Kurdistan: Federalism Within Iraq Or Independence?

2393 words - 10 pages

The failure of many states to provide a functioning central government suggests that not all nations can or should have states. However, the breakdown of the state is not just a result of the aspirations of nations to statehood. Rather, the failure of states to provide adequate government for the nations, tribes, and sects within its boundaries is as much a failure of state philosophy as it is of sectarian strife. Ironically, the emphasis on stability over democracy has led directly to the inability of states to govern adequately. Thus, in order to prevent all nations from desiring statehood, a liberal approach, emphasizing democracy and power-sharing must be established.A premiere example ...view middle of the document...

Evidence of the severity of the atrocious attacks against the Kurds was found in the University of Colorado's (UC) archives. 18 tons of paperwork and photographs were tucked away, in a secret location, in the warehouse. The paperwork was of President Saddam Hussein's Secret Police: orders for mass murder, rebels' arrest reports, and lists of people turned in by informants. The archives also contained seven colored photos of a black-bearded man from different angles. This man had bloody wounds of torture and beatings on his open mouth, face, and bare chest (www.kdp.pp.se).Although the UC archives portrayed a very vivid display of the heinous acts committed against the Kurds, perhaps the worst and best known, was the chemical attacks in Halabja. Halabja was a Kurdish city, with an estimated population of 70,000. It is located about 150 miles northeast of Baghdad and 8-10 miles from the Iranian border. Over a three day period, in March of 1988, approximately 5,000 innocent civilians were killed with nerve gas, mustard gas, and cyanide in order to put down a rebellion (www.kdp.pp.se). The chemical agents used against the Kurds, was President Hussein's way of retaliating. Prior to the attacks, a group of Kurdish rebels had been fighting the Iraqi government, in hopes of gaining equality in Iraq. Thus, on the morning of the attacks, the Kurds seized control of Halabja. Therefore, because the Kurdish rebels had fought the Iraqi government for their rights, and had taken over their own land, they had to be punished.My great grandfather, Mullah Mustafa Barzani, experienced first-hand the terrible discrimination. While in Iraq, he was treated as a second-class citizen. Opportunities for educational, professional, and economic advancement were extremely limited. His children were denied the right to speak or learn Kurdish in their schools, and successive Iraqi governments actively tried to destroy the Kurdish culture and identity.Moreover, after the first Gulf War, the Kurdish people thought themselves free of President Hussein's gruesomely brutal attacks. Just after the end of Gulf War I, a rebellion, led by the Kurdistan Front against the Iraqi Central Government, liberated almost all of Kurdistan. However, the Kurds did not get the opportunity to rejoice over their victory because the Iraqi army quickly retaliated. In hopes of successfully escaping President Hussein's regime for good, a mass exodus of Kurds fled to the Turkish and Iranian borders. In response to the brutal attacks of the Iraqi forces, The U.S government created a no- fly zones above the 36th parallel and labeled northern Iraq as a "safe haven,' and the Kurds were safe from Saddam (www.kurdistan.ws.com).The brutal repression suffered by the Kurds at Halabja and after the end of Gulf War I reveal the failure of the realist philosophy of stability in Iraq. The chemical destruction in Halabja was so dire, that even after 15 years, the city still has no growing trees or flowers. Many of the...

Find Another Essay On Kurdistan: Federalism Within Iraq Or Independence?

Overview of Kurdistan Essay

2445 words - 10 pages defining characteristics of a state, thus Weber’s notion of a state can be used to describe the prevailing conditions within the Iraqi Kurdistan (Zunes 19). It has been a difficult struggle for Iraqi Kurdistan to achieve legitimacy as a state due to a lack of acceptance by the international community and constant disputes with Iraq and neighboring countries. Notion of a state Based on Weber’s notion of a state, a state can be defined as an

Kurdistan Essay

1416 words - 6 pages Kurds, and the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) who is also representing the Iraqi Kurds. The PKK was created in 1974 as a Marxist-Leninist insurgent group primarily composed of Turkish Kurds searching for an independence movement. Its first and only leader, Abdullah Ocalan, or Apo as he came to be called, was at that time a student of political science at Ankara University. From the late 1970s, Ocalan worked closely with both the then Soviet

Ocalan, Kurdish Terrorism

1450 words - 6 pages , Haki Karer of Turkish origin, was killed by Turkish agents in Antep.On November 27, 1978, Ocalan founded the Workers Party of Kurdistan (PKK). "The Manifesto" was presented for discussion and finally adopted as the founding programme of the PKK at the First Congress. The PKK programme calls for independence, democracy and unification for Kurdistan. Its aims and means can be summarised as follow: "The Revolution is twofold, i.e. national and

Kurdistan's biggest problem?

518 words - 2 pages Afghanistan due to Iraq's Prime Minister Nuri Al' Maliki. Baghdad has cut salaries for the employees of Kurdistan region for the current and previous 2 months, and this has created a great deal of problems. Many employees have to pay rent, pay for their children's schools, and pay for everyday necessities like food, or gasoline for their cars but they are unable to do so due to the lack of income.The society we live in today faces a lot of problems

Kurdistan's biggest problem

518 words - 2 pages Afghanistan due to Iraq's Prime Minister Nuri Al' Maliki. Baghdad has cut salaries for the employees of Kurdistan region for the current and previous 2 months, and this has created a great deal of problems. Many employees have to pay rent, pay for their children's schools, and pay for everyday necessities like food, or gasoline for their cars but they are unable to do so due to the lack of income.The society we live in today faces a lot of problems. In

The Kurdish and the Palestinian Cases of Struggle

2024 words - 9 pages eased, and within time there was a better official tolerance for Kurdish cultural activities encouraged by the European Union. The Iraqi Kurdistan or Southern Kurdistan is second largest Kurdish region after the Northern part. It borders Iran, Turkey and Syria. Kurds of Iraq has successfully established an official government within the borders of Iraq in 1970, known as the (Iraqi-Kurdish Autonomy Agreement of 1970). The agreement was the result

The Role of Turkey in the Pacification and Rebuilding of Iraq

3163 words - 13 pages ), was brutally suppressed by the Iraqi government.? Since Saddam Hussein was removed from power early this year, 263 suspected mass graves from the Anfal campaign have been discovered, containing hundreds of thousands of Kurdish bodies.[v]? The Kurds, however, have managed to attain a degree of autonomy in Iraq.? After the Gulf War, a Kurdish region, called Kurdistan, was established, that stretches from the Iranian border to the Syrian

The Politics of Turkish National Identity

1667 words - 7 pages whereas the Rumelian Turks are immigrants from the Balkan region when it was occupied by the Ottoman Empire. The Central Asian Turks live in communities in differing parts of the Turkey. Kurds About half of all world-wide Kurds live in Turkey. ???? If they not in Turkey they reside in neighboring Iran, Iraq, or Syria. Kurds have been migrating into the Turkish region for centuries and since 1960 Kurdish neighborhoods have sprouted up around

The Kurdish Genocide in Iraq

1938 words - 8 pages 1991, when Iraq tried to take over Kuwait to the US's disapproval. In March of 1991, the Kurds rebelled and took control of nearly all of Iraqi Kurdistan. Hussein soon crushed the rebellion. Some 1.3 million Kurds fled to the mountains of Iran and Turkey, and soon after this the Allied Coalition helped to create a "safe haven" for them in the northern part of Iraqi Kurdistan. The Kurds formed two parties within their new state, and today the US

The Kurd's Fight for Independance

1244 words - 5 pages is morally just. It is the purpose of this paper to analyze the Kurdistan Workers’ Party’s history and ideologies, concluding that they are a terrorist group. The Kurds are an ethnic Muslim group inhabiting a region known as Kurdistan, which includes regions of Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Turkey. The Kurds comprised 18 to 25 percent of the population in Turkey, 15 to 20 percent in Iraq, 9 percent in Syria, and 7 percent in Iran during the 20th

The history of Federalism in the United States and it's roots, meaning, and effects

1256 words - 5 pages are supreme within their respective spheres of power. Cooperative or "marble cake" federalism underscores the importance of cooperation between the two levels of government. Creative federalism called for cooperation between state and national governments, along with the private sector to solve problems like poverty and urban decay. The "New Federalism" under President Nixon moved to shift creative federalism in the direction of state-centered

Similar Essays

United States Kurdistan Unsc Essay

925 words - 4 pages appears to be working well; Jalal Talabani, a Kurd, is the current President of Iraq, while Iraqi Kurdistan has elected its own President (Massoud Barzani); this balance represents a healing of the rift between the KDP and PUK Kurdish groups. America has long given support to the Kurds on the issues they face, whether it involves Kirkuk, oil, or the peshmerga; in return, the Kurds have assisted US forces in Iraq in maintaining stability and security

The Kurds: A Nation Without A State International Relations Essay

1834 words - 8 pages unified individuals always pursue their own national interests. It is said that the Kurds are a one of the largest groups (or ?nation?) without a state. The idea of having a nation, but not having an official or legal state is hard to digest for the Kurds. However, as I mentioned earlier, if Iraq fails, Kurdistan would be in trouble too. Thus, the idea of independence does not guarantee success for the Kurds. Following realism would mean that, even

Kurdistan’s Choice Of Independence Essay

1181 words - 5 pages For more than a century, the demand or desire for a Kurdish state somehow divided the Kurdish people and their neighbors in terms of their opinion toward an independent Kurdish state. Kurds are possibly on of the largest ethnic groups in the world that do not own a country of their own. They are the largest minorities in Iraq, Iran, Turkey, and Syria (Murray p.31). It has been a challenge due to the radical ideologies of the neighboring

Kurds A People Without A State

1889 words - 8 pages actually succeeded in forming the Kingdom of Kurdistan, which lasted from 1922-1924; later, in 1946, some of the Kurds established the Mahabad Republic, which lasted for only one year (Prince, p. 17, 1993). In 1924, Turkey even passed a law banning the use of the Kurdish language in public places. Another group of people to consider is the Kurds living in Iraq. Major conflict between the Kurds and Iraqis did not really begin until 1961