. In America as in a majority of European nations, dog owners cherish their dogs as

Extreme Cuisines Essay

1373 words - 6 pages the taboo. Across the street, vendors sold ready cooked dine-in dog including canine kabobs. While it is expensive, many chinese locals are happy to pay the price as the Chinese also believe that food brings special powers and abilities to the human body. For example, the heart provides a sense of emotional happiness while overall, eating dog brings good fortune, however, these feelings may actually stem from the mind than from the dog. So what

Family Essay

1649 words - 7 pages . No matter how it is structured, a loving family is the most wonderful and beautiful thing in the world.I come from an ordinary Korean family. My immediate family consists of my father, mother, an older brother, a 90 year old grandmother, and myself.In many Korean families it is very common to live with two generations in the same household. I also have many relatives all over Korea and a few in America.My father worked as an investigator for the

Live Long Bullfighting Essay

1087 words - 5 pages if you call yourself an animal defender and you are against it you should stop eating meat. My mother Guadalupe Monterrubio, she is a bullfight fanatic since she married my dad. She said “If I would have never met your dad I think I would of never like bullfights, but I’m glad I did, it is such a beautiful tradition full of color.” Long live the bullfighting!