La Croix On Descartes Essay

828 words - 3 pages

La Croix on Descartes

La Croix in his essay disputes the position set forth by Harry Frankfurt in his article "Descartes on the Creation of the Eternal Truths" (The Philosophical Review, 1977), charging that Frankfurt misrepresents Descartes’ view of God’s nature and power. According to La Croix, Frankfurt holds that, in claiming that God created the eternal truths and could have done the opposite with respect to establishing the law of contradiction, Descartes conceived of God’s power as extending beyond the laws of logic. For Descartes to take such a stand, according to Frankfurt, is to have his notion of God’s omnipotence be open to the charge of being incoherent. La Croix says that Descartes’ view might in fact be incoherent, but it is for reasons other than entailing the possibility of what is logically impossible. This, he says, is not at all what Descartes intended, and he points to passages in eight of Descartes’ letters and Replies 5 and 6 to the Objections to the Meditations to confirm his thesis.
Frankfurt goes wrong, says La Croix, in his understanding of what Descartes meant when he said that for God the negation of the law of contradiction is possible. He says the assertion can be understood in three ways (1) For God the negation of the law of contradiction is a possibility; that is, God could have chosen to actualize its negation instead of actualizing the law of contradiction. (2) God can repeal the law of contradiction and replace it with the negation of the law of contradiction. (3) God can violate the law of contradiction, that is, God can bring about logically impossible states of affairs. La Croix shows that Descartes’ view cannot be construed as entailing that God can do what is logically impossible under any of the three ways of understanding the assertion. However, more importantly, from Descartes’ doctrine of divine creation it follows that the negation of the law of contradiction is not a possibility, that God cannot change the law of contradiction, and that God cannot violate the law of contradiction.
La Croix explains that God does not bring about state of affairs by choosing from a list of alternatives and then choosing one of the possibilities. Rather, He creates them ex nihilo. The eternal truths, including the laws of logic, depend on God’s will in the sense that God freely creates them and determines their nature....

Find Another Essay On La Croix on Descartes

Descartes - Discourse on Method Essay

1127 words - 5 pages . There were harsh punishments for any who dared to question the church's views, no matter how logical. One of these who dared to dream, reason, and doubt was Rene Descartes, a French born mathematician and philosopher.Descartes was born in a small village near Tours in France in the year 1596. He was lucky, compared to most in his time, to receive an extensive education. At the age of eight, he was sent to Jesuit school where he was instructed on

Descartes Essay

1285 words - 5 pages In the early 17th century a philosopher named Descartes, questioned his existence. His life was dedicated to the founding of a philosophical and mathematical system in which all sciences were logical.      Descartes was born in 1596 in Touraine, France. His education consisted of attendance to a Jesuit school of La Fleche. He studied a liberal arts program that emphasized philosophy, the humanities, science, and math

Rene Descartes Bio

598 words - 2 pages Rene DescartesRene Descartes, the founder of modern philosophy and Father of Modern Mathematics, was born on March 31st, 1596 in La Hayne (now called Descartes), Touraine, France. He was an amazing Philosopher who completely changed the world of arithmetic; he influenced many throughout the 17th century up till modern day.His only parent was his father; his mother died a few days after his birth. His father, Joachim Descartes was a Councilor of

The Scientific Method

1188 words - 5 pages contributions, he is especially well known for the tremendous weight he put on utilizing human reason to solve problems. This emphasis on reason allowed Descartes to introduce a number of revolutionary concepts to the fields of mathematics, science, and epistemology. In 1637, the decision was made to publish Descartes’s La Géométrie, a decision that would forever alter mathematics. In La Géométrie, he shows how one can apply their innate reasoning

The Enlightenment

1599 words - 7 pages things."– René Descartes René Descartes was born on March 31, 1596, in La Haye, a small town in central France. He was the youngest of three children, and his mother, Jeanne Brochard, unfortunately died within the first year of his life. Descartes father Joachim, a council member in the provincial parliament, sent his children to live with their grandmother. He was concerned with his children receiving a good education, so Jaochim sent René to

A short essay about Rene Descartes written for my College Algebra class

865 words - 3 pages Rene DescartesThe French mathematician Rene Descartes was born on 31 March 1596 in LaHaye (now Descartes), Touraine, France. At the age of eight, he entered the JesuitCollege at La Fleche where he developed a lasting interest in mathematics. He studiedvarious subjects until he left in 1612. Ironically, attending school had made Descartesunderstand how little he knew. He discovered that the only subject satisfactory in hiseyes was the study of

Rene Descartes: Trouble Kid

903 words - 4 pages Touraine (now this little town is named Descartes), Indre-et-Loire, France in March 31st, 1596 from a noble family: Joachim, a lawyer, and Jeanne, who died when he was thirteen months old. He spent his first years with his grandmother and his older brother and sister, Pierre and Jeanne. The little Descartes grew up in a careful environment given his sickly character. At the age of 8 years, he moved to the city La Fléche to attend the prestigious

Gottfried Leibniz (01 de julio de 1646 – Leipzig, Alemania / 14 de noviembre de 1716 – Hannover, Alemania)

1944 words - 8 pages Pascal, Fabri, Gregory, Saint-Vincent, Descartes y Sluze. Comenzó a estudiar geometría infinitesimal, a la vez que la Royal Society no tardó en descubrir el genio matemático creativo de Leibniz. Al año siguiente viajó a París y perfeccionó las características básicas de su versión del Cálculo Diferencial. En el otoño de 1676 Leibniz descubrió la fórmula que hoy lleva su nombre: la Serie de Leibniz. Newton escribió dos cartas a Leibniz entre 1676

Critique littéraire- Flaubert et la phrase

1133 words - 5 pages émiotique et poétique, on peut considérer la permière comme une branche de la seconde.«Le but de la .recherche sémiologique est de reconstituer le fonctionnement des systèmes de significationautre que la langue selon le projet même de toute activité structuraliste qui est de construire un simulacre des objets observés».Roland Gérard Barthes est un critique litt&eacute

Rene Descartes

1009 words - 5 pages Rene Descartes lived from 1596 to 1650. He was a French mathematician, philosopher, and anatomist. He contributed to modern ideas, mainly those associated with science, rational thought, and the scientific method.He was born in La Haye, a city in central France. His father was a lawyer and left him an annual income for life. He attended the college of Henri IV at La Fleche when he was 10, ordered by his father. Descartes left La Fleche in 1614

Dissertation: Literature et Science

1658 words - 7 pages littérature, moyen efficace de traduire ses pensées en prose, a toujours eu diverses fonctions différentes... La science est une de ces fonctions. En effet, la rédaction a populairement été employée pour la promulgation des faits scientifiques. On parle ici de la vulgarisation de la science. Les savants, voulant faire part de leurs explorations, publient ces trouvailles dans des ouvrages accessibles

Similar Essays

Rene Descartes Essay

1091 words - 4 pages Rene Descartes was a famous French mathematician, scientist and philosopher. He was arguably the first major philosopher in the modern era to make a serious effort to defeat skepticism. His views about knowledge and certainty, as well as his views about the relationship between mind and body have been very influential over the last three centuries. Descartes was born at La Haye (now called Descartes), and educated at the Jesuit College of La

Rene Descartes Essay

2268 words - 10 pages While the scientific revolution brought many integral philosophical thinkers to the forefront, few made the impact than Rene Descartes. Descartes metaphysical, mathematical, and theological contributions can not only be seen as some of the contributing influences to modern societies aiding future discovery in other various sciences but also as setting the stage for the coming humanist movement, putting an increased emphasis on the individual

Rene Descartes's View On God Essay

1337 words - 5 pages methods of science and mathematics to philosophy by the "Cogito ero sum" (I think, therefore I am), he started to argue the existence of God by saying that God and science could co-exist, since he proved that he existed.   Rene Descartes, a Catholic, had the benefit of an extensive classical education, which influenced him to become a great philosopher.  When he was eight years old, "he was enrolled in the Jesuit school of La Fleche in Anjou

Cirque De Soleil Essay

1608 words - 6 pages "employed" at a hydroelectric power plant in James Bay, his job ended after only three days due to a labour strike. He decided not to look for another job, instead supporting himself on his unemployment insurance. He helped organize a summer fair in Baie-Saint-Paul with the help of a pair of friends named Daniel Gauthier and Gilles Ste-Croix.[4][6] Gauthier and Ste-Croix were managing a youth hostel for performing artists named Le Balcon Vert at